Food is delicious and the service is quick and it's all relatively inexpensive the ambiance isn't what you would normally expect from a pizza place but that's not necessarily a bad thing. They have a strange rule against minors eating in but one would assume there is a reason behind this overall a great restaurant with great food. read more

The pizza was decent, placed a big order last night for 6 pizza and 2 GF pizza, had to pay by card on the phone, they asked if I wanted to tip, I said not on the card. When they presented the receipt to who was picking up, he signed the slip, (card not in his name) and left a large tip... I didn't tell him not to tip, I didn't think he would be asked since I already declined. I'm kinda pissed they did this, it felt deceiving. I'm fine with leaving a tip and always do in cash when I am there weekly and for personal meals, but this receipt needed to be presented and approved for reimbursement and no one thought it was worth the large tip he left. He felt like an ass. Not sure I feel like giving my business there anymore. read more

Great chicken tenders good price- Greek salads good too. Price is average. Good options for a party

We ordered two sandwiches for delivery at 5:33 pm. We were told approximately 45 minutes to an hour. At 6:52 pm we called to get an update and were told it was being bagged and we would receive our food soon (we live about 5 minutes from the restaurant). I called back (again) at 7:20 pm and was told " it's on the way". Nearly two hours to deliver two sandwiches. Unfortunate because the food is usually good. Definitely won't be ordering delivery ever again . Cancelled the order , really poor service. read more

The food was wonderful and they were very friendly. Their single slices of pizza are very large, which I appreciate quite a bit.

The restaurant looks very good from the outside and they recently did some work to improve the dining room. It is much nicer although it definitely holds a more "takeout"than "eat in" vibe. The staff has always been very nice and quick to serve. The pizza in its "by the slice" form is really good and in my opinion among some of the best in Northampton/Florence. Getting the whole pizza pie somehow had a different texture, presentation and taste which was disappointing, but for my purposes I absolutely love their slices for their taste, texture, and ample serving size for the money. I recommend Starr Pizza. read more

The pizza was quite loaded edge to edge but lacking in flavour. The crust was basically flavorless and under-done. Texture that of a pre-made crust. They seem to be doing a good business though, so folks must like their product. read more

This is the very, very best pizzas and my family and I absolutely love them!!! The service is very friendly and they know you by name and by face when you appear in their restaurant!!! Highly recommended and give it all of 5 stars! read more

Excellent value. Great food. They don't like credit cards. They'll take credit cards but they give a discount for cash.

Some menu items are really good while others are sub par. Don't get the soups! I swear they have a single, thin, soupy Alfredo like sauce they use on all their cream based dishes and as the base to their soups...it all tastes the same!! A weird, cheesy mess but with tortellini or mushrooms or broccoli in it. Its really bad...worse when rewarded. Calzones are decent as are the pizzas. Grinders and sandwiches are so-so. Deserts are nothing special. Freaking awesome delivery driver though!!! read more

Nice space. Only $5 for 2 slices and a drink. Open on Sunday and they were very friendly staff. I would highly recommend Starr's Pizza of Florence. read more

Starr's Pizza - Cute place. Spacious with nice light, spaced tables. - Pizza Near Me - Florence, Massachusetts

My favorite food in Florence by far. I work locally down the street and I get stars 3-4 times a week for lunch. They have awesome affordable lunch deals with so many options. And don't get me started the lasagna dinner is unmatched with the garlic bread it's awesome. I recommend everyone that comes through our store to go to stars if they are looking for food. 10/10 for stars read more

On our way to VT we stopped here bc my grandson wanted pizza. Did not disappoint. We had the pizza combo and steak sub. Portions were huge and priced reasonably. But more importantly both were good! I liked the pizza crust. It was light and crunchy. The person at the counter taking orders was very helpful too. read more

Passed through Florence the other day, parked my car and decided to give Starr a try. I was really hungry and this place was close. Really glad I went here. I ordered a pretty basic grilled chicken grinder (which is what they call subs in New England?). Lettuce tomato Mayo and chicken and my goodness. It was so delicious that on my way back to New York yesterday, I detoured back into Florence to grab another one. That good. read more

They are a little on the pricey side but the pizza was good thin crust (which I am partial to). I would give a 4 but their customer facing people are not the best and they weren't helpful ("Do you need plates, napkins?"). Had to ask for everything. But the pizza is good! read more

-5 stars on their local dinners - especially their starr's pesto dinner. frozen and microwaved total yuk action - gross upon immediately eating. i asked for added spinach, they di not add it. too much pasta - very little product. negative five points. read more

Amazing pizza spot it is affordable than any other place over the summer I was there nearly every day

Decided to check it out on a day when Florence Pizza (my go-to deliverer in this COVID time) was having driver shortages. The delivery wasn't TOO late getting to me, the prices weren't bad, but the food just wasn't much good. I'd have had a more enjoyable pizza making it up myself with naan, and the sub was bland and tasteless. Perhaps other people have their own experiences, but this was mine. read more

Can't say enough about this place! Best Pizza in all of Northampton without the parking problems.

Over an hour for delivery to a house that's 5 minutes down the road. It's a shame. I called and complained and was just told to wait for the delivery guy, he's on his way. I'd expect a quick pizza order to be here a little quicker. Or at least an apology. read more

After often ordering delivery from Starr's for about a year to the VA where I reside I will never order from there again!! Something is wrong!!! Maybe they changed the cook, but last things I ordered- calzone is super dry - you must have water to push it down! The food came cold a couple of times and the last time I ordered chicken parm dinner there was a piece of blue fingernail in the sauce that made me gag and put the final nail on the coffin for me... sorry never again!!! read more

Went on a whim with a friend as it was time to try something new...we decided to go for something from the Mexican variety on menu,it's really good and quite reasonable! Next time I am likely going to try a sub,but the mex offerings were very satisfying. Pleasant staff,low key place for eat in or take out/delivery. read more

Worst service ever. I understand being busy on a Friday but 2 hours for a small order called in at 5 is silly. When I called to find out about delivery time I was hung up on. Then when I called to ask about canceling the order and getting a refund I was hung up on twice. I was always polite, never angry but was treated with disrespect. I work in customer service and know how hard it can be. This is inexcusable. read more

Best pizza I've tasted in Northampton, big y's pizza is a bit better but Starr's is faster at cooking the pizza than big y. I don't think the owners speak good English because it took me a while to get them to understand my order but they are friendly. Would recommend if you're looking for quick pizza but if you have time big y is better taste. read more

I started coming into this place after I took a job in Florence. They have a great special for 2 slices and a drink for under 6 dollars, and those slices are huge. My lunch break is 30 minutes and I can rarely finish both slices. They're polite and friendly and I love that they always have the telenovelas on! Can't be beat, baby! read more

They have a wide variety of food for usually good prices. It's more affordable than Friendly's usually for lunch and dinner and about the same quality. It's nothing spectacular and the dining room is a little dingy but everyone is usually polite and professional and it's a good pick up dinner spot. read more

Actually never had their pizza as I am living in Germany at the moment. I called them asking if I could put a delivery order in to be delivered the next morning to my girlfriend's place of employment. The lady who answered the phone was extremely helpful, said no problem and would be delivered at a specific time! Dead on delivery, Haply Girlfriend, Happy Co-workers! I'll def be eating there when i get back in town! read more

I gotta say I really like these guys, good subs, calzones are great, the chicken bacon ranch calzone being just hella good stuff. It's one of my regular places. It's really saying something to have eaten here so much and never having gotten a bad order. read more

Favorite pizza. Love the food and the service. They're so kind and make you feel like a "regular." Won't go anywhere else for pizza in the area. read more

After a few drinks at Brew Practitioners across the street, we sagely decided to eat before driving home. We asked folks at the brewery which of the four pizza places within 2 blocks they recommended, and we got pretty mixed responses, with one enthusiastic (tipsy) endorsement for A-1, so we went with the one rated highest on Yelp, A-1 Pizza. But they only took cash, so no go (plus it was pretty dingy inside). Then we went to the place across the street from that, Pizza Factory, and they only sold whole pies (plus all eight or 10 seats in the dining room were occupied). Looping our way back to the car, we wound up at Starr's. For $9(total!!) my husband and I each got two slices, each as big as our face, and two drinks; paid on a debit card, which was welcome. The dining room isn't anything to write about (except on Yelp!), but it is more spacious and comfortable than either of the other two places we entered. Lots of flies on this particular day, but they probably just snuck in whenever the door was opened. And a/c, so yay for that. The pizza quality was "A-OK"; the crust was soft but sturdy enough to allow for folding without cracking or ripping. Cheese was greasy but not disgustingly so. We had to nab some red pepper from a nearby table; ours had only salt, black pepper and ketchup. I would definitely grab a pizza to go from here if I lived in the neighborhood. read more

I enjoy getting pizza here as well as my cream of broccoli soup. And their chicken gorgonzola wrap is delicious. They offer free wifi and the staff are friendly. I think they have new owners for about a year or so now but the service is still great and menu options are pretty much the same. read more

I love the food and all but I think it's weird deal #10 and #2 are no longer available, but yet they are shown online!

cheapest place in Florence for food. the menu has a wide variety of food. Everything I've ordered I've yet to be disappointed. I recommend any of the pasta diners and the chicken and broccoli alfredo pizza. read more