My wife and I've been in a couple times to grab a bite, it being the closest place by the library. While the seating is small, it certainly isn't dirty or dingy, and the prices aren't outrageous for being right across the street from a college. But the pizza itself is meh, and the dough really is greasy. The REAL problem came when I foolishly tried to order delivery. I don't know if the person who took my call had a hearing problem, but they got EVERY element wrong ... from my card number, to my address (which I reiterated to the person TWICE, in my rather loud booming voice), to what we wanted on it, and he even didn't quite understand me saying "PIZZA" as opposed to a sub??? The delivery person went to the wrong address, and to top it off, the pizza itself was unusually thick: more the Greek style prevalent in New England (and which we hate) rather than the thinner ones they usually make. Never again. read more

The Service today was not great I ordered 9:15 online order for delivery and so I placed a call to them because they had not arrived yet , at 9: 45 and the employee states that they are closed, which on Google states they closed at 10pm. Can't get my refund until tomorrow because they closed driver went home read more

Great friendly service. Slice was great, and got exactly what I enjoy on my slices. Quick in and out. Nice lil shop

A late lunch as I'm around town, I found Pizza Amore and it was great. Friendly folks and the pizza slice was delicious. Bummer about the construction scaffolding but yes, they're open. Limited space inside. I took my slice to go. [Review 18426 overall - 1144 in Massachusetts - 1948 of 2022.] read more

Pizza Amore - Pizza Amore - Pizza Near Me - Northampton, Massachusetts

See all

Best pizza in Noho, hands down! It is always timely and delicious. ***************************

Pizza slices are big, sauce is good, crust is good. Can't beat $3 slices!! Not a big place 13 chairs seats only. Family owned and operated it appeared. Very very nice people. read more

Pizza Amore - Slice of cheese pizza - Pizza Near Me - Northampton, Massachusetts

The cashier was friendly. Unfortunately that's the only good thing i can say about this place. Worst margherita slice ever. Individual slices of all kinds were listed as $2.80 on the menu, but they charged me $4.28 plus a credit card fee of 17 cents. These fees were not disclosed prior to purchase. Packaged dough, poor quality sauce. Wrong ingredients: aged mozzarella instead of fresh, what looked like burnt spinach where basil should be (only a trace of actual basil was present), and shockingly, contaminated with traces of lettuce and provolone, which do not belong here. The tomatoes were obviously refrigerated, leaving them oxidized and bland. Dusted with a fuzzy looking white substance that I hope was cornmeal. So greasy. And this took 10 minutes to prepare?! The place (which was very dark and dingy) wasn't even crowded. read more

Pizza Amore - Margherita Pizza, one slice. - Pizza Near Me - Northampton, Massachusetts

Build your own always tastes great. I usually pick up myself. Never ate in the restaurant. Easy to park. Cordial staff.

The food is good. If you actually receive it. Also, I was charged 3 times for an order I never received and they will not refund me. Go to Filo's instead. read more

SAVE YOUR MONEY!!!! My favorite food is pizza and the pizza here almost made me puke! Sp greasy, dough undercooked place is dirty and dingy, customer service needs work too. read more

I placed my order online throught their website. I had a ton of kids at my house and they were all hungry from a busy day. When my food came my pizza was made incorrectly. No big deal since I live 5 minutes away from the place. I called and I formed them of the issue ( since it needed to be JUST pepperoni in order for the kids to eat it and the one I had was also covered in hamburger and sausage which the kids would not touch). I was Informed by the lady who answered the phone that they would make a pepperoni pizza and send it right out. An hour passes and I now have a house of ravenous kids so I decide to call and check in on the pizza. I get the same lady who answered before and she tells me that the owner checked the camera and said that the first pizza was correct so I would not get another. At this point I am shocked. I had originally offered to return the first pizza since half was correctly made and half was not just pepperoni and I was told to just keep it so it was half gone. Now after almost 2 hours since my original order I'm being told that no pizza was ever made to replace the wrong one and they also never bothered to call me to tell me this so I could order from somewhere else. I will NEVER order from them again after that appalling display of customer service. I've worked in customer service for over 20 years and I would never have done something like that. There are plenty of other local pizza places that will enjoy my weekly giant orders. read more

Pizza Amore - This was the half pepperoni pizza they claimed was made correctly. - Pizza Near Me - Northampton, Massachusetts

Ordered a grilled chicken salad today for lunch..good size with plenty of chicken and dressing was good..I had the house Italian..pita bread was hot and good..only reason not 5 stars is because the restaurant itself when I went in to pick up the food was really dirty which to me makes me think nothing is sanitary. Also halfway through my salad I found a piece of ziti pasta in it which was really hard and had hardened sauce on it..I am guessing the salad is either not freshly made or as I stated with the place being dirty other food gets around and ends up in new orders.. read more

Pizza Amore - Grilled chicken salad..old ziti pasta noodle I found in it - Pizza Near Me - Northampton, Massachusetts

Ordered online. The menu described the sandwiches as coming with lettuce tomato cheese and mayo. I assumed it would be a toasted sandwich and added a comment- add pickles and onions. We got 40$ worth of sandwiches that were in a cold bun with nothing at all on it except pickles and onions. To top it off the pastrami was completely burned and even after adding ingredients to try to make these edible, we just tossed them in the trash. When I called, they kept saying that they called me to clarify and I didn't answer. My phone was in a different room and what is confusing about the word ADD. Add to what is described is pretty much what that means. Never again. read more

Not very good pizza. The interior is very cramped with not many tables. The inside is only good for grabbing a slice and that's about all. It's fairly obvious the majority of their business is take-out/delivery. Now I like greasy. I'm from New Haven and our pizza tends to be pretty darn greasy on average. It's what I like. But this pizza was very very greasy in a very very bad way. So Pizza Amore, while I do very much love pizza, I'm afraid I don't love yours. read more

Pizza Amore - a slice of pepperoni pizza on a paper plate - Pizza Near Me - Northampton, Massachusetts

The food that I've ordered is not the greatest, between the chicken parm, stuffed cheese ravioli. The doe for the pasta was undercooked and swimming in sauce. Where the chicken was also swimming in sauce. Pizza wise it's alright, not great, not bad. I'd only buy from here if nothing else was open tbh. read more

Well I heard great things about Amore Hamp. Sorry. Mushy crust tasted like frozen dough. Not impressed Stick with my tried and true Florence Pizza. read more

Friendly staff, great place for pickup, delivery, and dine in. Try the boneless wings :)

Tonight was my second order from Pizza Amore. Generally, I like to wait until I've visited a place a couple of times before I write a review. This time, it's to the detriment of the restaurant. While the food the first time we ordered was above average for the type of fare we ordered, I'll never know how the food is again because we didn't get our order delivered. Pizza Amore says they deliver to Easthampton. We told them we were in Easthampton and the first time we ordered, this wasn't a problem. However, this time someone apparently didn't tell the driver Easthampton. More than an hour went by and we wondered where our food was. We called Pizza Amore back and they said they would have the driver contact us. Still nothing. Finally we called them back again and they told us of the mistake. However, this was our option: Have the food delivered (now an hour and half after the order) and get a coupon for free onion rings on our NEXT order, or get no food. That was it. The food we ordered (pitas and onion rings) would be horrible an hour after they were cooked and they made no offer to make us new food and deliver it properly. The people at Pizza Amore including whom we assume was the manager was rude, unhelpful, and quite frankly a jerk. With so many other fine establishments in Northampton, I STRONGLY recommend you do not do business with these people where apparently their mistakes are the customer's fault. (edited for typos) read more

Really excellent pizza with the best, thin, chewy, flavorful crust! We ordered a small (8 pieces, easily big enough for 2 people or maybe 3), with fresh ricotta and black olives, and were filled after 6 pieces (we ate more because it was so darned good). It was $10. Though there's not much room (just a few tables) to eat in, I'd highly recommend Pizza Amore for take-out. It's open till 11, which makes it the perfect stop after a night on the town. ;) They also offer delivery. They have a big list of grinders (subs), pizzas, and other Italian fare. And, as mentioned, Pizza Amore has great pizza with friendly service! read more

Oh, Pizza Amore, I wanted to like you, but alas, I do not. I've both eaten at the restaurant and ordered food to be delivered. When I ate at the restaurant, I dined in with a friend. We both had wraps (the Italian and Sante Fe), which came with steak fries. The wraps were good and the fries were okay; to be fair, I'm not a huge fan of steak fries in the first place, thinking that they're too pasty. The service, on the other hand, was terrible. There are only a few tables, and the person taking our order pretty much just stood there staring at us, rather than asking what we'd like to have. My delivery experience was even worse. I ordered food to be delivered to my place of work (about a five minute walk from the restaurant) so that a friend and I could eat before a meeting. I called early -- about 11:15 a.m. -- and ordered a small, two-topping pizza. I was told it would arrive in half an hour. After an hour had gone by, I still had no pizza. When I called to complain I was told that the driver would be leaving shortly. Seriously? I ordered a single pizza at the beginning of the day (long before a lunch rush), it needed to be delivered literally around the corner, and it was going to take more than an hour!? When the pizza finally arrived, it was room-temperature, dry, and pretty much tasteless. The dough was bland, sauce was unremarkable, and even the toppings (bacon and pineapple) had virtually no taste at all. Save your money and grab some food elsewhere -- you'll be glad you did. read more

I've never actually been inside Pizza Amore, but their salads are one of my favorite local deliveries when I neglect to pack anything and can't get away from the office for lunch. I've tried several of the varieties, and my go-to is the chef salad. It is a HUMONGOUS bed of fresh iceburg lettuce, topped with green peppers, cucumbers, tomato, hard-boiled eggs, purple onion, ham, turkey, roast beef and cheese (lately I've noticed that you have to ask for the egg specifically or risk it being left off). When I say humongous, I mean straight-up massive and will seriously serve two hungry people or one person for two meals without any supplementation. All of Amore's salads come with your choice of garlic bread or freshly made pita, and salad dressing. I'm extremely partial to the buttermilk ranch that they make themselves, and the pita which is big, soft and puffy and made in-house daily (I once heard a rumor that root beer is their secret pita dough ingredient?!?). My mother usually opts for the garlic bread...which is about half of a large grinder roll (but I don't think they make it themselves? It seems fairly standard)...and instead of eating it with her salad, she saves it for the next day and tops it with tomato slices and cheese and throws it under the broiler to get a whole other meal out of it. The house salad with chicken is my second fave (iceburg, hardboiled egg, bacon, feta, mozzarella, purple onion, green peppers, cucumber and loads of smallish chunks of grilled, seasoned chicken -- I think it may be the same chicken that they use for their suvlaki? its' great)...with their homemade Italian dressing. I can also recommend the Greek salad and the antipasto salad. I did order the cobb salad once, but it was indistinguishable from the antipasto. I don't know whether that was a mistake or just a peculiarity of Amore...because around that same time, their chef salads would often come as the antipasto salad and we had to ask for "the one with the egg and turkey, not the one with the salami and pepperoncini." But for the last year or more, the chef salad has consistently been the chef salad without the need to specify ingredients when ordering...so perhaps the cobb salad is now the cobb salad. Not sure. Anyhow! Their stuffed grape leaves are very good, and the gyro, chicken souvlaki, and turkey club sandwiches are all decent. Pizza is rather bland as I recall (but I haven't had it in years, so it may be different now), and the reuben was disappointing. The fries are jumbo steak fries and are excellent when dipped in the homemade buttermilk ranch instead of ketchup ;) They have some interesting sounding Turkish-inspired sandwiches and wraps on their menu which I always say I'll try next time but then never do... it's like, I want to say "Istanbul wrap" ... but before I know it I've blurted out "Chef Salad with Ranch and a Pita"... read more

Pizza Amore - Chef salad - half eaten - Pizza Near Me - Northampton, Massachusetts

See all

The customer service here is excellent, as I constantly order delivery to my job everyone is always friendly and professional. Between the pizzas and club sandwiches it's hard to pick a favorite. This is a company that serves the surrounding community very well, and I thoroughly enjoy every experience I've had here. A definite reccomendation from a very happy customer. read more

I was at Conbust this weekend at Smith College. I did a food run here for my sister and I. Being limited with time and not being able to go far, I decided on this place. My sister ordered a grilled chicken wrap and I ordered the meatballs. The grilled chicken sandwich was pretty good and the sauce used was amazing. The meatballs on the other hand sucked. Everything was wrong with it. The meatballs didn't taste fresh and the sauce had some type of spice that made them taste a bit off. So a combo of the meat not tasting fresh and the sauce not being awesome, the end result was that it wasn't eaten. The people that work here are friendly and the service is pretty fast. read more

I placed an order for delivery and it was speedy & pretty tasty! I got a calzone & mozzarella sticks. Both were tasty - can't complain. I'll go back again! read more

Disappointing. Had a Margherita and Amore special pizzas. Both had soggy crusts in the center with a dry crumbly edge. The eggplant on the Amore special was just slimy with some vague attempt at breading. The Margherita was just a solid glob of greasy cheese with some burned, flavorless, basil on top. Even (insert pizza delivery chain here) would be better. 2 stars just because it wasn't in-edible. Just not particularly good. read more

Best delivery pizza in Northampton. I worked here when I was a senior at Smith and the owners, Eyup and Rico, and really nice people. They have really good pizza (especially when you order it fresh on the spot) and give you generous portions. The salads are pretty big, too. But really, if it's finals week, your friend's birthday, or you just got out of a break up, head straight to pizza amore and get their chocolate cake. It will make your day, promise. Also, the owners are nice when it comes to customer service. We've redone orders before if people complained, and Eyup once made a custom pepperoni pizza for a girl to give to her boyfriend on Valentine's Day, and he didn't even charge her extra. It was really cute. I used to make my own pizza there, and you probably could ask them to make it for you too---I used to make my boyfriend a little pizza with no sauce, extra cheese, with chicken tenders on it. It was good. Go to pizza amore--support local business and eat good food :) read more

Friendly! family-owned! New York style Pizza I've lived in Northampton for 6 years. This is hands down our favorite place for pizza! This family run business has been around forever....that should tell you something! Pick up is easy and (super fast) and delivery is reliable. My husband is a New Yorker- he agrees: Best pizza in town! read more

Don't buy your food here! I ordered a chef's salad and chips for my one and only lunch break on a 12 hour shift. They forgot the chips but charged me for it. The lunch meat in the salad was slimy, smelled disgusting, and was mottled. In addition, many of the salad greens we literally rotting in the container. I called to ask for a refund, spoke with the OWNER who refused a refund and offered to make me another salad. Why on earth would I want another rotten salad? Gross. After several refusals to refund my $10, I hung up and wrote this. read more

I've gotten delivery from here a few times, and orders are always made correctly! The calzones and pizza are great. I really cannot recommend the appetizers though. The fries are legitimately what you can buy in the frozen aisle at a grocery store, barely reheated, like would be served at a school cafeteria. Don't bother!! Jalapeno poppers were also clearly from frozen. But I really do enjoy the calzones! read more

Worst food ever! I ordered Wings and a cold cut grinder. First the wings were supposed to BBQ and they were spicy and the grinder was cold and disgusting. read more

Pizza Amore - Worst food ever! The wings were soggy and the grinder was cold and disgusting. - Pizza Near Me - Northampton, Massachusetts

See all

This place is horrible, their wings are disgusting, taste like candy not wings. Pizza is whatever.

We decided to try Pizza Amore because they deliver, and it's hot outside! I write this review as I wait for my replacement pizza. I ordered a puttanesca without cheese, and it came covered with mozzarella. This is after a clear and extensive conversation about vegan options, and having our order read back to me. My (non-vegan) partner is eating a beef, ricotta, onion & garlic pizza. The toppings are so sparse that her first bite of garlic was on the third slice. She also had to add Muir Glen's portabella pasta sauce, oregano & garlic powder in order to get enough flavor. While the folks at PA are very nice, we'll stick with Hillside from now on and just go pick it up or eat there!. read more

Unfortunately, it was not a great experience. I had heard decent things about Pizza Amore and decided to place a delivery order. I can say that the person on the phone and the delivery driver were very polite and that the delivery took the 30-40 minutes that they had promised. However, the pizza sauce was rather bland and the cheese had slid partially off the pizza. The latter is pretty unacceptable. Since Noho is a college town, I suspect I will be trying one of the myriad other delivery choices the next time I have a desire for pizza. read more

Got the late night hungers at my hotel and this place was listed in the local eating list they gave me upon check in. I got a cheese pizza delivered. Fast delivery and the pie was tasty al;though a tad dry. It didn't have a lot of tomato sauce, but truthfully that's better for me so i don't get heartburn. The crust was great too, like one reviewer said- kinda thin and chewy. read more

Amazing Greek salad. Awesome price and giant portion. I always get chicken on it with garlic bread. It comes with giant chunks of Feta along with all the other Greek salad fixings but to top it off it comes with 4 or 5 stuffed grape leaves. Each and every time I come to town I have ordered the salad at least once. Delivery is quick and easy as is picking it up in store. Great customer service. I have had other food as well, pasta a la vodka, spaghetti and meatballs etc and I have yet to have something I did not enjoy. I highly recommend if you are in the NoHo area. read more

This review is not for the establishment as a whole, nor even for their pita sandwiches. It is for their pita breads. The pita bread here is all handmade, made in-house. It is a little thicker than your typical store-bought, maybe a little less sturdy, light, and yeasty-tasting. I have never tasted pitas as good as theirs. Whenever I ordered a pita from here, I felt like I was cheating fate somehow-- there are almost no sandwich shops that make their own pita bread, and even if they don't, $5.25 is a pretty good price! read more

I've ordered from here a lot and I know not to expect a lot, but tonight was the worst yet. I ordered a simple BLT club and when I open the Styrofoam box I at first thought they forgot the sandwich. Then I found it under the pile of heavy steak fries... smashed, soggy and inedible. The Styrofoam box they packaged their delivery food in had made most of the fries smashing my sandwich completely steamed, soggy and inedible as well. The lid of the box was dripping with condensation when I opened it. I have no idea what the owners are thinking packaging food like this. The sandwich was likely perfectly fine until it met it's doom in steak fries and Styrofoam. I wouldn't recommend the pizza here (low quality in every way) and the appetizers are all frozen/fried and no better than you get in the frozen section of Stop & Shop. Unless you're looking for basic dorm delivery or food you plan to eat while completely drunk, your money is better spent in so many other places in Northampton. read more

I went out of desperation I was craving pizza and everyplace at the time was just closing. I can't speak for the bulk of the menu but the pizza is the worst I have EVER had. The pizza is tasteless and the crust tastes like cardboard. If your in the mood for pizza look elsewhere. read more

Ordered their Cobb salad and got a salad with rolled cold cuts and cheese, iceberg lettuce, tomatoes and chickpeas... When I called to say they must have mixed up and sent me a chef salad they said that was their Cobb salad and that their chef salad contains ham and not turkey rolled with cheese. You can't reinvent the definition of a Cobb salad - and if you're going to at least list the description because when you just say Cobb salad people assume they're getting avocado, blue cheese, bacon, egg and grilled chicken. read more

Great pesto pizza. I had one slice of pesto, it was large and very tasty. One was more than enough for dinner. Had a piece of their carrot cake as dessert, also quite good. Would totally recommend! read more