The Scarlet Vetter says.....First off, I really love this restaurant. The service, ambiance, and…read morethe food are top notch. Simply great. The owner is present almost all the time tending to things and checking in on tables. I have never ever had a bad meal here. Like not ever. Not even a mediocre meal. Always rates very good to great. From the steaks. To the seafood, to the Italian specialties.....just tops. It is hard to get into during the ski season, and not too easy even off season, so please do plan and make a reservation. If you can snag a booth, that is the best. The bar is a great place to come for a drink with a friend or to watch a sporting event. My most recent visit to the restaurant was this past Friday, a nice night in early May. We met some friends here for dinner. We had two appetizers of stuffed peppers which are absolutely amazing with just the right amount of heat, and the Nona's Meatball with gooey rich ricotta cheese.....yum yum. My husband ordered a house salad, which was crisp and delicious. For entrees, our companion couple ordered the twin filets and the fish fry. Both were reported to be fantastic. My husband ordered the Chicken Parmesan and I ordered the Chicken Milanese. Absolutely excellent. For dessert, both couples shared their own order of Tiramisu. I ordered an Espresso and that simply rounded out an amazing dinner. I really can't recommend this place enough.

Went to Villagio at 6pm on Sat,Oct17. 5 of us ( 3 grandchildren), were quickly seated in the bar…read morearea, our server was Tyler. He took the drink order and then we waited and waited. Finally drinks (three sodas and house merlot) were delivered and we gave our food order. Then we waited and waited for more than an hour to receive any food. The first item served was something we did not order, and it continued to be downhill from there. A manager came over and apologized explaining two entrees were burned and they had to redo. She said we would get a free dessert (meanwhile we hadn't even eaten). Eventually, food arrived. The chicken parm was hot but the pasta was not. The orders of macaroni and butter for the kids were tasteless and mushy obviously having been overcooked and sitting in warm water. The bucatini carbonara was lukewarm and the Caesar salad we ordered was never was served. Yes the place was busy and the atmosphere was family friendly. Tyler was certainly trying, but completely befuddled. Not sure if this was a fluke experience or expectations at this restaurant are low to begin with. Our grandchildren ages 12, 10 and 7 were well behaved and patient but my husband and I were extremely angry and frustrated . Tyler was obviously overwhelmed as we observed other tables receive their food orders long after orders were put in. We were there for more than 2 1/2 hours, served mediocre food and received extremely poor, slow service. We did pay our bill and left a 20% tip, but we will never return again. As weekend visitors, this place was recommended. However, I cannot recommend this restaurant. Our experience was not good, very frustrating and unsatisfying. Service and food need improvement.

One of the BEST taco pizza's we've ever had! The fried mushrooms were the absolute best I've had…read moresince a kid at a bowling alley, only ordered 1 and wished I ordered 3!! The service to place delivery order was phenomenal, the girl on the phone was super sweet, EVERYTHING arrived super hot and fresh! They accommodated my son's request for a chicken bacon ranch pizza, even though it is not part of the menu YET. Wish we had something this good where we are in Ohio, but we will order from here again when we come back to Ellicottville, NY!! Seriously still craving the mushrooms

Hole in the wall! Let me start with that. Super friendly staff and cozy interior. We ordered a…read morecouple things... cheese pizza, pepperoni, meat lovers, some garlic bread, and a cookie. The cookie was killer! Garlic bread was good but nothing crazy. The meat lovers and pepperoni pizza were amazing, they use the good pepperoni cups which always get bonus points. Cheese pizza alone was ok. Would definitely recommend to all!

We had a party of 12. Very courteous staff. Pizza & wings were great. We will definitely return…read morenext time we are in the area!

Industrial "Chef Boy R Dee" Pizza. Take out... $53 for two…read more very disappointing pizzas. Amazingly expensive for the product we got!

What an absolutely perfect experience from the delicious Friday fish to our server, Eric (who also…read moreturns out is the owner!) to the music and atmosphere on the deck. We will definitely be back.

After enjoying the fish fry for a number of years last Friday night meal was a huge disappointment…read more The fish was pre-breaded then frozen from a supplier. The appearance was unappetizing and the taste marginal. A shame as the fish fries used to be outstanding.

Nice little diner. Driving through and stopped here for breakfast instead of hitting a chain…read morerestaurant. It's a Monday morning and right now it's a one man show. The guy was very friendly and looked a little busy. A lot of older locals in here like most diners have all the retirees The food was cooked as ordered and tasted good. They do use American cheese. Will eat here again. As we were leaving three state troopers came in to eat so Atleast they are police friendly.

An update 09/19/2025: I love this diner! Seat yourself,…read morequick service, and you can either read the news or watch sports TV while eating (once the Yelp review is done!) My breakfast was less than $10, and I left feeling well-fueled for the day!

Service and food were great! I got the Philly steak sandwich with the fresh cut fries. I eat about…read more3200 calories a day for maintenance and this meal satisfied.

The Scarlet Vetter says....This place is fabulous. I have been to a few events here now and had a…read moregreat time and delicious food at all of them. The bar is open and airy and the drinks generous. The artisian pizzas are mouth watering. At a recent event they served vegetarian and meat options and they just kept coming. Crisp and chewy crusts, wonderful flavors and visually stunning. Their craft beers are worth the trip alone. I wish this location was open more hours. I would definately make a special trip for this one, it will not dissapoint.

Always busy. Not that way unless you have great food and service! Very comfortable atmosphereread more

You HAVE to have restaurant reservations on weekends, dinner, and holidays or the manager/hostess…read moreCarol will lecture you and correct you to call her Carol instead of Ma'am. Our waitress was so fast, friendly, and knowledgeable about everything on the menu. Very loud bar, but nice comfy old fashioned dining room separated from it. Great alcohol selection including non alcohol beer. Juicy perfectly cooked and seasoned steak over noodles with a cream sauce. Amazing creamy buffalo chicken over 3 cheese mac'n'cheese. Decent garlic bread stick. We promise to have reservations next time!

You could improve pretty much everything. Two of us ordered…read moreclassic poutine. What we got was a sloppy mess in a bowl of cold dry pot roast on top of hard red potatoes with a little bit of mozzarella, cheese and gravy. That was the most disgusting mess ever and if I wanted to pay top dollar for pot roast I would have ordered pot roast. Another person in our party got a hot honey chicken pizza. When we ordered it the waitress didn't even know what it was. That was so inconsistent. It wasn't even funny. Three of the pieces had nothing on it while others had tons of cubed canned chicken and very sparse hot peppers. I think we counted 1/8 in pieces of hot peppers on four slices. Another in our party ordered a burger and she found that to be tolerable and the other person got the lobster Po boy. Kind of hard to screw that up. If you don't mind kids free-ranging running around then this is the place for you. Even after saying the pot roast was cold, dry, and definitely not poutine. We got charged for it anyway Of all the restaurants we've been to on the East Coast, this is definitely the most disgusting one ever. The tables.. every single one of them had a folded up piece of cardboard under one leg because they don't sit right. One of the girls in our party got a sliver in her finger from the edge of the table. What a hot mess of a place After a 7-hour drive to get to Olean New York, this was more than a disappointment.

An update: Came in again for lunch, and the soup of the day was a hearty French garlic soup, with…read morecheese and croutons. It was awesome! My DH got the BLT, and it was so loaded with thick-cut bacon it lopped over the edges of the sandwich! I had the artichoke sandwich again, and fell in love all over again. They serve very generous portions here!