Beautiful setting, but not so great if seated inside. Food was pretty good overall. Fried okra, fried pickles, shrimp & grits, pork chop, burger all good for our table. Way too much salt on tots and fries. read more

I read the reviews and the history of this establishment and was really impressed. So, my husband and I went on Friday night, it was tough to get a parking spot. Our server was Grace, she was fantastic taking care of all our needs. The anbeance was very pleasant, and the chef prepared food was extraordinary and plated to appeal to your eyes and then to your taste buds. The courses were nicely timed and spaced out so you had time to conversate in between dishes. The dining area had a rustic historic feel about it, next time I would like to sit outside for a different atmosphere. The prices were about average $$, overall I give this restaurant a 5-star for great atmosphere, quality food, and friendly service. The only issue is parking on a busy night. read more

See all

Outstanding service, an amazing steak, great seafood and a relaxing atmosphere. Very accommodating to gluten allergies. I can't think of anything negative to say about Table 23 at all. It's a little bit more expensive than the rest of the restaurants in town, but well worth it for the food and service. read more

Best steak I've had in Tally. Super accommodating as far as allergies go (labeled menu) and the drinks were great! No gluten free desserts but the waitress was so kind and careful and there were several safe drinks! Loved sitting outside under that fabulous tree! read more

Table 23 - Fabulous views - New American Near Me - Tallahassee, Florida

Trying out Table 23 during its soft opening over Fathers Day weekend. Has a nice selection of food and beverages. The interior and decor has been updated. Their motto: You're always welcome to our table. Sums up things nicely. It's fantastic. We tried the Midtown Sundown and the Dirty Gentleman cocktail. The Sundown was flavorful without being too sweet, but was missing something. The remake was outstanding. The DG martini was smooth and not too harsh. The old fashioned tried subsequently was amazing. The appetizer we tried: Oysters Two ways. The fried oysters were large and fantastic. The broiled oysters were microscopic....definitely not local oysters. Perhaps the small size is due to the time of year. We had the fresh fish which was grouper. Delicious. We also had the Lucky Goat coffee-rubbed ribeye....amazing!!!!! It came with asparagus (al dente) and roasted new potatoes. Capped off the evening with their pretzel strawberry parfait. Wow!!! Will definitely visit again! read more

See all

So goood!!! the spinach dip was amazing and the burger as well! a bit overpriced for the food but worth it. amazing environment and service. parking was annoying though. read more

Table 23 - burger - New American Near Me - Tallahassee, Florida

See all

We have been coming to Table 23 since it first opened about 2 years ago. The food and service are quite good. But what makes Table 23 special is the porch. The covered porch wraps around the restaurant with fans going in the summer and heaters in the winter. It has a relaxed atmosphere and is a great place to have a leisurely drink or meal. Table 23 has a great selection of appetizers; some of my favorites include the pecan crusted okra, southern slate (a meat and cheese plate), fried cheese curds, and the spinach dip. The spinach dip is not your typical boring restaurant dip, Table 23's dip is brightened by the addition of Parmesan cheese and is delicious. You should give it a try, but share it with the table since the portion is quite large. A couple of entrees that we like include the gulf grouper, the fish of the day, and the 23 burger. And in case you over do it with the appetizers, one of the salads topped with fried oysters is a great choice for an entree. read more

Great food and customer service! I have always had a great experience here and the portions are always awesome.

Great ambience. Slow but polite service. Inconsistent bartending. Got the same drink twice, different taste and presentation. Appetizer fried okra good not great. Meatloaf special was good, but twice baked potato was smallish and asparagus was tough. Shrimp and grits was not good. Watery and the shrimp had a bad taste. One shrimp was still completely shelled. All others still had tails, which seemed strange. Doesn't come close to Jonas or Paisley Cafes shrimp and grits. Overall disappointing, especially considering the price. Wouldn't recommend for anything other than a cool place to have a drink and a appetizer. Gave this place another chance. Much better! Oyster appetizer was incredible. Sweet potato fries and salad were really good. Outdoor seating is perfect when the weather is good. Good service. read more

I've been here a few times and am definitely a fan. I love the outdoor seating with beautiful decor (and fans, thank goodness!) Excellent brunch and drink menus, decent appetizers for dinnertime. I can't wait to come back and try the bottomless mimosas when I have an entire day to waste! Staff here are incredibly nice and willing to help you out with suggestions. read more

Two of my fav reasons for going to Table 23: Southern Slate & Mason Punch. I've not had a bad meal either. Love that they seasonal dishes, too. I will admit that I'm disappointed it's NOT open for brunch/lunch on Saturdays. Seems a very odd time not to be open. We started to remember that only because we've been let down talking it up to friends in town only to discover it's closed. read more

The drinks, food and service was amazing! Our food came super fast, drinks were great- old fashioneds and banana dessert to die for!

Was in town for a wedding one weekend and needed a place to kill some time and was so happy to come across table 23! One of the best bottomless mimosas deals and attentive staff I've ever had. ALSO LETS TALK ABOUT THAT FRIED GREEN TOMATO BLT top 5 sandwich for me no questions read more

Table 23 - @wich_bitch fried green tomato BLT - New American Near Me - Tallahassee, Florida

We are from out of state and have been to Table 23 four times, including one brunch. I can honestly say, having extensively travelled through the United States, the food is spectacular. we have never had a bad meal. the pickled pear spicy margarita is wonderful. The fried pickles are a must. My husband loved the prosciutto wrapped filet as much as the burger, whereas I am partial to the chicken fingers and sausage gravy. The mashed potatoes are actually mashed with some lumps, not whipped or puréed. All off our servers have been great. Tonight we had Gracen and she was friendly, knowledgeable, and attentive. We have been seated on the covered porch and inside, and we are happy no matter where we are seated. This is a must do every visit. In fact, we are going back tomorrow night. read more

food was good but very overpriced and was not worth the money. eggs Benedict for brunch was prepared in a way I never saw before. the ham was as big as a half dollar. service was good but door and drinks were well over priced. won't go there again. last time I was there a few years back it was much better. and they also add a 3 percent surcharge if you use a credit card. why not just build this cost into prices since food is already over priced? read more

Came here for dinner opening night. We got seated straight away outside. The place was relatively busy for it being the first night of service, but it wasn't packed. Our server was fantastic so overall I would give the service 5 stars. I ordered a drink with mint in it and when I got the drink it didn't look like what was described on the menu. The server went back to check with the bar and they said it was the correct drink they just ran out of mint. On opening day, I don't know how you run out of things like that. So my server was nice enough to let me exchange my drink for something else. I ordered wine and this time is came with a whole bunch of cork in it. So now I had to try for a third time to get a drink. It took about 45 mins to get a drink I could drink. The oysters are probably the best thing out of the appetizers. They were delicious and so was the green bean tarter sauce it comes with. For the main course, I ordered a filet. The real test for any restaurant is if they can cook a steak right. I ordered it medium rare with the hope of it being medium and unfortunately, it was a little overdone. My husbands grouper was delicious and cooked perfectly. The dessert was good but nothing to rave about. I will definitely be willing to try this place again. But overall, it gets 4 stars for now because if I am paying $34 for a meal when the restaurant isn't completely filled, I expect it to be cooked perfectly. read more

See all

This is one of my favorite places to eat in town and it's a regular go to for me and my friends. Their brunch is really good and the menu is always fun. I love their charcuterie boards. The food is well priced and the menu is pretty diverse with an interesting take on southern style cuisine. I really enjoy this place. read more

Came here for the first time for brunch with some friends. They have a great deal on bottomless mimosas and they are very generous with how much they give you! I had the chicken and waffles and it was absolutely delicious. I will definitely he going back there soon. read more

Table 23 - Chicken and waffles - New American Near Me - Tallahassee, Florida

All I can say is wow. This place was delish. We decided to go a little crazy on the appetizers. Pimento cheese and guac was yummy. Bacon wrapped scallops were amazing. And the blackened tuna and fig was to die for! For dinner I had the gulf grouper. Although the grouper was slightly undercooked, the shrimp and crab cheesy heaven on top made it spectacular. My wife had the burger, which she didn't care for, and the sweet potato fries were bland. My mother had the catch of the day, which was mahi, and she seemed to enjoy it. My son had the three little pigs but he wasn't too fond of it! Dessert time. The creme brûlée was good but could have used a little more crunch on top. The key lime pie had a little too much crust but the flavor was great. The service was great and our server was attentive and pleasant. All in all if I were back in Tally I'd visit this place again! ESP for the appetizers and grouper. read more

Upscale place, very nice inside. We sat on the patio which was nice and shaded. Food was excellent, waiter made sure our substitutions were taken care of and was very attentive. Good selection of tasty drinks. read more

All you can drink mimosas are 100% worth the brunch visit. Delicious appetizers with amazing flavor as well!

This place as really good food. I love the coffee rubbed ribeye. The deviled eggs are also great. Great for small plates to share. Great location in midtown Tallahassee. read more

Me and my Mom went for an early dinner here maybe 2 weeks ago. We sat at the bar (where my Mom likes to sit so she can have fun conversations with the bartenders) the lack of customer service by all who worked in the bar that night minus the bus boy was pretty bad. You typically hear great things about this place so I was really suprised by the shallow atmosphere provided by the staff. Next the food. I'm sorry to say but it was nothing short of nasty. We had fried green tomatoes (btw I'm vegan) the batter literally tasted like it had been used for breading fish. There was a very fishy taste to it. I ordered the black bean burger wrapped in lettuce no cheese and all the burger came to me on a bun with cheese. This was the most disgusting black bean burger I have ever eaten in my life. It tasted like mushed up tasteless black beans. Straight up gross. I will not be going back to table 23 anytime soon. #AVeryDissapointedCustomer read more

I love this place so much. The Sunday brunch is delicious. I always get the Chicken and Waffles. Their blueberry siracha sauce is AMAZING. Dinner is spectacular as well. I really enjoy the atmosphere around the bar. There is a beautiful chandelier hanging above the bar. There is also plenty of outdoor seating underneath a beautiful Live Oak. This is where I take my friends who come in from out of town for a dinner. read more

Great spot either for dinner, a few drinks and occasional live band, or huge banquet hall for large groups. Easy apps menu too. I personally loved the outdoor small TVs at the outside bar, and they pour a few good signature drinks as well. A must to go to if your passing thru. read more

Had the Southern Slate charcuterie board for my meal. Well presented and quite good although a little pricey at $20. Place was packed on a Thurs night and I sat on the outside deck, which was cool but very loud with so many people talking. Biggest tip I would give is if you set outside make sure that you are not near the door to the inside. It was a constant barrage of fast-moving servers and patrons flying by my table and the bouncy & loud decking added a lot of noise and vibration to my dining experience. read more

came in for happy hour with a friend, sat at the bar and had an absolutely excellent experience! mickey was fantastic and honestly very fun to watch at the bar! he was so friendly while being insanely fast and efficient. great job! read more

From Washington State. No idea there would be a steakhouse this good with a waiter this good. Steaks were fantastic just as the deserts. Celebrated our daughter 13th and she loved her filet!! This is a come beck place!!! read more

The food was great and the service was very good . We really appreciated the ambiance

Enjoyed a wonderful meal last night for a birthday celebration. Had the Spinach Dip, very good. Also highly recommend the Grouoer. . read more

One of my favorite brunch spots by far! Every weekend me and my friends don't even have to think where we're going to eat. They have an adorable ambiance paired with excellent food and drinks! Can't beat unlimited mimosas for brunch! I particularly love the chicken sandwich or the grouper sandwich 10/10 I love upgrading to the truffle tots or the grits too! Definitely check this place out. read more

Table 23 - Truffled tots with grouper sandwich - New American Near Me - Tallahassee, Florida

See all

AWESOME FOOD. This was my first dinning experience in Tally and they set the bar high for everywhere else. The service was quick and friendly. The food is amazing and true to their description. They have a unique spin on classic southern food and even improve on some dishes! Wonderful selection of indi-brews, most are even local! The atmosphere is cozy but classy at the same time. Dining on the porch is the way to go as there are several TVs and fans. I think I'vee found a new foodie home for the summer! read more

Super improved. Brunch here is a big deal. They really do a great job at accommodating a huge crowd. I did however have some trouble getting assistance at times. The steak and eggs came out amazing. Fabulous flavors. A glorious smoked New York steak. My hash was more like a green pepper hash but still eggcellent (did you see what I did there). I could of used some more hollandaise but to be honest I always want more hollandaise. I honestly would swim in a river of hollandaise. I'd flop around it for days gobbling. Back stroking. My eggs while cooked over medium they were fried a little hard. You know when they get brown and crunchy on the edges due to excess heat. With all due respect this was a very busy joint pumping out hard core brunches. Nothing like a perfect fall day ordering wine and eggs with the breeze gusting in. We couldn't of asked for Better weather. read more

See all

Great atmosphere on the porch or deck, especially with nice weather. Inside is nice too but sometimes a bit cramped. Brunch and lunch menus are great. If you go for brunch, I highly recommend the bottomless mimosas--only $12 and seriously bottomless. Also, their sticky buns are amazing, and the biscuits and gravy is great (I orders mine with chicken tenders.) The lunch menu is good, specifically the cornbread croutons on their salad and sandwiches. As to dinner, there are a few things we love (I could eat the Grouper 23 for dinner every night!), but it's not the best menu. Always good service when we've been. They take reservations. read more

While the food is good, it's a bit overpriced for what it is. It's in a great location in midtown, easy to find, though parking can be a bit challenging on a Fri/Sat. You can park across the street in the Midtown parking area. read more

Atmosphere was beautiful and relaxing. Had the prosciutto wrapped filet and it was hands down the most tender and delicious filet I've ever had! The hostess's were very friendly and our server (Morgan) was very attentive and had a great attitude. I very much recommend anyone try this cute place. read more

Great food. Highly recommend the grouper! Tuna and coconut shrimp appetizers are fairly predictable, but very good. Tomato, feta, basil salad is a refreshing twist on a Caprese. Key lime pie was also predictable, but excellent. Would not suggest the house cabernet, but there are other very good options. If you're making reservations there are 2 options for "outside", 1) outside similar to outside at any other restaurant, 2) is outside under the porch, which is enclosed and would be my choice, even over inside, assuming its air conditioned. read more

Expensive Food. Poor quality food. Went for an anniversary dinner with my gf and all we laugh about was how bad it was. Don't understand why this place has a decent rating. Maybe if you bought just drinks or something. Entrees we're cold. Plate was hot... read more

Great atmosphere and great food! Whether you want to have a few drinks or sit down for a good dinner this is the place to go. I can't wait to go back and try their brunch. read more

This is one of go-to spits when I travel to Tallahassee. I will go out of my way to have dinner here. Each time I've dined, I haven't a bad meal or bad drink. The service is friendly, attentive and provides great suggestions for food. There is a lovely atmosphere here all days of the week and always packed. read more