We live in Sedona and were very dissatisfied with cakes available in Sedona, so we ordered a birthday cake from Sugar Mamas in Flagstaff. We ordered a white cake with buttercream icing. Lexi was great to work with and came through with a tasty cake made from great ingredients. The cake was delicious, it felt like a real cake. So many bakery cakes these days taste like they were made from a mix and with cheap ingredients. Caution: When the cake is this good you feel like eating more so order a larger cake then you think you'll need.... read more

Sugar Mamas - a birthday cake on a table - Bakeries Near Me - Flagstaff, Arizona

Beautiful and tasty as ever! My Fiancé has made it his mission to get something for me from here every year on my birthday! Lexi is always very accommodating and helps him get what I would love!! They have very reasonable pricing too which is appreciated when having college kid budgets As always, thank you for your baking skills, these are the best! read more

Sugar Mamas - Coconut cream pie, red velvet cupcake, carrot cake cupcake - Bakeries Near Me - Flagstaff, Arizona

My daughter is in grad school at NAU and stuck at home for her birthday due to COVID 19. I was able to call and order the cake over the phone. It turned out great! read more

Sugar Mamas - Birthday cake - Bakeries Near Me - Flagstaff, Arizona

We were going to celebrate my son's graduation from NAU and I was looking for a local bakery for a great cake. Came across Sugar Mamas and boy, did Lexi (Sugar Mamas' owner) did not disappoint! The cake not only turned out beautiful, it tasted delicious! Freshly made vanilla buttercream with chocolate cake and raspberry filling. My graduating son loved it as much as we did. We highly recommend them if you are looking for a custom cake that tastes delicious! read more

Sugar Mamas - NAU graduation cake with NAU colors, navy & gold. So pretty I didn't want to cut into it! Tasted delicious! - Bakeries Near Me - Flagstaff, Arizona

They saved my bacon. I needed a last minute birthday cheesecake and somehow she pulled off a honey lavender massive cheesecake in under 24 hours despite having more than full capacity of orders. Not only that, this was hands down the best cheesecake I've ever had and my wife concurs. The only other cheesecake that was even close was at Sarge's Deli in Manhattan. Sugar Mamas is legit! read more

So happy that we spotted this place!! After a disappointing lunch experience across the street... Definitely made me feel better! They had two shelves of sweets...super cute sweets and pretty yummy! My favorites were the salted caramel brownie and the key lime pie! Yummy! Def will come visit again next time im in Flagstaff! read more

Sugar Mamas - Salted caramel brownie - Bakeries Near Me - Flagstaff, Arizona

See all

Wedding Cupcake Success!! We used Sugar Mamas for our wedding cupcakes and sweetheart cake and what a great choice! Everything from the personalized tasting to the final product was amazing! We were able to order various flavor combinations so that we had something for all of our guests. Everyone had nothing but compliments for them! We would highly recommend Sugar Mamas if you are planning a Flagstaff wedding, you will not be disappointed! read more

Lexi was wonderful! We ordered a cake and cupcakes, and there were none left. So delicious, and beautiful.

I have wanted to try Sugar Mama's for some time now and during my last trip to Flagstaff, I came here with my sister-in-law. We were walking around downtown Flagstaff and decided to get a sweet treat. At first glance, the outside and inside isn't much to look at. If I wasn't specifically looking for sweets, I might not know to pop in Sugar Mama's. The inside has two display cases with empty counter space between them and a cash register to the far right. Behind the counters is a prep area with storage and a wall of cookie cutters. (They had some interesting shapes!) When we entered, there were two employees working and a customer discussing a custom order. We were greeted with a friendly hello and offer to help. After scrutinizing the delicious looking contents of the two glass displays, I decided on purchasing some cookies. They had several cookie flavors to choose from, but I went with the classic chocolate chip and ginger molasses cookies. Additionally, they had sugar cookies, cupcakes, chocolate covered strawberries and a few other miscellaneous pastries. The cupcakes looked delicious, but none of the flavors stood out. My sister-in-law purchased some chocolate covered strawberries, which she inhaled later that evening. I enjoyed the chocolate chip cookies and my husband loved his ginger molasses cookie. (So did my father-in-law.) Overall, we liked our purchases. If they had more variety of cupcake flavors, I'd love to come back and give them a try. read more

I'm SO happy we stopped here. We love cupcakes. We ordered a strawberry vanilla and a strawberry lemonade cupcake. So yummy! Then out of the blue the baker said, "We also make fresh homemade challah on Fridays and Saturdays." I think the heavens parted and there were angels singing because when I decided to stay in Flagstaff for a while I searched the city for challah for the high holy days. Now I know just where to go ... sugar mamas. read more

See all

Thank you so much Sugar Mamas...we absolutely loved our cutting cake and cupcakes for our fall wedding...we were married in the aspen trees early October and the birch bark look frosting was beautiful and perfect! The cake and cupcakes were beyond delicious!! Thank you so very much! Love, Jody & Joe read more

Sugar Mamas - a wedding cake and cupcakes - Bakeries Near Me - Flagstaff, Arizona

I live in CA but I wanted to have homemade treats delivered for Fathers Day to my dad in Flagstaff. Sugar Mamas went above and beyond to find out what my dad would like and personally delivered them to their front door. Thank you for helping me out. My parents said everything was DELICIOUS!! read more

Lexi was easy to work with, willing to make my cake (it was vasectomy-themed in the writing, but not in decoration), and the cake was INCREDIBLE. It looked good, was what I asked for, and she helped me brainstorm a clever decoration idea when my initial plan wasn't going to be possible. The cost was totally reasonable as well. I never like cake, and only got a cake to be festive and for others to enjoy, but I couldn't put it down. I especially never like icing, but this one was great. The cake stayed moist and delicious for days. We finished every last bite, and we've been missing it since then! The Mexican chocolate was exactly the right amount of spicy in the after taste. Perfect. (My previous review was from when she was located downtown and not as a special order bakery. Literally none of that review is relevant anymore, as she is now a special order bakery.) read more

Had never reached out to a local bakery before, but IM GLAD I DID! Sugar Mamas is amazing and came through with more then I expected! They made an amazing carrot cake and cupcakes for my girlfriends birthday! They came out so delicious and I will definitely be doing business with them again. If your trying to decide where you want to get your goodies from, no need to look any further! Sugar mamas is definitely the best place to go! You won't regret it!! Thank you so much Lexi!! read more

Sugar Mamas - two cupcakes in a box - Bakeries Near Me - Flagstaff, Arizona

See all

So I've never actually been to the location but there was an evening on a lonely dirt road when hundreds of people were stuck in a traffic jam and... BAM! There was the owner of this wonderful, majestic business... cookies in hand! She offered them out to all of us who were waiting for the freeway entrance to open up and we basically had a great time eating delicious cookies and enjoying the beautiful night. I'll be visiting this establishment the very next time I'm in Flag for sure! P.S. I'm sorry I forgot your name... The 6 hour drive home rattled my brains and the only things I remember were the deliciousness of your product and the awesomeness of your dog. Thanks for helping to turn our disaster into a fun story instead! read more

I was visiting Flagstaff from Las Vegas and ordered a German chocolate cake on the phone! This was my husbands birthday cake and he had no clue I ordered it! He loved it! Thanks a lot! read more

Sugar Mamas - Bakeries Near Me - Flagstaff, Arizona

Lots of candied apples and treats to choose from There is also a case of gelato ( which we enjoyed). Limited seating- there is a table and a few chairs up against the window. read more

I had a horrible experience here! My mother-in-law and grandmother-in-law were in town visiting and we were looking for places to order our wedding cake from. We had just come from "A Touch of Sugar" (whom I recommend!) and had basic questions about cakes. The woman there was very rude and short to my 101 year old grandmother-in-law who was asking for a ball park price, price of delivery, tasting fees, etc. When I showed her the design I was interested in she said "Its never going to look like how you want it".... not a real selling point! Then we bought a few cupcakes to try out the taste... and they were completely stale and hard as a rock!! I would not suggest this place to anyone! read more

Sugar Mamas baked the cake for our wedding at Shoshone Point on 10/3, *very* last minute (our original caterer dropped out mid-June). They were very responsive and helpful with the super short deadline. On top of that, the cake was *amazing*. When we took our first bite, we both paused and then kept shoveling cake into our mouths it was sooo delicious! Another fun thing - my husband's favorite cake is German Chocolate, so they made us a cupcake to have in our room at the end of the night (also scrumptious!). We cannot thank Sugar Mamas enough, they were the best! read more

I was just looking into spots I could get a cake from for a special occasion later this year. Saw mama had to have a minor surgery andI hope she feels better soon. Blessings to her. read more

Above and beyond great! Amazing homemade sweets! I had a cupcake and tried a key lime cheesecake. Both were sweet, flavorful, dimensional and I wish we lived here so we could become regulars! read more

Sugar Mamas - Cookie! - Bakeries Near Me - Flagstaff, Arizona

Best bakery in the world!!!! I was forced to send a cake box full of goodies to my house hold back in Philly, only to come home to an empty box and a happy house hold. Go to sugar mamas!!!! Or if you don't enjoy life then don't go. Please sugar mamas come to Philly!!!! read more

Awesome stuff, a huge selection and great prices for the high quality. Nice people too! I am thoroughly impressed and the world needs more Sugar Mamas!. read more

I absolutely love, love, love this wonderful little locally owned downtown business. You can tell they've been up all night baking, everything is fresh and amazing. I love that they really use their imaginations in their recipes, using ingredients that make you drool, but aren't necessarily the usual. They post their daily featured items on Facebook, so follow them there, I bet won't be able to resist! Www.Facebook.com/sugarmamas read more

Sugar Mamas - a variety of desserts - Bakeries Near Me - Flagstaff, Arizona

Sugar Mamas killed it! I had them make my wedding cake and it was hands down the best cake I've ever put in my mouth. We chose carrot cake with a rumchatta frosting and it was divine. It really was a Pinterest worthy cake, absolutely beautiful. Mostly I worked with the owner and overall I would say she's pretty easy to work with. She's accommodating and she gives good recommendations on how to transport your cake, whether or not it will keep well, and a ton of other little details I probably wouldn't have even thought of. I totally recommend it! read more

Sugar Mamas - a three tiered wedding cake - Bakeries Near Me - Flagstaff, Arizona

Such a delicious and special dessert to celebrate a birthday! Came up north from the valley and Sugar Mamas was all that reviews said it would be. Caramel macchiato cheesecake (unique speciality!) was a hit. Crust tasted like bischoff cookie. S'mores cupcakes were amazing! Marshmallow frosting was light and fluffy (kid approved!). Thank you for making the ordering and pickup process easy. Worth every penny! read more

I have bought a bourbon pecan pie and a few other little treats from this place over the last few months. The pie I ordered was way too sweet for my tastes, but was decent overall. I've also always bought the cupcakes, cookies, and brownies after 3PM, so I suppose that everything is made in the morning and that over the day things just get a bit stale. Overall, however, I really do enjoy coming to this location and would definitely recommend it. read more

Wow...these were some super amazing cupcakes - blackberry, white chocolate strawberry and chocolate/vanilla...and the best part is that they are all filled - bonus! I am craving these tasty treats just writing this review. Everything in the bakery looked amazing and I can't wait to visit Sugar Mama's again on my next trip to Flagstaff! read more

My son attends NAU and for his very first birthday away from home I wanted to have some spectacular cupcakes delivered to his dorm. Sugar Mamas' schedule was tight, but they gladly accommodated my special request and delivered them (not their normal gig). Lexi was incredibly helpful in taking the order and making sure it was delivered to the dorm on time. My son and his roommates absolutely raved about the cupcakes (chocolate and red velvet). It was a sweet Cupcake Party at Wilson Hall! Special thanks to Lexi for making my son's birthday extra special. I highly recommend Sugar Mamas and we can't wait to try some of their treats the next time we visit Flag. Thumbs up, Mamas! read more

July 2012 Location: Sugar mamas is located off the bustling downtown area in an area that seems to be undergoing gentrification. It seemed a good place to wonder about a bit and see what was being constructed. Atmosphere: inside there is no seating. There re two bakery cases with a mixture of pastries and baked goods, heavier on baked goods. Did not seem to be coffee options. Service: the day we were there the place was being run by one young woman. I asked her if she did all the baking and she said yes. She was efficient but not particularly friendly. Food: There were cookies, cupcakes, brownies, danish, and scones. We ordered an almond cheese Danish, a red velvet and a spicy chocolate cupcake, an orange sugar cookie and a plain sugar cookie, and a brownie. The Danish tasted better than it looked. It was covered with slivered almonds and a light drizzle of frosting. Inside it was not flaky but chewy and flavorful with only a touch of cheese. I heated half the next day, and it was still good. Cookies were crunchy but tasty. The plain had a definite taste of almond extract. The other tasted of orange. Both were frosted with a glaze that was dried on the cookies. These tasted very good, fresh and not stale, but they are not soft. The brownie was very rich and deep, dark chocolatey, quite good with a rich dark chocolate frosting. The cupcakes were the least appealing. While the frosting was good, the cupcakes were dried out and crumbly. read more

I wanted to order a cake for my mom's 65th birthday. I'm new to flagstaff and wasn't sure where to go, but I knew exactly what I wanted - vanilla cake with raspberry filling and lemon frosting. I came across Sugar Mamas website and they offered that exact combination. The cake was beautiful and delicious. More old-fashioned, denser cake and didn't have that aftertaste you sometimes get from a too sugary cake. My mom said it was the best birthday cake she's ever had!! Plus it was reasonably priced, can't wait to order again! read more

Sugar Mamas always has the BEST baked goods in town! This small, local owned and operated business has a special place in our heart. The staff does an amazing job and makes you fell like an old friend as soon as you walk in the door :) Amazing pastries and sweets that taste like heaven and melt in your mouth. We stop here every time we are in Flagstaff! read more

We were in Flagstaff last week for our daughter's NAU orientation. We asked a local server about finding the best chocolate chip cookie in town (a fun adventure when we travel). They suggested Sweet Mamas and we were not disappointed! I asked the two ladies/owners what the best cookie was and they suggested the gingersnap cookie (one of their grandma's recipes). That was seriously the best cookie I've ever tasted. Crisp on the outside, chewy on the inside! The choc chip one was equally as good. This will be my new "have to" on our visits to Flag for (hopefully) years to come! read more

We used Sugar Mamas for our wedding cake and it was absolutely fantastic! Lexi, the owner, was so professional and on point at my tasting that I knew she was the one! My husband couldn't make it to the tasting and she was sweet enough to make two mini cakes to take home to him! The guests raved about the taste (we did red velvet and carrot) and the cakes we had looked incredible! Lexi will tell you that they never freeze your cake like other places will and you can tell the difference! I wished we lived in Flagstaff so we could frequent this wonderful business more often! Thank you Sugar Mamas for an incredible wedding cake and groom's cake! read more

So delicious! Ordered 4 flavors of cupcakes and chocolate covered strawberries for a special retirement party and everyone loved loved loved them! It is sort of that thing when you are eating your first cupcake and you are actually thinking about when you will have a chance to eat a second one Lexi is great to work with and and that's why I just ordered goodies for another "goodbye party" next week. So looking forward to the salted caramel almond brownies, lemon bars, cannoli's, and white chocolate macadamia nut cookies. Can hardly wait to pick them up! Checkout Sugar Mama's FB page to see some more pics of Lexi's sweet treats. read more

I guess because I live above the jamesbeard Tartine in SF I'm a little biased but...We have tried a variety of baked goods from Sugar Mamas which include: Tarts, cookies, cupcakes etc. Everything was good but nothing blew our minds. The baked goods are very rustic and not refined. In our experience it seems you never know what you are going to get. One day the cheesecake crust is thick, one day it's thin and some days the black and white cookies have lemon, some days they don't. It's a crap shoot. That being said they are one of the better bakeries in town and we continue to give them our business. read more

I had heard some great things about Sugar Mamas. I had the pleasure of stopping in last week while out doing some marketing calls. The place rocks. Lisa Born was amazing. The goodies were scrumptious. I picked up a cheesecake brownie for my sweetheart, a lemon bar for myself. I love anything lemon. Also a brownie with Carmel topping OMG it was perfect. I am hooked and I shall return. What a great place this is. A must for any one's sweet tooth. read more

Probably the most disgusting pastries I've had in the entire world. Being a traveler, this was a very poor bakery my party and I to chose. Customer service was horrendous and there is no way that I will be going back. I will suggest to friends and family never to go and purchase from this bakery. read more

I liked this place and I would go back, but some of the items are hit or miss. The cookies were ok, but a bit hard and I prefer my cookies softer. The cupcakes were fairly decent, but a bit dry. They were better if you let them warm up a bit. My brownie...the salted caramel part was good, but the brownie itself was rather dry. read more

My family was spending our summer vacation in Flagstaff with my parents, coinciding with my mom's 80th birthday. I told my dad I'd take care of the cake and then tried to figure out where to order one! Sugar Mama's reviews on YELP convinced me to call. Lexi was super patient with all of my questions. We are a family that is obsessed with the "family recipe" for chocolate cake, so I was a little worried about choosing the two-layer sheet cake with one white and one chocolate layer. I should never have doubted! The chocolate was as fabulous as our family recipe, and her ganache filling was SO DELICIOUS. My parents and all of their friends were delighted! And the staff where we had the party, who declined cake at first, grabbed it the minute they heard it was from Sugar Mama's. Apparently YELP helped me discover a local treasure. And just look at the beautiful decorations on the cake, which COMPLETELY matched my picky description of what I like. Could not have been happier. And did I mention how long the leftovers were tasty? . . . . read more

Sugar Mamas - loved this birthday cake for my mom! - Bakeries Near Me - Flagstaff, Arizona

See all