Great pizza! Lots of cheese and toppings. We got one regular crust with pepperoni and extra cheese, and then one gluten free taco pizza. It really hit the spot! The gluten free crust is nice and thin and not at all dry or crumbly. The pizza had good flavor and was a really nice change of pace. The other pepperoni pizza was good too. There wasn't much to say on the ambiance, it's basically just a takeout place. The guys were We will definitely be going back to try other combinations:) read more

Total rip off, small pizzas don't Terribly and overpriced. Do not support places that charge 18 inch prices for a 12 inch price. Not cool, not even good. read more

I came across PJays pizza watching New Day Cleveland. We saw the pizzas and immediately bought the deal! I ordered the Jumbo 3 top pizza, 12 garlic parm traditional wings and 12 mild buffalo. I also ordered the chicken salad and an order of French fries. Everything was amazing! Every bite made us very happy we made the right decision for lunch today! Everyone was happy. The woman who I placed the order with and made our food was very polite and her manager was nice too. Transaction was smooth with the new day deal and paid difference. We will definitely drive from North Olmsted again to grab excellent food. Thank you for not disappointing us! read more

P.Jay’s Pizza - Jumbo 3 topping. Italian sausage, pepperoni and mushrooms and light sauce for $17.99. Soooooo delicious pizza perfection! - Pizza Near Me - Parma, Ohio

This is not a restaurant, but they do have good pizza., and other things you would expect in a pizza place. There was no service from behind the counter, and the ambiance was, well just like a lot of other pizza places. All I can say was the pizza I have gotten there was better than most chains. read more

Pizza was absolutely amazing! Veggies still had bite to them and let's not forget about the Italian sausage on it! Huge to say the least. We customized our pizza, 1st time customers as well. Definitely going to order again! read more

Ordered a pizza, Stromboli and the cookie for dinner for three ppl. ~The pizza was supposed to have, and I paid for, extra pepperoni. Nope just regular pepperoni pizza. ~The Stromboli was advertised to have banana peppers...it didn't. It's a real shame bc without them it's just not as good. ~The cookie was fine a little small but very rich you only need a small piece at a time. Not a great dinner. Probably wouldn't order from here again. read more

Pizza and salad were very good. Delivery was in less than 30 minutes even though I was given an estimate of an hour. Will definitely order from there again. read more

Heard good things about PJ's Pizza so I decided to make the 20 minutes trek to try it out and it didn't disappoint. Got a traditional veggie pizza and the sauce was tasty, not too sweet. Tried something entirely different with the potato pierogi za and it was like eating a twice baked potato which I love. Finished off with a sampling of the apple pizza and it was tasty. Definitely would recommend PJ's Pizza. read more

One of our favorite lunches at work. Consistently well made. Great pizza and wings. Friendly staff and good prices.

I searched for pasta via Door Dash and PJays came up. Prices looked reasonable so I gave it a try. I got the spaghetti and meat sauce and that was really delicious. It came with a small side salad that was only lettuce with a little diced tomato and red onion (yuck) on it .. took me awhile to fish all of the little pieces of onion out. I opted for the honey French dressing so the salad once de-onioned and the dressing added was edible and fresh tasting for what it was .. really just a pile of lettuce and diced tomatoes. I would order from this place again. read more

pjays is or go to! great for parties and everyone is super friendly! Just the right amount of sauce to

I am not sure why the ratings are so low! we ordered food for eight people, and it was ready and under an hour for pick up! when I got the food, it was still hot and very flavorful, and not too greasy! I wish I could speak to how the place looked however, I did not pick up the food so for ambience I apologize you will have to view other reviews! read more

See all

Place doesn't look like much from the outside, but some of the best takeout pizza joints don't. P Jay's Pizza is a lil pizza shop near the intersection of Ridge and Snow roads in Parma and I genuinely enjoy their pizza. Hey he sign for them on Ridge isn't much, but there's ample parking in the rear parking lot with a takeout entrance. Just give em a hollar and let me know whatcha need. They'll get your order ready and then when you park in the back, go in the back entrance and walk all the way to the front register to be served. You'll pass the kitchen and the ovens, in case you wanna see the works. We ordered an extra large deluxe and I emailed to ask if they offer take and bake pizzas. Mainly because I was going to be in the area around noon and wanted to pick up a pizza I could bake later that evening. The awesome folks at P Jay's got back to me quick and offered fantastic advice. They said they offer a half baked pizza that I could finish baking later. They even asked in I had a convection oven and provide excellent instructions for baking. The pizza came out amazing and had wonderful cheese, a savory sauce, plentiful quality toppings, and a tasty crunchy crust. I could not find a single thing wrong with that pizza. Just look at the pics! read more

See all

The Parma area pizza shops must be known for their large pizzas being on the smaller end. Ordered pizza for delivery and was impressed with the large selection of specials they had to offer. I decided to go with the (2) 1-topping, large pizzas. You can't beat this special for around $20 including delivery. The pizza wasn't my favorite in the parma area. The sauce was a little too sweet for my liking but overall the pizza was okay. read more

See all

I spent an hour composing a fair & detailed review on Google Reviews & it wouldn't post. We got the New Day Cleveland $25 for $50 deal. You get 2 certificates. They are good on take-out or dine-in. We had never been there so I looked at the website menu. The first order was 2 lrg. pizzas. Sausage & m.rooms & bacon and chicken, g.pep. & bacon. I was never asked what SIZE toppings I wanted. The bill was $35. This time we got 2 lrg. pizzas with sausage & m/rooms, and m.balls & g.pep. "Jumbo" size toppings. The online menu is not clear as to what you are getting or paying for. The bill was $31. No matter how I try to figure out the cost, it won't come out like they say. The pizzas were ready on time. They were very greasy so PJ's put a waxy paper under each one. But this made it hard to get the slices out of the box w/o getting paper in the food especially since the crust was barely cut. The meatballs come in slices. There was about one piece per pizza slice. In general, the taste was fine. We may or may not be back. read more

I have been getting P.Jays since I was a teen and have always enjoyed it. The sauce is on the sweeter side. It's pretty cheesy, and the crust is crispy on the outside-soft on the inside. We really enjoy everything we get. The jojos are great, and we love the sauce they come with. We usually order the pierogi pizza, which is pretty good imo. We never have issues with getting our order. read more

Hands down, the best pizza in Parma! We ordered the supreme pizza. They also have amazing stromboli's!!

was just delivered the worst pizza I've ever had in my life from P.Jays. It was a speciality pizza called Sicilian Sausage. When you bake a pizza with sausage on it, the grease will exit the sausage, and filter down to the crust. Imagine a pizza filled with sausage and what would happen. And that's exactly what I got. A grease laden crust so wet, and disgusting, you could actually pick up a piece and watch grease drip from it. Never ever again. read more

See all

My parents wanted to order pizza Friday night and they didn't want to dine in. So I ordered a large mushroom, sausage, and black olive for my parents. I ordered a large stromboli with hot peppers for me, and a small cheese pizza for my kids. Delivery took 45 minutes as indicated. The pizza was hot and fresh. The sausage and mushrooms were large and very tasty. My stromboli was very good. The peppers had just a hint of heat. I was hoping for a little more kick there. The mozzarella and ham were tasty. I grew up eating oily stromboli and this was dry by comparison. We haven't eaten PJ's pizza in a long time, so we were due. We liked it and we would order it again. read more

P.Jay’s Pizza - Large stromboli - delish - Pizza Near Me - Parma, Ohio

See all

Was delivered right on time and made perfectly! 2 large 2 topping pizzas for $7.99 each and no charge for the 2 toppings on each half Delicious! read more

P.Jay’s Pizza - Large Half cheese, half crab and shrimp mix and spinach - Pizza Near Me - Parma, Ohio

See all

Have had this quite a few times. I'm from Chicago, and we really don't have pizza like this anywhere where I live. Authentic Cleveland-style pizza. Great! read more

I highly recommend getting your next pizza from Lee @P.Jays Pizza. The owner made me my favorite pizza , which is pepperoni, banana pepper, and it was phenomenal. read more

Ever since I moved to Parma pjays has been my number 1 go to for pizza the food is great they have great deals if you want good pizza go to pjays thanks pjays for the excellent service and great food read more

Glad I tried this place. Love their garlic white sauce, I won't get anything else. And using their online ordering I see they gave a big crust option. Oh lawd, this Italian went to heaven. Bubbly crust ooooooohhh! Get in my beOld world sausage? Don't mind if I do. They have a big menu but I have yet to try anything else than pizza . read more

P.Jay’s Pizza - Large cheese pizza; thick crust; white garlic sauce. We love it - Pizza Near Me - Parma, Ohio

See all

I wish I could tell you whether or not P.Jay's is good, but they refused to even make my order due to some dispute over a Doordash promotion. When I arrived to pickup my order, I was told that "All Doordash orders are cancelled today." No warning, no notice, no apology. The manager even argued that I hadn't placed an order at all. After showing my receipt, she very rudely told me to deal with Doordash directly. I completely understand that sometimes mistakes happen, but there's no excuse for not informing the customer that you've canceled their order and then being completely rude about it. Let's hope their pizza isn't as salty as their attitude. read more

Service was good, and I thought the pizza was pretty decent. Only had one kind with one-topping, but I'd rank it over most of the chains.

Meh. That really does sum up my entire experience. The large salad (~$5) has a ridiculous amount of cheese, 4 tomato wedges, and lettuce that was wet. They make spin driers for a reason. Great that they do the sanitary thing and wash their lettuce. Most don't. Got a black olive half sheet pizza (~$16). Pizza was nothing special. In fact it was better cold the next day. It was almost a poor Convenient Food Mart pizza clone. Maybe their normal pizzas are made differently? Doubt we will be back to find out. Redeeming the experience was the hot wings (~$9/dozen). They actually had a bit of spiciness, which is lacking in the area. This might bring us back. Breadsticks (3 for $2.50) were pretty good - light and airy. Other pluses are the staff is very courteous and this is the only place we've encountered in the Parma area that includes their menu with orders (take note competitors). read more

See all

It is as hot as an inferno in the store.... they dont make orders on time and then lie about the wait times!!! I would not recommend anyone waste their time patronizing this business!!! They are unprofessional and slow and not forthright about when the food will be ready read more

They had a promotion today via DoorDash that unfortunately seemed to have ended up being a mistake. Received no notice of an order being cancelled. Was notified my order was ready to pick up via DoorDash. All I said was hello and that I'm here to pick up an order. The lady up front asked if it was DoorDash and I confirmed it was. The lady immediately copped an attitude and said all DoorDash orders were cancelled and to take it up with DoorDash. No explanation of why or an apology. I'm fine that it was a mistake and that they wouldn't honor the promotion, but they didn't need to have an attitude. The last time I had it, it wasn't the greatest. Was willing to give them another chance and would have done so in the future if it wasn't for how rude the lady at the front was. read more

I had the seafood pizza........ it was okay. I felt like it was missing a really good sauce and cheese. I expected something more supple.... the shrimp was kind of rubbery read more

Wanted to try a new pizza place in my area. Found this place on door dash. Definitely not my favorite pizza place around. I ordered the thick crust pizza. I did not realize that thick "crust" meant that the crust around the pizza was super thick while the rest of the pizza was super thin. So thin in fact that it could not hold the topping on it and they all fell off when I picked up the slice to eat. Flavor was good so maybe I'll try again some other time with regular crust. read more

I've learned new owners here. I've been a super frequent delivery/pick up customer. Flavors are pretty good, however NOW, if you get a LARGE Za, expect it to not be completely covered w/ cheese (1/2 in circumference; around the middle only). A SMALL Za is completely covered with cheese. Sounds petty??? - I guess I'm used to the higher standards before new owner took over. CHEAP skimming on cheese to cover za. Plain Jane cheap. read more

Ordered for the first time and they gave me the wrong pizza and the pizza was wet at the bottom. Also gave me cheese fries that were stuck to the aluminum and wet underneath. Called business manager was rude. Stay far away! read more

Great steak subs!! The pasta is also very good! Love supporting a local business and this one gets five stars from us! Big portions and very quick!! read more

Blah. I ordered a small pizza w half pepperoni and half sausage, bread sticks and a 2 litter. Almost $18. Def not worth it. My bread sticks were not bread sticks, they were flat pizza crust w sauce that was so thick I couldn't even get it out of the container. Won't order again from there. Also Sent a message on Facebook to the pizza place. It was read and I got no response in return. Wow. read more

P.Jay’s Pizza - Not breadsticks. Hard as a rock. And sauce wasn't sauce it was tomato paste. - Pizza Near Me - Parma, Ohio

See all

For years this was my go to place for pizza. Recently they have cut back. The sausage used to in large chunks. Now it looks like small crumbs. The pepperoni seemed to be limited to 1 or 2 per slice. One time the crust is burnt. One time it's almost raw. I won't go back. I can get better at the grocery store. Very sad. read more

I ordered the deal for 12x12 with a large pizza and 12 wing to feed 5 people. assuming a large has 12 pieces given the deal and the website does not show the amount of pieces, They gave me a TINY pizza so I called to tell them they gave me the wrong size and the lady told me the size of the pizza is 12 inches.... Who would ever guess a 12x12 deal would go by the inches and not the AMOUNT OF PIECES?? Overpriced and bad customer service read more

Pj's has consistently had our vote as one of the best pizza places in town. Their crust is to die for. We usually get the sheet pizzas and they have always been awesome no matter what toppings we get. Ingredients are always fresh. Just love that they use bulk sausage instead of those strange little kibble like sausage! read more

Big Money for Small Pizzas. If what I got was a large, I could only imagine that a small would be the size of a DVD. Pierogie Pizza: Just normal pizza crust, layer of mashed potato / onion, and a slight sprinkle of cheese. A very small "Large" pizza for 14 bucks. For what you get (mashed potatoes and bread) I think this one needs to drop a few bucks. Wing Prices are competitive, and very good. I would not hesitate to recommend the wings to a friend any day! read more

We tried to love this local pizza place and gave it too many chances. 6 of 7 orders were wrong and had to be remade! Nothing special just a half sheet deluxe, how do you mess that up 6 times!! Today was the last straw. Got our usual.... it was burnt black on 3/4 of the bottom. The owner tried to argue that it wasn't and we had to flip every piece over to show him. He said "be happy you got a free pizza." Uh no.... this is the pizza we already paid for that you remade! Then he said if you don't like it don't come back, well we certainly won't! read more