I really do enjoy this diner. The service is always friendly and prompt, the food always tastes fresh and delicious, and the prices literally can't be beat. Plus the place is quaint and rarely super busy except for weekend breakfast times. I will say, I love the chicken fried steak here. It's probably my favorite breakfast item on the menu. My kids absolutely devour the pancakes, which are always fluffy. The omelets are also always cooked well, and never over done. Also, a surprising standout on the menu was the French onion soup. The server recommended it and said it was popular, and wow, it was shockingly good for a diner soup. It was rich in flavor and I loved the cheese on top. read more

See all

Came in for lunch today with my parents and daughter. Every seat was filled due to the after church crowd. In spite of how busy it was we only had to wait 10-15 minutes. My dad and daughter got breakfast and both portions were very large and they both loved their dishes. My mother and I got lunch and both our dishes were a lot smaller and lacked flavor. The chili might have been one of the worst I've ever had. We were to get rolls with our meals and we had to ask for them. When we asked we seemed like we bothered our waitress to bring out what was supposed to come with our lunches. I would come back but definitely get breakfast instead. read more

Visited the Starlight Diner for the first time for breakfast with my dad one Tuesday morning around 9am. The restaurant was very crowded, but they have a ton of seating available and we were directed to a booth as soon as we walked into the building. Our server was over within a minute and took our drink order. We ended up ordering a good amount of food because my dad was coming off a 1.5 day pre-operation fast. Needless to say, we took a few leftovers to go. The food was delicious, though. I personally had a breakfast special with 2 eggs, french toast, sausage patties, and hashbrowns. I added cheese to the scrambled eggs. All of the food came out piping hot and exactly as ordered. The portions for the pancakes and chicken fried steak were huge and the quality was fantastic for a diner. We left very full and very happy! Would definitely recommend. read more

See all

The Food is Good, the Staff is great and the atmosphere is pleasant. Everyone is very nice and always friendly.

Excellent food .. service .. friendly staff .. reasonable prices .. clean .. efficient!

The food looked good and it tasted delicious . It was really busy but the service was great and there is alot of parking as well. I took the rest of the food home and ate it. read more

Starlight Diner - This is on the under 12 kids menu and my daughter liked it as well. - Diners Near Me - Hanover, Pennsylvania

See all

The place is alright. Lots of standard diner fare. My friend and I each got an omelet. He got the 3-meat-filled Ultimate Omelet and I got the Philly Cheesesteak Omelet with shaved ribeye, provolone, and peppers. The food was cooked fine but I have to say it was all pretty under-seasoned to the point where I felt awkward salting my food a second or third time as our waitress checked on us. I enjoyed my side of scrapple which was perfectly crispy and served with a touch of syrup. The inside is plain but cozy enough. It's clearly built to feed lots of people and turn over tables fast. We only had a short wait before being seated and to their great credit, our waitress was super fast greeting us, getting us drinks and taking our order and I think our food was out in maybe 5 minutes - impressive. read more

I come here a lot and it can be very good.I have hit times that if it was my first impression I would not return. Like all places it has it bad days. And it is easy to pick a place apart. Service and food can be inconsistent. Overall this place is good for food and service. I have tried enough on their menu that I know what I liked. And there are things on their menu I would not order again . read more

Starlight Diner - Inside of dining room - Diners Near Me - Hanover, Pennsylvania

I love diners. The Starlight is a diner in every sense of the word. The inside is clean and bright. The counter, booths and dining room are well laid out and comfortable. The server staff was prompt, efficient and friendly. The food came out quickly, but the temperature was barely lukewarm. It tasted fine, but was less than enjoyable. When the cashier asked how our meal was, we told her that it tasted okay but that the food was cold. She just kind of shrugged her shoulders and was very indifferent. I'll probably go back to try it again. I really hope my next experience is better. read more

Would recommend this to all! Only needed to wait 5 - 7 minutes at 12:30 on a Sunday for a table. The service was super quick even though it was packed. Our waitress was fast to take our drink and food orders and was very friendly. Food came out within 10- 12 minutes. It's a loud environment as a typical diner is. Food was prepared with fresh ingredients. Pricing is the best I've seen in a long time. read more

Starlight Diner - Sausage and cheese omelette - Diners Near Me - Hanover, Pennsylvania

See all

My husband and I usually eat there at least once a week. The food is excellent, always hot and fresh and delicious. The menu is excellent because it has a wide variety of appetizers, entrees and my favorite desserts. Many times I don't get to dessert because my eyes are bigger than my stomach. We need to just start with dessert. read more

Ms. Brittney was welcoming and ensured I was comfortable. Food came out quickly and fresh. read more

Starlight Diner - #11 - Diners Near Me - Hanover, Pennsylvania

See all

The waitress & staff was rude until I believe the owners came in. The chocolate milk was expired. Won't be coming here again.

Great place to go get breakfast, prices are good compared to other diners I've been too. Very quick service and good food!

Great service, the Eggs Benedict here was absolutely amazing. They have a really good menu to choose from. Can't wait to stop in again to try more. read more

First time here. Wow, huge menu selection. Diner style food & decor. Busy, but no wait time on Saturday around noon. Service was good. We will definitely go back! read more

Starlight Diner - The Knickerbocker sandwich; turkey, ham, swiss cheese and thousand island dressing on toasted rye bread. - Diners Near Me - Hanover, Pennsylvania

See all

Everything is very good. The eggs are extra large. The bacon is crispy and well done and delicious. The toast was just great. Definitely recommended. Do I have to say more than that? What else is there to say other than the facility was beautiful, modern clean well appointed. The toilets were to die for. read more

Very disappointed in this diner. We were at a show which ended at 9:25 the diner said it was open till 10:00 we walked in at 9:30 and the owner said the kitchen is closing at 5 minutes well that doesn't give us much time to order anything considering if it's closing at 10:00 you stop the kitchen at 10:00 so we ended up with desserts which we did not want and walked out after that not happy and won't go back read more

Out of two dishes, one was inedible. The service was poor - you are on your own and the waiter can't communicate well with patrons. The ambiance is okay. read more

Food is good & the serivce is excellent. The peak times for Breakfast, Lunch & dinner are crowded which you would expect & sometimes wait list is long. But the turn around is quick for a table. read more

This place is awesome. It's not your basic "old rundown" diner, it's very modern. The food was SPECTACULAR, can breakfast be spectacular? Yes, it can here. The service was super fast. They have an extensive omelet selection. We for SURE will be coming back!!!! read more

Good diner. Good menu selection. Place was spotlessly clean. I had the chicken stir fry. It was pretty good. read more

Starlight Diner - Diners Near Me - Hanover, Pennsylvania

First time I hear and let's say that u won't be making a return to this place. Ordered the chicken Alfredo, and when I started to eat it. I found charred something or another from the grill mixed in my food. When I found more, I couldn't even eat it. Chicken was dry and over cooked. When I asked for the manager the waitress told me she left at 8pm. Didn't even offer a refund or discount for the dinner. I might not be on the line of owning a restaurant, but last I heard when you are getting blacken charred from a grill, that means it's not being cleaned properly and now it's contaminating the food that customers are Recieving in here. I will not be coming back to this and advise others to be very careful on eating here. read more

The food was unseasoned and undercooked. The service was alright and quick but it didn't make up for the lack of seasoning. The ambiance was pretty standard when it comes to restaurants. I would NOT order any sort of steak under well done from there. read more

The food is dry and it was uncooked. I ordered a steak and it was DISGUSTANG! OUTRAGEOUSLY UNSEASONED IT MADE ME WANT TO HAVE EXPLOSIVE DIARRHEA. Do not order steak from here these people don't know how to season food.. read more

I love this place! I love getting Chip beef gravy with potatoes. My grandfather used to get the same thing as well. Friendly staff, amazing food! read more

They don't deserve a star at all. We got sitted on a corner front but waiters didn't come and even acknowledge us. No coordination between host and waiters. Bunch of idiot staff. Walked out and will never give business to them! read more

Stopped for breakfast and it was great, exactly what you expect from a classic diner. Staff was friendly and efficient, highly recommend.

Food was pretty good overall but honestly the service was absolutely ridiculous. Our waitress came to our table we placed our orders and then once we got our food never checked back to see if we needed refills, if we needed anything, or if the food was even good. All the waitress sat at a table in the corner talking and eating not even paying us any mind. We waived them over multiple times and only got acknowledged after 10 minutes of trying to signal them over. Then it took them another 15 minutes for us to signal them and get our check. Definitely need to be taught better customer service and better etiquette on how to be aware of your customers and what they need. Definitely won't be back! read more

The food was excellent and the service was very good. There really was nothing to ding this place for.

This place is great for lunch... always clean, quick service. They have your typical diner food (without looking like a diner) and more. Pretty big menu, with a lot of different options. Breakfast is served all day. read more

Starlight Diner - Ham and cheese triple decker - Diners Near Me - Hanover, Pennsylvania

Breakfast was amazing!! Was very fast and everything came out right. Server was very nice and helpful. The environment was great, wasn't loud very nice decor. read more

Looking for cappuccino in the area you need to stop by they have it. Plus there food is delicious breakfast, brunch, and dinner. Desserts are yummy and nice and clean place. I love their ice cream read more

Starlight Diner - Pumpkin spice coffee - Diners Near Me - Hanover, Pennsylvania

Had lunch here today with a friend. Very good food and great service. We ordered from the Senior menu. Crab cake dinner, broiled haddock dinner. Very good and not skimpy portions. Plenty of food with a senior meal. Entree, soup or salad and two sides. Did not take long for the food to arrive. The salad was very nice. I was surprised that there was actually chunks of cucumber and tomato instead of the usual fluff of lettuce on a plate that many places serve. Icing on the cake was the dressing tasted homemade; delicious. We were sad that we were too full for dessert because the desserts looked wonderful. We will definitely stop again. read more

Earlier this week my wife and I stopped in for breakfast before heading off for our day. This is the second visit we made to the starlight in the last couple of weeks and I have to say both visits were less than good. The food is on par for the Hanover area which basically means it's terrible. There are absolutely no good places to eat in Hanover Pennsylvania. It is as if this town is a Mecca for crap on a plate. I really can't say breakfast was screwed up however when it comes to reviewing their service that's a whole different subject. Once we were seated we waited almost 10 minutes just to get water. Once the waitress showed up to take our order and we ordered our breakfast we again waited more than 10 minutes for a plate of eggs. After being served our meal we didn't see our waitress again. She never came back to check on us. She never came back to offer us a refill on our drinks. She never came back at all until it was time for her to walk past our table and drop the check as she kept on going. At least when the Russians owned it there was hospitality in the restaurant business here. So unless you think mediocre quality food and absolutely lousy service is what you're looking for... don't go to the starlight. We certainly will never return. read more

Huge menu, including breakfast offerings all day. Everything I've ordered -- omelettes, soups, wraps, salads, burgers -- has been delicious. It's clean, bright, and service is friendly and efficient. The bakery case is always full of incredible cakes, pies, and other pastries. Yes, it's a diner, so expect diner atmosphere. Sit at a table, booth, or the bar. You will not go away hungry! read more

Great food portions were good waitress was at our table often pleasant amazing service. Money well spent.

Always awesome staff and great food! Enjoy coming here often and doesn't disappoint. Breakfast is very affordable.

While I am not a diner fan especially, this place is still one of our family's all time favorites! The service is always quick and with a smile! If we ever ask our young grandsons where they would like to go out to eat, this is ALWAYS their first choice!! We have truly never had a bad experience there and we go there ALL the TIME! Everyone works very hard to please and it shows! read more

Clean, nicely decorated, comfortable, lots of seating, convenient parking, large selection of menu items, fast and friendly service. I'm not typically much of a "diner person" but this one is an exception. We usually have a waitress named Nicki who is always wonderful. Definitely give this place a try. read more

Starlight Diner - Hot chocolate with whipped cream! Yum! - Diners Near Me - Hanover, Pennsylvania