Brooke took excellent care of us on our last visit. The food usually very good, although we have had mixed results with their "Italian" entrees (none of us care for the sauces/ the way they've been seasoned). Best bets are the German themed dishes. Fabulous appetizers, particularly the calamari. Bartender Todd also excellent. We've become regulars. read more

Terrible food. Told the waitress to take the wings back and she looked at me like I was crazy?! They're smaller than a limp d***! read more

Crimson American Grill - American Near Me - York, Pennsylvania

See all

We ordered some road food before heading on a long trip south from York PA. They had exactly what we needed: as I recall we ordered buffalo chicken eggrolls and a chicken quesadilla. The eggroll "finger food" was quite unique and very convenient to munch on while traveling down the road at high speeds! Same with the quesadilla! I would recommend the crimson American Grill! Tasty food at a fair price! It was about three in the afternoon when we ordered and our order was ready when we arrived. It looks like a nice building inside and out. read more

We went here with a large group (18) and the service was superb! The server was friendly and got things right! The food: I had a chicken salad, bacon , lettuce and tomato wrap. It was pretty good. It came with one side and I chose the potato of the day which was steak fries. They were good, well seasoned. I'd have liked to have a few more though. This meal earned 3.5 stars from me. DH had fish and chips. He said the fish was not as good as he's had at other local places. He said the fries were soggy. I tasted the fish and it was good but nothing special. He'd give his meal 3 stars. Others in the group said the Alfredo sauce was only ok; the Chesapeake chicken was ok; the side veg of the day( stewed squash) was Jess than ok; the salmon got thumbs up from two diners. Overall it looks like 3 stars but my wrap was good and the service was terrific, so I amped up to 4. Thanks for the great service, but, I look forward to better food when I dine out. read more

Crimson American Grill - Chicken salad BLT in a warm pita with steak fries - American Near Me - York, Pennsylvania

Visited Crimson American Grille for dinner on a business trip. We were greeted with enthusiasm by the 2 hostesses & seated quickly. We ordered drinks and the tuna appetizer which came quickly. We had to ask for plates and silverware, but the tuna was tasty. Our server took our dinner orders and we ordered a second round of drinks. Oddly our dinner arrived before our salads. It seemed that communication between the servers and kitchen was off. Our server apologized but we were halfway through our meal before the salads arrived. After dinner we had a third round but felt no pressure to leave. The restaurant was simply decorated and clean. The food was all tasty. read more

Came here on a Tuesday night for dinner and drinks with a group of 6 and absolutely loved it! We sat in the bar area, which had plenty of seating. The vibe was very casual and relaxed. They had plenty of food options to choose from. I ordered the salmon and loved it! I also enjoyed their seasonal pumpkin martini! Our waiter was outstanding and made sure everything was to our liking. If come back again and would recommend to others. read more

Crimson American Grill - Broiled Salmon - American Near Me - York, Pennsylvania

See all

I placed an order for delivery and never received it although the money was taken out of my account. When I attempted to contact the restaurant, it was closed for the evening. I don't know why they would accept an order, process the payment and not send the order before closing time. Very disappointed with this restaurant. read more

Our dinner was really enjoyable - good food, great service, lovely atmosphere. Our party of 3 ordered a garden salad w/champagne vinaigrette, beef noodle soup (light and broth-y, not heavy), Hong Kong chicken (tasty!), side of green beans and a burger with a baked potato, and everyone was satisfied, not stuffed. Great service from Skylar! We will be glad to come back on our next visit to the area! read more

Stopped in for dinner with friends. They have a great happy hour and 1/2 price appetizers on Monday. The egg rolls were great, as were the onion rings. I had the surf and turf salad it was fantastic.. The service was great . We sat on the patio and it was a beautiful evening. I would highly recommend. read more

Crimson is a pleasure in Americana food. The Ribeye was cooked as specified. The crab dip always a delight and creamy appetizer. The broccoli was the least liked item. Lacking in flavor. Still a must return in the future. Staff was very prompt and a true testament to the art. Restaurant was clean. read more

See all

This is the second time my boyfriend and I have come here for our anniversary. The service is so amazing and the atmosphere is very family friendly! Our server Marie, was incredible and made it such an enjoyable evening. I had the half rack of ribs which were so good and he had a well done cheeseburger along side the cream of crab soup! We also got a caramel cheesecake to go! read more

We went there on New Year's Eve as a family. Everything about the atmosphere was perfect. The server was Brooke and she was phenomenal. Portion size was very large and prices were reasonable for the quality of food. I would definitely recommend this restaurant. read more

Crimson is an old-fashioned restaurant serving quality food for a good price. The salmon is delicious, and feels like a fresh home-cooked meal. Although the rice looks plain, there is just enough seasoning throughout that it compliments the fish well. And one of the servers Syd was the best! read more

Crimson American Grill - Broiled salmon with light seasoning - American Near Me - York, Pennsylvania

Had the occasion to eat here today and I must say the service is 5 stars. Employees all super friendly and helpful. I had the black and blue steak dinner which was good. Not great but fine. I'd give the food 3.5 stars. Overall a 4 star rating. Great craft beer tap menu and beer prices reasonable. I'd give it another try. read more

Crimson American Grill - Black and blue ribeye dinner. - American Near Me - York, Pennsylvania

To be honest I wasn't expecting anything special when my party of six came here for dinner. The dining room is large and comfortable but the menu was pretty ordinary. However, I was pleasantly surprised. I had the ribeye which was delicious. Two of our party had the prime rib special which they loved and two others had salmon which was very good. Service was friendly and professional. Bad me for my initial neutrality. This is a good place! read more

we go here often for the bunless hamburger. It's absolutely delicious. We have never been disappointed with the food here. Highly recommend. It is very noisy when it gets crowded. And the side vegetables are usually zucchini and squash which is disappointing. read more

I dined at this restaurant for brunch yesterday with some friends of mine and really enjoyed my meal. I started off with a French Onion soup, I liked it but have tasted better. I also had a crab and asparagus omelette with potatoes on the side. I would get this again. McKenzie, our server was very attentive, polite, and professional...she even took a few pictures of the group. read more

Crimson American Grill - We all enjoyed our meals. - American Near Me - York, Pennsylvania

See all

Steak was well prepared, ribs were delicious our server was pleasant and executed well overall excellent meal.

Service is always excellent thanks to Katrina. Food is always delicious. Ambiance is always just perfect. My favorite restaurant in York Co. read more

Sad for me, we had failed to return to Crimson since the pandemic. No reason we hadn't returned; just had not. Not every restaurant has survived. Crimson appears to have not only survived but thrived. We arrived at 5:30 on a Friday evening to find the restaurant buzzing. With that came a good bit of noisy conversation. And while it was fine for this group, it would not have been for some others. We were immediately seated and enjoyed a wonderful meal. Our only new disappointment was one of the group wanted to have the ribs and a baked potato. The only potatoes available were French fries and scalloped, neither of which she could have for dietary reasons. I had the steak Gorgonzola which needs to remain my first preference at this location. Yum! read more

The Food is really made well and healthy! We loved the Sunday's brunch. Crab Asparagus omelet is amazing! And the french toast... WOW!! Lovely service! Its a quiet ambiance at times, family oriented!! We would go back!! read more

Came here on a Monday night and it was packed. The food is always consistent and the service is excellent. We left Vito's to come here and I'm glad we did. Our server had excellent recommendations! The lemon berry marscapone cake was the cherry on top. read more

Came in for lunch on a Saturday and found ourselves a table in bar/patio area. We were greeted quickly, and offered drinks. Great craft beer selection and good wines. The food was amazing. The crab pretzel (crab cake on a pretzel roll) was top notch. I had one of the Saturday specials, mushroom Swiss burger. Yum! Excellent service and a great time for all! read more

Our dinner here was very good. It was our first time coming here, it was busy but not too packed. I got the stuffed tilapia and lemme tell you that was delicious and real crab meat. My fiancé was also very pleased with his meal. We will be returning read more

Crimson American Grill - Stuffed tilapia - American Near Me - York, Pennsylvania

Haven't been here in years. Girls night out choice. Excellent service. Prompt, order correct. Food came out hot and delicious. Bruschetta burger was excellent. We shared a piece of canolli cake, decedent. Definitely going back. read more

See all

4.16.23 arrived at 2:45pm and walked out to the patio. Watched a waitress wait on the same table 2x. Never even looked over at the table my wife and I were sitting at. Waited 15 minutes, still no attention. Left the establishment after providing the appropriate feedback to the manager on site. Btw, there was only 2 tables occupied on the patio. Not like they were busy. WILL NOT BE BACK read more

Took my husband out for his birthday. Ordered fried shrimp and Baby back ribs. The food came. It was lukewarm warm, and we could not see any steam coming from it. When we proceeded to it, we realized that the food was in the process of spoiling and tasted funny. We noticed the waitress who got the manager, who informed us that she would take the food away, but for any other order, if there was an issue or not, we had to pay for it. We ordered calamari and chicken tenders. While waiting, my husband started to feel funny in his throat, and we decided it was best we leave and go get him some Benadryl. He went to the waitress and told her to cancel the order, and that he just wanted to pay for the drink he had. The manager came to our table telling us the order was done and prepared and they would bag it to go, and we had to pay for it. Instead of fussing with her we paid for it and left. Getting home, we noticed there were no utensils, and the sauce that should have come with the calamari was not there. In all, I would not recommend this restaurant to anyone as the manager has very poor customer service; needless to say, we will never be eating there ever again. read more

Ate here completely not knowing anything about it. A nice local place with a wide menu. Had bbq ribs and crab cakes with baked potato and salads. All were very good and we ate everything. Had margarita cocktails evict were good also. Nice waitress. read more

This is a very good Restaurant most times of the year. I ordered the Salmon fish special w/ sundried tomatoes and couscous . I received the fish and immediately had a bone in the fish. It was caught in the rear back of my teeth and i pulled it out immediately and waved over the Waiter. no big deal, but when you are spending 23.00 dolalrs for a fish meal at a nice restaurant you don't want to have bones in your meal. Waiter went and told the manager/ owner . NOW IT HAPPENNED A SECONF TIME AND I WAS VERY UNHAPPY. I KEPT THE BONE THIS TIME; The kitchen manager came out and explained to My Wife and I that Crimson has changed food Distributors. ** Be careful w/ the Fish Specials " I don't believe the new Distributor is filleting the Fish properly. Also the Quality of the Salmon was Subpar, as I felt Nausea as I arrived home. I frequent the establishment. I have not felt this way before- I almost always order " Fish " for my meal. Moreover, The establishment "never offered to comp my meal", not even 50 % or offer a Free Dessert. Apparantly, the owner doesn't respect me , nor my business . My Wife and I will spend our money somewhere else. read more

The carry out service is bad and has been bad for years. The restaurant's order accuracy is consistently bad. Tonight we order two simple carry out meals. They failed to provide the salad that was ordered as part of one entree. A future desert was offered or we could have driven back from home to get the salad. I requested a credit but they could not process a credit since a manager was not available at 815pm. If you order carry you must check each item before leaving if you don't want to get home and be surprised. This location has no quality control processes to ensure customers receive what they ordered. read more

Congested, difficult to access, not worth the bother. Better choices nearby with a more civil setting.

Our dinner here was very good, service was a 10 out of 10, fast, friendly, and smiling. The food was great, my only complaint was my husband ordered the prime rib and according to the waitress, the kitchen would not wait and we got the prime rib about 4 minutes later, about 20 minutes before the other entree. But it was delicious, as was everything else. Overall, I'd recommend and would definitely return. read more

We were seated right away and had great service. Waitress was nice and knowledgeable. The menu seemed fine - plenty of salads to pick from and plenty of pasta and other entrees for my husband. He ordered the chicken & broccoli alfredo minus the broccoli. It came with a big slice of garlic toast. He said it was good. Side salad also looked like a decent serving and nice mix of veggies. I got the strawberry chicken salad. It was the most blah salad I've had in a long time. I can't even remember a similar nondescript salad to compare it to. For $13.99, I was incredibly underimpressed. Nothing wrong but nothing right. read more

Crimson American Grill - American Near Me - York, Pennsylvania

First time here and let me start off with this...My stepdaughter is extremely picky when it comes to food so there is only a few items that she will eat. I called the restaurant ahead to find out if they would do something special that's not on the menu to accommodate her. They absolutely said yes so when we arrived at the restaurant, this was our first time ever being here. Our waitress is absolutely fantastic. She was so good with her and talked with her. They made her exactly what she wanted and how she wanted it, again it was not on the menu. Someone with limited things that she will eat, makes it very difficult to go to restaurants and I cannot tell you how much I appreciate this for her!! She loved it and she actually said she wants to go back so from the bottom of my heart for those don't understand how hard it is to have a picky eater. This is huge for a restaurant to do! 5* we will be back read more

We had not been here since before COVID. We were not really impressed then. Well a lot has changed. The staff is amazing for being as busy as they were. They are very attentive and let you know exactly what was going on with our food and drinks. And when I say food comes out quick. I'm talking within 10-15 minutes after you order. Not just fast, but hot and to order. We came two weeks in a row just to make sure the first time was not a mistake. Glad we now have go to place in York to finally depend on. read more

We were very pleased with this place, relaxing and comfortable. The food was outstanding- would definitely come here again. read more

Crimson American Grill - Stuffed Tilapia ( I believe that's what kind of fish it was). So good! - American Near Me - York, Pennsylvania

We came here for a quick dinner upon another local recommendation. I saw the specials and was immediately tempted to order buffalo wings and buffalo bites. A glass of red wine surprisingly went decently well with it. We also got the spinach and artichoke dip, which was tasty and hearty as well. The wings were a little teeny for my taste, but the spice was decent enough. read more

Crimson American Grill - American Near Me - York, Pennsylvania

Unfortunately this once fine restaurant has become victim to sloppiness and inconsistency. When a top menu steak comes out as all gristle, something is very wrong. This place has always impressed me in the past. Sadly I can no longer recommend it. read more

If you are looking for a upper class but not extremely fancy restraint this is the place! You can make it as fancy or casual as you would like. We got so excited about everything we forgot to take pictures. We tried the edamame potstickers, they were out of this world! Crispy potstickers, with a soft warm edamame inside. ( we ended up ordered them twice they were so good) Pittsburg Salad with parmesan peppercorn dressing. It was good the meat makes the salad I could've had more french fries. My boyfriend had the chicken Parmesan which he said was good it was not a heavy red sauce but a very light red sauce. My mom got chili, which was very good, came with chips which were slightly stale. Our waitress was great, we were meeting friends and she was extremely respectful, gave us time, but checked in and made she we knew she didn't forget about us! read more

This place is not very good. It's bland and boring food(at best). I call it boomer food. I get dragged here by my father a lot who "loves" it and let me tell you that man has no taste in food at all. He still eats frozen Salisbury steak dinners and knows zero about food or cooking. He always drags guests here and I have to apologize for him because I can tell every single person is not happy with the food. I always suggest the cove or eagles nest but no he's really cheap and he thinks this place is cheap but it's not. Did I mention I hate going to this dump. read more