16oz Steak that was highly recommended and also the most expensive meal was a let down it had no…read moresear and was not seasoned at all just a home cooked steak very disappointing customer service was good tho

Really nice spot great bar easy for a good space to hang out…read more If you are visiting town defiantly add to your list

So glad we stopped in! Had to try the new place, and it's a great spot for lunch. The sub rolls…read moreare made in house, and you will leave full. Staff was very helpful and hospitable. We will definitely be back!

Food is really tasty and affordable! I'm impressed by delicious pizza sauce, crust and sandwich…read morerolls that are all made in-house. And then there's the gelatos that they make!!! The staff are really friendly. I've been here multiple times and had subs, pizzas and burgers- I'd recommend trying them all, but the burgers were my favorites.

This is a farm to table restaurant near Olean. They actually own the farm where the raise the beef…read more Good selection of microbrew beers on tap. A few of us had the French onion soup. It was flavorful but could have used a bit more broth and the bread was a bit too dense for onion soup. Entrees included the hamburger, pittsburgh salad and dry aged steak. Burger was the best dish! Would definitely stop again, driving through Olean!

Went there for dinner New Year's Eve - excellent!! Limited menu but great choices - made it easier…read moreto choose! Great service and food was outstanding. Had crab stuffed haddock beautiful presentation,it was delicious!!

The outside of this building makes it look like a dive. Inside is a cool bar and back patio. Can't…read morebelieve it's not more popular. As a local the outside was discouraging. Now it's our favorite. American with a fusion. Amazing tempura fish tacos with slaw last time. Today we had a pulled pork with grilled pineapple over rice with an Asian leaning any red blooded American would love. Great Mac and cheese with Chinese Gen Tsaos chicken on it or orange chicken. Great pairings. So refreshing to not have things from the deep frier all the time. Best appetizers are the pierogies with bacon and sour cream. Heads up cash is cheaper. Card clearly stated costs 3% more. They have an ATM in their dining area. It's not overpriced. Most meals are the same as Hometown restaurant across the street. They have a whole other side of dining you don't see when you walk in. Would be great for a large gathering. I

A really cool vibe. Good food. More than a typical bar fare. You can tell this is family owned…read more A lot of care went into this place. I had the fish and it was a perfect wow. The fries were crispy and not oily. They are definitely not over using their oil. The bartender is attentive and will keep the pace of conversation so if you want to chat, this is a good place. Also they have some nice selections on tap including a cider if that is your thing. Will stop back here the next time I am in town. Thank you for welcoming a weary traveller

9/17/2025: Amazing! Updating my review because our last 5 experiences have been great all around!…read moreKitchen consistency is back to amazing again and so are the waitresses. THE BEST steak and prime rib in town without a doubt! Great burgers with a good variety to try! Good garlic butter pasta. The best steamed and buttered broccoli you'll ever have in your life! Nice big portion of spaghetti with meatballs. The meatballs are big and juicy. Good fried pickles. Good beer and drink options. Skilled bartenders. Very very very clean looking behind the bar always. No sticky bar, no dirty cups piled up, no fruit flies, no gummy soda guns, no stale beer smell, no dusty bottles.... very nicely kept. The only disappointment/thing I don't like on the menu is the little frozen premade beer fish fry. They're such a great restaurant, I think they should do their own big hunk of beer battered fish fry dinner instead at least for lent. My 2023 review issues have all been resolved! Yay! I highly recommend them!

Don't let the plain storefront misguided you, there is great pub food and a variety of good drinks…read moreinside! Staff also very nice.

My favorite wings in the Olean area…read more You have the most hospitable bar tending staff imaginable. Any issues with food get resolved promptly. A large variety of sauces to choose from and a great menu. Definitely my recommendation to anyone looking for an inexpensive fun night in Olean.

Wow! I thought the half way inn was the best wings in the area until I had wings at the 3rd base!…read moreOur minds are blown! It's more of a cozy friendly dive bar without a nice view like halfway inn, but the halfway in wings, fries, and staff don't hold a candle to 3rd base! The wait staff and management at 3rd base are what make it a Cheers type vibe. Don't sleep on it or be fooled by the unassuming outside. The place is dated, but very clean, fast, super welcoming, exceptional at what they do, a well oiled machine, and delicious! My mouth is watering and I can smell the wings and Cajun fries vividly in my memory while I write this. I'm kicking myself for driving by without trying them for forever. I'm addicted now!

9/3/2025: Hoped they'd still be open after Labor Day, and I lucked out! I was told by staff…read morethere's no planned date for closure, but late September (when the weather turns cold) is likely. It's still a huge pleasure to enjoy a cone while listening to the wind in the leaves. Enjoy the sunshine while it lasts!

So many flavors!! I got the "monster dough" it was good! They had different sprinkles for the…read moresurrounding colleges that were having graduations this weekend. Go Bonnies!! Lots of tables and chairs set up outside for a nice day. My ice cream order came out pretty quickly, which was definitely a plus.

7/2025 Update: We came for a late lunch and we're seated immediately. Our plates came out so hot,…read morethe waitress had to wear mitts!

Was down in the area for work... this is an area of the state that is really of contrast it's…read moreincredibly beautiful but incredibly poor. You can see some of these former manufacturing/railroad towns resemble something out of Alabama or Mississippi (Salamanca and Jamestown are poster childs of that). On the way back to the hotel in Olean I drove by St Bonaventure and found this Mexican restaurant. Astonishingly authentic excellent salsa with chips to start... along with a pork verde sauce with refried frijoles and yellow arroz.. A huge portion of beautifully stewed pork with a tomatillo sauce. Very friendly service and very very authentic. I think for the college kids they probably catered to there's a huge array of Tequilas as well. If you're going to Allegheny state park or the Seneca Niagara Casino or visiting your kids at St Bonaventure this is a great stop.

Had AJ's Subs, Pizza & Grill delivered to my hotel in Olean. I ordered 3 plain pizzas and a small…read morechef salad, all for just over $50. The pizzas? Honestly great. Hot, cheesy, classic--and for the price? Can't beat it. But that "chef salad"? Oh. My. God. What I received looked like something you'd win as a consolation prize at a school raffle. I paid $8 for a plastic container of lettuce, one slice of tomato, a green pepper ring, and like... three croutons trying to hold it all together. No meat. No cheese. No egg. Not even a shred of effort. I've seen more toppings on a flight snack. This wasn't a salad made by a chef--it was a salad that called in sick. It looked like it was assembled by someone who whispered, "Good enough," and walked away. AJ's--your food is good. Your pizza? A hit. Your prices? More than fair. But that salad? That salad needs to be exorcised from the menu. For $8, I expected at least a garnish of dignity. That container of sadness was delivered to my hotel and somehow still found a way to disrespect me. Rest in peace to my $8--you were tossed, not dressed.

The service is good but the food is overcooked and portions are small for the price. The sugar in…read morethe pizza sauce is the only thing I taste. Much better pizza elsewhere.