Good bakery. Outrageous prices. They have become another Villabate Alba. Service is good. But,13 small rugelach (3/4 pound) $19.50! $9.00 for two cannoli. To be fair their cakes and pies are a more reasonable, just avoid the the glass counter unless you are willing to mortgage your house. read more

Traditional Italian bakery tucked away. We were in the area to see Christmas lights and saw this was nearby and decided we needed something to warm ourselves up. The staff was friendly and the selection was huge. We got a Nutella hot chocolate (warmed my body and soul) along with some cookies an and a ferrero rocher pastry. Prices were fair and food was tasty! read more

See all

This place looks so cute from the outside. So decided to go in an get a few pastries to try out. I got a few small treat items. Even though i wanted a apple caramel almond pie, i knew it was too much for myself but the price was $12 for a good size pie. I know i will definitely get onefor events here. The staff was very friendly and helpful. The place was clean and nice enough to walk through but it can definitely get too crowded here. I wish they had seating options as i would love to sit here and havesome pastries with a tea or coffee. The cookie crisps i got were good. I got a rainbow sprinkle cookie amd a lemon crisp cookies they were super crispy and the perfect 1 bite (2 bite snack). The raspberry nut bar was interesting and i enjoyed but i would not get a full size bar to eat. The portion size they had available was also good 2-3 bites. I also got a red velvet cake pop because i lovered velvet. I thought the cake pop i ordered was white on the outside but was happily surprised with the turkey design cake pop. Since red velvet is done with a cream cheese frosting i thought id get a white chocolate but the milk chocolate was good. I would definitely prefer the white chocolate. Cant wait to return and try other items read more

See all

My favorite stop in Brooklyn! I was not disappointed this time around. All the sugar free items I purchased tasted really good! There was no icy feel in the mouth, nor a strong aftertaste. Everything was fresh and so good! I made it here from PA shortly after 3 and it was not busy on a Wednesday. Looking forward to my next trip out there, read more

Tasty Pastry Shoppe - I mostly got turnovers - Bakeries Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

We got my mother a vanilla cake with chocolate frosting and it was absolutely delicious! I'm not a huge chocolate fan but this cake wasn't too chocolatey or sweet. It was very good! I would def buy again! Workers were very helpful in helping us pick this out! And there was no line the day I went in the bakery. read more

Tasty Pastry Shoppe - Vanilla cake with chocolate frosting - Bakeries Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

The decorations were epic. It's a must see during the holidays. Very hype and line is out the door! But for some reason, Most of what I ordered was stale and dry: the Santa brownie, dry. The honey balls: dry and stale. The fudge cookie, old. The crumb cake donut: stale. The Lindzer tart wasn't bad but wasn't fresh. The prices were good and I'm so surprised that the goods weren't fresh since you'd think the product is moving. read more

See all

Went there for Easter Sunday around 6 PM got at least 8 Saint Joseph's pastries Drove from Brooklyn to New Jersey and they were stale like a rock. It looks like they made them on Wednesday to sell them on Sunday. Very very disappointed and I am a frequent customer. It would've been better just to go to Costco and buy one of the cakes that's always fresh . read more

The best desserts! I love getting the lobster tail and the tiramisu from this bakery. Can't go wrong with this place. There's something for everyone read more

Tasty Pastry Shoppe - Tiramisu - Bakeries Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

This is a old school Italian bakery filled with a large assortment of delicious cakes, cookies, cupcakes, and bread. They currently have the traditional rosca de Reyes sweet bread for 3 Kings day on the window display. There are also a decent amount of vegan options available. I was a bit overwhelmed by so many sweet options since everything looked really good. I decided to get the passion fruit cheesecake and the chocolate mousse cake. I justify buying two cakes as not just me being a greedy pig but really this was my attempt at testing out two very different flavors. The chocolate mousse cake was smooth and would be a great choice for any chocolate lover. I was blown away by the passion fruit cheesecake, the flavor was delicious. If you love passion fruit, this is the cheesecake to get. The prices are surprisingly reasonable. read more

See all

Great pastries, good coffee and some really nice cakes as well. I tried the key lime tart, berry tart and red velvet cheesecake and all were good and not too sweet. I also had an iced caramel latte and that was very refreshing as well. They have allot of cakes on sale which were beautifully decorated, so I plan on coming back and getting one. read more

See all

Fabulous blackout cake! My hubby's favorite and this one is spot on! Super fresh super moist and delicious . A must try if you're a chocolate lover. read more

See all

I knew we'd found a winner when we seemed like the only tourists in the joint. We left with a selection of cookies and pastries that we loved. It was bustling - like very busy - and there are about a gazillion options to choose from, but we managed to figure out the flow of service and hollered our order without annoying too many people! I particularly loved when one of the folks behind the counter came straight from the kitchen with a pie, hot from the oven, and offered it (for sale) to everyone waiting. Tasty Pastry felt like an authentic Brooklyn experience and the cookies have me wishing it was closer to where I live. read more

Tasty Pastry Shoppe - just some of the cookies!! - Bakeries Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

Best of the best, there is no better Italian bakery for pastries and cakes in Brooklyn- none. Quality ingredients fair price - great service great prices really nice clean place. If you want legit Italian pastries this is the place around the holidays and when All the morons come to look at the dyker heights Xmas lights the lines are out of control place appears like it's one of those hyped up places- it's not. Rest of the year it's great no lines. Legit fantastic read more

Good bakery overall. Owner is very nice. An associate, Cathy, is the most utterly ridiculous and useless person there. First and foremost, she is very rude!!!!!!! I had to call my son to ask which pastries he wanted for his basketball team, and when I told Cathy I needed a moment, she rolled her eyes and went to the back and whispered something about my appearance. When she came back, she threw all the pastries into the box and they were all messed up when I got home. It was ridiculous. I even tipped. Don't do ur job if you don't wanna be there!!!!!!! Very rude associate she needs to be taken care of!!!!!! read more

could be the best bakery in all of nyc!! everything is so fresh and flavorful, they also offer a wide variety of gluten free/sugar free desserts! i send my boyfriend in here a few times a month to get me the chocolate mousse cheesecake, nutella cannoli, buttercream vanilla slice and raspberry cheesecake!!! this bakery is old school with amazing service and even better baked goods read more

Tasty Pastry Shoppe - nutella cannoli and raspberry cheesecake - Bakeries Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

This is one of the few Italian bakeries that makes personal pan pizza Flatbreads. The Zucchini flatbread pizza is really tasty with the right amount of mozz to compliment this pizza. Also, purchased their pastry as well; the cannoli was good-though the shell was a bit soggy. Seasonally, got their Pumpkin Cheesecake tart- delightful. Aside from the flatbread pizzas; will definitely try their cakes and cookies on my next visit. read more

Tasty Pastry Shoppe - Pastries - Bakeries Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

See all

Come on you can't say anything bad about this place. They got every cake you can imagine excellent coffee Italian ice is excellent one of the best bakeries in Brooklyn. read more

This is a delicious old school Italian pastry still pumping out excellent pastry deserts. Gets crowded early with tons of locals so arrive early. I wanted to buy and try everything, but alas I will be coming back. read more

Fresh great cakes even the sugar free is magnificent I would definitely go back. Best bakery ever

Light and airy, and not too sweet--the best combination! We got a cheesecake with chocolate swirls and I expected to have a sugar rush after but I think the darkness of the chocolate paired well with the cheesecake. read more

Tasty Pastry Shoppe - Bakeries Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

Picked up a 4 pack of vegan cupcakes from the freezer. They were delicious! Tasted more like a chocolate corn muffin with frosting. Thanks for having that option for my son as he has food allergies to milk and eggs. read more

The selection of pastries and service was top notch. The staff were friendly and efficient. The business was very clean and ambience laid back and chill. read more

Lovely bakery shop with warm neighborly vibes. They are very popular and can easily have a line out the door, especially during the holidays! Service is fast thought and the workers are lovely to talk to. I've had a variety of Italian pastries here. I usually order the assorted cookie platter, which is always a standout at parties. The fruit tarte is AMAZING- has a tropical fruit on top of a chocolate- lined cookie crust. Their cakes are delicious. Their pies: my next try will be that blueberry crumble! I recently had a s'more latte, which I was able to customize to minimize the sugar content. They made it just right. I will always stop by hère when I'm in the neighborhood! read more

Tasty Pastry Shoppe - Outdoor pastry case display- muffins - Bakeries Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

See all

I love this bakery there are so many options. I have family members who are gluten free and others who are sugar free. There are options there for both these diets. read more

Pastries are as hard as a rock here, especially their cookies and Hamantashen (I did not come here late in the day either, but good bakeries are better than the early bird rule). They up-charge you if you pay with a credit card. Their Linzer tart is tasty but it literally crumbles right after that first bite. I was barely able to save it. I also found the staff gruff, and not in a great way. It felt like they wanted me to get in, pay, and get out. It is like a milled out selection of baked goods, which they have a great selection of. The location is also not too conducive, a bit of a hike from the D train. That is no fun. For a Dyker Heights bakery (just outside Bensonhurst), it is a bit of a letdown. Get your baked goods elsewhere. read more

Tasty Pastry Shoppe - Bakeries Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

I got a cake for my guest I got the cake the chocolate is black and it stains everyone's teeth and clothes read more

Tasty Pastry Shoppe - My hand being stained from the cake - Bakeries Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

See all

This landmark pastry shop is well worth the trek. The folks that told me about the spot remember it when they were kids back in the early '60s and it seems to be doing just as well even considering the pandemic. I was able to visit the spot about a month ago and came back a few more times just to make sure the first time was in the fluke but I can say that probably some of the best pastry around. Also some pretty good pizza as well. parking wasn't too bad when I got there I was able to score a spot across from the church. read more

See all

15 minute wait for no coffee, no service at all. A better ordering system is needed. It's currently a free for all that allows the workers to glance at your face for 15 minutes but ask everyone around you, except you, if they need help instead. read more

Picked up a box of pastries and cookies on a random weekday morning. They were fresh and delicious after a 16 hour flight and layover. Only issue was we didn't buy more! Crew working that day were nice, local vibe. read more

My aunt usually gets cannolis from here, so when I stopped by to get them for her, I was immediately captivated by all the desserts they have. Everything looked so good. I bought a few things to try. I was so exited to try everything that I forgot to take a picture before eating them, but here is a picture of everything half-eaten. I ordered the chocolate mini cannolis, traditional mini cannolis, red velvet cake, oreo cake, and ferrero cheesecake. I don't have too much to say about the cannolis since it's something we eat often. I thought the cakes, both the oreo and the red velvet were OK. They weren't as light and soft as I expected, they were good, but just ok good, not something I would get again. BUT the ferrero cheesecake though.... We were blown away by it! The cheesecake was so soft and creamy, perfect taste, with the crunch of the ferrero covering, perfection. Actually weny back the next day to buy more! In summary, get the ferrero cheesecake!!! but I would skip the red velvet and the oreo cakes. read more

Tasty Pastry Shoppe - Half eaten desserts (sorry) - Bakeries Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

This place is just pretty nice. I see the wide variety of pastries and cookies and cakes that they have and it's really unique and colorful in there. There's not much space and there's no seating which makes sense because the pastry shop is just for to go. We ordered chocolate covered Oreos, some shortbread cookies, and also a cannoli. I haven't had many cannolis, but this cannoli just taste. OK there's nothing unique to it. I think that their pastries are pretty standard and they're pretty fresh because they just taste nice. The service is also good. The workers are friendly and they have your orders packaged so no notes on that. read more

This is a classic staple in the neighborhood. They serve a wide variety of bake goods from donuts to cookies and cake. I tried the Boston cream donut and it was nice and hefty not made with any cheap ingredients. Good amount of creamy filling and tasted freshly made. read more

Tasty Pastry Shoppe - Donut - Bakeries Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

While there are many around in Brooklyn still, I still find it hard to find good reasonably priced pastries. I am also a bit pickier because I used to work in a great Italian bakery :) Tasty Pastry Shoppe combines some of these elements and the price point is reminiscent of old times. They make specialty cakes and pastries, hot foods, they have breads and chocolates and have also kept up with newer trends. The look of the display is very nice and visually appealing and the pastries are pretty good. The Ferraro Rocher pastries are vert rich and decadent, but delicious - I enjoy the hazelnut cannoli version of this. They also have the good French cream that isn't just whipped cream in pastries like the lobster tail. You can also get an extra large version and have them filled with cannoli cream if you want. Staff is nice and Jerry was so helpful and patient when I was here the first time. I had a wonderful experience and have been back since. I also enjoy the toffee candy which is hard for me to find a good one that comparable to the best one I've ever had (in Chicago). If you're looking for good pastries at good prices, Tasty is the place to be! read more

A small Italian bakery hidden in dyker height neighborhood. Inside is very bright and clean. Plenty of variations. Each small slice is about $3, very reasonable price. And they also have lots gluten free and sugar free bakery. This time, I got 4 slices Chocolate cake: strong chocolate taste, it's very sweet, but good with dark coffee! Red velvet cheesecake: good balance between red velvet cake and cheesecake. Medium sweet. Ferrero's mousse: it basically taste like giant Ferrero Rocher Chocolate. If you like that chocolate, then you will love this. Passion fruit cheesecake mousse. This is my favorite one. Perfect balance of sour and sweet. And the passion fruit just taste really good with cheesecake! Can't wait to come back to try other items! read more

See all

Everything at this bakery is delicious. I ordered a gluten free custom cake and no one could believe that it was GF. They have sugar free and vegan desserts as well. And their regular cakes and pastries are amazing. read more

Tasty Pastry Shoppe - Bakeries Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

The blackout cupcake was stupendously delicious! Perfect balance of sweet and chocolaty

Another Rock Star bakery in Brooklyn, they have it all, and all items are made with the finest ingredients. Everything is so fresh and so perfectly made. They claim they have the largest selection of sugar free bakery items, I don't know for sure but it's a huge selection as well as their gluten free selections. Cookies are to die for, as well as the peach tart. Counter help are the sweetest girls and they can actually make change. Highly recommend this bakery and the prices are not for the owner to retire after you leave. Run and enjoy this old school bakery, parking is street only with meter except Sunday read more

See all

I love this pastry shop! Not only do they have pastries but also breads and other Italian specialities like rice balls. The breads are AMAZING! The cakes are not too sweet or dry. They are all just right. I have came in to grab a cake for parties and gatherings and everyone ALWAYS asks where I got the cake. They also have a sugar free selection as well. Warning: around the holidays it does get very very busy. read more

Tasty Pastry Shoppe - Bakeries Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

Wow. The best Napoleon pastry I have ever had. I was told this was the place for the best Italian pastries and desserts and they were not lying. So good, if we are ever in Brooklyn we are definitely making a stop read more

Tasty Pastry Shoppe - Bakeries Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

We were walking the Dyker Christmas lights and literally just happened upon the Tasty Pastry Shoppe, and WHAT a find! They had cases and cases of every possible old school Italian bakery item you could possible want, incredible looking Italian bread warm out of the oven, two dedicated cases to sugar free and low carb re-dos, AND several different sized boxes of some of the best Strufoli, i've had in a long time! This is one excellent bakery HIGHLY reccomend!! read more