Romito's Pizza West has some of the best Italian pizza around. My favorite way to order it is well-done with onions, mushrooms, extra sauce, and extra pepperoni. If you give it a try, let me know what you think! The customer service is amazing. They never have a problem accommodating special requests, and everyone is always polite, friendly, and welcoming. It truly feels like a family-owned business that cares about its customers and takes pride in what they do. Great food, great people, and a great experience every time. read more

Just arrived home and opened my pizza box and my pizza toppings look like this. Pizza was placed on flat surface in my vehicle on the drive. Saw a review about this same issue and thought everyone's experience is different and decided to still place an order. read more

Romito's Pizza West - Pizza toppings - Pizza Near Me - Independence, Ohio

See all

I ordered take out here for lunch. The staff were very attentive and made my order very quickly. I had a cheese pizza. It was full of flavor. It gives old school pizza parlor. read more

Romito's Pizza West - Cheese pizza - Pizza Near Me - Independence, Ohio

Traveling in area. Went with Yelp recommendations. Ordered a large pie for delivery, took about 45min to independence Embassy Suites-not long at all in my opinion. Good pie overall, generous on toppings. Would return & recommend :) read more

please tell me my pizza wasn't as good as it usually is because they were busy! My pepperoni was missing and the crust was so hard I couldn't chew it. I love this place and I so looked forward to my usual pepperoni, sausage, and black olive pizza! I'm not giving up and I will look forward to my perfect pizza on Friday! read more

We got a large pepperoni pizza and an order of breadsticks as a pickup order from Romito's West last night. The price is competitive, the food was ready quickly, and the pizza was solid. Good crust, good sauce, good cheese. Overall very enjoyable. Only point of improvement is that our pizza wasn't cut well-- we couldn't pull the slices apart very well. Normally we'd grab a knife and cut it better ourselves, but we were staying at a hotel and didn't have access to a knife. read more

FINALLY, a 5 star pizza review in Cleveland! I got a carry out 1 topping with extra sauce which cost me $13. The crust tasted freshly made, the cook had a slight perfect crisp to it too. The cheese was delicious and had the stringy pull factor. I had a decent amount of sauce on the pie after requesting extra sauce too. Broccoli was fresh and not frozen which was a plus too. I have been let down by local competitors due to skimpy sauce and frozen ingredients recently. I finally found a pizza place close by I want to return to. Friendly service too. read more

Hey hey, I'm back . . . again. Wife and I enjoyed the pizza here last night. We started with a Chef Salad which we split, and then we had a large Pepperoni, Sausage, and Mushroom pizza and it was perfect. The food deserves 5 Stars and only reason it's rated just a 4 above, is the Ambiance, or should I say the lack thereof. (I'm chuckling) But we don't care about that here. The pizza makes up for it. Just wish we lived closer. Keep up the good work guys!!! read more

I thought the pizza was good, the salad was also good. I would go back again. The value was there for sure.

Had great pizza and cheese sticks! Nothing fancy, just great ingredients! Really great service as well! Would definitely come back.

I'm from out of town and was looking for a good pie to take back to my hotel. Nice guy on the phone helped me build my medium black olive, green olive and mushroom. It was hot and ready to go in under 20 minutes and very delicious. Great stuff. read more

Romito's Pizza West - Medium 3 toppings. - Pizza Near Me - Independence, Ohio

Went in to eat with my family, flys took over the whole restaurant. I may have ate 289 flys in a 25 minute sitting. Close the door. Pizza was mid. service was non existent. Order only takeout if you sit in, be ready to fight fly's for the whole time you are there. Disgusting. Never again. Fake Italian. I would rather have papa John's. And that means something. read more

Lived in 5 cities around the country. This is easily one of the best pizza places EVER! Legit good. Sure the aesthetics are not the best, but that is part of the charm. Do yourself a favor and get some pizza here. read more

Out of towner review : I wanted a good, local pizza, got exactly that. Not only were the pizza and wings excellent, but you could feel the mutual support of the community. read more

Romito's Pizza West - Wings - Pizza Near Me - Independence, Ohio

See all

This is probably in my Top 3 pizza places in Cleveland. It doesn't get the hype of some other places but you really just can't beat it. Salad, pizza and fountain coke. Really not much better in life at a counter service pizza spot. Pro Tip: Order the salad and pizza but grab a chicken parm hold the pasta read more

Romito's Pizza West - Pepperoni and Extra Cheese - Pizza Near Me - Independence, Ohio

The pizza here is delicious! Everyone was nice and I would call it an upscale hole in the wall. Definitely coming back!

Very excellent pizza definitely has become my new favorite in Cleveland most definitely read more

Romito's Pizza West - Large pepperoni Two Items Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Independence, Ohio

See all

Hot and delicious... always looking for a good pizza place while traveling for work and this did it. Will be back. Only issue was parking is tight so I parked down the street. read more

I have to apologize to Romito's for not yelping this amazing local gem sooner. Romito's has been enjoyed by my family for decades. The quality has remained stellar and they have never changed the recipe. They're crust has to be the best!!! It is soft and chewy under the cheese and sweet and crispy at the crust. The sauce has a wonderful rich, classic oregano taste. The cheese is top notch and you can tell by the fact that it could stretch for miles! Gooey and delicious! read more

Good pizza find just off the main path in Independence. Ordered a sausage and pepperoni pizza and cheesy garlic bread. Pizza was tasty except I wasn't a fan of the sausage which had a lot of fennel seeds. The garlic bread was kind of small for the price. read more

In the moment, the pizza tastes great; however keep in mind you are consuming an ungodly amount of grease. I remember having a slight stomach ache the night I ate the pizza when I got it delivered. The next day had the pizza again for lunch, and my body was like "nahh son" and I was B-lining to the bathroom multiple times after eating. I don't feel like they're horrible, but I'll never personally get them again. read more

Pizza was really good! Would have been better if it was sliced into pieces. Easy to access store front read more

Romito's Pizza West - About 3 pieces were sliced. The rest was not - Pizza Near Me - Independence, Ohio

Everything was great. The service on the phone was good, the salad and homemade dressing was great and the rigatoni was awesome. However, I am the pizza guy. I'm giving the restaurant four stars but the pizza I would only give 3 stars. The crust was good however, it lacked in sauce. I don't know if it's because it was a sheet pizza or what but they must put more sauce on this pizza and I believe it would be great. I will try it again, but will ask for extra sauce. read more

Solid pizza solid price, thicker buttery crust with fresh toppings. Perfect for post hockey meal. read more

Romito's Pizza West - Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Independence, Ohio

This is the best pizza in the area. The sauce has a good flavor to it and the crust is outstanding. I always told them to a little longer like my Pizza more done. Just a little extra sauce so you can reheat it the next day. It's really good. And their local people that work there and own it. Worth the trip. Small eating area inside, but does it smell good in there? read more

Exactly what we were looking for when traveling! Friendly service, constant action with phones ringing and cooks in a great rhythm, solid food and plain old comfortable. Reasonable prices to boot! Can tell it's a locals' favorite by all the carry-out orders, so it's gotta be good! Would love to find a spot like this in every town we visit. read more

We love the sheet pizza! Always ready on time and consistent, been coming here for years and it's in our regular rotation of favorite Cleveland pizza spots! read more

I really wanted Romito's to be good, but it's tasteless. The sauce is more like tomato soup than pizza sauce. The dough doesn't have much flavor. The crust was just ok. The pepperoni isn't even spicy. In fact, it just made the pizza horribly greasy. Unfortunately, I'd rather visit a pizza chain than go back Romito's. read more

Had a large pizza. So much cheese and sausage it caused a meat-slide of the ingredients to one side. Delicious!!

We had a cheese and a pepperoni sheet pizza. We also had 3 types of wings. Had I been the one to pick up the order I would have left those burnt wings at the store. The pizza was good but I certainly cannot recommend the wings. What a wasted $60. I wish I had taken a picture. So disappointed. read more

What a wonderful spot! The pizza was amazing and the staff was so nice. We had a great salad to start. Nice little spot to eat inside but most business looks to be delivery or carry out. The dairy king custard next door was stellar as well. Yum! read more

Romito's West catered our family reunion yesterday in Sagamore Hills for 85 people and the food was fantastic!! It was delivered - on time - and was packaged well and very hot!! They have the best Italian sausage and peppers in town and the pizza went fast!! Thanks again for making our family reunion special!! Your team is the best!! read more

First time ordering and it won't be the last. It was delicious. Fresh mushrooms, great sausage and the extra cheese was definitely extra. It was fast too! The pizza was hot, and the cheese had a great pull. The pricing is extremely reasonable. I'm so glad I decided to give it a try. I do believe I've found my local pizza place after searching for two years! read more

We went here looking for a sit down pizza place. It has a nice seating area but we were the only ones taking advantage of it. It was super busy with take out and delivery which excited me to try the food. We got the basic pizza place meal, a large pepperoni pizza with the hot wings. The wing sauce was really good (not too hot) and the wings were large and cooked well. The pizza hit all the right notes. The bottom was crispy and the pizza was cooked through. It had a ton of cheese. I wonder what it would have looked like if I had ordered extra cheese. read more

Great pizza, quick delivery! We always like to find local pizza joints when we travel and Romito's was a winner.

I never thought that I would dislike a slice of pizza until I tried Romitos. They somehow managed to ruin the reputation of pizza and I will never purchase again. Do yourself a favor and get pizza from somewhere else. read more

Romito's is me and my and boys favorite pizza ever! We order a sheet and eat for a couple days then freeze and reheat! Delivery is efficient and timely! Only $2 for delivery, and they have coupons online always. The drivers are always polite. Phone manners? Pretty bad most of the time. They sent us food that they substituted for something else, without even calling us to ask, then didn't even call to apologize. Doesn't make us not want to come back because the pizza is that good but they should know that customer service matters to their guests. Still our favorite though! read more

By far the best pizza in Cleveland and maybe anywhere in the country. The fact this isnt even in the top 5 on yelp shows that yelp is full of shit and that consumers buy in to propaganda. If you're getting pizza anywhere else, you're a major loser read more

It's small pizza place not your typical pizza chain, it's nice to try something different.

Customer service was horrible and disrespectful and just plain rude. I was trying to make a order and the man on the phone sounded like he didn't even want to be at work today. I ordered before I enjoyed the pizza but the service today was horrible and I would never put money into their pockets again, the breadsticks aren't even good and the first time I did get my order they left my delivery with someone else I had to go find it so all in all two thumbs down. read more