This pizza is good, maybe not the best but absolutely in the running! Depending on who you ask you may hear that people love this place or miss when they used to love it. I eat here regularly, always getting a pizza and it is always delicious. However, the staff here could be much friendlier. Also, the bathroom situation here is dodgy at best. This would be a three star review because the customer service and bathroom leave much to be desired but the pizza is just that good! All in all this is an average shop in the mall but it serves stellar pizza. I haven't tried any other food here. read more

The pizza was overcooked yet slimy. Disgusting actually. Place is nice but the service sucks. Won't be back ever

So...pizza. It has become rather an innocuous cuisine in the American lexicon of food. Friday nights spent at the local take-out sitting in front of Netflix for the evening, though fun and relaxing, is not usually a gastronomically orgasmic experience. But every so often, the moon and the stars and the planets align and The One is born. Renna's Pizza is the Chosen One. I believe it is housed in a Super Fund site at the old Olean Center Mall. A tiny hole in the wall to be sure with cramped, though ample seating. But the smells are to die for. And the crust...light, crispy, airy, crackly, flaky and bursting with that flavor you crave in pizza. And the cheese is not too much but just right. The sauce straddles the line of perfection. I was greeted with quick smiles by the staff and lightning fast service. 3 hour drive for pizza...oh yeah. And I'm doing it again. read more

See all

I have always said Renna's was the best pizza around... not anymore I asked for very light sauce and extra cheese and there was so much sauce on it and not even cooked all the way and not extra cheese worst 30.00 read more

Renna's Pizza East - I asked for very light sauce and extra cheese was not cooked all the way and A LOT of sauce will not go back - Pizza Near Me - Olean, New York

We get pizza from Renna's East on most Friday nights. The ordering is easy on the Slice app. It is always ready when I get there to pick it up. The staff know me and are always friendly & positive. Renna's had been around for most of my life so it is like a bit of nostalgia. I really love the pizza and I am SO glad they have the "original" pizza oven! read more

We ordered 2 Panzerottis today. We always loved these but the price is crazy and they don't even fill them. The two we bought today were very light and definitely not worth the price. We can get a good size sandwich anywhere and includes fries for less than $16 dollars each. Sorry you just lost us as customers. read more

Renna's is a long time staple in Olean. The best pizza around. The new staff is great and the atmosphere is a typical small town pizzeria. Always has great service and the smell makes your mouth water. read more

Will not be ordering again. Poor service and no resolution to inconveniences in their mix up.

This pizza is bussin'!!!!! Just as I remember it 25 years ago. The staff were super friendly. This cool little pizza place hasn't changed a bit and I absolutely love that about it!!! read more

So scrumptious and delicious. used to live in buffalo and i've never had a pie as good as rennas. read more

Renna's Pizza East - The best pizza ever - Pizza Near Me - Olean, New York

It wasn't very high up on the hill to begin with, but now it's way down hill. Rude dirty older guy working there. Dirty old out dated place. $21.45 for a pizza, 1 ranch packet, and 1 cup of parm. Nickel and dime to damn death. You're treated like it's an inconvenience to serve you. Pizza is a 3 at best. Sloppy and not cut all the way through the dough. read more

Renna's Pizza East - Sloppy over priced mess not cut through the dough. 25 cents extra for a tiny cup of parm. - Pizza Near Me - Olean, New York

See all

The staff was super nice, not rude at all, and gave what was asked of them, except.. the were on their phone mostly the entire time, and did not use gloves when making, or packaging the pizza. Overall the food was great though read more

Have had pizza from here through the years but tonight's was the end of the line Absolutely worst pie ever, a large pepperoni with banana peppers. Pie and cheese was dry and the banana peppers were dropped on top apparently after the pizza was cooked. If I could select zero stars, that would be my choice read more

I was there this past Friday. The pizza was as good as I've ever had from there and the gentleman working was friendly and talkative.

I had heard that the pizza was good here, but while waiting to order, I watched the girl go from using her phone to making pizza to handling money and back to making pizza, all with NO GLOVES ON or hand-washing. That was a deal-breaker for me, so I did not order! read more

Had pizza at Renna's today, would not go back again. Pizza was soggy, no crispness to the crust, ate the cheese and mushrooms on top and that is all. They even made me another piece, but was the same as the first. Not like it used to be, not same recipe. read more

Best pizza around. The crust is amazing. Thin chewy and crispy. How do they do it ? Plain cheese is the way to go.

$7 for a steak n cheese sub and its STEAK-UMS!!!!! Seriously??!!!!!!!! Should've went to subway in that case!!!! Yep, been sick since I ate only half of that "sub"! How does this place have 4.5 stars!???? read more

If you love a great homemade pizza with thin crust and just enough sauce and cheese, you'll love Renna's. Of all the pizzas I've had in my 40 years, I'd say their pizza rates among my Top 5 all-time favorites! read more

Pizza crust wet from being old plus 25 cents per slice for park. Went in to try as was having a pizza party 6 pizzas after the. 25 cents went somewhere else read more

This is real NY pizza. It's good, thin fold-able crust. Everybody & their brother uses their restrooms so, they're not always the cleanest. Seems like they've always been there - since I can remember anyway! We grab a quick slice every time, we stop at JC Penney's. read more

Yep, Renna's is located at the mall in the center of Olean, NY. Its probably the kind of place you wouldn't go out of your way to find unless you happen to: A). be a local B). be at the mall C). have a friend who is a local tell you about Rennas D). have a friend who was at the mall tell you about Rennas This can serve as a shout out to the pharma reps who have to drive out to Olean from Erie, PA and Buffalo, NY to visit their 1 or 2 docs who most likely have huge Rx-writing potential, all the sales people floating through town, and parents, friends and new students affiliated with St. Bona's... and anyone else that might be in the neighborhood for lunch. If you're on the other side of town on W. State Street (near Tops), Renna's has recently opened a new standalone location. Since I have only visited the original mall space, I can't quite Yelp about the new digs. Hurry up and get out there... you can be "First to Review"!! read more

I remember when I was in high school Renna's was the best and only place you went for pizza(well except Tasta and that was only late night) I hadn't had Renna's since the early 90s when I was home from College. Last year my husband and I were in town and got a pie to go...it was exactly as I remembered it, Yes we went to the mall to pick it up. My husband was surprised the best pizza place in town was at the mall. If you are new to Olean or passing through and want pizza, call up Renna' and get a pie or just wander in and order a slice! read more

Renna's is my gold standard of pizza. It's the pizza I was raised on and the pizza that I compare all other pizzas to. It's thin and crispy with just enough sauce and absolutely perfect, slightly greasy cheese. There are very few restaurants that I have been to in my life where the quality is exactly the same now as it was when I had my first slice 30 years ago. They have the most awesome homemade lemon, lime and orangeades too. The mall location is better than their "new" standalone store. I don't know why...it should be the same, right?...but it's not. read more

If you find yourself in Olean, NY for a St. Bonna's game or for some post-holiday shopping... Make sure you stop at Renna's! It might be a pizza place in the mall, but it is far from Mall Fare! The pizza is thin, perfectly crispy, and topped with the finest sauces, cheeses, and accessories. I've been a fan of their cheese pizza by the slice for 2 decades now, though it's been 2 years since my last slice... I'm totally jonsing! Oh and if the arcade is still there... Go play some old school Mrs. Pac-Man or Joust, and a little pin ball! read more

Being from near NYC I grew up with true NY pizza. A thin crisp crust, spicy sauce, stringy cheese. Since moving west I have sought out that taste, with no luck. Till now. Thank you, thank you. I have come home to true pizza. read more

okay.. here I am in town for my annual slice of heaven at Renna's . I was a little nervous because I DIDNT see my favorite pizza worker ("Blondie") making the pizzas...... and my last experience was not so good. I ordered a large to go. It actually turned out pretty good. The only concern I didn't like it this worker was constantly sniffing as if he had a bad cold (??). Never a good thing at a food establishment. Karen read more

The pizza was legit cold and you could tell it had been sitting there for quite sometime, all they did was pop it in the oven for a few minutes to heat it up... and the crust was burnt. almost $3 a slice for that? NO thanks, i'll stick to Tasta. Better pizza, better prices. read more

I would give 0 if i could. This place used to be the best in the area, but after its sale and subsequent hiring of, let's say, not very intelligent or friendly workers, it has turned into maybe the worst pizza place in town. If the blonde guy isnt working the pizza isn't good. Ordered 2 slices today in hopes it would redeem itself, however, the worker put my 2 slices in the oven, removed them in under a minute and the pizza fell apart. So, he put 2 more in, REMOVED them even SOONER than he did before. I got home (2 min drive) and the pizza fell apart just like the first 2. I'm not sure why they think it only takes 40 seconds to heat pizza properly, most people want a thin and slightly crispy slice. I was served a soft, mushy, cold mess. Sorry, Rennas. you used to be magnificent. now, you're an afterthought, and after today I will never return. read more

I agree with the reviewer who stated that this is their gold standard of pizza. I've never found another slice that has quite compared to what Renna's produces. True NY style slice with a super-thin, crisp crust roughly the size of a toddler's torso. Delicious. read more

Worst sub ever, if you want to even call it that. One slice of ham so thin, and no cheese. I basically had a mayo sandwich with lettuce and a very small slice of tomato. Zero stars is my actual rating, had to give it a star to post. read more