We were looking for something quick and easy for dinner. Stopped here cause you can't go wrong with a diner. Oh yes you can! I had the pork and sauerkraut which had absolutely no flavor. My friend had the captains broiler seafood platter. The haddock was tasteless the shrimp were watery and the crab cake was bad (as in rotten crab) scallops ok. Told the waitress crab was bad and we got 4 shrimp to replace it doesn't seem quite what was needed. Was asked at register if things were ok I said just ok only got an oh there. When you are severed something so bad you should at least be able to talk to management. I will NEVER GO HERE AGAIN. read more

Went here Saturday morning with my brother. Had been before and will go back. Place was packed. We waited 15 minutes in a packed waiting area. Got seated. Waitress came and served us very well the whole time. I got an omelette and scrapel. Bro got pancakes, a bagel, and bacon. Everything was good. read more

We took our daughter there for her birthday. We ordered a chicken quesadilla, T-bone steak they were both very good. I on the other hand ordered liver and onions. I asked the waitress to please have the cook make it medium. I got my meal my liver was covered with gravy I went to cut it. It was so well done I couldn't even cut it with a steak knife. I took the knife and pushed off the gravy everyone at the table looked in shock. It honestly looked like beef jerky. Our waitress was busy so I decided to eat the sides. By the time our waitress came back to our table everyone was finished eating. As she was picking up the empty plates she got to mine. I showed her my liver she apologized and asked if I would like them to make another for me. We had no time to wait because we had another place to be in less then 30 minutes. She did not offer to take it off our tab. I didn't want to make a scene so my husband paid And we left. I've been there for breakfast several times it was always very good. I know now to never order their liver again. read more

Had good service previously. Today meal was Luke warm on the seafood chowder & the lettuce on the salad should have been tossed. The noodles on our dishes was only warm not hot . the scallops and shrimp had not taste . not sure ill be back here anytime soon read more

We needed a place to bring some hungry soccer players between games for a tournament. This place fit the bill; so much so we came back a second day. We fed 10 people for less than $100 with good food. We had lunch one day and breakfast the next. If we ever visit Hanover again we will be back. read more

Had the best waitress. She got our order right and was on point with refills and napkins. Wings are messy lol. Really good food. Homemade loved it and will go back. read more

My hubby & I went out Sunday for breakfast. We wanted to try the Starlight Diner but, the place was packed. We came back the next day & there was still a pretty good crowd. I am so glad that we came back! My husband ordered two eggs with hashbrowns, corned beef hash & a slice of ham. It was a lot of food! I had the Belgian waffle with fresh strawberries. My waffle was crisp on the outside & light & fluffy on the inside. Our food came in about 5 minutes, I kid you not. It was hot, it was good & there was plenty of it. My coffee cup was never empty.Wonderful service all around. Best of all, our breakfast only cost us $10! I do not think you can even get breakfast at McDonald's for that. Everything was just wonderful! I can not wait to try them for dinner! read more

Our first visit to the Starlight now that we have family living nearby. Late on a Sunday afternoon, trying to find a place for an early dinner before the long ride back home, we decided on diner food at the Starlight. We ordered two senior specials: Grilled marinated chicken and the turkey platter. We were served two hot, large, selections with a small salad and two veg. included with each dish. This was a lot of food for a very reasonable price. Good basic fare at a decent price, not a bad deal at all. Beats a chain restaurant anytime. read more

This was our first visit to the Starlight. Stopped for breakfast - but, it was actually lunch time by the time we made it there. But, we still opted for breakfast - which is served all day (always a plus for us). Service was fast and very good. Our coffee cup was never empty. The server was very attentive & friendly. Food was pretty good. It wasn't overly creative...but, a good basic breakfast - hot, food was as we ordered, and tasty. We both got the same breakfast with slightly different components. The Starlight Special include pancakes, eggs, meat, and home fries. We were able to choose blueberry pancakes and added a side of sausage gravy (it was tasty...not as good as my aunt from OK used to make - but, not bad). Overall - a nice place, good service, prices were fairly reasonable and food was good. Would definitely stop back again and try other menu items. read more

Really displeased with the Customer Service, quality and value of the food, and the general attitude of this diner. After several visits, I figured it was time to post a review, as each visit was a confirmation of the initial experience. And not that the patrons are a reflection of the diner management or even that the management has any influence on the patrons and their behavior, but for my interracial family, we have been greeted repeatedly with rude stares, nasty looks, and turned up noses. To the extent that our son has asked, "why does everyone have a mean look on their face?" and "why do people turn their heads and look away, when I catch them staring at me, and I give them a smile?" Hmm. I wonder. Perhaps the patronage is more indicative of the population in the area, than the restaurant, but it's awful chilly in there, no matter what the temps are outside, if you catch my drift! Though the decor is charming, and the building airy and open - with a big plus for ambiance and environment of the physical structure of the building: we were disappointed with the prices, portion sizes, and the taste of the food, from breakfast to lunch/dinner fare. Perkins is right around the corner, and while no diner, we normally get decent food, a decent quantity of it, for a decent price. Just saying. I don't foresee returning to this diner, and that's perfectly ok with our family. read more

Stopped in for breakfast one day after a really tough workout. The server was pretty attentive and kept the water coming, which I was very thankful for. I had only been in Starlight once before and I wasn't impressed, but since it has been a few years I decided to give it a second chance. I had a delicious omelet with feta cheese, spinach and tomatoes, and side of bacon that was actually perfectly crispy. The food was decent, the service was decent, and the prices are excellent. I will definitely be back... at least for breakfast. read more

While the staff was very nice and friendly, the food was terrible. The food was very obviously microwaved and not cooked fresh at all. Everything was either undercooked or over cooked. Overall not a pleasant experience, we will not be returning. read more

I've only been here once but the experience was absolutely dreadful. The waitress was completely incompetent. It was nearly empty and she still failed to attend to our table. The food took ages to come out and was hardly worth the wait. It was extremely bland and poorly presented. One of my group was brought a very cold serving of beef and gravy, which was unceremoniously carried from the table by an uncaring waitress, and only after we had alerted another member of the staff because she was nowhere to be found. They threw it in the microwave. Disgusting. The salad was an absolute joke, literally just bits of iceberg lettuce with a single cherry tomato. The establishment itself was dreary and uninspired. No price is justified for service of this kind. read more

The food is good people are friendly. Prices are yery reasonable for what you get. I,ve eaten here for breakfast and supper. read more

See all

Clean. Quick. No wait for seating, even for large parties (at least on weekdays). Decent breakfasts. Nothing special, but certainly edible and filling. Cheap too. Family friendly. We were in town visiting family nearby, and came here twice for breakfast. read more

Every worker there had their mask half off. Like what's the point then. My steak was cooked well done when I ordered medium rare. Not coming back. That place is gross for both the food and staff read more

So decided that we would give this place a try. Had read some good reviews and some awful. Well, my experience with the staff was good. The guy who waited on us was friendly. But when the food arrived, (not to long of a wait after ordering) was not even to the standard I would feed my dogs. The eggs were rubbery. How do you mess up over medium eggs? My home fries were barely warm and bland. Another person in my group ordered the Chicken Cesar salad didn't even resemble a Cesar salad, with watery like dressing, no croutons and slimy chicken. The last order was French Toast which she seemed to like, and actually looked like something I would eat. The price we paid was dirt cheap which is pretty much matching the food. Therefore we did not complain and figured we should accept the fact that you pay cheap prices you get cheap food. Except I would have paid the same at McDonalds and actually enjoyed it. read more

We went for dinner with some friends, Place was crowded so good thing we had reservations. the menu is diverse and service is excellent. The atmosphere is vibrant and energetic Place is very clean read more

Eating at this place was a disappointment. Ordered the honey dipped chicken and it was the worst chicken platter I ever had in a restaurant. It reminded me of the pieces of chicken placed in store bought frozen TV dinners. Heavily breaded with tiny pieces with very little chicken to eat. Waitress did say it comes frozen and pre-packaged. Soup was very salty. The salad I had with the meal was quite small with cheap iceberg lettuce and one cherry tomato. The final scenario was when I went to exit the table and my foot slipped out of my sandal since my sandal was stuck to the floor! My husband mentioned the lousy quality of the meal to the cashier when he checked out and they did not care! There are many restaurants in the town to pick from and it surely won't be this one! read more

Great breakfast venue. Lightning fast service. Very reasonably priced. Sunday morning lots of folks waiting. No wait for table for 2. Sweet

Good food, good prices, and the waitstaff is very good. This is not a high-end restaurant, but you can get what you want, if you just ask for it! I have had a lot of things on the menu, and several that are not! The things I did not care for were not cooked bad or tasted bad, just not the way I would cook them, so it is not their problem! If you want a good meal, in a nice clean place, with good staff, then you will like it here! read more

Had the Greek omelette, unique and amazing. Fast and friendly service even at peak Sunday hours! If you love scrapple be sure to order a side!!! read more

This evening was our third visit. BEYOND excellent, as always! Breakfast, lunch, dinner...American, Italian, Oriental...steaks, chops, pancakes, stuffed shells, spaghetti, seafood. THEY CAN DO IT ALL! And do it FANTASTICALLY!!! Best food we have had, at ANY price...and theirs are pretty darn reasonable! Shady, Shenouda, and Roumani...and all their staff...are wonderful, welcoming, and genuinely glad to see you! If you leave this place hungry...it is YOUR fault! read more

Basic dinner food , service was wonderful, bathrooms clean . Food came out very quickly

one star is to much to give. started with service. place was empty maybe 10 customers. still sat for 15 minutes before server stopped to ask if anyone offered me a menu. asked for Chicken fried steak as a breakfast, didn't come with side of pancakes. was talked into CFS as a dinner. not what i was looking for. but hungry. asked for a French onion soup. came out no taste cheese hot soup was cold. didn't taste like anything good. food came out and was a mess. asked for corn, n/a mash potato cold and loaded with burnt gravy. there was so much white pepper gravy on the chicken you didn't know it was underneath. biscuits were burnt on one side. i wish i would have taken a picture. had one bite and stopped eating. the worst meal ever. chicken was dry and hard. after a while i knew why it was empty. server walked passed and asked if everything was ok. took longer for a check. when she returned asked me if everything was good i explained the issue and it seemed not to like was heard. her answer was do you want this for free? i was a paul ed by that. i payed it in full. thE cashier asked i told her never coming back worst food and service ever. didn't phased her. $22 bucks. ripped off. went to Dennys. should've went there first. my next call is health Department read more

Okay service, bland food. Our waitress was friendly enough, but forgot a side on one of our meals, and even after reminded, and acknowledging the mistake, still never brought the item. I got the breaded chicken cutlets and it was the blandest food I have ever eaten. I think they just rolled microwaved chicken in leftover toast crumbs, toasted for 10 minutes and sent it out. My son's pasta was okay, but it's hard to mess up pasta. We drove the extra mile to Perkins the next night. I would not recommend. read more

The prices are excellent! Staff was nice. I got the prime rib special which wasnt that great. Probably the worst I've had.

Went for breakfast this morning. It was busy, but was sat right away. Super quick service and the food came out super fast! We were beyond impress and totally found our new breakfast spot! read more

If you go there go for the breakfast, lunch and dinner items lacking in flavor. I had the Turkey and stuffing with mash, and corn. I mean nothing had flavor out of all that food. There chipped beef gravy over toast was the best I've had from this place so far. read more

This was our first time at this diner and my wife and I really enjoyed our meal. The help was friendly, prompt and the place was very clean. The prices were reasonable too. We'll be back for sure! read more

My wife and I ate there for our first time. The restaurant is clean and the prices are more than reasonable, but that's where the "positives" end. The soups were okay and homemade, but too salty and not hot enough. Too much rice in the chicken-and-rice soup and too many beans in the ham-and bean soup. Some more broth would have been nice. One of my wife's sides--the cole slaw-- was delivered at the same time as our soup, which made no sense to me. The slaw was cold and crunchy, which was a positive, but so sweet (like in too much sugar) that she could barely eat it. After a reasonable wait our entrees arrived. My salmon was acceptable, both in taste and size, but the cauliflower side was over cooked and absolutely bland--not a speck of any seasoning on it. My wife's stuffed flounder was terrible. The crab stuffing was obviously canned/frozen and thus ruined the whole meal. We both had French fries which were just fair. We had to ask for bread, which is supposed to accompany the meal, and we were nearly done before it arrived. We also had to ask for our water to be refilled. All and all it was not a real positive dining experience and we'll probably not go there again. read more

I was pretty disappointed eating a late evening dinner here. This appears to be a repurposed Perkins restaurant. Some places should remain closed, harsh words but the food here was subpar at best. The bacon cheese burger my date ordered was a frozen patty. I ordered eggs, no potatoes, bacon, grits and rye toast. I got the potatoes I didn't order. The rye toast was undone and mushy. The grits were lumpy and watery. Another table mate ordered the steak and shrimp. Tiny steak and two medium fried shrimp. In all 5 people are dinner / breakfast and the total came to $52.40. There in lies the problem. Quality sacrificed for cost. Cheap ingredients equals poor quality food and a poor experience. My suggestion is to increase quality by purchasing better food and you'd probably have more repeat business and happier customers. Meh' at best. read more

I was not impressed. The service was lacking and the food was bland. I ordered the waffles with strawberries. Based on the menus description and picture I was expecting waffles with sliced and whole strawberries on top, that was not the case. It was drenched in strawberry syrup with a few bits of mushy strawberries. I haven't been back and don't plan on it. read more

My Wife and I dined here twice while staying in Hanover PA and the menu was very large, food hot and plenty of it plus we were waited on both times by Vanessa and could not have had a better waitress. read more

Nice ambiance for a diner, but mostly typical, semi-bland diner food. Vegetarian options are lacking.

When visiting family in the area I LOVE to eat here! Good "home style" food at a GREAT price!

Sorry to say, the service was terrible, (she said she was having a bad day), the food was very bland, bad texture ham, cold mashed potatoes, au jus was not au jus, even when we complained and said we would never return nothing was done to make it right. We weren't the only ones unhappy, the guy at the next table sent his steak back 2 times, then refused it, they put it in a box and made him pay his bill. This was a Sunday at 5pm. Save yourself, eat somewhere, anywhere else. read more

If the waitresses would stop worrying about your husband or boyfriend when you go in there it would be a great place too eat

I enjoy diners and this place was really nice. I like how the tables are spaced out and you don't feel like your sitting on top of the next table over. The service was a tad bit slow but the waitresses were all friendly. I wanted to order dessert but I was never given the option that's why I bumped this review down to 4 stars. Portion sizes were huge, especially for the price. I got a western Omelet and my friend had wings. Great price for the wings and they were super meaty! I WILL return. read more

My husband and I go to Starlight about 3 or 4 times a month. There are a few waitresses that are so-so, but for the most part the staff is very nice and very attentive, including management. Their food is typical diner food, but they do have the best chipped beef in Hanover and a more extensive menu than most places. Prices are awesome and we can usually eat for about $17.00. Definitely worth checking out if you're in the area! read more