I had made a reservation through their website which brought me to open table. On Open Table it said they were doing a "new" happy hour during my requested visit. However, when we arrived at the location there was no happy hour going on. This was my first visit here. The ambiance was bright and roomy with New York deco and photos. The staff were friendly and courteous. Our server who was also the bartender greeted us in a friendly manner and told us the specials of the day as well as recommendations of best sellers. We opted for the $30 special for 2 which was a choice of Greek salad, Caesar salad or soup to start for each person and then a pizza to share. The pizzas are 12". We ordered the Greek and Caesar salads and the Arugala Bianca pizza. We also ordered the Smoked Burrata as an appetizer. The Caesar and Greek salads were fresh and rather large portion. The Smoked Burrata doesn't come with any bread so you have to pay extra for $3 for that. I feel it should be included. Delicious! The roasted red pepper pesto is very tasty but does have a little bit of heat. The bread is made in house and served with an herb butter. Very yummy! Definitely a must have! The pizza was nicely layered with toppings. It comes with a truffle oil but because I am allergic to mushrooms we did not have that. It definitely needs a little more of something. A balsamic drizzle would have been perfect and probably the truffle oil. It was nicely cooked with a crust crunch with each bite. Everything so fresh on it. Yummy! Definitely of the NY style type of pizza. Overall we were pleased with the meal and experience. We will be back to choose a pizza with some sauce on it. read more

See all

If you're gluten-free, they have a great cauliflower gf crust that is one of the best in the area! I love brick-oven pizza, and SoHo Slice didn't disappoint. I've had the quattro formaggi pizza twice now, and while I enjoyed it both times, the second time had a bit too much wet cheese on top, which is the only reason I gave this 4-stars instead of 5. The inside of the restaurant is cute, and the menu has a nice selection of options. The staff were conscientious of my gluten allergy, which I really appreciated, and they were kind. I've been surprised many times when we've driven past that there aren't more cars in the parking lot, so I'd highly recommend giving them a try if you're on the fence! read more

SoHo Slice Pizzeria - QUATTRO FORMAGGI on a gluten free crust - Pasta Shops Near Me - Rehoboth Beach, Delaware

Stopped here on a Saturday night for a quick bite. Inside is cute and tables aren't crammed together so that was nice. Overall good ambiance. Service was great, super friendly and attentive. We ordered the cheesy bread and it was excellent so we had high expectations for the pizza. Unfortunately you can only get one size of pizza unless you order to go which I think is really strange. The pizza was okay - we had a pepperoni and vodka sauce pizza. The pepperoni's were the mini ones and a little too spicy for my liking and the vodka pizza was really lacking in flavor. The best part was the crust which was delicious, and I am not a crust person. I might give this place one more try and get a different pizza but overall, not my favorite pizza I have had in the area. read more

We tried Soho Slice for happy hour and for HH it's ok... Very pleasant bartender,good pour on the wine . The food, we tried a bunch of the HH food, for the most part it's ok. The pizza was disappointing,from the crust to the sauce . We added on onions and salt and the sausage was piled on top like crazy. It didn't even look nice. ( at first the pizza came out missing the toppings- they brought it back to the kitchen and I'm guessing they were upset how it returned). read more

Amazing pizza! Service was awesome and very very clean. Seats comfy and clean. Other foods are great. Bathrooms are nice and clean. Drinks are good. Prices are low and great for stuff you are getting!! I recommend this pizza place ALL the way! read more

This is a spot where you can quickly get pizza, salad and a drink. It's super cute inside! We had heard good things so my friend and I wanted to give it a try! My friend and I were not impressed by the pizza. We got the Hot Italian and added roasted red peppers. The sauce and flavors were fine. However, it was very wet and the toppings slid off our pizza. Not sure if the crust was supposed to be super thin but that would lead to toppings falling off. Our Caesar salad tasted fine. Service was good. If you don't wanna go back into town and you're shopping at the outlets, maybe this is the spot for you.. read more

See all

We absolutely loved our experience. The food was great, customer service was stellar, and the prices were reasonable. Sorry to Crust and Craft, but SoHo bested you on pizza and pasta. Can't wait to go back! read more

Yes it's cute, but idk, we both felt it was not NY at all. We're both pretty big pizza people. I love all kinds, my husband is a bit pickier. Transparently we wouldn't come back. There are a lot of places to pick from and I just think it was lacking something. Great if you need a quick bite which I did. Service was wonderful and parking is ample. I just can't imagine picking here over some other local pizza spots in the area. read more

See all

Waitress went to get the draft beer list and never returned. Someone brought water. We left after 10 minutes and saw her hanging out behind the bar as we walked away. I will never eat in there again. I will state that we have had their Hot Italian pizza as carryout and it was ready on time. However it was soggy in the middle which indicates it was not cooked enough and it fell apart when we pulled the slices apart. Pizza selection is limited and sauces on them not appetizing. Go to Crust & Craft or Henlopen Pizza instead. read more

Always a great bar experience and food to match. Parking and just off Rt 1, always a win for locals!

We tried this restaurant after seeing reviews for it and being close by. We were promptly seated and built our own pizzas. I got mine with mushrooms and my wife got one for her and my son which had pepperoni and Italian sausage. We also got a child sized cheese pizza. The pizza was very good, with crisp crust and the fresh toppings. We didn't think the prices were too out of bounds, as the pizza for the full sized one were around $17-20 each. The service was average, especially given how slow they were on the day we went. We would probably go back. read more

SoHo Slice Pizzeria - Pepperoni and Italian sausage. Very good. - Pasta Shops Near Me - Rehoboth Beach, Delaware

See all

Not sure why everyone gives this place such low reviews. I ate there a few months ago and discovered they were to my knowledge the only pizzeria in the area offering vegan cheese. Since having Covid I developed a dairy and egg allergy, but was excited I could once again get restaurant pizza. I gave the owner feedback that he should try a different supplier and their new product now tastes exactly like real mozzarella, melts perfectly and to top it off, Monday nights are half-priced pizza. My son got the meatball sub and loved it. They have very good sauce, not sweet like some of the other places nearby, and the crust comes out crisp and is not too thick or thin, imho. This is the Goldilocks of upscale pizza places in Rehoboth for people with food sensitivity but who also want a good pizza at a price lower than national chains for a 10" personal pie. read more

So, lets talk about all of the things!! Ambiance, its pretty nice here, I won't complain for sure. Its a little loud, and a little basic but its fine. All is well! Service, hey man its good, its fast, waiter was cordial and polite. No problems there, the pizzas came out in a reasonable time. Appetizers came out before the entrees which is ideal, absolutely 0 complaints! Finally the food. My crust was delicious, nice, just crispy enough to hold everything up and support my pizza, but not burned. Now, my wife got a regular pizza, no cauliflower, and it was also quite tasty. Not too crispy, not too soft, hers was admittedly a little less crisp than mine but that's okay she likes it less crisp. All in all, I can give them a 4, well done lads. read more

SoHo Slice Pizzeria - My delicious cauliflower pizza! - Pasta Shops Near Me - Rehoboth Beach, Delaware

See all

Meh. Overpriced and unremarkable. $12 for the zucchini appetizer that only included 7 slices of zucchini - $1.74 per slice... read more

SoHo Slice Pizzeria - $12 for 7 slices of zucchini.... - Pasta Shops Near Me - Rehoboth Beach, Delaware

Friday afternoon lunch at the bar Andy was bartending I tried the limoncello martini with pizza both were excellent read more

SoHo Slice Pizzeria - Italian pizza - Pasta Shops Near Me - Rehoboth Beach, Delaware

Being gluten-free is very difficult in southern Delaware. The majority of restaurants have been slow to catch on that, for many customers, it's not a choice. I finally got to experience all the delicious pizza toppings my husband husband has been raving about here. The gluten-free cauliflower crust was outstanding. You would never know it was cauliflower. I had the Putanesca & it was delicious. I don't know that it qualifies as New York pizza...other than it's thin and you can fold it! It is brick oven pizza with a wide variety of unusual toppings. Open your mind and give it a chance. I will be back. read more

The food was amazing. The portions were perfect. We ordered lunch - Fried zucchini, Cesar salad, pepperoni pizza and rigatoni and everything was delicious. The service was great. The bar service was great as well, cool wine glass, large drink menu and the best Shirley temples for the kids. It's casual but more upscale but not stuffy which is a nice option for this area. Nice ambiance. We will definitely be returning! read more

Great Friday night place. 1/2 price wine night. They have gluten free pizza that is delicious. read more

SoHo Slice Pizzeria - Pasta Shops Near Me - Rehoboth Beach, Delaware

This restaurant/bar replaced Atlantic Social. Imagine my surprise when I found out that I couldn't get a slice of pizza at a place with the word "slice" in its name. I'm from New York City (Manhattan, born and raised) so, frankly, I'm fully qualified to judge pizza, at least as much as Portnoy is. I got a 10" personal pan pizza and a Coke. The pizza was good, no question about it, but it wasn't "New York". A good crust, but not "New York"; good sauce but ... well, you know. There were a few small islands of mozzarella in addition to a thin veneer of shredded, melted pizza cheese. So it was good but I'm not sure one would find it, just like this, south of Houston street in lower Manhattan. Otherwise, it has a nice, contemporary atmosphere and several big flat screens with (what else?) sports on display. Based on my brief, limited experience, I would give it a 8.25. read more

Save you money. The water is really bad. I won't go back. Customers were coming but turning around and leaving. Plain Wings were cooked in old oil (super dark). No towel in the men's room. This place might close permanently if changes are made. read more

SoHo Slice Pizzeria - Pasta Shops Near Me - Rehoboth Beach, Delaware

See all

We went there tonight had 3 different pizza, build your own pizza. Chicken Parmesan with pasta was perfect, The service was great, will be back. Very clean and pretty place. read more

Went in on a Saturday evening and the place was dead. Atmosphere was nice, service was really slow, food was ok, but overpriced. They bill this place as NY style...it isn't. Not even close. Took almost a half hour to get our 2 drinks because "the bartender was busy." Um...but the bar is empty. The pizza is a small 4 slice Margherita pizza. Tasted fine. All in all it is probably a one and done. I'll be surprised if the restaurant is still there a year from now. read more

Great pizza, wings good flavor but not very crispy. Place was very clean and the staff was very nice! read more

See all

The food was great. The service could have been better. We waited 20 minutes to receive our cocktails. The food took 30-40 minutes. The restaurant is new. The design is dark and and looks cheap. read more

See all

They got my order wrong and they won't answer the phone to fix it. In addition, the pizza was not ready till after 20 minutes after the time I was told it was going to be ready. You cannot get in touch with them. There's no human being that answers the phone and no place to leave a number for them to call you back. read more

We previously enjoyed their happy hour but yesterday the service was so slow we decided to leave. It took over 30 minutes to even get a menu. It looked like the bartender was serving the entire restaurant so most of the fault probably lies with the ownership. But he wasn't all that friendly as well. We went to Crust and Craft and wound up getting a similar happy hour and maybe even better food. read more

Very good pizza - its not NY style though. same price and quality as crust and craft up the street. Its the little things they need to change like maybe having a pineapple on the grilled pineapple drink. Removing black olives from the description for Greek salad and add Kalamata instead. Who puts mushrooms in penne vodka (not listed ingredient) - they need to work on the consistency before the summer starts. Service was great with no complaints. read more

One word. WOW! This place is phenomenal. We ordered alot, so we could try a variety of things. We ordered 3 different pizzas, the cheese bread and mozzarella sticks. Every thing was incredible. They also have the "good ice". read more

See all

It looks pretty, flavor is not giving. Service was terrible and slow. Flavors were very weird and not enjoyable. I don't think I want to go back nor my party that went with me. And I have a question. Only ONE sad slice of prosciutto for the whole pizza???!!! read more

This week I ordered delivery from SoHo Slice twice and was positively impressed! Their Buffalo wings were meaty and moist. Celery, carrot sticks, blue cheese dressing, and extra buffalo sauce were included. The Mushroom Madness pizza was the bomb! Mushrooms, porcini cream sauce, mozzarella cheese, arugula, and truffle oil... I'm drooling just thinking about it! Will definitely be reordering it again. Craving those scrumptious mushrooms again, I decided to try the Filet Mignon Rigatoni! OMG! Picture 2 thick, perfectly cooked (medium) tenderloin medallions, mushrooms, porcini cream sauce, truffle oil, asiago on top of rigatoni noodles! Yes, it was as good as it sounds! Definitely a lick-the-plate-clean kind of dinner that I highly recommend and can't wait to order again this week when my company comes to town. For dessert, I tried their Tiramisu. The serving size was large and it melted in my mouth. It did not disappoint. Perfect end to a wonderful meal. It is with great pleasure that I highly recommend SoHo Slice, giving it a well-deserved 5 star review. Kudos to the chefs and staff! Note: I ordered through Toast Delivery Service. On their menu, salad options weren't included. read more

See all

So I used to live across the street when it was Atlantic Social and after a very bad experience on NYEve I never went back. I have tried SoHo multiple times and the food is good. This trip I am writing about for the bartender (if I could only remember her name :). I went specifically for this Chicken Pesto sandwich they had but it was removed on the new menu. FYI - Online is the old menu you better change it :):) She quickly got me menu's and a water. Kept my water filled throughout. I ordered the 3 Waygu meatball...were good, came close to being excellent only because they were a tad warm but very good and sauce was excellent. I order another chicken sandwich and she offered to get me a side of sauce and pesto to make it like the old sandwich. Unfortunately to my dismay they had no pesto. Not sure how a Italian place does not have pesto, sandwich was excellent, fries were excellent. Alot of TVs, big bar, glad to see its hanging in. Wish I remembered her name to give her the proper shout out. read more

Pizza is very average at best. Ingredient quality is lacking for a place specializing in pizza - you would expect great pizza! If you've been to SoHo, you would laugh at this pizza. read more

The food was fair. Pizza was good. Service was below expectations. Entrees came out 20 minutes apart. Interesting that the suggested tips said the tip was based on 20-22-25%. The amount given had several more dollars added. They were deceiving their diners to bump their tips. read more

Second time eating there- not a great experience. Sandwiches were ehhh Eggplant parm sandwich had one piece of eggplant and was mostly bread. Cheesesteak was also fair. Took 30 minutes to come and there were tons of empty tables. Maybe just a bad night but hope they improve the quality of their food. read more

I ordered a plain cheese pizza in July 2025. The issues: not much taste; hardly any sauce, but loaded with chunks of tomato; very thin sparingly placed slices of mozzarella cheese; dough was much different than NY style. I'm from NYC, surprisingly they call this NY pizza. read more

Was really looking forward to a NY style pizza place... well this is not it. I ordered a BYO pizza and it was a margherita pizza with pepperoni. Heads up- NY style pizza uses shredded mozzarella, not fresh mozzarella. We won't be back. read more

Ordered takeout, it was ready quickly and pizza was delicious. It was overflowing with toppings. Didn't sit down to eat, but the dining room looked nice. read more

New to the area and trying to find the best place for pizza. Unfortunately, this was not it. In addition to paying $26 for a small pizza, the pizza was really not great. The crust was overdone and burnt and just didn't taste good. The best part was the sauce...that was pretty good. We will not be back. read more

Here is the thing, you want NY Pizza, go to New York and be sure to go to a "hole in the wall" run by Italian New Yorkers. Being a New Yorker born and raised I know better than to expect anything outside of New York or north eastern New Jersey to taste authentic. As for SoHo Slice I thought the pizza was good, the arugula salad was tasty, a tad over dressed but tasty, as was the pizza. The service was also good. Not sure I have to go back given there are other pizzerias in the area that are just as good. I also agree with someone who wrote about not being able to get a slice yet the word slice is in the name. I really do wish pizza restaurants would stop saying NY pizza. Try drumming up business some other way other than you have NY pizza. It's artisanal at best. read more

This review is in direct contrast with the popularity of this restaurant. It is a new attraction here at the beach. It is moderately priced and basically an enhanced pizzeria with a modern decor flare. We ordered a minestrone soup and fried zucchini as a starter. The soup was fair tasting but nothing that hinted as homemade. Fried zucchini was deeply fried and dusted with Parmesan cheese, which was unexpected. Service was good and waiters were attentive. Ordered a chicken parm on homemade bread and was able to substitute salad for fries. Sadly, their bread was not a good match for a classic Italian handheld. I was very disappointed in the small portion double breaded chicken cutlet that was overly fried (see photos) . The Mediterranean pita was sparsely filled however, had good taste. All in all this was a one and done experience for us. The place draws a large crowd for a week day evening, so they must be doing something right... maybe it's their pizza which we didn't taste. There are too many Italian restaurants in the area that serve premium Italian food for SoHo pizza to outshine. read more

See all