I recently went here with a friend to split a pizza on a weekend evening. We were able to place our order quickly and got our pizza in a timely manner. Master Pizza is a no-frills, hole-in-the-wall restaurant-everything is self-serve other than the pizza. My friend and I split the Ultimate Cheese Pizza on a Cleveland-style crust. The crust was perfectly cooked with a nice crunch and the cheese blend was also delicious. My only critique is that there was somehow too much cheese (a first for me), which could have been balanced out with some tomato sauce. read more

Master Pizza - Ultimate Cheese Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Mayfield Heights, Ohio

Great place to grab a quick pizza and wings. Interior had been remodeled with a few small tables and booths. Pizza's are delicious and cooked well. Not the largest wings you will get but great flavor and tender. Grab your own drinks or adult beverages from the cooler. Very good salads. Reasonable price and quick/friendly service. read more

Master Pizza - a slice of pepperoni pizza - Pizza Near Me - Mayfield Heights, Ohio

See all

Been a customer for the past 31 years and I'm not sure what happened to this location? I have had issues the past three times coming here. 1st issue was my pizza's were way overcooked. I called the store and offered no solution. 2nd issue was the sauce was bitter. I called them and they said they weee not sure who prepped it but no one else said anything. They didn't offer a solution either. 3rd issue was I ordered a pizza 30 min in advance. I get there and cook said it would be 15 more minutes as this was ok because it was a Sunday during football season so I expects that. After 20 min another person told me they just put pizza in the oven and it would be 12 more min. I asked them to cancel the order and refund me. I went around the corner to Georgio's instead. Not sure I will ever come back because after the last three trips there I was patient and all had bad results. read more

#ClevelandPizzaWeek This place is down the road from my work so I decided to try it out since it's pizza week! I'm always one to throw hot sauce on my pizza- and just about anything I eat! I had to try a slice without it first to get the full effect of flavor. No ragrets LOL!!! the char taste of the little pepperonis was soo on point! And the crust has such a good flavor to it, as well as the perfect amount of crunch and softness. It took about 30 min to be ready from when I ordered it, which is a little longer than the average 20 min for a medium pizza, but I imagine they're busy! read more

Master Pizza - 12" Pepperoni Passion - Pizza Near Me - Mayfield Heights, Ohio

After being a loyal customer since my friends and I started going in to the original location in Mayfield Hts. In high school (mid 1980's tonight they officially loste as a customer. I didn't say anything when they charged me forty six dollars and change for two SMALL pizzas and a salad... But when I asked for one more container of salad dressing and was told "ok, that will be another dollar" they lost me. Hey Mike (the owner) PIGS GET FED, HOGS GET SLAUGHTERED! read more

We always eat Master Pizza and they never disappoint. We usually get takeout but there's nothing like eating your pizza fresh out the oven! It's so good!! If y'all haven't tried them yet, you're missing a good thing. read more

Master Pizza - My favorite pizza pepperoni and pineapple. My husband's favorite pizza sausage with extra cheese. - Pizza Near Me - Mayfield Heights, Ohio

Great customer service for being a chain is probably one of the better pizza places around the Mayfield area. They're very consistent and the pizzas is very good if you're looking for a good decent pizza this is the place. read more

Some of THE pizza I've ever eaten. Very greasy but oh so worth it. The cheese was so melty and cooked perfectly, and it balanced so well with the sweet sauce and dough. Everything overall was incredible, and I will definitely be getting this pizza again when visiting the Cleveland area. Overall amazing!!! read more

Master Pizza - Pepperoni pizza - Pizza Near Me - Mayfield Heights, Ohio

Master Pizza has been a family favorite since I was a child! We love all of the different pizzas on the menu and I often cater Master Pizza for lunch at work. They offer delivery, but also have a dining room that's great for a family meal or to catch up with friends! read more

See all

It's ok pizza. You can purchase by the slice and get in and out quickly. Not sure if the pizza is my favorite.

Pizza was over 30 minutes past time it was supposed to be ready. Today was the first playoff game so you'd think they'd anticipate increased demand. The Bear, they were not. They were super chill. I sat I. Their cold, dull dining room for over 30 minutes. Couldn't watch the game because " their tv was broken." While I waited, they never offered me a glass of water or anything. Bottom line: they don't really value their customers read more

Sorry... after over 35 years as a customer you lost me when I paid $42.00 for two small pizzas and a salad then you insisted on charging me an extra $1.00 for a second ounce of dressing. Pigs get fed hogs get slaughtered! read more

My co-workers treated me to Master Pizza this week for lunch. They even called our order in ahead so it would be ready when we got there. Upon arrival, we were promptly seated and a few minutes later, our salad arrived. The salad and dressing were very tasty and there was a lot of it. A few minutes later, the pizza arrived. It looked and smelled wonderful! The pizza was not too thick and it had the right balance between dough and toppings. The pepperoni was fresh and the pizza was delicious! The service was excellent. I am looking forward to visiting again to try a calzone and other pizzas. Recommend! read more

Master Pizza - Large pepperoni - Pizza Near Me - Mayfield Heights, Ohio

I grew up with Master Pizza in Mayfield Heights, always a Family Favorite. Now I live in NYC, the West Village, home to Joe's Pizza, and a ton of other great spots. I was just in Cleveland, and stopped in for dinner. Hands Down, Master Pizza is the Best Pizza in the world!!! A Large 1/2 Mushroom, 1/2 Pepperoni pie, UNBEATABLE!!! I give all the credit to Old Man Petti, the original owner and chef of Master Pizza!! Still the exact taste that I loved as a kid about 30 years ago. read more

We had a large, thin crust pizza with one topping. It was delicious and perfect for the Browns game.

With all of the pizza chains around, Master Pizza is my go to Pizza place around Mayfield. I ordered a large sausage and pepperoni and after devouring my portion of the Pizza, my stomach felt like it had hit the jackpot. I always go for their garlic bread which is a nice little appetizer before the main pie. Will definitely be back. read more

Master Pizza - a pizza in a pizza box - Pizza Near Me - Mayfield Heights, Ohio

See all

As far as pizza in the area, Master is master, in my opinion. Always great taste, friendly staff, good prices. Recommended.

I've had pizza here many time over the years but haven't had one for a while . I placed a order on the phone for a Detroit style pizza which I've had in the past here, and it used to be great . Well when I pulled up and looked at the big Help wanted sign in the window and then I got worried.. Sure enough the pizza was a train wreck , nothing like it was before, and certainly not tasty at all, if fact I've had much better Detroit style straight out of the box frozen from the supermarket. Nothing good last for ever . Don't waste 18 - 20 bucks for a pizza that sucks. maybe try somewhere else. read more

Master Pizza - The pizza not to get! - Pizza Near Me - Mayfield Heights, Ohio

Maybe some of the best pizza in Cleveland. Detroit style was good. Regular zah was also better than average. This would be my go to if it was a bit closer. read more

Not only were they friendly, but quick service too considering the times right now. They maintained a safe distance and I got my pizza in 20 minutes! It was delicious and super tasty! Sadly I don't have a picture because we devoured it the minute we got it but we ordered a large buffalo chicken pizza and it was amazing! read more

Ordered a few pies and some toasted ravioli. I have been going here for years, dining in. This was our first go with online ordering and takeout. The web portal was pretty user friendly and we were able to order up a large Popeye and a medium black olive to go with our ravioli. The ravioli were breaded lightly and had a good crunch. The sauce to go with it was superb and had a good amount of garlic to go with the quality tomato ingredients. Our longtime favorite has been the popeye that has a garlic sauce, cheese blend, tomatoes, artichokes. And spinach. The crust was perfectly done and has a great garlic taste. The olive pizza is pretty simple and the red sauce is a little sweet. The pickup was simple and easy. Drive up... and call the number in the window. They come out to your car with mask and gloves... and drop it off. Simple! read more

Delicious pizza, very friendly staff! I've never been disappointed with the food or the service here. They offer a buffalo chicken pizza if you're looking for something different that is always a favorite when I've ordered for parties. I also think it's nice that they will provide you with paper plates and utensils if you ask. read more

Several people have made the statement that this is best pizza in Cleveland. Although I cannot confirm that, I can say without any hesitation that this is on the list of top 3 best pizzas I've ever tried anywhere, period. The double pepperoni with artichoke was extremely flavorful, you could taste the quality of ingredients. Freshness, quality and exquisite preparation. I will now be a regular here. read more

Master Pizza - Double pepperoni and artichoke - Pizza Near Me - Mayfield Heights, Ohio

See all

Master Pizza has a $5.00 lunch special. I decided to try it before I ordered a whole pizza and I am glad I did. The sauce on the pizza is disgustingly SWEET. I have never had a pizza like it. I called and complained and was told they know, that they get alot of complaints. Well, then why don't they correct it??? I will NEVER get a pizza or anything from them again. I imagine everything with the sauce is equally awful. I guess they don't care about customer satisfaction. They would not give me a refund. No problem, learned my lesson at only $5.00 - many other GOOD pizza places to order from. AH read more

Had a quick day trip to Cleveland, wanted pizza or pasta. Reviews for this place checked out so I walked in the place an order. I was treated quickly and given a few suggestions. I end up going with a small Philly Calzone. Within 15/20 min my food was ready, food was fresh and delicious. The bread was tasty and seasoned well, it was full of lots of peppers and onions. It also came with a side or ranch and marinara which I didn't end up using much of due to the taste of the food. I would def go back again for pizza :) read more

Master Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Mayfield Heights, Ohio

Tonight we treated ourselves to a pizza. Since it was raining we decided to splurge and have it delivered. We ordered a pizza, salad, and loaded potatoes. Our food arrived promptly and steaming hot. The delivery driver was very nice and called us shortly before he arrived which we really appreciated since we have dogs. Our pizza was very good, the crust done to perfection. If you know Master Pizza, you know about their House Dressing. Do yourself a favor and order extra. It's so good you'll be glad you did. All in all a great meal from a family friendly restaurant. Thank you Master Pizza!! read more

Make Em Say Uhh!!! Uhhh!!! Yah, Ya, Yah, Ya!!! --Master P. Master Pizza has probably been around for much longer than the aforementioned No Limit Soldier, but you know what? Master Pizza made me say Yah, not Nah, Na, Nah, Na. Better than average pizza dough, flavorful sauce, greasy cheese and quality toppings (ie. thick chunks of bulk sausage w/ fennel seeds), not the typical unsavory grayish slices. A 50% off coupon from an entertainment book brought me to Master Pizza recently. Located in an unassuming plaza on Mayfield Rd, just across from WalMart, expectations weren't the highest. I've never been here, never heard about it, but decided to give it a shot. And I'm glad I did. Although we didn't eat in, they do have a small dining area. We chose to take the pie home. Sinfully greasy, I was presently surprised at how great this pie was! It's definitely in the running for my top 5 pizza joint's on the East Side list which I'll be compiling shortly. read more

Just going off Matthew M's review, this place is bout it bout it. There was a Master Pizza in Lakewood growing up. I always liked the logo. It is like an Italian dude in a cowboy stance popping his collar. One of my friend's thought it was great when we were kids. A friend at work said he would eat this pizza with his wife when she was going to doctor visits on the east side. We ate it for lunch today. It is Friday in lent so people didn't want to eat it because it has meat on it. So the cleaning lady just came by my cubilcle and offered the scraps! So happy about this! It is all mine! I will use this later after having a few beers so I don't get a hangover! Hooray for Master Pizza! I really think it deserves 3 stars. This is a situational review. read more

I have been eating Master pizza since I was a kid! Stopped in yesterday, what a disappointment! Nothing was the same! Didn't even have coffee! The sauce was completely changed, so sad. Why mess with a good thing? If it's worked in the past 50? Years? read more

BEST PIZZA IN CLEVELAND AREA! This is the original Master Pizza that I had every week in the 1960s, they are still using that recipe from the originators! This location has been here for many many years, and it's fantastic. This is not a fancy place, but that makes it even better that it is your local Pizzeria. It is delicious pizza, and the service was very friendly. I LOVE it here, and I wish I lived closer. Any time I am out on the East Side, I have to eat here. Best pizza this side of New York City! I am so glad they are still around! read more

THIS is the THE Original Master Pizza I grew up with over 30 years ago in Lakewood. It is the same taste, excellent quality ingredients and perfect balance I've always loved about Master Pizza. I went to the new location on Bagley Rd in Middleburg Hts. All I can say it that you must try it! It deserves every accolade and pizza contest victory it has received. I picked it up from a great distance away twice in one week. They also have dine in and the restaurant appeared to be clean and new througout. A good family pizza place with plenty of room. YOU MUST HAVE THIS PIZZA. It is a 10. My family agrees read more

I have been a huge fan of this pizza shop. I even voted for them. As we know sometimes we can grow too fast. We have had several problems with Master pizza including tonight. We have been waiting close to an hour and a half. With no call from them at all..ordered a penne pasta from them last week and got spaghetti.i will post picture of the receipt with the food. Dont take a genius to figure it out..going down. Very fast..i guess we would feel better if they showed us a little respect and they gave a crap. Think twice b4 u call. Great food when its right. But not worth the hassle anymore. read more

Master Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Mayfield Heights, Ohio

I grew up eating Master Pizza. It's not what I remember but it's an ok pizza. Had a Medium pepperoni and sausage, their sausage is pretty good. The crust is too "bready" thick and soft. I would eat it again if someone else had one but I wouldn't order again with so many other choices. read more

I have been eating this pizza my entire life, more than 30 years. It is hands down my favorite pizza in the entire world, and I have eaten pizza in Italy! The crust is real crust, not this crazy flat, no edge crust Columbus, Ohio people seem to love. The cheese is delicious and they do not skimp on it. I almost only get pepperoni and the pepperoni is my favorite pepperoni. This is a greasy, mouth watering, wonderful temptation. I have lived in Columbus for over 12 years and EVERY time I am visiting Cleveland (which is several times a year) I get a pizza from here. I sometimes get one to take back home also. This pizza also reheats amazingly well in the oven. My husband sometimes likes it better reheated (only in the oven! no microwave!)! I should also mention my husband has never lived in Cleveland and this is now one of his favorite pizza places also! The restaurant itself is very small and there is not enough seating. Pizza is something we almost exclusively get to go so that doesn't bother me but if you do want to actually eat there, be aware that it's not the easiest place to snag a table at. read more

Ordered here for the first time a couple days ago. I ordered a small double cheese pizza. That's it. Ready in 40 minutes. Ok. Stopped in to pick it up and first was surprised by how small a small pizza actually is here. It's literally about the size other places call a "personal" size. Then there is the price. $9.25. What?!! Holy cow. A VERY small double cheese with absolutely no toppings...$9.25! Yikes! As far as the taste goes, it tasted fine and I liked the cheese ok. The dough was just ok. I was still hungry after eating this thing. Way too little for the price paid. Considering everything, I would much rather purchase a large 1 topping pizza at one of those $5 for a large pizza places. May not be quite the quality of Master Pizza, but I would be paying half the price and walking away with a full gut. read more

BEST PIZZA IN CLEVELAND - hands down!!! I've been going here since before I can I remember and it's a favorite spot for the whole family. Still haven't found a better pizza place, nothing can beat Master Pizza! read more

Master Pizza - Cheese pizza - best in Cleveland!! - Pizza Near Me - Mayfield Heights, Ohio

This place is a hidden gem and one of my favorite pizza places in cle. I love the house dressing and am a huge fan of the buffalo chicken. What a great quick, casual pizza spot! read more

This is probably one of my favorite pizza places (outside of Chicago:-), I prefer local pizza places over national chains. The crust is just right, not too thin, not too thick. I love, love, love the Italian sausage, nice size pieces with lots of fennel. The sauce is also very tasty. The staff is always very welcoming. Definitely my go-to place for good pizza. read more

The best pizza in the Cleveland area! Great crust great cheese. Be sure to try the meatballs?

Good, but not great. I went here after my friends and I saw this pizza shop had received national attention on clevescene.com. We ordered the master Popeye and master deluxe pizzas. They were okay, but not worthy of national recognition, from our opinions. It could have been that we had anticipated this pizza to be so amazing, and then it was sort of a letdown. We stayed there to eat. There was a large party in the dining area. One of the party members was throwing spitballs, that I had been hit by accidentally. When I looked up to see what happened, he started talking about how I was staring at him, pretty loudly. This knocked the experience down another star for me. I know this place has multiple locations, so maybe the pizza and experience could have been better a different location. I know I won't be going back. read more

Master Pizza - Master Popeye - Pizza Near Me - Mayfield Heights, Ohio

See all