Super cute little shop. Stopped here to see if they had any mini options for my finances birthday, it was a last minute stop so wasn't sure what to expect. They DID have the mini dot cakes! So I grabbed one of those! & for $6 you can't really beat that! It was really good! Love that the shop has items on hand, such as cakes, cookies and brookies as well! Did try any but they cooked gorgeous, so big and decadent looking! read more

What a beautiful and delicious cake they made for us for our friends retirement. It was carrot cake and everyone loved it

The buckeyes and cookies here are quite good. They're a very fresh, homemade style. I've been here several times and my picky family always gobbles up everything I buy there. I haven't tried the cakes or decorated cookies yet. read more

I've been trying different bakeries in my area and decided to stop at sweet tooth after running some errands. Neither my daughter or I had been there before, but the pictures in their website looked pretty appealing. The shop is small and has a limited selection of items. There are no pastries but they have cookies, cupcakes, bars, and other small treats. Oh and they do custom cakes! Anyways we wound up getting some cake bombs, a cake bar, a cupcake and coffee. The young lady working the front register was super nice and helpful. All of the items tasted great, totally worth stopping in. read more

See all

I ordered cookies this weekend for my son and daughter-in-law baby shower. They were delicious, beautifully wrapped & perfectly designed. We could not have been more pleased. We ordered pink polka dot onesie and espresso martini cookies. To follow the theme "A tiny something is brewing". If you have not had a chance to pop in I highly recommend you do! read more

I have travelled by Sweet Tooth Cottage many times and finally had the time to stop. They have a variety of desserts. Their sugar cookie cutouts are adorable. I tried a cheesecake slice and a brownie. Both were delicious. The staff was nice and gave me a moment to see all the options before making a selection. This is a cute bakery off Sawmill. read more

If it would be possible to give more stars I would. This is a fabulous bakery with lots of tasty treats, not that we have tried them all, yet. The customer service is definitely worth noting, particularly in this day and age. We purchased some of their custom sugar cookies for our vet after our dog passed. They could not have been more helpful, going so far as asking for a picture to help when decorating. The cookies tasted great as has everything we have tried. They even put the extra cookies in for no charge, again outstanding customer service.!! This is a great place and I would highly recommend to anyone looking for a good bakery in the area! read more

Sweet Tooth Cottage - The tasty sugar cookies, and personalized. - Bakeries Near Me - Powell, Ohio

I have always loved Sweet Tooth's custom sugar cookies, but this was the first time I ordered a cake from them and it did not disappoint! The team at Sweet Tooth is always incredible to work with and they helped make getting my mom's custom lemon cake with lemon icing for her birthday/retirement process very easy and the cake was as delicious as it was beautiful! read more

Sweet Tooth Cottage - Custom lemon cake with lemon icing - Bakeries Near Me - Powell, Ohio

See all

Great customer service and friendly staff. This was my first time ordering from Sweet Tooth Cottage. I've been told that their cookie cakes are better than the ones in the mall and of course way better than what the grocery store has to offer. Super cute cake and my son loved it! It was soft and the icing was delicious. Our only minor complaint was that the cookie cake was a little too dense for our liking. We will be ordering again and happy to support this business! read more

Sweet Tooth Cottage - a birthday cake in a box - Bakeries Near Me - Powell, Ohio

See all

Owners husband the manager is Very rude. I asked about a rewards program for returning customers. He advised me that I obviously know nothing about small businesses or I wouldn't be asking that. As I tried to explain that I spend lots of money with his wife's business, and they should consider with the pricing. He then said he's not having this conversation anymore, and hung up. I'm done patronizing this company. I use to speak highly of their cookies, but no more. You have lost a loyal customer, maybe if you loose enough you will care. read more

I mean.....quite possible the best cookie I've ever had! You cannot go wrong here....its almost hard to choose because everything looks and tastes so delicious! We will return often! read more

I ordered a birthday cake for my sister's 75th. It was perfect and everyone said it was DELICIOUS!

I found sweet tooth cottage to be a delightful shop with a great selection of baked goods. The snickerdoodle had the perfect amount of cinnamon! A great treat! read more

Solid selection of beautifully decorated cookies and amazing cupcakes. Great customer service.

My bf found this place by accident.. and two days later he brought home an AMAZING decorated cake!! The lady working was so kind and helpful, he said. He brought home cookies as well .... And let's just say they didn't last long! The no-bake cookies were to die for, and the pb blossoms were amazing! And they don't skimp in size! read more

Sweet Tooth Cottage - a birthday cake in a box - Bakeries Near Me - Powell, Ohio

See all

Ok, wow! Love this amazing bakery! Their treats taste even better than they look...I mean, Yum!!! The young wanna helping me was so kind too! We'll be back for sure!!!! read more

See all

Sweet Tooth Cottage is a nice and sweet addition to the Powell area! Although the nicely decorated interior, and rented strip mall storefront doesn't necessarily mean they are a new contender in the realm of Northern Columbus sweets. In fact, I was informed by the owner that Sweet Tooth had been operating in her home for a while doing special orders, and decorated sugar cut outs for parties and other occasions. Experience shows here. The cookies are decorated perfectly! They're EXCELLENT for celebrations, or the office potluck. They have some skilled ladies (maybe gents) working here. I smell a second coming Cheryl's Cookies here, folks. The sugar cookie cut outs take the cake! Sweet tooth also focuses wholly on cookies. No other gimics, or unfocused travesties here. Cupcakers look elsewhere. (At least for now) Sweet Tooth also offers other types of sweet treats like salty caramel cookies (one of my faves), Chocolate no bakes, banana chocolate chip cookies, and just your regular chocolate chip cookie. Although they were good, but the last time I was in the chocolate chips were running a bit on the soggy side from too much butter on the bottom. Not going to ding them for that, though, because the other selections were great. It's a shame they're kinda tucked on the unseen side of the strip mall off of Sawmill PKWY, because they may not get as much foot traffic as they deserve. "Sweet-tastical", professional and YUMMY! read more

Sweet Tooth Cottage - Bakeries Near Me - Powell, Ohio

See all

I am comfortable enough in my own brand of masculinity that I can say that this place makes cupcakes that are DIVINE you guys. Also, and this is the salient feature of this place, they have a drive-through so you can bring all three of your kids in the car to come get some cupcakes because the days are looooooooooooong AMIRITE and sometimes daddy needs some refined sugar and butter to go with his existential ennui. Anyway they're not cheap @ $28 for a dozen but I didn't care. They sell other things too probably. read more

Just the best baked goods, no matter your need! I can stop in on a whim and they always have plenty of desserts to choose from. A wonderful Powell staple. read more

WONDERFUL bakery!!! This bakery was great to work with. The owner created 2 special carrot cakes for the luncheon after my mom's Celebration of Life service. Carrot cake was my mom's absolute favorite. First of all, they were so very delicious... many guests commented on this. Secondly, the owner was happy to apply the sugar butterflies to the cakes for me, so I didn't mess them up. Finally, she waived the delivery fee for me, which was very kind... I am so grateful I used this bakery. read more

Beautiful cake as well as great communication and service...would definitely recommend!

Great service! Always kind, understanding, and willing to make things work! What's even better is the cupcakes Fluffy cake and delicious icing. The icing is light and creamy with a cake that has a perfect soft bite. Cupcakes for a great price as well! Highly recommend!!! read more

Nice little bakery in the middle of suburbia. The boys liked a Easter themed sugar cookie. Seems fresh and definitely made in house. I am not from the area so I am unlikely to return but I would recommend. read more

Oh my! Stopped in and got two of their little petite cake things- one was like an amazing ho ho and the other has raspberry buttercream and was vanilla- absolutely incredible! Also the s'mores bar was to die for! Stop in to this gem for sure!!! read more

The cookies are to die for! I have used them for a few events and the cookies are a show stopper and are fabulous as well! And I am sad to admit there is a pick up window! Great addition to Powell! read more

OMG! I'm so so glad I discovered this bakery on a recent trip to Ohio. I wanted something different in the line of cookies to take to friend's that were hosting an Ohio State football TV watch party. Got there a good 15 minutes before they opened but since someone inside at the door, they let me in. WOW, I asked so many questions about their very unique cookies and they graciously answered them all. read more

Love this family owned business. Always friendly and kind. Treats are something special that is often needed for a special occasion or to spoil someone!! read more

Phenomenal! Everything is fresh, delicious, and such a range of treats! The owner is also incredibly generous-I won both cookies and a gift certificate last year at our elementary school's art auction. We went in today and got THE BEST chocolate chip cookies (and I'm picky!), plus a fresh, soft, delicious oatmeal chocolate chip cookie and an equally delicious snickerdoodle. In addition, a PHENOMENAL vanilla with vanilla frosting and chocolate with chocolate frosting cupcakes, chocolate frosted brownie AND amazing buckeyes. We will be returning often! read more

I have never been to sweet tooth cottage and Im going to give you my perspective from a drive thru (which is what I experienced). I took a trip to go get some sweets with a kid in the backseat and saw sweet tooth cottage along the way! I pulled up on the side of the building and saw they had a drive thru. I was elated as , I didn't want to get out of the car with a sleepy 16 month old. I asked what they had and they are known for their buttercream frosted cookies so and their cookies in general. So I got a chocolate-chocolate chip cookie and a vanilla cupcake with buttercream . They were so delicious and the man at the window was so kind in answering all my ridiculous questions about what all they have in the store since, I couldnt see from the car I definitely think it's such a great sweet satisfier !! Go try them! Oh , if you go to Local roots right now they are giving their cookies as desserts ;) ! read more

Sweet Tooth Cottage - Bakeries Near Me - Powell, Ohio

See all

Not sure where to start other than to say this place is amazing. Started out of Sue's kitchen nearly 7 years ago and finally morphing into Columbus' finest location for sweet treats. Sweet Tooth Cottage is a trip worth making. Each succulent "butter cookie" is not only flavored with imagination but the custom cut outs and icing design take these cookies far over the top. I have used STC not only for private small events but also large corporate events and gifts and have always received incredible feedback. Sue, Steven and Jamie along with the entire staff make this place not only a must stop in Powell but are the perfect trifecta to bring these cookies to life. In addition to Butter Cookies they also have a number of other sweet tooth favorites such as Oatmeal Chocolate Chip, Snickerdoodles (OMG!!!), Peanut Butter, Sallty Caramel, Lemon butter and many many more. Stop by their drive thru window for a quick treat or go in to see this beautiful bakery and meet the staff. It will be well worth the trip! read more

Made my order over the phone and they knew exactly what I was going for. Staff were very nice over the phone and in store. Great customer service! Will definitely be returning! read more

Sweet Tooth Cottage - Ordered over the phone - these look great! - Bakeries Near Me - Powell, Ohio

I have gotten many things from Sweet Tooth. Cookies, cakes, s''more bars and everything is amazing! I called last minute for a cake and they were able to accommodate me. They are super nice and great service!!! read more

Small little bake shop in the back of the shopping plaza. The man at the counter was pushy and rude. A little bit of customer service can go a long way. We decided on a lemon cookie and a snickerdoodle cookie as well as a smore bar. While all were okay, there was no originality behind any of the offerings. Not very memorable at all. read more

Sweet Tooth Cottage - Snickerdoodle, lemon and s'more bar - Bakeries Near Me - Powell, Ohio

Took a trip to Sweet Tooth for the first time yesterday. The bakery is cute, the employees are friendly and attentive, and the sweets are fantastic! We bought PB cookies drizzled in chocolate, Buckeyes, salty caramel cookies, and no bakes...all of which were well worth the visit. read more

Worst service ever. Not sure about the baked goods as they've run me off the 2 times I've been in there. 1st time I chalked it up to a fluke. Gave them another try and it was different people and the same crappy service. I'd rather give my money to Giant Eagle. read more

Honestly I'd rather get premade desserts from Kroger than from here. I've been here twice now, got a cookie the first time and a cupcake the second. Both times the dessert was very dry and didn't have that much taste. It's sad because I really wish there was a good bakery to go to around here, especially since Pink Moon closed, but the best place to go is honestly the bakery at Kroger or Giant Eagle. read more

I love the cookies here. They are soooooo good. They make them soft and it's so good. My favorites are the snickerdoodles

Needed 50 cookies fast. Came in 15 minutes before closing with this unexpected order. Got an assortment of 50 beautiful (& delicious) frosted sugar cookies in less than 10 min! Very friendly staff with a great assortment of hoodies! Very happy! read more

I love this place because good service and cookies and cakes. It's the best cookies ever! I loved it! So if you are looking for a good cookie place come to SWEET TOOTH!!! read more

I have had the pleasure of ordering cookies from Sweet Tooth Cottage several times and each order is made to perfection. I had confirmation cookies made for my granddaughter that were beautifully decorated and delicious. Cookies for friends for a special occasion.Always a hit! . Recently I ordered 9 dozen cookies for a special event. They were individually wrapped and tied with ribbon. My guests were amazed at not only the presentation but most importantly the delicious taste .Thank you Sue and staff for a high standard and great business. PPeyton read more