What an absolutely perfect experience from the delicious Friday fish to our server, Eric (who also turns out is the owner!) to the music and atmosphere on the deck. We will definitely be back. read more

After enjoying the fish fry for a number of years last Friday night meal was a huge disappointment. The fish was pre-breaded then frozen from a supplier. The appearance was unappetizing and the taste marginal. A shame as the fish fries used to be outstanding. read more

The food as well as the service is always great. A good selection of salads, sandwiches, entrees and the bar area is great for catching the game or chatting with staff. read more

We keep comign back for the great food Tim B is making in the kitchen. He is a stellar guy!

We happened to stop at Mickeys while they had Honeycrisp bbq there. Saw & smelled it driving by so obviously we had to turn around. Food was fantastic! Service was friendly & courteous even tho it was busy with a ton of take out orders. We sat up at the bar & thoroughly enjoyed our lunch read more

See all

The best restaurant in Plattsburgh for authentic Italian and classic ambiance..the wait staff is attentive and goes out of their way to make their diners happy. read more

Stopped in on a random Friday afternoon, new to the area but my fiancé knows the owner. Has since been sold to the son. Had an amazing time talking to both of them. As someone who has gone through an exact situation, it was heartwarming to see that their legacy is still going strong. Highly recommend the stuffed peppers appetizer and the fish sandwich read more

Subs are good, but need more meat compared to competitors sub shops. Pastas are good. You will need to ante up for a side salad if you want one with meal. Usually sit at bar, so service is excellent. Clean for the most part. read more

Terrible food. We sat there for almost 45 minutes before anyone acknowledged us and when we finally said something we were told that we needed to learn patience. We decided not to judge the food on the character of the server (who we found out later on was the owner ) but still try to enjoy the food but when we finally got our food almost half an hour after that the food looked nothing like what they advertised. When my wife pointed out to be what looked like rat droppings I brought it to the owners attention and he jokingly said "it adds flavour then laughed. I would never eat there again and they should be shut down honestly. Don't eat here if you don't want to get sick! read more

This place is amazing and I'm so sorry that I've passed it by so often. I had one of the best strip steaks ever with a side of impeccable garlic butter noodles. Totally worth $24. My sister and I split the steak and the delectable shrimp scampi. Eight fresh, plump and perfectly seasoned. My mom enjoyed her fisherman's platter so much she didn't share and the kid's size spaghetti and meatball was more than enough for my little cousin. You could tell most of their items were homemade. Top it off with great desserts and excellent service. This place is a hit that shouldn't be slept on. We will be back. read more

First time in Olean. Asked some people around town. Mickeys was recommended.. Walked in during lunch. So we had limited time.. We sat down. It wasnt that busy. Filled with many elderly ladies.... We waited 10 mins and noone came over.. We had to grab a waitress... We waited for menus.. All of us ordered 3 burgers and fries.. Not a big deal.. Should come out quick. Right?.. Nope... We waited 45 mins for 3 burgers and fries... We had to and ask them to box it up.. Which they weren't too happy about.. We asked separate bills. It took the waitress/cashier 10 minutes to cash out. She was dealing with some elderly ladies having problems separating their bills.. She was not happy...but showed patience.. Needless to say... Mickeys won't be the first in my list to eat in Olean.. On positive note: Loaded burger was big and actually really good.. Thats why I gave this place 2 stars.. read more

Best most consistent food in town. Great staff and great prices! Clean place too. Fresh catch fish, seafood options, killer pastas, and best wings around. read more

Without much doubt, the best Pesto Garden Pizza within Western New York. Covered in fresh peppers and Roma tomatoes oozing flavor throughout. Great selection of craft beers and IF you really want something spicy, ask to speak to Tom for some of his private collection of hot peppers. I Dare You read more

Mickey's is the place if you're looking for the area's best wings. Many choices including hot buffalo, garlic butter, cajun, bar-b-que just to mention a few. The full menu is sure to be a hit no matter what you order. The variety of bottled and draft beer is endless and always ice cold. Tom and his crew are the friendliest bunch of people you'll ever meet. Highly recommended for great food at a fair price. read more

Mickeys is an average place where many local townspeople gather and enjoy good food, drinks and TV. There isn't much that is spectacular and the interior is close to outdated. However, it is a hot spot. Food: Our group ordered the Fried Walleye, seasoned tilapia, and sirloin steak. Presentation isn't a priority here however the food looks tasty. But looks can be deceiving. The seasoned tilapia, or should I say seasoned salt, needed more fish. My tongue nearly shriveled up once this fish landed onto my poor tongue. Easy there fellas, hypertension is the leading risk for heart attacks. The Fried Walleye had too much breading and not enough fish. There was even some bones in there! Offer a warning before serving bones! There wasn't much flavor here either. The sirloin steak was more like sirloin cardboard with steak flavor. It was a tough chew and lacked seasoning. There wasn't anything that was served to us that made me reach for more. I only finished so I wouldn't look rude. Service: Mediocre. Our waitress have terrible laughing fits. I wonder is she was high or something similar... Valium? The food came out quickly but probably could have used some extra time back in the kitchen for a second look. Interior: Outdated and uncomfortable. You can picture an Applebee's from the 80s. It's pretty bland just like the food. One plus that grants it a additional 3rd star was the Sriracha sauce. I won't come back here. read more

Rhino head on the wall, Yankees wallpaper, piano in the dining room: all the good things in life are here. But don't get distracted. You're here for the fish and Southern Tier beer. Fish fry is the best in town. It's a hotspot on Fridays, so be prepared to wait. Also, the service is really good. All the servers are friendly and efficient, but not in a dull anti-personality way. read more

Can't find a better Maker's Mark Manhattan! Mickey's is best, you can feel like family there! read more

Mickeys Restaurant - Can't find a better Maker's Mark Manhattan! - American Near Me - Olean, New York

I took a family group of 12 yesterday for dinner. There were 3 tables being served when we arrived. We all ordered and got our beverages fine. The issues began forty five minutes later when we began getting portions of our meals, served separately and cold. Example... I ordered a strip steak with garlic mashed potatoes. I got a "cold" steak and the waitress advised my mash potatoes are being made fresh for me, over 30 minutes later the potatoes are dropped on the table "ice cold" and after my steak was beyond cold. My wife ordered au jus with her entree, 20 minutes after she was done eating her "cold" pork chops , the waitress brings the au jus and says, "do you still want this?"... REALLY !!! Needless to say, out of 12 of us, 2 got their order correct and fresh. I explained my concern to the acting manager and was told... I quote, " I'm really sorry ". The last $, or in this case, the last $205.00 I'll ever spend there. I only wish the owner, Tom would have been there. read more

Went here on New Year's Eve. The people were really nice. Not the fastest place but very relaxed and had pretty decent food. Their pasta and salad were both very good. Will be back. read more

As I type this, I'm craving a chicken sub from one of my favorite spots in Olean. You can't go wrong with anything you order...chicken and steak subs are some of the best I've ever had in my life (seriously). Make sure you ask for some hot pepper spread on the side! The fish fry and chicken wings are also delicious. Food always comes out hot, tasty and served with a smile. I agree with a previous reviewer that this place is run by some of the friendliest people you'll ever meet. Highly recommend! read more

Limited lunch and kids menu. Everything is cooked suprisingly well. Dinner specials are always delicious. We've always left satisfied.

The atmosphere is not good: Its a dive, not our thing. I would overlook this if the food was delicious and made up for it, but it didn't. We had 3 entrees. The pizza was satisfactory, nothing special. The crust was just a bit doughy and it didn't come with the extra cheese that I requested. The second dish was the "Penne ala Mickey." For $18 it comes with only a roll, no salad. The pasta was swimming in oil. My father ordered the prime rib. At $25 this was a terrible disappointment. Again there is no garden salad included with the entree. The presentation on the plate was very sloppy. A real prime rib connoisseur, my father judged this to be the worst steak he has ever been served. He had to spit several bites out. This place charges to refill your soda. Who does that anymore? I honestly can't think of anyone. Finally it was very cold in the restaurant, I wore my winter jacket throughout the entire meal. read more

First time visitor to Mickey's on a recommendation from the hotel desk clerk in Olean. My wife and I both ordered the local beers on tap and we both each ordered a steak. I had a 10 ounce strip steak and she had a 8 ounce sirloin. Everything was excellent and our server was extremely nice. We even got desserts to go which were a slice of peanut butter pie and the cheesecake. Absolutely no complaints and I would definitely go back again. read more

Had my first trip to Mickey's last night. There's plenty of seating for both large parties or just a table for two. It's not the kind of place that feels cramped or crowded. The decorations on the wall were mostly nautical (a few paintings, including a very nicely dressed ship captain on a black background), but there's a giant hot pepper for the logo of the restaurant, along with smaller pictures of hot peppers on the wall, too. It has a sort-of dive feel. The waitress took our drink orders and handed us menus but didn't return after several minutes and we were the only people seated at a table. The rest were at the bar. We had to let the bartender know we were ready to order and he sent the waitress over. We ordered an appetizer (onion petals with dipping sauce) and two burgers. You have your choice of cheeses and toppings. The burgers don't come with fries automatically (which I thought was unusual) so we added a side order of fries. I ordered a BBQ Burger w/ Cuba Sharp cheddar (Cuba Cheese is a local company). I added bacon (not usually on the burger) and lettuce and tomato. Asked for the burger to be medium well. My friend ordered a Mushroom Burger with Provolone, well done but no toppings. The portion sizes even for the appetizers are HUGE. There were three of us and we were able to get our fill of onion petals, plus some leftover to take home. The fry portion was large as well (another takeaway). The lettuce for the burgers is shredded into what seems like strings. The bun was soft but still toasted and the burger wasn't greasy at all. I have to say it was one of the best burgers I've ever had. The waitress was more attentive after we got our orders and refilled our drinks. I think she was just busy before we took our orders getting ready for the bigger crowd that was coming for an event later in the evening. As for the whole menu, there are lots of choices like pasta, steak, fish, subs, burgers, sandwiches, and desserts. I've also heard the pizzas are good and saw several people come in to pick up takeout orders. Mickey's seems to have a large crowd of regulars who come, too, so it has a friendly neighborhood restaurant atmosphere. It's definitely worth a return trip and if you live in the area, consider becoming a regular customer. read more

Great spot for lunch! The bacon cheeseburger was delicious as were the fried onion petals. They also have Four Mile's Green Street!

Why the hell does a tuna sandwich cost 15 dollars? It's wasn't even that good. If you are a rich old person who has no taste buds and doesnt care about them forgetting your order then this place is for you. read more

Awesome seafood and prime rib with great hometown bar atmosphere and feel. Many regulars that enjoy meeting new folks. Lot's of tasty cold beer on tap with a good variety of styles. Ask Tommy to make what ever you order "Hot". But watchout cuz "Tommy like it Hot". Hang out on the new dock and take the sailboat for a spin be careful of the "No wake zone". read more

Went to Mickeys tonight after not being there for a very long time. Wasn't sure why we never went there. Figured it out pretty fast. I do have to say the steaks were very tasty and hot. On the other hand, the fries were cold and was a small portion. I tried to order ranch dressing for my salad but was informed that the meal only came with 1 side and the side salad was extra. But what really got me was after paying $22.00 for a 12oz strip steak with a handful of cold fries, the drink refill of soda and iced tea were not free. They were an extra $1.00 to refill. What? Everyone serves free refills, everyone! Regardless of what size glass you use. Apparently, they made a point to inform you on the menu of what size drinks they serve so refills will cost you extra. I failed to see that, but was informed by my 16 year old son after the meal when me cup was empty and needed a little more. For some reason my son's 8oz sirloin steak with his handful of fries was $23.00. You see, they do not post the price of the steaks on their menu. You are supposed to ask your server what they are. When I did, she avoided the question and never did tell me. Guess that was my own foolish fault. However, I will never be tricked into that again. I will go elsewhere the next time. Going to remember to never go there again. read more