Milkman, you were so, so, so good to me! I've never been into the restaurant, though I have gotten…read moreDoorDash once before. It was as delicious as I wanted it to be! When my friend and I walked in, we were greeted by such a sweet staff who immediately welcomed us in, shared their thoughts on the menu (since we were first-timers), and suggested we leave a review (they were so lovely, so how could we not!) The entire restaurant feels like the diner Sam worked at in Cinderella Story from the early 2000s - very vintage, very retro, very 50s! It's what I imagine restaurants looking like when my grandparents went on dates when they were my age. I had gotten the tofu nugs via DoorDash, which were better IRL and the milkshake was scrumptious too! My friend got the Milkman Burger, fries, and a fruity pebbles shake. It was all great but let me tell ya...we had this meal almost two weeks ago and I'm STILL dreaming of those French fries. I have had so many iterations of fried potato before...shoestring, steak, wedges, sweet potato, those made from yuca, curly, dipped in ice cream, etc. and these are the best fries I've had in my life. If I could live off the fries, I would. They were that good. I already have plans to share this place with other friends of mine as it has officially worked its way into the rotation for me!

Absolutely love milkman! It's a consistent experience every time and I love the food! I get the…read moredeluxe burger with no bun and a side of fries with their house sauce and wow! My favorite part is that they are smash burgers and filled with flavor. The restaurant itself is in the heart of OTR and very clean. All of the servers are always super nice and provide great service to the customers.

Sizable and delicious portions. Had a burger and fries. So good and so much food! Our server was…read morewarm, friendly and helpful. There were TVs everywhere but on mute so it wasn't noisy. Well appointed with comfy booths. Good all the way around.

Had a meeting to attend to and it happened here. Got the appetizer of soft pretzels. 3 sticks that…read morecame with three types of cheeses. All decent though the horseradish one does take a getting used to. They have this burger called the snack Bru burger (3 oz) for those with smaller appetite. Alsobtried the he teriyaki salmon sandwich - decent. Yes, a little fancy with the menu (heck they make their own ketchup) and maybe more than what you want to pay for a burger but its pretty good every once in a while.

We were visiting from out of state with our baseball team and families. They accommodated our large…read moregroup of teens and parents without batting an eye, and the staff were friendly and happy to share about their restaurant and the surrounding area. Delicious burgers, fries with coarse salt, fried pickles, and Cincinnati chili! Thank you!!

Ok - what a fun little dive!! Soooo much food and it was all good! I'm not much of a burger girl,…read morebut when I want one I really want it done well and they do good burgers. I had the delux with fries and it was nice and hot and piled high with the veggies. Malt vinegar at the table for my fries was perfect. They have an off menu menu too and we tried the stuffed mushrooms which were huge and gooey with some sort of goat cheese filling. A really nice refreshing strawberry lemonade to wash it all down and I was stuffed! Service was super nice diner and dive friendly and great for family or a casual date and everything in between. Will definitely be back!

I couldn't wait to write this review fast enough. I absolutely love this place -- it's officially…read moremy new Cincinnati go-to spot. I don't get to Cincy very often, but I was in town for work and this happened to be the closest bar/restaurant near us downtown that looked decent. Safe to say I got very lucky. The first time I went, I ordered the chili as a starter and a chicken tender platter. And when I tell you I was so happy with both -- I mean it. I love a good chili. I grew up eating it with my grandma, and this one tasted like something she would have made. The cheese and sour cream were perfect. I'm not a huge onion guy, but even those worked well with it. Now here's the catch... it was so good that I literally went back and ordered the exact same thing again. And somehow it was even better the second time. They really outdid themselves on both dishes. One thing I noticed the second time around: I asked for three sauces right away, and they brought them out on a plate with a built-in sauce area. It was actually really convenient -- perfect if you're sharing with people. Now let's talk about the tenders. I'll start by saying I know fried chicken pretty well. Pound for pound, these might honestly be the best chicken tenders in America. The easiest comparison I can give is this: imagine if Cane's and Zaxby's had a kid and named him perfection. That's what these are. Sometimes Cane's can be a little light on seasoning, and sometimes Zaxby's goes a little heavy. These are perfectly in the middle with a great crunch and just the right amount of seasoning. Another thing I really liked about this place is the versatility of it. It feels like the kind of spot where you could do anything -- happy hour with friends, a birthday dinner, a corporate dinner, or even a family night out. I love that kind of diversity in a restaurant. Just 10/10 ambiance. And the staff were incredibly nice and welcoming, which always makes a difference. Honestly, writing this review is making me want to book a flight back to Cincinnati just to eat there again. Wow.

On a work trip and went with my co-workers for dinner. Was immediately greeted and seated. The game…read morehas just ended so there was a lot of people coming in. It was noisy, but we were able to still have a nice conversation. We got the pretzels with beer cheese and spicy mustard. The pretzel was soft, beer cheesy is gooey and so good, and the spicy mustard packed a nice punch! Will definitely recommend! I got the BRU Burger; medium well cook Taleggio Cheese, Bacon, Tomato Jam, Caramelized Onion, Chopped Lettuce, Mayo I got the tomato jam on the side because I never had it and wasn't sure if I'll like it and asked for no bun. The server was nice to offer more shredded lettuce or leaf of lettuce for my burger. The burger was well seasoned, cooked perfectly yo my liking, and to my surprise the tomato jam was delicious! Only thing is... it doesn't come with any sides, not even fries!! You'll have to add that as a side if you want fries ($2). There are other side options. Service is super good, food is good, place is clean, cocktails made well. Overall, definitely would be back next time I'm here. Sadly, I devoured my deconstructed burger before a photo could be snapped.

Absolutely incredible burgers and great staff!! Great for carry out or dine in! Definitely a local…read morespot to visit often!

The "Mariah Curry" paired with the spicy coleslaw, has been the best chicken sandwich I have had in…read morea long time! Will definitely be back.

We stopped in on our way to our hotel around 2:30 on a Thursday afternoon. They were out of sweet…read moretea and chocolate shakes. There were two tables of people there when we arrived and it was fairly quiet. We ordered and sat at a table and noticed there was seating outside so we moved outside to soak up some sunshine. My husband ordered a strawberry shake and large order of fries to split and we both had the single bacon cheese burger. I had mine on a gluten free bun. The burgers came out and our mouths fell open. They were beautiful with the beef, bacon, cheese, sliced onion and tomato and special sauce. We could just get our mouths open enough for a bite. Wonder how that works with the double burger. The first bite was WOW. Now this is what a burger should taste like. And the hand cut fries were delicious also. I tased my husband's strawberry shake and that was also excellent, so much so that he felt better that they were out of chocolate...lol. The chef asked us on our way out how our food was. We would definitely come back here for these burgers, fries and shakes done just right!

My wife & I were driving back to Indy from Lexington. We were checking Yelp along the way, looking…read morefor someplace to eat. This place popped up & we thought it looked good, so we stopped in. The outside looked quite nice, as did the interior. There were plenty of seats inside, but we sat on the very large patio, since it was nice out. We ordered two bacon cheeseburgers, large fries & two drinks. Everyone we interacted with were very friendly! The burgers were HUGE & amazing in construction & taste!! The fries & Hansie sauce were very good, as were the fountain drinks. The prices were pretty good, well, especially since we got the singles & not the double burgers. One of the people even suggested another restaurant in town if we ever came thru again! How classy is that?! We will definitely be back if we are even remotely close to here in the future. I just wish they were closer to us.

Sarah was a great server and kept my family updated about the status of our food and the drinks in…read moretheir current rotation. The inside of the place is really interesting and I love all of the different cars. We sat next to a nice blue one inside. The themed bathroom was also unique.

I'll start off by saying the burger was very very good. I also had ordered the onion rings and they…read moretasted pretty good as well. I could tell the burger was 100% fresh and cooked to the temperature that I asked for. I'm not sure if the onion rings were fresh or not, but they were still good. The reason for the three stars is because the service at the bar was absolutely shit. The server seemed to cater more towards five extremely obnoxious, loud, drunk guys versus other people that were around them. There were several times a bartender would say they would get with me when they notice that I was ready to order and get a drink, but then they never came. The restaurant theme itself is very cool and unique. Overall, I will come back more than likely, but if I have another experience with that same type of service, then I will be done.

Shake Shack is heads above the rest for delivering an incredibly tasty burger; however, prices are…read moreridiculously exorbitant. I'm not just whining like we all do these days at the expense of eating out but, for God's sake, we're talking about 2 burgers, 1 fries, 1 onion rings, and 2 drinks for $35-$40 without tip. In the future, I'll either do take out of the burgers and pick up fries at McDonald's and head home or just skip it all together. Honestly, I felt as if I were grabbing Shake Shack at LaGuardia where I first experienced it.

Stopped here on an impulse. Parking is bad, you're gonna pay and circle the block a few times but…read morethis is college area and most are on foot. Burger was good. I plan to go back to get a shake.