2/5 Stars Unfortunately, I have to give this place two stars. We ordered two turkey burgers, a chicken sandwich, chicken tenders, and two milkshakes. The burgers were $15.95 each and didn't even come with fries. The fries were an additional $5, and sauces cost extra as well. Our total bill came to $81, which I thought was extremely expensive considering none of the meals included fries and even the sauces were an additional charge. The ordering process was strange from the moment we walked in, and the staff was not particularly friendly or welcoming. The food came out fairly quickly, which was one of the few positives. The chicken sandwich was actually pretty good--I'd give it about a 7/10--and it was easily the best thing we ordered. Unfortunately, the turkey burgers were not good at all and lacked flavor. The chicken tenders were clearly frozen and did not seem homemade. The milkshakes were also disappointing and didn't taste like much. What really bothered me was the service. After realizing the burgers did not come with fries, I went to the front of the restaurant to ask if I could order some. The employee told me yes, but explained that orders had to be placed at the counter in the back. I immediately went to the back counter and waited. Both employees saw me standing there, but neither acknowledged me or offered to help. One employee was delivering an order while the other was simply standing there. After waiting about five minutes without anyone taking my order or even speaking to me, I finally left without ordering the fries or sauces. It was frustrating and made me feel completely unwelcome. Overall, I did not feel welcome, did not enjoy the experience, and would not return. The chicken sandwich was the only item I would consider ordering again, but unfortunately the food, service, and value just weren't there for me. read more

Found this little spot on Yelp while in the Snowmass area, and sure glad I did! The atmosphere was pretty cool with an open style kitchen and a cooked to order style ordering. The burgers were fresh and delicious, cooked exactly how requested. Fries and shakes were great too! Would definitely recommend to anyone in the area looking for a good burger! read more

Everything was amazing from start to finish. We had two regular cheeseburgers and a Turkey Burger in a lettuce wrap. All were delicious and Skylar our server and cashier was awesome. This was a great burger within in 100 miles. Easily and by far heads above the rest. read more

The turkey burger is delicious! Good flavor and juicy with cheese, lettuce and tomato on a delicious fresh tasty bun... The regular burgers look great too and I'm going to try the Asian chicken salad I just saw which looks really awesome. It's quick, casual, clean and satisfying! And don't forget to get a free mini-milk shake when you leave...nice!! read more

Pretty good burger and fries served hot and fresh. The chipotle mayo was the bomb! Good with hamburger and fries read more

Sure Thing Burger - Burgers Near Me - Basalt, Colorado

Average burger terrible fries. Extremely overpriced even for the roaring fork. They have decided to stock supplies all over the dining room and really degraded the overall ambiance by increasing clutter. read more

This was my first time at this establishment, and probably my last. I had the Sure Thing Burger with fries and the fries were the best thing about the meal, and they were bland - no salt or seasoning. The burger was under seasoned and the "special sauce" was underwhelming. The food is too basic for the price ($60 for 2 burgers, 2 fries, 2 drinks). Disappointed as this place bills themselves as a craft burger joint. read more

I got a BLT and it was great. Next time I'll ask for extra bacon though.. a personal preference. It was perfectly toasted and yummy! My boyfriend liked his burger and the fries were HOT and tasty. I think the ambiance was a bit lacking unfortunately. It seems like during Covid they moved the ordering station to the front and never moved it back. There were boxes of dry storage items in the dining room which felt a bit awkward honestly. I think If they adjusted the dining-room back to the way it was designed it would be a more comfortable dine-in experience. read more

Sure Thing Burger - BLT - Burgers Near Me - Basalt, Colorado

Ordered Ranchito burgers and fries. I really liked how the ordering process was smooth, the second I walked in. No silly confusing lines of kiosks (overrated tech) The restaurant was clean and so was the bathroom. Now let's address the elephant in the room. The prices are premium. But let's compare it to the likes of Shake Shack...you get more bang for your buck at Sure Thing. And you get free ice cream with your purchase. All things considered, you can't say it's overpriced given the proper comparison. So keep things up and don't let my 5 stars go in vane! read more

Crazy price increase for average tasting burgers. Very disappointing.. This isn't Aspen for you to be justifying these prices

Stopped here on a recommendation from a friend and was not disappointed. I had the turkey burger, which was very good. At many places they can be bland, but this one was well seasoned, without being too spicy. Fries were good, not the best ever, but a good side. Knocking off one star because: the person who took our order seemed put out that she had to do some work (we were some of the first customers, but once you're open you should expect people to come in). And the prices are pretty steep--it is a resort area, and the burgers are good, but nearly $20 for a burger and fries, without a drink? read more

Tried this place out for a quick burger as the kids wanted cheeseburgers for lunch. The place is fairly clean. Good staff helped me order. 4 burgers, 2 fries, and 3 drinks will run about $60-70. read more

Was looking for a place to stop on the way home from snowboarding at Aspen and found this place. The burgers were amazing. We both got them lettuce wrapped and shared a basket of fries which was certainly enough for the two of us. The fries were perfectly crispy and we asked for their home made sauce to dip in, which was delicious and had a little kick to it! They are SERIOUS about lettuce wrapping their burgers. They did not fall apart and we're extremely satisfying and a healthy kick on a burger! The customer service was great too! The owner asked if we wanted some complimentary ice cream after we finished our burgers too! Very kind! Will definitely return next time we're in town. read more

Sure Thing Burger - Veggie burger. Home made ingredients and deep fried as a patty. Not frozen!! Fresh!!! - Burgers Near Me - Basalt, Colorado

The burger was juicy and delicious. The crinkle fries were hot and crispy. The extra was the complimentary ice cream cone! Yummy! Service was great and the atmosphere and vibe was that of a fun and chill hang out. Wish there was one in my hometown of Houston, TX! read more

The burger was hot and amazing. The ice cream cone so delicious. Services was very fast and quick. Staff behave friendly with every customer. read more

Way to expensive. Just a burger is 16$ (not including fries) paid $25 for the burger and fries. However, the burger was good but the fries are average. Probably won't go back due to price. If I wanted an expensive burger, I'd go to a nice restaurant and sit now. read more

The food itself is pretty good and their sauces are amazing (also liked the shakes). However, we paid nearly $70 for 2 burgers, 2 shakes, and 1 "shareable" fry that were clearly not made in house. Price is extremely steep. read more

I typically order veggie burgers. This one was very flavorful. It was made at their restaurant. I had it served with grilled onions. My husband had their signature burger. He enjoyed it too . After a day of hiking in Aspen this place was the perfect end to our day . read more

Best burgers in Town fresh Ingredients my favorite is the Ranchito Style Burger with bacon and a slight spicy kick to it. Nicely cut lettuce just how I like it! 5 stars hands on read more

Sure Thing Burger - Surething Burger - Burgers Near Me - Basalt, Colorado

See all

Well... the theme is very familiar.... walk up order, self serve drinks and cleanup after yourself. Family table setting. Open kitchen. They're offering a free soft serve ice cream cone. Dipped of course... if you wish... This area needed a good burger joint. Clean kitchen and dinning area. Staff stayed busy and kept things tidy and moving along. Honestly, having eaten at many of these type burger joints it ranks in the middle of the bell curve. Wasn't bad, but wasn't exceptional. I'm trying to figure out exactly what is their claim to fame.... read more

Sure Thing Burger - Sure Thing Burger, fries - Burgers Near Me - Basalt, Colorado

My picky 14 year old said "it's the best burger I've ever had" and to be fair, I'd say it was one of the best I've had from burger joint too. Quick service, lots of smiles. We'll be back next time we're in the valley. read more

It's not worth $13 for a burger. Meal was mediocre at best. Ordering was confusing. You go to the corner that looks like a group of random people just hanging out at a table but that's where you place an order. Then you wait for a mediocre burger and milkshake that cost wayyy too much. read more

We walked in to see what that in the way of a veggie burger. They have one. It's fried - which is unusual and out of our typical wheelhouse - but we tried 2 anyway. Surprise! Their fried veggie burger, made in house, with whole vegetables inside the patty, are delicious, or as they would put it - a sure thing. Recommended for their unique and delicious veggie burger. read more

4.5 stars Wow this place is great! I had the deluxe burger with bacon, cheese, & chipotle sauce and my wife had the veggie burger which she said was the best she had ever had, rolled in panko breadcrumbs to give it a crispy texture. My burger was juicy, flavorful, & served on a homemade brioche style bun. Free soft serve ice cream with purchase was a nice touch. -0.5* for the lackluster fries, which were fine but not worthy of the great burgers they were paired with. Great lunch here & looking forward to returning! read more

Ordered a Pattie Melt and Fries today and they were both swimming in grease. Disgusting. Never again.

You're in for a treat at Sure Thing Burger. Top tier burgers paired with great, crispy crinkle cut fries. One of the better burgers I've had in recent memory. Clean environment and helpful, friendly staff. Highly recommend! read more

These folks do a very nice vegie burger. It is a house-made patty with some grains and legumes. It is served with a nice sauce and bun. The fries are an extra but worth it. They have a few good local beers on tap. The outdoor seating is ok and their COVID procedures seem in order. A good experience. read more

Great place. Delicious fresh salad but please use freshly grated carrots (and assorted other grated veggies) rather than the pre-grated variety package.They taste musty/mildewy . A takeaway from an otherwise delicious salad. read more

Really strange to have moved the order area to the front window. Ruins the whole flow of an orderly and nice place otherwise. Someone doesn't appreciate feng. read more

Cool spot in willits for a burger! Great veggie burger as well. Misters outside will keep you cool!

Excellent burger. Everything they make is fresh and you can taste the quality. The buns are very light and tasty.

Best burger in town! They give free ice cream cones with your meal as well. They are a bit on the pricier side but totally worth it. Fresh kombucha on tap and great beer selection! read more

In town for a wedding and staying at elements, and went here for dinner with a friend. This was in my top 3 burgers I ever had in my life and I consider myself a burger expert of sorts. Order the standard sure thing burger and subbed out caramelized onions with raw onions. I also added a fried egg as a little food lube. So dang tasty. Washed it down with an October fest beer and I was in heaven. read more

Sure Thing Burger - In all it's glory. - Burgers Near Me - Basalt, Colorado

See all

Amazing burger!! Best gluten free bun. I have celiac & had no issue. Highly recommend!

We wanted a place that had a dog friendly patio. Our kids loved it, my son says the double, double was stupendous. My daughter said her cheeseburger was awesome. I had the local burger, it was great, and all the kids liked free ice cream. The staff was friendly, and the service was fast. read more

Go for the patty melt, a creation that is a revelation. Chef owner is rightfully proud of this patty melt. Stay for the whipped dairy dessert included with your meal. Love they show skiing on TVs. Only wish that a half order of fries was an option. read more

Best burgers around, wonderful staff, and a free ice cream cone? Are you kidding?!! Love this place.

Second time was a much better experience. Bacon, egg burger was Ono! Only gripe - sides are extras like pickles. Whatdawhat! Really?! read more

Sure Thing Burger - Pretty decent. But no In-N-Out. - Burgers Near Me - Basalt, Colorado

Wonderful hamburger joint. Loved the Ranchito burger and Sure Thing Burger. We have the vanilla milkshake which was tasty. The fries were crisp and hot. One order was enough for two.Service was excellent and the staff very friendly. Was worth the drive from Snowmass. read more

Great burgers with friendly and fast service. Friend had Sure Thing burger with bacon in it's own food group, I had Ranchito and it was a nice level of spice, we split a fries, crinkle cut with crunchy goodness on the outside, resembling proper fish n chips chips. He liked the free chocolate vanilla squirrel ice cream read more