Carmella&#x27;s Pizza Bazaar

Flat out, hands down, best pizza in Cleveland. Walk in,…read moreplace order, wait 10 minutes and walk out with an awesome pizza. There is no ambiance. It's a little hole in the wall. Big enough to make pizza with an imported wood fired oven and some floor space for customers to stand. What else do you need?

I recently popped into this pizza shop before heading over to The Beachland Ballroom. The pizza is…read morealways amazing and the staff was super friendly, too.

Oven

Smoked Pepperoni Pizza

See all

Outside

Beach Club Bistro

3.8(136 reviews)

1.2 mi

Always have a great time here. Tim Delaney, the owner does a great job. The menu selections are…read moretraditional American food, in good value for the quality. I had the salmon, and it was delicious. A friend of mine had a pizza made to order, and they have a woodfire grill that makes great pizza. Another head of hamburger and said it was great. So plenty variety and medium priced good value.

Great food and great service. Tim is wonderful. And so is his staff. Always a fun time.read more

Beach Club Bistro Patio

Garden salad and fries

See all

Beach Club Bistro Patio

Angela-Mia Pizza

3.3(52 reviews)

4.2 mi•Collamer

Whenever I'm in Cleveland Ohio it's a must to stop by Angela Mia to get some pizza. I even take an…read moreentire pizza back with me in the plane. Now that being said, it's take out only, the lobby is very small but the taste of the pizza is grand. We usually order three or four pizzas to have for the next day but they usually don't make it through the night. If I were you I would call it in and pick it up otherwise you will have to wait in the lobby and while that's not too bad of a thing you will certainly be upset as you smell all of that deliciousness coming from the kitchen. They serve more than just pizza so go check them out. You won't be disappointed. If you stop by tell em Drew sent ya! Be Easy! Drew

This pizza was terrible is Cold burnt barely any sauce I would never order from here again they…read moreshould be ashamed to sell this to customers

Angela Mia Deluxe Pizza

Overcooked, no extra cheese. Disappointed

See all

Over cooked no extra cheese

Angela Mia Pizza - Richmond Heights

3.2(35 reviews)

3.9 mi

Not the Angela Mia's of the past . No longer taste the same of the past and still expensive.read more

Located on Richmond Road across from what used to be Richmond Town Center, Angela Mia is a small…read morePizza and Italian food takeout only place. It has been there for quite awhile and the Euclid location even longer; I have been meaning to try it and finally got the opportunity when Groupon offered a deal. I ordered the 2 large (16") cheese pizzas and while the prices have gone up slightly over those on the website, they helped guide me through the order on the phone. Pickup was easy and I got my pizzas and headed home. The pizzas were what I would describe as old school Cleveland style, medium crust, plenty of sauce and cheese and fully cooked. Overall these pizzas are very filling; they load up the crust with plenty of sauce and a generous portion of cheese. The sauce is nicely balanced, not sweet or particularly spicy, but with a rich tomato taste and you taste it with every bite. The cheese is great, thick and chewy with good flavor. The crust is strong enough to support it all, yet still flavorful with the sauce and cheese making it almost to the outer edge of the pizza. The pizza itself is thoroughly cooked, which some people may believe is overcooked, but it was perfect for me. All three elements come together really well to a nicely balanced whole, a near perfect oily cheese pizza. The large is cut into 12 pieces and 3-4 slices were more then enough to fill me up. The pizza was as good reheated the next day thanks to the oil and it even microwaves pretty well. If you are looking for some good flavorful pizza on the East Side of town Angela Mia should be on your list. Prices are OK, especially when you factor in the amount of food you get. If you like your pizza fully cooked this is the place for you.

Our original Deluxe Pizza

Store front

See all

Medium Pepperoni & Mushroom

Cleveland Pizza Co

3.6(74 reviews)

3.4 mi

Usually I like to see pictures before I order food and for some reason I couldn't find any online…read moreof their deep dish. I've been going here for years but never tried it. Today I ventured out and I was not disappointed! I called and had to wait a long time for someone to answer, but when I went in I saw they were extremely busy. I'm not sure if there is something special going on or if other people just love their pizza as much as I do. The pizza was well worth the wait. It was a tad pricy at $23 for such a small size but honestly due to the quality of their ingredients I understand.

Cleveland Pizza in Willowick the best delivery driver is Matthew. He is so polite and kind each and…read moreevery-time he delivers our food.

Vape and dirty items on the food prep table

Deep dish

See all

Small Pepperoni Plunge Pizza

Congin's Pizza

4.2(55 reviews)

1.7 mi•South Collinwood

I was craving a calzone, so I finally tried Congins after hearing good things. I placed my order…read moreonline and the worker was friendly and helpful. Decided to go with a calzone with pepperoni, sausage, and mushroom, which came to $12. I also got some chicken fingers. The total bill was $21.50 and they told me 35 minutes. I was a little put off by the customer service when I got there. They have a pick up/order window outside. There were two cars in the line with one person waiting for an order they just placed when there. I called to see if I could come in to pick up my order since it was already placed and ready and the same girl who took my order was kind of rude on the phone and told me no, I had to get in line and wait. It was a cold night and I just didn't want to have my food get cold. Luckily, when I got in line someone came out and asked me about my order and went to see if it was ready, I was able to give him my card and receive my order pretty quickly, but I didn't like that notion. The chicken fingers were basic. Maybe not frozen but not like hand breaded or anything. They tasted fine though. My calzone was a good size and pretty cheesy. It also came with a side of marinara sauce for dipping. All very good.

OK, here's the good the great and the awesome of this place. The good the wings are crispy meaty…read moreand not over sauced the great is the pizza. I think this place is a hidden gem . Now the awesome if you want an authentic Chicago deep dish pizza without having to go to Chicago this is the place. Let me tell you this was a showstopper. I love Chicago deep dish pizza, and this was made in true fashion a family of four will only need one of these any one from Chicago would agree

Outside

See all

Guys Pizza Co

2.1(20 reviews)

0.1 mi

I must give credit where credit is due. I live nearby, so I tend to go to Guy's when I'm really…read morecraving pizza, but don't want to order a full pie for myself. Most days the pizza by the slice is just fine. It gets the job done. Last week I stopped by and I must say that my slices were on point. They were all hot and fresh. The sauce was just a tad sweet which I've always loved about Guys and the cheese was melty. And at $2 a slice, it was perfect! Honestly, it was such a positive experience that I've been thinking about it all week and decided I HAD to write a review and spread some love. Thanks Guys!

I'm pretty surprised at all the negative reviews. I've gotten pizza several times from this…read morelocation to feed my crews and I've only ever had good experiences. The food is every bit as good as their competitors, my orders are always completed quickly and accurately, and I believe they're a good value. In addition, every crew member I've ever spoken to has been courteous and helpful.

See all

Too good to wait for a picture

Rascal House

3.0(25 reviews)

1.6 mi•Highland

great food gd environment in downtown cleveland service great open late and next to a lot of other…read moreplaces that you can try after your meal

First time customer, just stopped in and ordered a medium pizza w pepperoni and sausage, got a 2…read moreliter of soda, too, Total was less than 20. I thought the pizza was a bit undercooked and felt shorted on the sausage, otherwise we enjoyed it. Going to raise issue on the bottled soda as I don't like coke at all and if your going to sell bottled then include pepsi in your offerings. I'll probably not return on that alone.

See all

Tony's Pizza & More

3.4(23 reviews)

2.3 mi

Always satisfied, and great customer service, great pepperoni pizza and meat lovers. So sad to see…read morethem go

Friendly staff everytime I walk in and the food is always hot, fresh & ready. It's nice to finally…read morehave a spot with low prices and quality food. My closest and most frequented pizza shop for sure. I recommend their calzones the most. I do love their cheese bread but it can sometimes be very greasy / oily on top.

Soooo delish!!

See all

$5.99 special.

Whistle Stop Tavern

4.7(20 reviews)

1.3 mi

The food was amazing and the waitress was very nice considering multiple people was trying to order…read moredrinks & she was the only person in there, she still took great care of us and was very friendly and quick! would make the trip just to come back to this place The atmosphere was very laid back and not too overpacked which i love. A great hidden gem. (food was pretty cheap too considering the burger was bigger than my head)for a meal between my fiancé and I we only spent 35$ and he got a pizza.

I forgot to take a pic of the food that I ordered which was a shrimp basket and onion rings which…read morewere both delicious. I also ordered the tater tots which would have been delicious but they were overcooked, other than that the service was great.

Whistle Stop Inside

All Aboard Chicken Sandwich with Tater Tots

See all

Whistle Stop Tavern

Why does Yelp recommend reviews?

Hundreds of millions of reviews are posted on Yelp, and our automated recommendation software works in the background to showcase the reviews that it …

13 reviews that are not currently recommended

The reviews below are not factored into the business's overall star rating.

Peter D.

Elite 12

100

323

17 years ago

While Euclid may be going down hill in many respects, Pizza Bazaar keeps the same high quality I've come to expect over the years. Definition of mom and pop pizza place. No goofy italian crap allover the place, no stupid Scarface posters or Sporanos junk like they are wanna be mobsters. The staff is all very nice, and you can tell every pizza is made like the success of the place depends on it. Do yourself a favor, lay off the Little Caesars or Pizza Hut or pappa johns and see what a real pizza is supposed to taste like. read more

S W.

17 years ago

Family owned and operated. This pizza is outstanding. The place has been in business since the 1950's. The flavor of the sauce and the delicious crust make this a must stop. The family atmosphere is great and the staff serves a delicious pizza every time. Thank you Carmella's Pizza Bazaar! read more

debbie s.

16 years ago

You have pizza then you have Carmella's Pizza. Go to your local Pizza Hut, Papa Johns etc. and then go and buy a pizza from Carmella's and tell me what you think. I will take the little extra that it costs me to sit and have a real pizza. Carmella's is by far one of the best pizza's i have had read more

J H.

16 years ago

I was told about this place from some friends up in Cleveland. I thought, pizza is pizza, but I was wrong! I live in Westerville and get excited everytime I head to Cleveland, knowing that I am going to be going to have some of the best pizza around. read more

Mindy S.

14 years ago

This is the tastiest pizza in the Cleveland area, for sure. We try to get it whenever we're in the area. It's a little pricey, but I think it's worth it. There's no place to dine in, but who cares. Love the sausage. read more

D R.

16 years ago

Every time I eat here, it's solid food. Good prices and friendly service. I live in Columbus, and this is one of the three restaurants in the greater Cleveland area I always try to stop at before heading back home. read more

Angela D.

17 years ago

My friend's and I usually get Villa Rosa... we decided to try Carmella's this time. OMG! What GREAT pizza! I am what people consider a 'snotty dago' and this pizza is DELICIOUS!!!! read more

Angela P.

3 years ago

I have never been here but I go to Euclid once a month to stay with a friend. The picture oof the pizza looks good so when I go back next month I'm going to order from here!!! read more

casey b.

14 years ago

The owners are delightful and make it clear they have put everything they have into each pizza. I really like the deluxe but the pepperoni is good on its own. read more

Bob F.

100

5 years ago

Been going here for years. The last pizza I ordered had under baked crust that was very bland. Disappointed after many years of quality pies. read more

Brittney D.

7 years ago

If you want a QUALITY pizza this is where you go!!!! Always fresh, The best sauce around!

Jennifer W.

17 years ago

This place has some of the best pizza around. It's always a must-have when I'm in town.

kathy d.

17 years ago

best pizza,hands down.Everything is fresh,homemade from scratch,best pizza

Carmella's Pizza Bazaar - pizza - Updated October 2026

Browse Nearby

BEST of Euclid, Ohio Restaurants near Carmella's Pizza Bazaar

BEST of Euclid, Ohio Coffee near Carmella's Pizza Bazaar

BEST of Euclid, Ohio Breakfast near Carmella's Pizza Bazaar

BEST of Euclid, Ohio Things to Do near Carmella's Pizza Bazaar

BEST of Euclid, Ohio Parking near Carmella's Pizza Bazaar

BEST of Euclid, Ohio Desserts near Carmella's Pizza Bazaar

BEST of Euclid, Ohio Dinner near Carmella's Pizza Bazaar

BEST of Euclid, Ohio Burgers near Carmella's Pizza Bazaar

BEST of Euclid, Ohio Shopping near Carmella's Pizza Bazaar

BEST of Euclid, Ohio Movie Theatre near Carmella's Pizza Bazaar

Best of Euclid

Things to do in Euclid

Browse Brands

Brands by name

Browse Articles

Articles by date

People who viewed Carmella's Pizza Bazaar also viewed

D'Amico's Pizzeria

4.2

(27 reviews)

Excellent pizza! Great crust, sausage and pepperoni. I wish…read moreI had ordered extra cheese and sauce. Pickup and order online worked perfectly.

I am trying to eat at small businesses. I love meat lover's pizza. Ordered last weekend & was so…read moresad to have the middle of the dough be raw. Had to cook the pizza on my skillet and then put it in the air fryer for a quick moment. Would not order the pizza. Wings were great, but the honey mustard sauce (which is my go-to) was too tangy, not like any homemade or store bought I have ever bought before. Would not recommend this place (especially with creating a password to order online...such a pain), but not too bad if you're in a pinch.

Noce Gourmet Pizzeria

3.8

(84 reviews)

Last I tried NOCE Pizza was 20+ years ago. My wife and I sat down at a table for service. We…read moreordered a pizza and opened the bottle of wine that we brought. 45 minutes later our pizza arrived as we finished our bottle of wine! Fast forward to yesterday as I saw a Noce menu and was curious! We ordered a 12" Grecian Pizza for take out. It was ready on time but before handing to me the waitress said that the Tzatziki sauce had run out; not a good start! Pizza was flavorful (ground lamb, onions, cheese, garlic with an excellent crust! Prices are a bit steep for a great value but it has improved over the years!

my first experience at this restaurant was so terrible that I will never return. I would love to…read morerate the food, however it never arrived at my table. When I asked the wait staff why other tables who had arrived after us were getting their meals, I was given excuses in a rude and condescending tone. Asking "Have you ever worked in a restaurant?" I have never ever been treated this rudely in a restaurant in my life.

Romito's Pizza West

3.9

(117 reviews)

Romito's Pizza West has some of the best Italian pizza around. My favorite way to order it is…read morewell-done with onions, mushrooms, extra sauce, and extra pepperoni. If you give it a try, let me know what you think! The customer service is amazing. They never have a problem accommodating special requests, and everyone is always polite, friendly, and welcoming. It truly feels like a family-owned business that cares about its customers and takes pride in what they do. Great food, great people, and a great experience every time.

I ordered take out here for lunch. The staff were very attentive and made my order very quickly. I…read morehad a cheese pizza. It was full of flavor. It gives old school pizza parlor.

Carmino's Pizza

3.5

(79 reviews)

We ordered a 12-Cut Pizza. Carmino's calls it a Jumbo. We selected four toppings -- pepperoni,…read moresausage, green pepper and onion. When we got home and opened the pizza box, our "Jumbo" pizza had 1 slice of pepperoni and one sausage per slice on the pizza. This was very, very disappointing. Carmino's, is being so cheap that it will cost them future business and poor reviews. Their pizza is typically good (not excellent or great as others have reviewed). I have had better.

Very happy! Great prices, good service with accommodations/substitutions, and the food was…read moreexcellent too. I rarely have "go to" places to eat but this is about to become one.

Angies New York Style Pizzeria

3.9

(40 reviews)

Great pizza! We put a big order in for 17 people and the pizza was delicious! Crust was a little…read morethicker than NY style but it had a nice chew. Very tasty, would go back and would recommend!

Was looking for a new pizza place. Read the reviews on here so decided to try it. And Yes, it was…read moreworth it. Smelled awesome so jumped in before pics, sorry. Big slices, generous toppings. Just a great pizza, best I've had in awhile. Really enjoyed it. Will Definitely be visiting again.

G-Licious Pizza

4.5

(35 reviews)

Best pizza in Mentor so far. Great menu and fast service. Carryout only but what you…read moreCan see it looks clean and well run.

Just moved to the area try to place It was very good. Adequate amount of sauce appropriate amount…read moreof cheese crust was good. We tried it for the second time and it was the same very consistent. Very good.

Revolution Pizza

3.9

(74 reviews)

I'm I have been a big pizza eater for years. The last time I ordered pizza I was unhappy without…read morethe crust was the toppings weren't enough on there and also the service that I received. Just recently within the last couple of weeks I went ahead and tried Revolution Pizza in Manor and Willowick the mentor one was absolutely phenomenal just like Willowick. The thing that made me stand out the most was that the owner

ordered online (and paid in full). estimated time was 50 minutes. 1.5 hours later it's still not…read morehere. when we called to inquire about its status, we were put on hold for over 7 minutes. unreliable.

Don G's Pizzeria

3.6

(41 reviews)

Horrible pizza. The deluxe tasted stale. The pizza tasted like it was cooked in a dirty oven. It…read morewas soooo gross!

Great food, great service. Quick delivery. when my…read moregranddaughter comes up from Tennessee, it's the first thing she asks for.

Big Cheese Pizza

4.2

(22 reviews)

My work gets this pizza all the time. For the price and the quality it's worth giving it a try. Try…read morethe Buffalo Chicken Pizza.

Love this place!! Friendly and amazing place. They are quick and the food is always hot and on…read moretime. Staff is helpful and family like. Great place!!!!

Pizza Roma

4.2

(59 reviews)