I was very disappointed by the experience. The service was absolutely terrible from the start. I went to order a meatball Sub with French Fries and he accidentally cleared out my order. Once that got resolved, my phone let me know that Pie Cafe offered guests Wi-Fi but I didn't see it on the chalk board. When I asked the cashier about the password, he unenthusiastically. I asked him why not and if he could obtain it for me. His response was, "I just work here." When my order was ready, the French Fries were missing. I went back to the cashier to inform him He did apologize and handed me a very small, soggy container of French Fries. They were disgusting and there is no way they were wort $4.00. I went to ask for Ketchup but the Cashier was nowhere to be seen. This was only my second time eating at Pie Cafe. Then first experience was right after it opened and the food and service was much better. The next time I want a meatball sub, I probably will go to Papa Joe's in Eastlake. read more

Pie Cafe - Meatball Sub - Coffee & Tea Near Me - Willowick, Ohio

See all

Awesome cafe and pizza spot in Willowick. Don't be fooled when you walk in, it looks mostly like a pizza shop, but they have a full coffee bar, breakfast sandwiches, muffins, and of course lots of pies. I got a pistachio cortado, which was absolutely perfect. Hot, creamy, and strong. I also got an egg and cheese sandwich on an everything bagel. The sandwich was pretty big, I think it had 2 eggs and lots of cheese. Almost too much. It was melty and gooey, mozzarella and provolone cheese, plus some type of house sauce. The sauce was great, but I could have been okay with half the amount of cheese. It does make be believe they can make a mean pizza pie. Service was super friendly and you can tell that it is family owned in operated. I stayed for a little while to send a couple of emails. Internet was easy to connect too, and it was pretty quiet. Looking forward to returning for a pizza or even one of their make-your-own pizza bagels. read more

See all

This is a halal place so no pork products which I love. We got turkey, egg and cheese bagels and added turkey bacon. We also got the banana bread latte and the cherry berry mocha latte and they were both really good. They had a lot of desserts and pies readily available to grab and go. There was a big seating area and huge shock boards for kids to draw on if they get restless. There's also seating outside. Everything came out really fast and our food was brought to us. They have bagels, subs, pizzas, and a variety of desserts. It's off of a really busy street but there aren't many coffee shops or food stops like this around. I'd recommend if you're in the area and want a quick coffee or dessert. read more

See all

Pie Cafe is my favorite. First time trying their cookies. Omg, my new favorite cookie. $5 for 5 cookies. I will definitely add these on to all my pizza orders from now on. Sooo soft, & the best cookie I have ever had. I wish I knew their recipe! Cheesy breadsticks were soft & flavorful; can't go wrong with ordering those. My go-to is always the meat lover's pizza. I personally don't like turkey bacon so order it without bacon & then just add my own crumbles since bacon is my favorite topping. No complaints from me. Everyone I have met that works there is friendly. I hope they stay in business forever. read more

See all

This place has been on my "to try" list since I first heard of them and seeing so many good reviews. Unfortunately I was very disappointed in this pizza. They call it Detroit Style but the only resemblance to Detroit Style is the rectangular shape. The first and only time I've thrown away the crusts of a DSP. Even after forgetting that it is off style, it wasn't even a very good thick crust pizza. Very bland flavor and dense dough, the most prominent flavor came from the burnt cheese on top. The pepperoni was almost unnoticeable. read more

Pie Cafe - Coffee & Tea Near Me - Willowick, Ohio

My sister is very particular and always asks to stop to order from here. Great food, Great service! read more

Great pizza and wings. Service is always friendly and professional. Pies and cookies are pretty good as well. read more

We stopped through here on a road trip. We needed food, it was late, and we thought a quick slice sounded good. This place had great slices at $2/slice. Ours were hot and fresh. The slices were pretty large, as you can see from the photo. They keep it simple, as their name might suggest, and focus on pie, pizza, and wings. They clearly do this well. They also serve coffee and a number of specialty drinks options. This was a great little find. read more

Pie Cafe - Chicken wings with dry rub - Coffee & Tea Near Me - Willowick, Ohio

See all

His food is always excellent. Bread is amazing. One of the best sub rolls I've ever had.

I'm a frequent customer of their pizza and sandwiches. Always delicious, ready on time for take-out, always pleasant on arrival. Doesn't look like much from the outside but, a great place! read more

The pie was excellent, we ordered a sheet half pepperoni and the other half was sausage and onion. the people who work there are the nicest as can be. The restaurant is clean and plenty of room. The only reason I did not give 5 stars was for the delivery, the pie was left on my front stoop, and no one notified me that it was there. I recall an option to allow or not to leave the pie on the stoop. I was under the impression I chose not to do that. Maybe it was my fault but I'm not sure. That was the first time ordering the pizza the crust was very tasty and the sauce was just the way I like it not too sweet, but you could taste it They also make sub sandwiches that are very tasty. read more

The quality of the food stood out plus the delivery time was also great!! AND the meatball sandwich was very tasty and I'll definitely be ordering that again, plus the bread was magnificent!! Thank You!! read more

I am excited that Pie Cafe is now open on Vine Street in Willowick. Across from Pasha Turkish Kitchen Pie Cafe is very conveniently located. On my first visit I got a latte from the coffee bar selection. If you enjoy Starbucks but don't want to deal with the prices and the lines this place is definitely for you. I am very keen to come back and sample pizza, sandwich, and pie offerings. Pie Cafe is definitely a welcome addition to the neighborhood. read more

Pie Cafe - Coffee & Tea Near Me - Willowick, Ohio

See all

Ordered 4 subs for delivery and was given a 1 hr wait time which at first I was fine with. So I waited and waited then next I knew it was already 20 past and still no delivery so I called the store they told me they lost my order and just found it. So I then had to wait another 20 mins for my food to be delivered. Once I received it guess what they weren't even made right the pizza sub had lettuce and this Italian dressing on it which it should have, the bbq chicken sub which was ask to remove tomato and onion from had them, and lastly the teriyaki chicken sub which was asked to not have cheese had cheese only one sub was made right. So I called the store back and they don't do anything to fix no remakes not discount nothing just a sorry and that was all. I'm not trying to be a dick I've ordered from here before and it was good but I'm just pissed because of this and they didn't even seem to care at all. read more

Pie Cafe - Pizza sub right bbq chicken left - Coffee & Tea Near Me - Willowick, Ohio

Quick and friendly service, and a nice clean environment. Food was very tasty and drinks were great aswell! read more

Pie Cafe - M Pizza (12"), 8 Slices and a Turkey & Cheese Sub. Chai Tea Freeze and Apple Pie Chai Latte. - Coffee & Tea Near Me - Willowick, Ohio

See all

Pizza was ok, thin crust pizza. Crust was good. Service was bad. Ordered a personal 4 slice pizza, received a 6 slice instead. Waited almost an hour for it They did adjust bill for the mistake read more

Very cute little cafe! Clean, modern and friendly staff every time. The subs were excellent and the bread is amazing! Great variety of tasty drinks! read more

See all

The food here is great and the staff is friendly. We eat from here at least once a week.

I have been seeing the social media advertising for this place for weeks and had not had the chance to try it. I was lucky to do so early this week. It's a large building with plenty of space to sit and enjoy a coffee or sandwich. They even have some fun games while you wait. Service was excellent and the owner himself took our order, patiently explaining our options and making sure we got what we wanted. We had two hot subs, the Italian (Unnfff) and the Chicken Ranch with bacon. So delicious. Hot and crunchy bread with plenty of meats and melty cheese. Wonderful subs. The fries are the hand cut variety, a bit soft but tasty with a little spice. Not crispy fast food style. I have not tried the pizza but it looks delicious as well. I will be back for sure! read more

Pie Cafe - Sandwich comes all wrapped up. Fries are soft like carnival fries with a touch of spice. Very tasty. - Coffee & Tea Near Me - Willowick, Ohio

See all

Been enjoying the pie Cafe several days a week including chai and regular lattes. $5 served as a large and even tailored with preferences. Very well done and nowhere near having to wait in the lines at Dunkin donuts Also enjoyed a pie once and it was hot and fresh. Out of the oven. Was very good read more

My work ordered food and pops and had it delivered. The order was incorrect, I called and he offered no solution to get it resolved because he didn't have a driver. It is a shame because our previous order was great. 3 days later, my manager orders food to be delivered. That order was incorrect too. Salad dressing was incorrect, and was sent 3 different kinds. Also, ordered a cookie and received a dry muffin. read more

Starting with the chicken tenders, while they were decent, they did seem a bit overcooked. They could have been juicier and less dry. As for the pizza, it appeared to benefit from being cooked at a hotter temperature as it came out rather crumbly, reminiscent of a cake, and felt very soft and doughy. Additionally, the scant amount of tomato sauce, combined with the texture, affected the overall dining experience. read more

Good food and service coffee is great and fast service too large sandwiches and appetizers

The Italian Sub is one of the best sandwiches I've ever eaten. The fries and Cajun dry rub wings were also delicious. Perfection!

The best around town! Great food, the wings are the best. So big and juicy. Happy they came to Wickliffe.

We love Pie Cafe! Every visit has been great. Food is good and the people are very nice.

Excellent pizza and pies and subs! We haven't tried the coffees yet but are planning to very soon. We haven't ordered pizza from anywhere else but here since we tried them the first time. The dough is fantastic and the sauce is delightful. Every time I have gone the employees are helpful and happy. This is a wonderful place and I highly recommend it. read more

i saw this place on tik tok & realized how close it was so we had to stop by and im so glad we did! the pizza was amazing, and the chocolate chip muffin was delicious! the restaurant itself was super clean and cute inside & everyone there was super nice:) i will definitely be coming back to pie cafe!! read more

I'm visiting from out of state and needed a little afternoon pick-me-up. I came across this place by accident... Best accident ever! Fresh Pie! Need I say more? Heck yea! Pizza and wings and sandwiches are all fresh made- nothing frozen. These guys offer fast friendly service!!!! read more

The food here can be awesome- however, if you order in the store 99.9% of the time your order will be wrong. Completely wrong. If you order online, 50% of the time it's wrong. If you try and speak to the employees about your order being wrong, sometimes they are understanding and will fix the problems, other times they tend to argue with you. It becomes an issue with ordering and getting the wrong items when you have given several chances and each time is essentially the same outcome. Not to mention having to wait an extra 20 plus minutes to fix an order that was placed correctly but made wrong when you have a house full of people who are hungry and have already waited over 30 minutes as it is. read more

They have amazing food and all the pies are off the chart amazing.. All the staff are super nice especially the owners. If I could give more than 5 stars I would.. There is absolutely nothing bad I can say about this place at all. The restaurant is clean, well lit, and over all makes you feel so welcomed when you walk in. Thank you to all the hard working staff there!! read more

This place is wonderful. The pizza is great, the coffee is fantastic, the pie and desserts are incredible (with cute little mini pies with flavor designs as an option!) and the staff is super friendly. Prices are reasonable. Fairly large dining area for a new business, so you never feel crowded. Haven't tried their subs yet, but like. Look at the photos. They're gonna be awesome. read more

Great food my fiancée and I ordered chicken parm and I had the cheese steak, the bread was fresh & delicious and the meat was very tasty and cooked well. half size sub is $7 and filled us both up with chips on side. We also ordered a cheese cake slice and peach pie. The cheese cake was great. The pie my fiancé thought was dry (not enough filling for her) but I really liked how it was not sugary with all the filling. Overall great food. read more

Superb sandwiches and generous portions. The staff is quite friendly. Love this place!

Great new place in Willowick! Great subs, coffee, and everything else! We really enjoy places that are locally owned and operated!

Good food, good prices, friendly staff. They have gluten free pizza! And it's also cheaper than other places!

Have picked up several times..pizza,chicken wings (bone in), sandwiches and pies were all great! The people are great and it is very clean. Haven't tried their coffee yet but I look forward to it! Great Job! read more

The Italian sub is the best! The chicken tenders are great. The potato wedges are fabulous.

The shrimp sub was so good! Blueberry pie for dessert was great! I will be back! Definitely want to try more from the menu!

I decided to give this place a try since my daughter and I were both hungry and they have pizza slices for 2 bucks. Everyone was super friendly and the place was bright and clean. The pizza was really good and at some point in the near future I'll definitely get a whole pizza. Definitely worth checking out! read more