Basic, no frills pizza spot with a variety of slices. The cheese slices came out pipping hot but were slightly devoid of flavor. They had a nice chewy crust with just the right amount of sauce. A little bit of Parmesan and pepper flakes improved things. I'd try some of the other slices next time and maybe the spinach pie. read more

Pinocchio's gets my vote for areas best pizza. And I'm a znob. Great staff. Solid biz.

HANDS DOWN, the best pizza I've had in forever!!!!! We got a chicken broccoli BBQ slice. OMG. It was sooooooo delish. The crust was amazing. Topping were fresh. Staff was very polite explaining all the different choices. The place could use a good cleaning but it's sooooo tasty you won't even care! read more

See all

Amazing pizza love the NY feel to the place French fries tasted fresh. They definitely use new oil read more

Very tasty! My boyfriend couldn't stop talking about. "That pizza was so good, it was like the perfect slice" read more

Ella says it's the best pizza she ever tasted and the lemonade was so good. She also loved the pictures and how fast they were ordering and delivering. She also likes how you can ask questions without getting up since you're so close and the prices. read more

I no longer eat meat so I get the Hawaiian pizza without ham, that is I get a slice of pizza with many pineapples on it and red onions. It is totally delicious and they make that special for me, so they accommodate what you would like if the slice you want is not there!! Ooh la la read more

Today was my first time coming back to Pinocchio's in about ten years. I was first introduced to this pizza place during high school while I was in summer camp and we used to come here on weekends and grab a slice. Everything is exactly as I remembered -- huge variety of slices, enormous pieces of pizza, and fantastic pesto tortellini pizza!! The dough is nice and chewy. The pizza is a bit light on the sauce but they lay on that cheese! The women working today were lovely and friendly. I will also add, I had to drive across state today for an appointment in Easthampton and made a point of stopping for pizza before leaving, which was the only nice part of my trip. So if you love a good slice, check it out! read more

Pinocchio's Pizzeria - Tortellini pizza and Margherita pizza - Pizza Near Me - Northampton, Massachusetts

We were in Northampton quite late into the night getting drinks and we noticed that most eateries were shut by 9-10PM. We thought we were going to have to get McDonald's or Wendy's and thankfully we found this pizzeria. Very friendly staff. Good amount of seating. Lots of options to choose from in terms of pizza by the slice. You have to be buzzed into the bathrooms which is a good system to have. The pizza tasted really good. Pricing is very decent. read more

Pinocchio's Pizzeria - Pepperino slice and bbq slice - Pizza Near Me - Northampton, Massachusetts

See all

We had a birthday party and ordered 7 pizzas a day in advanced. Came to pick up exactly on time , and the pizzas was there waiting for us warm and ready. Our party really enjoyed the pizza ! 5 stars from us ! A++++ read more

The pizza is warm and toasty, they give you big slices one could feed you for lunch. The people who work there are so nice and kind and will help you find what you need, and they make the pizza perfectly and by hand. read more

There are several pizza places to get a quick slice of good pizza in Northampton. I usually go to Mimmo's which has make your own large "two plate" pizza slices. Pinocchio's, on the other hand, has several different types of pizza already made and there is no argument about the size of slice you get or the types of toppings you have to choose from. Let's face it, sometimes it's better to have 2 decent slices of pizza so that you can have different toppings on It rather than one enormous slice with the same toppings. If you go with somebody else who gets a different slice, sometimes you can share, results may vary depending on the person you go with. :-) walk up to the counter pick your pizza and sit at a small counter that runs along the wall. I will be the first to admit that I don't have a strong feeling about crust or that type of sauce, but I like a good cheese and I was happy here. To be honest, I think Domino's has a really good buttery garlic crust that nobody else has, so I am perhaps somebody that should be disregarded as far as crust goes :-) read more

Honestly I was expecting really cheap pizza when I walked into this hole in the wall for a quick bite. But I was pleasantly surprised by how good their specialty pizzas tasted. They have so many different types of pizzas available. Looking forward to coming back for more. read more

See all

Pizza in the morning, pizza in the evening, pizza at supper time. For what this is (a slice shop), it is jammin'. The slices were tasty, the prices were on brand, and the seating was plentiful. Plus, love that they're open late. In a town of this size, it's hard to find any kind of 'drunk food' served after 10pm. Need a slice on the go? Defffff stop here. *praise hand emojis* read more

One of the main things about a Pizza by the Slice place is that you have to be open late! Especially if you're in the heart of Northampton's Downtown. It's almost criminal. Pizza is about cheese, sauce, and bread. The one thing Pinocchio's excels in is its cheese. The crust when I had it was a bit burnt, and the sauce didn't really have a presence. The other specialty slices are good, but only because I think to myself: "How does someone mess up Chicken, BACON, and RANCH?". Same can be said about others. Now, they do get a bit feisty with some of their other specialty slices, and I appreciate it. It's a nice refreshing taste. But the one thing that really disappoints me is that Pinocchio's is only open until midnight on Friday and Saturday. Other than that, it's a decent spot to stop by for a cheese slice (But only at normal hours :( ) read more

Pinocchio's Pizzeria - Avocado, feta cheese, tomatoes. Not bad to be honest. - Pizza Near Me - Northampton, Massachusetts

Authentic delicious affordable and open later than most places in the area. Great for a quick bite or a whole pizza.

Great food and friendly staff! Lots of specialty slices to choose from if you can't decide.

Wandered into this place almost by accident (I am a vegan). They made me the best veggie sub I could imagine. Broccoli, red and green sweet peppers, mushrooms, red onion, carrots, all sauteed to order, slid into a large sub bread and toasted in the pizza oven. You could add cheese if you wanted it, but I don't think it would improve the experience. read more

Amazing pizza and amazing service! They are so sweet and always have the best pizza, ready fast, and there is definitely some wizardry going on that makes everything cooked to perfection. read more

This is a "Totally low key" pizza slice place. ...There are 3 good places for slices in NoHo and this one is number 2 for me. Number 2 is a good rank though and all 3 compare super well outside the North East. Anyway, you will find a good variety of pies by the slice here. I have never had a bad one. Unsurprisingly the ones very late at night always seem to taste the best though ...and as you can judge from that statement Pinocchio's is a great place to hit after or before (as is the case tonight) hitting the bars of NoHo. The service is always quick, efficient and no frills. The prices are very reasonable and what you would expect. Mmmmm that was good. read more

See all

I have been eating Pinocchio's pizza for over 25 years. Back in the day, what they were doing in terms of fresh toppings and creative combinations was pretty cutting edge for a take-out by-the-slice joint... and now, even though there are plenty of other places with similar "gourmet slice" offerings, Pinocchio's remains a standout. Their massive slice of Spinach Pie (for about $4, which is a STEAL for something this delicious and filling), has long been one of my favorite on-the-go indulgences. Loads of gorgeous spinach, onions, thick slices of meaty mushrooms, feta (and other cheeses?) topped with a second, much thinner crust that helps hold the whole thing together. Pure. Heaven. And I remember when the man behind the counter was just a young teenager! On a Main Street where business come and go, I really appreciate the familiar faces of our long-time memory anchors. Thank you, Pinocchio's! read more

See all

Seriously, the best Pizza in Northampton. I love to stop in and grab a slice on my way now and then. I've been coming here for years, and the food never disappoints. Typically a slice place. You can get take out, tho and bring home a whole fresh pie. They have a LONG counter with slice options up, usually kept pretty fresh, you can tell they have years in this game, and have many options. A LARGE number of Vegetarian pies. They recently added small 10" Gluten Free personal pizzas. They also generally have Calzones too, I've not had one, but that's probably soon to change. They've changed up the soda and drinks. These used to be behind the counter, but they have a fridge now with lots of unique choices in it. All the sugar mexican sodas. (Mmmm, Mexicoke) and energy drinks. They also have Jarritos soda's in many flavors (Including Tamarind.) They used to be cash only, but this has now changed! They take plastic now. Seating is VERY limited. Lunchtimes can be busy. They're open late-ish, too (about 11pm) most nights, so good to grab a slice on the way home from a show. read more

This is definitely the best pizza place to go to if you're in the northampton area. There is a variety of pizza flavors, and the price is reasonable. My favorite slice is the tortellini. It fills my carb cravings, and the crust is so fluffy. When my boyfriend ordered the classic hawaiin pizza, it was very average, however. The crust was a lot thinner and you couldn't really taste much on top. The pizzeria had some interesting decorations, which is entertaining to look into when you're there too! I wish this place stayed open a little later though, so I could go after some bar hopping. read more

Pinocchio's Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - Northampton, Massachusetts

See all

If you are n the area this place is a must eat. Not your typical pizza. My experience included a slice of black bean pizza which was amazing. read more

Inexpensive pizza in a cramped place... that is absolutely amazing. I have never seen a place with preprepared pizzas like Mexican (including black bean base and avocado), broccoli & mushroom on a pesto base, and something best called a Mediterranean pizza (artichoke hearts, roasted red peppers, kalamata olives, and a whole lot more). I was shocked by the vegetarian selection and there options for meat eaters too. Get a few slices to go and eat them while you walk around the cute downtown of Northampton. I love it when someplace exceeds my expectations and Pinocchio's did. read more

Pinocchio's Pizzeria - Margarita pizza & broccoli mushroom pizza - Pizza Near Me - Northampton, Massachusetts

See all

Best slices in the area. Reminds me of Pizza you get from NY or NJ. Consistent quality, good dough. A good reminder that many of the pizza places in New England don't suck because of "the water", no they just suck! read more

Love this place. Delicious pizza and it really feels like you're in a great hole-in-the-wall place in the North End that only the locals know about. read more

I love this place. I found it by mistake and what a great mistake! The slices are huge. The variety of their menu is great. The prices are low but the food is great quality. Glad I found it! read more

I love this place I got a tortilla pizza and it was delicious and each time it gets better it's made right after you order it. Amzing. Y haven't lived till you ate here read more

It's fine, I guess? People kept raving so I got pizzas for trivia at the Deuce and the pizza was... bland. And kind of tough. So, uh, it's not terrible. Maybe try another option. read more

Not the best pizza in town, but extremely convenient place to grab a slice on the run and they usually have a few flavors to choose from.

Oh, Pinocchio's.... yet another item on my short list of things I miss about Northampton/Smith College. Hands down, the best pizza I have ever had. The cheese is flavorful, and there is a totally unique and massive array of topping combinations (already made for you, but I'm sure you could request your own mix). Feta, tomato, and avocado was my #1. So good you forget they're not even Italian! Just a couple of quarters more expensive than Mimmo's for somewhat smaller, but balls to Mimmo's. Why would want a too-huge slice you can't finish that tastes like nothing, when you can get enough to fill you up that tastes like the best ever? read more

Dear Pinocchio's, You are an integral part of my life in Northampton. You're a regular stop in my shopping routine - just when I'm running out of steam from pouring over everything in Broadside, Faces, and cedar chest, your slices give me strength to spend the next hour cd shopping in Turn It Up. Just when my friends have had one too many beers at the Brewery, your late night offerings help them regain their balance before we head off to drink more at the Dirty. And in moments of desperation due to hunger and long lines at Eastside, you're always available with no questions asked about why you're our last choice for dinner. I heart you. Just one request - could you please be nicer to me when I'm ordering? Then I'd happily fork over five stars. Thanks, Lauren read more

What an incredibly strange little place with what I would call exotic pizza: cheese, black beans, avacado and more mexican toppings or large slices of potato Im not totally sure what these people are aiming for I wonder if they know at all but the pizza is pretty darn good. AND, they stay open late which is aplus in a small place like NoHo. But something to note is that they do not have ranch but do have several mexican sauce flavorings read more

This has been my favourite place to come for food in noho. They have some crazy pizza toppings and nearly all the pizza is good. Prices are reasonable and the pizza is belly filling. Favorites include cheese tortellini, bbq chicken, taco. read more

I didn't expect much from this little cash-only joint, but I walked out with the closest thing I've found to an NJ slice in the area. The crust was almost crisp enough, just a few millimeters too thick, the sauce just barely too sweet. But I was homesick that night and it hit the spot. Northampton is saturated with pizza places, some better and plenty worse than Pinocchio's, but this will be the first place I head whenever I start jonesing for the thin not-too-cheesy slices of my youth. read more

Pinocchio's Pizzeria - Not a pretty pic (I was starving), but look - it's foldable - Pizza Near Me - Northampton, Massachusetts

Awesome place to come for a slice of pizza. They have a wide array from the basics like cheese and pepperoni, artichokes & veggies, hamburger, to my favorite chicken tortellini. Has a bbq sauce with generous pieces of chicken and tortellini on it and is seriously so yummy. They also have calzones and salads but I usually just come in for the pizza. They are reasonably priced at $3.50 (for the specialty). They are also open late night, so its very convenient if you are roaming around downtown after the bars.. There is a high top table with about 5-6 bar stools where you can sit at and also a couple of four top tables. CASH ONLY! YELP 365:036/365 read more

Fresh pizza with lots of variety. Can't beat the price or quick service. Will be back. read more

Pinocchio's Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - Northampton, Massachusetts

Great variety at a great price! Came here to grab a quick lunch before exploring the nearby shops (we just moved to the area). I love casual pizza by the slice places like this! read more

I was visiting from the Philadelphia, PA area and found the variety and quality of pizza excellent. The restaurant was clean, the decor was inviting and the service was great. The entire experience all made me feel welcome and looking forward to my next visit. read more