Still excellent. Extensive selection of unique and interesting toppings on pizza. I'm a big fan of their steak taco pizza. But they have all sorts of options, even ones that wouldn't come to mind - like tortellini (which is surprisingly good). They do also have cheese pizza. While this place is predominantly set up for 'pizza by the slice' - great for a quick lunch option; you can order any of their pizzas whole, they even do half/half. For a whole pizza, I've found it helps to order ahead. Service is friendly, quick, and efficient. Even during their busy times when the line is practically out the door. read more

the Italian sub was a JOKE! $13.00 for a crap sub. The owners should be embarrassed to charge this amount for 3 thin slices of meat and a slice of cheese read more

Antonio's Pizza by the Slice - Chicken Wings Near Me - Easthampton, Massachusetts

See all

Incredibly slow and mediocre pie. Energetic staff that just can't get it done. At least you can get the pizza by the slice

Antonios just always has the best pizza. There's no question about it. Diverse interesting format Pizza.

Pizza was great we tried White Pizza, BBQ Chicken Bacon Ranch, Pepperoni/Jalepeno & Hot Wings. The service was excellent the 2 ladies working at the front were very polite and helpful. read more

See all

You legitimately just sent me a half-cooked pizza. The dough is raw. I'm putting this back in my oven for another 20 minutes. Thanks, Antonios. read more

Best pizza around. Only complaint is they never put enough sauce on so I always ask for extra. My favorite pies are the unique ones - Potato cheddar and the avocado quesadilla are to die for. Hubs like the BBQ chicken. Service is fast and friendly and they are almost always packed. read more

Great spot. GREAT DELIVERY. Delivery is faster than the website anticipates. Good on fronts- good pizza, good subs, good pasta, etc. You wont find it on any "best of" list, but Antonio's is a very solid pizza/sub shop. Your average NE town pizza, really great delivery. read more

I've loved the pizza at Antonio's in Easthampton for a few years but the past two years I've been disappointed. The pizza I had delivered tonight had a crust that was way overcooked. The toppings were awesome but when your jaw aches after eating 2 pieces it's not worth it. Florence Pizza here I come. What is this $2.00 "Driver Fee?" See ya later Antonio's. read more

I love Antonio's but I don't know what's going on lately. The pizza is undercooked. If they literally kept it in the oven 2-3 more mins it would be perfect. The flavor is there it just needs a little more time. Boneless chicken wings are on point though! We usually have to now throw a slice in the oven to get it cooked a little bit more. You're better than this Antonio's! read more

I love Antonio's pizza. I order from here at least twice per month for the past 10 years, but it's so hard for me to understand why they package their wings in a metal container with plastic top. Why would anyone want soggy steamed chicken skin. Just put them in a container that won't steam the wings and maybe just toss them in sauce, ya know, cause it's not soup. I'm not lying, I do love Antonio's and the chicken bacon ranch pizza is crazy good, but please, please up the wing game. Love, Me read more

I havent ordered from them in years, so idk if they changed owners since I last ate there, but it is definitely not what I remember. I was craving cheesy bread. What I got was salty grease on dough. Totally nasty. We also got chicken fingers and I swear there was a knuckle... though it isnt like they make their own so thats not really on them. It was hot and "fresh", even with delivery (door dash), the fries we got were still crisp. I wont be back. Sorry to trash a local business but the quality has gone WAAAAY down hill. read more

I purchased a large half cheese and half combo pizza. I was told 45 minute delivery time, which ultimately was 1.5 hours. The delivery driver sounded like he was on drugs, as well as the male and female I spoke to on the phone.. maybe all had the same bathroom break? The pizza was delivered ice cold and looked like it had been sitting out for 4 hours. They offered to make another one and "send it right out", but after this disaster, we were all set. I've honestly had better pizza at a convenience store in Newark NJ. Good luck! read more

Antonio's Pizza by the Slice - a pizza in a box - Chicken Wings Near Me - Easthampton, Massachusetts

It's a small place but the staff is super friendly. The pizza is amazing! I love how they have these unique slices. I also appreciate how you can get slices or a box. It's simple but so delicious! The crust is good! Highly recommend. read more

We hadn't been to Antonio's in a while, we always loved the boneless chicken wings with the honey chipotle ranch dressing. We were very disappointed to get over cooked, dried out wings. Sorry Antonio's but you have definitely been better. read more

Complete disappointment. 30min for pick up - great! 90 min later still being told to wait - keep it. This happened twice, that was enough. I'll never be back. Thanks for nothing. Your pizza was never that good. read more

Huge selection of slices and typically 5+ options for vegetarians. Quick service and honest thin crust pizza- no bait & switch- consistent quality. Limited walking space poses a challenge. If you have mobility concerns be sure to come between mealtimes. read more

Amazing cheese pizza. Lots of parking up front. Was able to walk in and grab my slice with no sides and friendly service. read more

Antonio's Pizza by the Slice - Outdoors - Chicken Wings Near Me - Easthampton, Massachusetts

I stopped in during the dinner hour and the place was rocking and rolling with take out business. I ordered a bbq chicken pizza and added my own sautéed onions to it (i'm thrifty. So sue me). The pizza was good, but not great. You want details? It was just a little bland. It was fresh though. I can make a homemade pizza that's every bit as good. This place offers a serious variety of pizza toppings. That is their calling. Their wings are meaty. My meal did not break the bank and I had a ton of food between the pizza and wings. read more

Antonio's Pizza by the Slice - Bottom of Pizza - Chicken Wings Near Me - Easthampton, Massachusetts

Pepperoni & chicken pizza was fantastic. Great idea. You really need to eat the pepper & onion pizza while it's hot. Don't let it sit. read more

When I want pizza this is where my wife and I get it from. It's worth a drive from south Hadley to get. They have plenty of different kinds to choose from if you just go in on a whim, or order over the phone. Highly suggested. read more

Don't waste your money on their pizzas! I stopped ordering from this establishment years ago and thought I would give them another try. Last night I ordered the Florentine and it was terrible. The crust was hard and dry, like it had been precooked and sat around before the toppings were added. Way too watery due to the amount of spinach. A very poor excuse for a pizza. Years ago it was the best place, but now it's terrible! read more

Not the first time my order has been wrong. I should have checked it before I drove home but figured the last time was bad luck. This time we ordered a pizza, got home and it was missing toppings. After being on hold for ten minutes I was told we could pick up another pizza but I'm already home and the kids are hungry. Wish Amherst Antonio's was closer, this one is not the same. read more

This place used to be good. Unfortunately, over the last few years, it has gone down hill. The food is fine, it's the attention to detail. They have consistently gotten my order wrong over the years. It's became a gamble on if it would be correct. I would probably say it's now 50% of the time. Whether it's pick up or delivery, the order isn't always right. A few times I even received someone else's food in the delivery order. Several times it was wrong altogether, despite it being correct on the receipt. This was one of those times. I definitely don't always get what I paid for, literally. I don't know if the other locations are having issues, but this location really needs to pay better attention to what customers are ordering. Being a longtime customer of this location, I have to say this was my last time ordering from here. read more

Antonio's has slipped big time. The antipasta salad had very little meat and baloney was in there. There were two small slices of tomato and the lettuce was scarce. The vegetable burrito was a veggie wrap and was not as advertised. This restaurant, which used to be excellent, has really declined. We will not continue as customers. Anthony Colao Easthampton, MA read more

I recant my previous review-I had a large pepperoni takeout today that was perfect. Chewy and greasy deliciousness.

Prompt delivery, fun pizzas, and an easy slice on the go. Antonio's in EastHampton is tasty and hits the spot. Not as cheap as dominoes or Pizza Hut but still OK price range. read more

This place deserves a little more attention. I really like the pineapple bacon pizza. I always mention it when we are driving by. love it!

They left our pizza on our porch for an hour without calling or letting us know. I love the food I love the pizza by the slice but they're too expensive for shitty service. This is not the first time they have ruined my order and I'm sure it wont be the last. I'd say 1 out of 10 orders have been correct. If I could give them 0 stars I would. read more

Should have ordered Dominos - Antonio's is generic at best. Very forgettable crust and mediocre sauce. So disappointed ...

What can be said about Antonio's Easthampton that hasn't already been said? It's true! This is some fantastic pizza, served by a super-friendly staff, in a really laidback, homey location. Their only competition for "Best Pizza in the Valley" is their sister location in Amherst. And as has been said before, Amherst is much busier, a little less friendly, a lot noisier, and a bit more "beaten up" than Easthampton. The only thing better in Amherst is the people-watching, and that's got nothing to do with pizza. Not a day goes by that I don't crave an Antonio's slice. I can only hope that in their thirst for expansion they'll partner up with MGM to get a store here in Springfield when that whole casino thing goes down. Yes, I will take a casino in exchange for Antionio's. Take THAT Ludlow! read more

Antonio's Pizza by the Slice - Chicken Wings Near Me - Easthampton, Massachusetts

Every single time we order the food arrives cold and we end up waiting over an hour every time no matter the day or time of day. My order is never correct , our pizzas have been flipped over in the box with all toppings off. The worst is that the delivery driver was not masked. He knocked on my door to handed me my order with no mask. I request contactless delivery but I was glad to see there was no mask. My order went right in the garbage and I will never be ordering from here again. I'm not sure if ownership changed but this place used to be great. read more

Antonio's pizza and wings. I was with my buddy who was getting a tattoo next door at shark tank tattoo (Great guys! Check em out!) They recommended we try this place. Working at a pizza place myself, I was prepared for run of the mill stuff here. Boy, was I wrong. We walk in and were greeted kindly by not only the bro at the counter, but the plethora of original and creative pizzas. If you have ever been to Otto pizza, the style and setting are very similar, in a good way. I ended up deciding on a slice of pizza with a pesto sauce, fresh mozzarella cheese, chopped tomato, fresh basil leaves, and sliced portobella mushroom. The portobella is what really took me aback. I have never been to a pizza place that's used those big brown awesomes on their pies. Being an avid mushroom lover this was great, and definitely not run of the mill. Not to mention as I walked in I caught them scrubbing the hood fan which having a clean one will always get points in my book. They didn't get five stars because I take consistency into consideration and I only got one slice. I will be back again to try the other items on the menu and see if they are up to snuff. read more

Antonio's Pizza by the Slice - My friend and I's slices. - Chicken Wings Near Me - Easthampton, Massachusetts

They deliver and seem to know every part of Easthampton, even the tiny A1 apartments... they stretch as far as Mt. Tom in the South to Old South Street in Northampton... OK, inexpensive pizza if you get basic toppings... do not get their wings, do not get their things... read more

Antonio's Pizza by the Slice - Chicken Wings Near Me - Easthampton, Massachusetts

They replaced a meat lovers calzone I'd ordered with a steak sandwich. The calzone had been extremely salty.

When my sister and I came in to pick up the order I placed online a half hour after I ordered it it hadn't even been started. I was told it would take 15 to 20 minutes. 40 minutes later it's still wasn't ready. I was told they were very busy and that the people working the cash register didn't know how long it took to make a pizza as they didn't work in the kitchen. My sister was a frequent customer. But she'll be looking for a new place for pizza. It would have been different if there had been a little courtesy or an apology for the wait. read more

Best pizza ever!!! The Texan is one of the best pizzas I've ever had. The only down side is having to drive there to get it since there isn't one in my city. read more

Very good pizza. Lots of different toppings. I go there all the time. Great subs too.

I very rarely write a review but this is something that is worth sharing. I placed an order for delivery at 3:40 and I was still waiting for my food at 5:00. Needless to say, the food was cold and unedible. I called and the manager offered to come and pick up the cold food and remake it for me, umm no thanks... I do not feel like waiting another hour and 20 minutes. I would not suggest ordering delivery from here unless you want cold food! read more

Amazing thin crust . Very good variety for a small place. Recommend: taco, pepperoni, Plain slices were generous with cheese. I don't remember their Amherst store being this good. read more

Antonio's Pizza by the Slice - a man at the counter - Chicken Wings Near Me - Easthampton, Massachusetts