So...pizza. It has become rather an innocuous cuisine in the American lexicon of food. Friday…read morenights spent at the local take-out sitting in front of Netflix for the evening, though fun and relaxing, is not usually a gastronomically orgasmic experience. But every so often, the moon and the stars and the planets align and The One is born. Renna's Pizza is the Chosen One. I believe it is housed in a Super Fund site at the old Olean Center Mall. A tiny hole in the wall to be sure with cramped, though ample seating. But the smells are to die for. And the crust...light, crispy, airy, crackly, flaky and bursting with that flavor you crave in pizza. And the cheese is not too much but just right. The sauce straddles the line of perfection. I was greeted with quick smiles by the staff and lightning fast service. 3 hour drive for pizza...oh yeah. And I'm doing it again.

We get pizza from Renna's East on most Friday nights. The ordering is easy on the Slice app. It is…read morealways ready when I get there to pick it up. The staff know me and are always friendly & positive. Renna's had been around for most of my life so it is like a bit of nostalgia. I really love the pizza and I am SO glad they have the "original" pizza oven!

One of the BEST taco pizza's we've ever had! The fried mushrooms were the absolute best I've had…read moresince a kid at a bowling alley, only ordered 1 and wished I ordered 3!! The service to place delivery order was phenomenal, the girl on the phone was super sweet, EVERYTHING arrived super hot and fresh! They accommodated my son's request for a chicken bacon ranch pizza, even though it is not part of the menu YET. Wish we had something this good where we are in Ohio, but we will order from here again when we come back to Ellicottville, NY!! Seriously still craving the mushrooms

Hole in the wall! Let me start with that. Super friendly staff and cozy interior. We ordered a…read morecouple things... cheese pizza, pepperoni, meat lovers, some garlic bread, and a cookie. The cookie was killer! Garlic bread was good but nothing crazy. The meat lovers and pepperoni pizza were amazing, they use the good pepperoni cups which always get bonus points. Cheese pizza alone was ok. Would definitely recommend to all!

Had AJ's Subs, Pizza & Grill delivered to my hotel in Olean. I ordered 3 plain pizzas and a small…read morechef salad, all for just over $50. The pizzas? Honestly great. Hot, cheesy, classic--and for the price? Can't beat it. But that "chef salad"? Oh. My. God. What I received looked like something you'd win as a consolation prize at a school raffle. I paid $8 for a plastic container of lettuce, one slice of tomato, a green pepper ring, and like... three croutons trying to hold it all together. No meat. No cheese. No egg. Not even a shred of effort. I've seen more toppings on a flight snack. This wasn't a salad made by a chef--it was a salad that called in sick. It looked like it was assembled by someone who whispered, "Good enough," and walked away. AJ's--your food is good. Your pizza? A hit. Your prices? More than fair. But that salad? That salad needs to be exorcised from the menu. For $8, I expected at least a garnish of dignity. That container of sadness was delivered to my hotel and somehow still found a way to disrespect me. Rest in peace to my $8--you were tossed, not dressed.

The service is good but the food is overcooked and portions are small for the price. The sugar in…read morethe pizza sauce is the only thing I taste. Much better pizza elsewhere.

My friend has been sick for days and is finally recovering. She worked up the energy to order food…read moreand your piece of shit phone operator was horrible to her and made her cry. Your food tastes like dogshit on cardboard so I don't know where you get off exactly, but you need to seriously review how your employees treat customers. The last lady she spoke to was lovely but this one ruined her whole day and I barely kept myself from finding him and kicking his fucking teeth in. Do better.

Small town pizza place, its not fancy, but it doesn't need to be. It's really good and clean with…read morereally nice staff. Prices aren't too bad. We got thin crust which was awesome and perfectly crispy. I'll be back!

I stopped here again today. I ordered a sub (weekly special). They were in the middle of lunch…read moreorders and said it would be a few minutes, not a problem, I could see they had a system going and no one was ignored, the sub was really good for the price. I love the local people and friendly small town atmosphere.

Stopped yesterday for a quick bite to eat. I remember their food being fantastic and hadn't been…read morehere in about 10 years. Absolutely TERRIBLE these days. Half a sub,2 slices. Pizza was not even close to what it once was. The sub contained one layer of thinly sliced meat and the cheese was thicker than the meat. Definitely do NOT recommend.

Industrial "Chef Boy R Dee" Pizza. Take out... $53 for two…read more very disappointing pizzas. Amazingly expensive for the product we got!

Good pizza in the middle of nowhere for a city slicker couple like us. Fair prices and cool…read morebuilding.

Hidden sanctuary for a 80s mentality person. The arcade was pretty cool with some classic games and…read moreI loved the memorabilia on the walls. It's been awhile since I saw a pizzeria with the oven out in the open. The customer service was very welcoming. The pizza was great. I also ordered the wings of the month which were dill pickle flavored and they were a HIT!!!! It's definitely a MUST to get them with the blue cheese. Trust me on this one! I will definitely be visiting again. Happy Yelping

The food is fine not the BEST but not Worse. The Ambiance is great if you love the 1980's them. The…read moreservice was ok.Only reason this place is getting the review it is because of the 2 time we have ever been there we have had issues with the Customers!!!!!!! Both times they have been drunk, rude, and border line violent! If you are going to serve alcohol wouldn't you think you would stop before the regulars got like that! Our family will never be going back!

Maybe we stopped on an off day for them. Nobody was in line to order but 4 people waiting for…read moreorders when we got there. We ordered 1 hamburger, 1 fries and a Beef on Weck. It took 35 minutes to get order. The hamburger was okay. The fries were soggy. The Beef on Weck was not good. Much of "meat" was fat. and the meat that was edible was bland.

I don't think I've ever had one single bad item from here. They cook everything fresh to order and…read moreit's always ready in a timely manner. Somehow find my way there for Texas hots weekly