D&#x27;Amico&#x27;s Pizzeria

ordered online (and paid in full). estimated time was 50 minutes. 1.5 hours later it's still not…read morehere. when we called to inquire about its status, we were put on hold for over 7 minutes. unreliable.

Ordered tonight for the first time. Spent $80. Order time given was 50min, it arrived at 80min. My…read morelobster Mac n cheese dinner was just Mac n cheese, no lobster and no salad or roll. My husband's sub missing mayo and tomato. Took FOREVER for me to get through on the phone and I was given 20% my next order. Why would I want to order again? I could've made myself Mac n cheese for $1 in about 10min lol the rest was wings and those were fine.

Undercooked and only half of pizza with toppings.

Buffalo Chicken with a Drizzle.. Revolution Pizza Style

See all

Giuseppe's Pizza & Subs

4.1(85 reviews)

4.4 mi

Ordered a chicken parmigiana meal and the sauce was so sweet , they should have called it candied…read moreparmigiana . Almost like a cook messed up in kitchen . And no garlic or Italian herb flavor to sauce . Very disappointed in the meal and I could not much. Makes me question why I even tried them when Dino's is next door and has the best sauce . Sticking to Dino's from now on .

The meatball and roasted red peppers pizza is to die for. Their hot Italian sub is xcellant…read more Good wings also

Large Sicilian Style Pizza - pepperoni,1/2 sausage,1/2 mushroom

Buffalo wings

See all

Small Deluxe Pizza

Cleveland Pizza Co

3.6(74 reviews)

4.5 mi

Usually I like to see pictures before I order food and for some reason I couldn't find any online…read moreof their deep dish. I've been going here for years but never tried it. Today I ventured out and I was not disappointed! I called and had to wait a long time for someone to answer, but when I went in I saw they were extremely busy. I'm not sure if there is something special going on or if other people just love their pizza as much as I do. The pizza was well worth the wait. It was a tad pricy at $23 for such a small size but honestly due to the quality of their ingredients I understand.

Cleveland Pizza in Willowick the best delivery driver is Matthew. He is so polite and kind each and…read moreevery-time he delivers our food.

Vape and dirty items on the food prep table

Deep dish

See all

Small Pepperoni Plunge Pizza

Pie Cafe

3.9(54 reviews)

3.1 mi

First time trying the pie Cafe. Ordered takeout for a quick pizza to go with our salad. The…read moreorder process was so convenient! I like that it gave the option to indicate which 1/2 had which. 1st half and 2nd half. There was also a place for comments. Upon ordering for pickup, it gave an estimated time to pick up and a status. It was right on. I even received a text when it was done and once picked up, order completed. . Ordered a large Pizza (14") 8 Slices with sausage. 1// jalapeños and 1/2 pepperoni. The crust was light, but fully cooked. I liked that it was not greasy. The sauce was flavorful (could've used a tad more - next time I'll ask for more sauce. ). They have other things that I will also try next time! The inside was clean and the person who gave us the pizza was very nice. Will come again and recommend Pie Cafe for pizza. Hope to review other items next time. Unfortunately, they don't have any menus. I'm sure this helps keep the costs down. This was unfortunate as my dad liked it too, but at 86, he is not going to order online. I told my dad he can look online and just call.

Best pizza ever says this 72-year-old pizza conosseurr or however it's spelled!? Lol…read more rr

See all

Biagio's Donut Shop & Pizzeria

4.6(365 reviews)

2.5 mi

How have I missed this place my entire life!!??? In my defense, I live in Chicago but visit nearby…read moreoften. Just complaining recently that Chicago has very few old fashioned donut places left then I walked into this gem in Eastlake. Best vanilla filled donut ever. So fresh and it was 4pm! They still had a huge selection too. I then looked up their insanely long hours. The place barely closes and must be churning out fresh donuts constantly. Going back for a dozen this weekend and every upcoming visit to town.

Tried again years later. The cake donuts were not good. Too…read moredense and dry. No crispiness anywhere. Lacking in glaze for both chocolate and the off almost lemony flavored plain cake. The only winner here was a big hit- the unfilled Bismarck! Super soft and fluffy- bordering on syrupy but not quite- this donut was almost ideal. Light texture, sweetness but not too glazed, just about perfect in texture and flavor! The cruller was god awful. Stale, dry, rubbery, like it didn't belong at all with the fresher donuts I tried from the mix I got. The ones I got to try were inedible. BIG DOWNSIDE: CASH ONLY. $17 flat cash for a dozen.

Bad chocolate cake. Dry. Dense. Bleh

See all

Giovannis Pizza & Pub

2.8(4 reviews)

4.2 mi

I ordered pizza online for pick-up at Giovanni's . More of a Pub than restaurant. Pool table and…read moretables as you come in . Large long bar in middle. I asked for where I pick up takeout and barmaid answered her and repeated my order. Told me it would b 15 minutes. So I had a whisky with ginger ale, reasonably priced. The Hawaiian Pizza and salad were ready and paid and left. Pizza was good and chopped chef salad was good and fresh.

Came here last week before my physical therapy with my dad while my mom was out shopping…read more We came here since someone my dad knows said they had really good food. We walk in, and we weren't greeted at all there were 2 people sitting at the bar. Eventually thr girl comes over gives us menus, and takes our drink orders. She takes our food orders. My dad ordered a burger, and wanted lettuce, tomato, and onion since it said that's what it came with. I got a cheese calzone. It took awhile to get our food. We got our food my dad didn't get what he asked for, and my calzone didn't come with dipping sauce, and had cheddar cheese. My dad said something that he wanted the toppings. The girl tool his food back, and took a little too long. She came back with a salad in a basket He told the girl he wanted another beer which he wasn't done with his first beer. She took his glass, and filled it up. I ate my calzone, but dipped it in ketchup since I had no sauce, and it was burned on the bottom. My dad felt they did something to his food since he said something. He didn't eat the rest of his food. Just in case I told him to see if he feels sick. Which he didn't he was fine. He asked for the check, and it was over priced, and he got charged for 2 beers. His beer was half full, and she took his glass, and filled it up, but she charged him He had 1 beer, and she charged him for 2. We left, and he wasn't happy at all, and said when we left he wouldn't be back. He said his burger was overly salty.

Giovanni's Pizza closeup!

Un-cooked dough

See all

13 sauce flavors for wings at Giovanni's Pizza and Pub

Marco's Pizza

4.1(13 reviews)

3.6 mi

I ordered from Marco's pizza through Yelp. It said my order would be ready in about 30 min and when…read moreI arrived, my pizzas were ready to go! The service was great too. It's a small shop, so you'd have to takeout- there's no seating to dine in. My friends and I ate it so fast that I didn't even get a picture. But I ordered a cheese pizza and veggie pizza. Both were very good. This is one of the few pizza spots in the area that was open late on a Sunday, so that's also a plus. Definitely check out Marco's if you're craving some 'za!

I'm a guy who is willing to pay more for a better product and I had been ordering from 2 other…read morelocal pizza places assuming they were better than Marco's. I found that the quality of those other 2 places no longer justified their very high prices so I tried Marco's based on the recommendation of a friend. The pizzas from Marco's were much more reasonably priced and were better in every way. They were loaded with toppings and tasted great. I don't know if the quality is typical for the entire chain, but the Willoughby Marco's pizza is very impressive. I highly recommend it.

See all

Dino's Restaurant

3.9(109 reviews)

4.4 mi

It's been a while since I dined at Dino's so we stopped in for lunch. Place is very basic nothing…read morefancy but the food is always good. The chicken parmigiana was tender with just the right amount of sauce and cheese. The Chicken Piccata was one of the best. It's a perfect blend of lemon and white wine. Every bite was so good. The server was friendly and took her time to explain their menu to us and recommended her favorites.

If you're craving some great authentic Italian food, then this is the place! Their artichoke dip is…read moreawesome, and they served it hot and cheesy with fresh bread. Tiramisu is top-notch. You really can't go wrong with anything on the menu. The bar area is very cozy in a Cheers kind of way. I've been utilizing the carryout quite often, and I always enjoy the brief ambiance when I pop in to pick up my order. Very friendly staff. And did I mention that the portions are grandiose? A good bang for the buck in this economy. I highly recommend checking out this restaurant!

Dino's Restaurant

Free rolls

See all

Angel Hair

Big Cheese Pizza

4.2(22 reviews)

5.0 mi

My work gets this pizza all the time. For the price and the quality it's worth giving it a try. Try…read morethe Buffalo Chicken Pizza.

Love this place!! Friendly and amazing place. They are quick and the food is always hot and on…read moretime. Staff is helpful and family like. Great place!!!!

See all

Angelo's Pizzeria & Ice Cream

4.0(44 reviews)

7.7 mi

Another great family meal at Angelo's. Service is quick and friendly. Spacious seating. Great…read moreItalian dressing with the salads. Traditional pepperoni pizza was excellent. Always worth the stop.

Good food. Lots of staff. Ready on time! Staff was friendly and seemed to know their menu and how…read moreto prepare food efficiently.

See all

Why does Yelp recommend reviews?

Hundreds of millions of reviews are posted on Yelp, and our automated recommendation software works in the background to showcase the reviews that it …

3 reviews that are not currently recommended

The reviews below are not factored into the business's overall star rating.

Craig C.

0

1

5 years ago

Recently moved back to the Cleveland area. I had driven by this place a few times stopped to give it a try. Ordered the chicken and waffles pizza phenomenal. The dough was cooked perfectly and just the right amount of toppings created a wonderful flavor that will have me coming back. Chatted with the owner super nice guy. If you have not tried this place yet you need to put it on top of your list. Craig read more

Mary B.

0

1

0

3 years ago

We just moved into the area and after several attempts to find a Pizza place also taste them. D'Amico's. is EXCELLENT! their sauce is magical, thickness perfect and just the right amount of Mozzarella. Try it, u will not be disappointed read more

Dee C.

6

7

2

9 years ago

Great Place ! The new owner & his wife are so Nice. Miss the last owner & his daughter but Mike knows how to make great food too!

D'Amico's Pizzeria - pizza - Updated October 2026

Browse Nearby

BEST of Eastlake, Ohio Restaurants near D'Amico's Pizzeria

BEST of Eastlake, Ohio Things to Do near D'Amico's Pizzeria

BEST of Eastlake, Ohio Coffee near D'Amico's Pizzeria

BEST of Eastlake, Ohio Desserts near D'Amico's Pizzeria

BEST of Eastlake, Ohio Breakfast near D'Amico's Pizzeria

BEST of Eastlake, Ohio Dinner near D'Amico's Pizzeria

BEST of Eastlake, Ohio Burgers near D'Amico's Pizzeria

BEST of Eastlake, Ohio Shopping near D'Amico's Pizzeria

BEST of Eastlake, Ohio Thrift Stores near D'Amico's Pizzeria

Best of Eastlake

Things to do in Eastlake

Browse Brands

Brands by name

Browse Articles

Articles by date

People who viewed D'Amico's Pizzeria also viewed

Angies New York Style Pizzeria

3.9

(40 reviews)

Great pizza! We put a big order in for 17 people and the pizza was delicious! Crust was a little…read morethicker than NY style but it had a nice chew. Very tasty, would go back and would recommend!

Was looking for a new pizza place. Read the reviews on here so decided to try it. And Yes, it was…read moreworth it. Smelled awesome so jumped in before pics, sorry. Big slices, generous toppings. Just a great pizza, best I've had in awhile. Really enjoyed it. Will Definitely be visiting again.

Noce Gourmet Pizzeria

3.8

(84 reviews)

Last I tried NOCE Pizza was 20+ years ago. My wife and I sat down at a table for service. We…read moreordered a pizza and opened the bottle of wine that we brought. 45 minutes later our pizza arrived as we finished our bottle of wine! Fast forward to yesterday as I saw a Noce menu and was curious! We ordered a 12" Grecian Pizza for take out. It was ready on time but before handing to me the waitress said that the Tzatziki sauce had run out; not a good start! Pizza was flavorful (ground lamb, onions, cheese, garlic with an excellent crust! Prices are a bit steep for a great value but it has improved over the years!

my first experience at this restaurant was so terrible that I will never return. I would love to…read morerate the food, however it never arrived at my table. When I asked the wait staff why other tables who had arrived after us were getting their meals, I was given excuses in a rude and condescending tone. Asking "Have you ever worked in a restaurant?" I have never ever been treated this rudely in a restaurant in my life.

Biga Wood Fired Pizzeria

4.4

(160 reviews)

We love finding great restaurants like this one when we travel. The food was wonderful. My wife…read moreespecially liked the roasted broccolini, and I loved the pizza. The pie was finished just right for me, and I particularly enjoyed the sourdough crust. The service was friendly and efficient, and the ambiance in the small dining room was perfect for our lunch. We visited with the owners after lunch and told them we wish we could take them home with us. There are a lot of pizza restaurants out there, but not many as good as Biga.

We were very hungry and were nervous about having to wait because the parking lot was full, but we…read morewere seated immediately outside on their front patio. Allison was a wonderful server. We ordered their beet and goat cheese salad (without pickled onions), a one-pound meatball with marinara sauce and slices of bread, and a pizza with pepperoni, sausage, and mushrooms (onions and olives on half). The pepperoni was crispy and flavorful, but the sausage was sliced and soggy. I didn't notice any mushrooms. The salad and meatballs were delicious. We were too full for dessert. Maybe next time!

Master Pizza Painesville

3.8

(51 reviews)

This has been my fav pizza place for years. Went in last night (because they refuse to be on…read moreordering apps and I'm 1 street out of their delivery zone). The pizza has lost its charm. It was very tasteless. The water I got was truly disgusting and tasted like garbage. It clearly came out of an old faucet. This place is wonderful, I'm not sure what's going on right now, but hard pass until they fix it.

Great Pizza!! If your looking for a little place to get great pizza this is the place warm…read moreatmosphere and friendly service .

Corduroy's Pizza

3.8

(13 reviews)

The pizza was delicious long with the salad can't wait to try some other stuff on the menuread more

This restaurant is less than a minute drive from my place! We ordered through Slice and got two…read moremedium pizzas, a Piggy Pie and a Pepperoni, and also an order of Mac n Cheese Wedges. We ordered at 1:35pm, when they open at 1:30pm, and received a text saying our food would be ready between 2:15 and 2:25. Luckily, we got another text saying our food was ready at 2:05pm! Pick up was smooth! They have the option of curbside pick up, but I chose to go in. Nobody was in the front, but there's a bell to receive assistance. Andrew LOVES the Piggy Pie, it's been his favorite for quite some time now! I am a fan, although personally the pulled pork is a little too much meat for me. The Mac n Cheese Wedges were pretty tasty! Although, honestly it looks like Kraft is used, but that is my boyfriends favorite type of Mac n Cheese so no complaints from him! We rarely order from here since we tend to eat late night, but it's always a fun time!

Citizen Pie

4.4

(257 reviews)

Flat out, hands down, best pizza in Cleveland. Walk in,…read moreplace order, wait 10 minutes and walk out with an awesome pizza. There is no ambiance. It's a little hole in the wall. Big enough to make pizza with an imported wood fired oven and some floor space for customers to stand. What else do you need?

I recently popped into this pizza shop before heading over to The Beachland Ballroom. The pizza is…read morealways amazing and the staff was super friendly, too.

Concord Pizza

4.2

(29 reviews)

I love this place! Good pizza good wings definitely one of my favorite places to eat try the mild…read morewings!

This is some of the best pizza and wings. Garlic parm wings are the bomb. Definitely give it a try,…read moreyou won't be disappointed.

Revolution Pizza

3.7

(19 reviews)

Posted hours are until 10pm but I couldn't reach anyone to place an order at 9:15pm. Was unable to…read moreget food here during business hours.

High quality food and service. Try the lunch specials. I recommend the lunch salad to startread more

Boom's Pizza

4.3

(113 reviews)

This was our second visit to Booms. It wasn't busy, but it was also mid afternoon. We ordered at…read morethe counter and we were given a number to take to the table. We were offered a frosty mug for our drinks which definitely made it a more enjoyable experience. I have to give a big shout out to the staff and customer service. Our pepperoni pizza came out with a home in it . The staff member said it happens once in a while. She offered to make a whole new pizza. We thought that would be wasteful and said it was ok. She ended up refunding the entire pizza. They definitely want the customer to be satisfied. The dining room is fun with cute decor. I like that the to go boxes are out and you can help yourself.

First time at Boom's Pizza and it did not disappoint! The ambiance of Boom's is unbeatable! It was…read morenot super busy when we came in around 6pm on a Tuesday. We were able to get a good seat in the booths and the wait time was not long at all. The staff made sure to explain the menu to us, alone with any specials, as it was our first time here. We were able to split a pizza, which was INCREDIBLE! The red sauce is sweet and we both loved the herby garlic dip that we had added onto the side. That is a must!! I need to try more of their pizzas - 10/10 experience at Boom's!

Pizza Roma

4.2

(59 reviews)