Love the food! Outstanding service! Regretfully I always take out, so I cannot comment on the ambiance. read more

It was warm not hot looked like it sat around for a long time cheese wasn't stringy pepperoni was over cooked cheese was hard the pizza looked like it was yesterday's this was not the first time pizza was this way we tried several times No more never buy theirs again read more

They are the best pizza place in town it can't get no better, so if I was you I would bring your family your friends your neighbors anybody you can think of because it is the best best pizza I've had yet of all the places I have eaten before which is a lot read more

Workers preparing food need to wear gloves! Cell phones n÷d to be put away and not used while preparing food! Awful!! read more

I'm a 50 year customer of Tasta Pizza. Always excellent food and excellent service... until today. I paid $26 for 20 wings, and when I got them home, I couldn't believe how tiny they were. They're barely bigger than a slice of pepperoni! A picture is worth a million words! All 20 of them just covered the bottom of the box they were in. They would have fit into a sandwich size box! I called and asked for the owner, thinking perhaps he got different wings on their last order and didn't realize how small they were. WRONG!!! he not only told me they're using these because "the other ones were just too expensive," he also let me know that if I don't like it, I don't need to come back to his restaurant. Way to treat a lifelong customer! Btw, no problem. I understand Napoli's has excellent food at excellent prices. read more

Tasta Pizza - That's a photo of two tiny chicken wings. Hardly bigger than a slice of pepperoni. Those two tiny wings cost $2.60. - Pizza Near Me - Olean, New York

If you haven't tried the steak taco, you're missing out! This is my go to spot on grocery store days. The pizza is hot and fresh everytime. We have ordered everything on their menu atleast two times. We love the food here. read more

The nostalgia of Tasta will ALWAYS be 10/10 for our family!!!! No one in town can make a better Taco Salad. Their pizza is different than anyone else in town so I won't even compare it. One of my favorite places to stop in for my lunch break. They treat everyone like family. It's true hometown feel. 10/10 always and forever!!!! read more

Tasta Pizza - Tasta Cuts for life! - Pizza Near Me - Olean, New York

See all

Awesome Pizza! Best pizza in town. Cheesy and hot every single time I get it. Recommend

Always a local favorite but the quality has been inconsistent the last couple years. Sometimes it's super good, other times it's not cooked well or barely has any toppings. read more

The pizza was okay. However, The owner and the employees lack providing good customer service and they are not friendly at all and the pizza is overpriced. I would rather pay those kind of prices for food at places I can enjoy the friendly atmosphere and welcoming environment. So, I won't be visiting again. I thought we'll maybe they just had a hard day, but I went ahead and tried it a couple more times and unfortunately the unwelcoming attitude/personality and environment made this a definite thumbs down, the food just isn't good enough to overlook. read more

Ummm, I like the atmosphere in here, the employees are somewhat friendly but I'm just a bit underwhelmed with the lack of flavor and taste with the pizza sauce. Apparently, the sauce makes the pie and this was not what I was expecting. I've had pizza from Brooklyn and I foolishly thought all New York pies were created equal. I will say that the locals love it as business was booming on a Friday evening. Sadly, I did not enjoy as much so, I will not be returning for pizza. I may consider their wings, subs and salads. We shall see! read more

See all

I have ordered from taste to Pizza a couple times in the past month both times they screwed up my order and never wrote down the correct debit card number I called them back and the manager says it's all my fault and will not let me order from there anymore ,the manager sword over and over the phone at me. TERIBLE MANAGEMENT SHOUD BE FIRED read more

Does not look like much driving by it but it does have quick decent pizza. Prices are reasonable. A little dirty inside. Dough is thin crust. Square cut. It's good to resolve a craving for pizza in a quick manner. Sauce kinda tasteless but again, hard to have a bad pizza really. Would come back. read more

This place is the first unique pizza place I've been to in years that also actually makes real pizza! I wonder why I've never been in a place like this before considering I've been hundreds of pizza places in my life. I'm here for the summer and like Douglas Macarthur I shall return! read more

I was on a mommy son date with my oldest boy when he excitedly pointed this place out for lunch! It did not disappoint! The staff was super nice, the pizza is one of the best I've had so far in WNY. Love that they use normal pepperoni rather than the cup n char stuff personally! It will be our regular whenever we are in that area! read more

First time ordering from here...and will be the last! We ordered a Pizza and Wings,person who was taking order didn't care to say what sizes the pizza's came in,and didn't give the Prices over the phone. The wings were horrible...worst we've had..the wings were soggy and burnt!!! When the Pizza delivery arrived...We were shocked at both the Size of the Pizza and the PRICE,total was over $60!!!! The pizza could have fed about 12-14 people and we were 4 lol...This place is a joke and horrible!!! My Boyfriend wouldn't have ordered if they had said the price before confirming order! read more

Cheese is it ! Sauce makes you happy - #Trivalley Personality is the closer #Tiptop the local Pie read more

Pizza is so good it was a little messy but compared to the deliciousness of the pizza it couldn't compare really delicious if you are hungry and don't know where to eat I highly recommend this place read more

Their wings are basically inedible... very displeased. Rubbery, basically just hot fat covered in VERY thick skin. Pizzas okay

Great pizza, terrible wings, rude service and a dirty place (definitely bring the pizza home to eat). This would be a one star review normally considering how bad everything else is here, but the pizza is best in town. Clean up, hire new staff and invest in a deep fryer-you serve baked wings? Gross. read more

Just great pizza. Need I say more? Slices are a good size, prices are extremely fair service is good. No wonder why during lunch the parking lot is full. read more

Tasta Pizza - Lunch special - Pizza Near Me - Olean, New York

My favorite pizza place of all time, I started eating here 30+ years ago and its still awesome! When we co.e up from Florida we always make sure to get tasta a couple times. read more

Pizza was good but nothing amazing. I had the veggie pizza. Wings weren't up to par...they looked deliciously charred but tasted old. Had this as delivery at a conference for lunch. read more

People who live in Olean think this pizza is amazing but it's cheaply made SMALL sliced pizza covered in grease. The sauce is made in a garbage can...seriously..you can watch them mix the sause in a garbage can.... They charge $5.50 for four tiny slices of pizza and a drink that usually is 1/3 ice. There is a lot better establishments to eat at in Olean. I do no recommend eating here. read more

The best pizza in Southern Tier of WNY. We would drive from Rochester every few months just to grab a couple slices, and it was always well worth the drive. After moving to GA, this is one place I still miss! read more

May be the best pizza I have EVER had!!! Pulled off the hywy in the middle of a long road trip with the kids. So worth the venture off the hywy! My only sadness is that I may never get the opportunity to eat here again. Really cute little town, too. Olean, NY, you are one lucky town to have this great pizza place. Definitely worth stopping for!!! read more

Tasta Pizza is often my first stop when I visit Olean. Growing up in Olean it was always my favorite and never disappoints. I wish I could franchise a location here in California! read more

This is a STAPLE in our community for a reason. Great pizza! And it has never changed!!! We would always go to Tasta after school and after all our little league/softball games. I now bring my children. It will be here when they have kids and so on. I love the wings. Baked not fried! Great taco salad! Good subs too! But the pizza is the best!!! A lot of the staff has been there for years. They call you by name. They treat you well. They know how to give real customer service. We ONLY order from Tasta for birthday parties, large gatherings, etc. You can't beat their prices or their pizza! read more

My favorite pizza! I'm living in Buffalo NY now known for pizza and wings and I still crave TASTA! Whenever we go to Olean to visit family we get tasta pizza before hand (even if we're meeting them for dinner) . Super fast and great prices go along with their awesome pizza. read more

We were passing through town on a road trip and saw Tasta on the map. We called ahead of time and they had the pizza waiting when we arrived. The staff was friendly and accommodating, providing everything we needed to eat on the road. The pizza was great! We'll stop again next time we roll through town. read more

Good place for a pizza fix being an out of town guest. I liked it and service was good thanks Olean

Tasta Pizza has the best pizza in town.... weather you want a lunch or dinner for your self or weather you want to feed the whole crew, Tasta Pizza always comes through!!!! Great food and great service!!!! Yummmmm read more

Once again I am bewildered by the reviews praising this place as "the best in Olean." What a sad statement about Olean. Tasta was greasy, cool (we picked it up early even), and very ordinary. They only sell sheets or slices and won't deliver orders under $20. We wanted to try Tasta based on the reviews, but won't be fooled again. Seriously, Dominos is far more flavorful, and they will deliver an order for 2. read more

I was driving through and stopped based on other yelp reviews. It did not disappoint! I ordered 6 slices and you get one free. Came out in 10 seconds! Pizza was great! read more

One of THE places I have to grab a bite to eat at while visiting western New York. Always great. Never changes! Daily Special!!

As someone who no longer lives in the area, Tasta is one of the places I must get food from anytime I visit my family back home. Always get more than you think you will need because it's great heated up the next day. I cannot eat pizza anywhere outside of Olean because of two particular places in that town. You can't go wrong with Tasta! read more

Tasta is always busy, great place for a quick and inexpensive bite to eat. You can order by the slice (square cut) or a tray. No complaints on the food or cost, good pizza for a large crowd. Not the best pizza in Olean but a great quick option. The staff is proficient and the line moves fast. Atmosphere wise though, we always get it to go from the Olean location, nothing horrid that impacts the food, there is just a weird "bro" atmosphere and a bit too much ogling and flirting. Nothing major, it's just a little awkward. The Bradford location isn't like that. read more

Was very disappointed when we tried to place a Togo order for over an hour. They never answered the phone. We had to drive there and place the order read more

Our only issue was with the price. Online menu's are wrong. Called to try and get the advertised price of $20.59 for 21 slices but was charged 27.00 at the store. Manager could careless said true prices are posted in the store. It's a shame as they have good pizza but I will be spending my money elsewhere as management could careless. read more

My favorite pizza place in Olean. Great prices and good size slices. Tasta Pizza is most defiantly worth stoping by.