I had high hopes for this place based on the other reviews and I wanted try a local, rather than chain, pizza place. We ordered a large meat pizza and small Margherita pizza for delivery. It took over an hour, but was expected since we ordered during a peak time. We liked the thin crust on both pizzas and the meat toppings were good. The Margherita had chunks of tomatoes rather than slices which I was not a fan of. Rather than tasting the mozzarella, I got mouthfuls of tomato instead. I think we will try again and maybe dine in next time. read more

Slice Pizzeria - Margherita goodness - Pizza Near Me - Kill Devil Hills, North Carolina

Slice Pizzeria is one of those pizza places that just hit the spot. It's a pizza place that u can remember from younger years where the bread is delicious, the sauce isn't too saucy, and the pizza isn't greasy. There is a nice patio area if u wanna enough the nice weather while scarfing down your pizza. Definitely worth the stop to try! read more

Slice Pizzeria - Pic of truck from pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - Kill Devil Hills, North Carolina

Pizza was pretty good. Definitely better than most. Lack of indoor seating and wait-time were not great! We ordered slices that were right there ready to be boxed up. But it was a good 15 min before they did it. Probably great pizza if it was fresher. read more

2 words- Chicago Florentine! Omg sooooo good! The crust is perfect, thick, actually cooked all the way, and the toppings are so fresh! 10/10 Unfortunately We ate it all before I remembered to take a picture! So good! read more

Great place to stop in and grab a slice. No frills, cans and bottles of soda, outdoor seating. Had a great variety of pizza by the slice with quick turnaround. Chicago style is more of a sicilian, but still tasty all around. read more

Really good pizza, we got it by the slice. We ordered a couple deep dish pizzas and the chicken bacon ranch. Solid pricing for great pizza. Quick service as well. They move fast. read more

Deserves all 5 stars! The pizza was that good! I grew up on Long Island and always on the search for the elusive great cheese pizza. This town has numerous pizza places and so glad I stopped here first! They have Chicago style as well but that's not my cup of tea. It's small with only a few seats that consistently has a flow of patrons. Small but loaded strip mall, next to ice scream, fudge and nuts shop and donuts. Omg! What more could you possibly need?!! read more

See all

Great Pizza! It pairs well with beer and soda It was open which we found out that alot of places are closed for the off season read more

I ordered a Hawaiian Pizza I did not want Red sauce but add Olive oil Pizza crust Very good but the pizza itself had no flavor because there were no spices at all This is not the first time ordering from Slice but tonight was very disappointing read more

I am seriously puzzled at the number of five star reviews for this place. I have rated restaurants for quite some time on yelp and I do not give out bad ratings very often, but I feel I need to be honest about this pizza place. There are many pizza options in the Outer Banks. There is a pizza place practically every block or two up and down the main highways, so when people are all saying that this is the best one I really feel bad for the folks who live in North Carolina is Outer Banks. I ordered a Chicago style pan pizza with pepperoni and sausage. It looked OK until I got into it and found that it was grossly under cooked. It was basically like eating toppings on top of uncooked though. I realize that they were very busy and probably pushing pizzas through the oven faster than they should, but at the end of the day it is all about the product. I can forgive bad service if the product is good. To be clear, the service here was fine, but the product was under done. As I'm staying in a hotel room I have no real way to be able to cook it to get the dough baked. I seriously hope that they read this review and remember what makes them great, according to their five star reviews, is an excellent product. They failed tonight. read more

The food was great. We had the garlic knots and the natural pizza. The food was great. The service was good. There is outside dining.

This place was amazing. They offer a LOT of different types of pizza. This place is EXACtly what you need when you are tired of the seafood in Outter Banks and don't want a whole pie. This place offers pizza by the slice and their customer service is amazing! This place gets a 4.5/5 for me. And that's coming from two people visiting from Detroit and New York (so we know our pizza) :-) read more

See all

Good food great staff! Would definitely eat here again. Open fairly late for a Sunday night also.

Fast service under the estimated time. Pizza was good and so was the cheese steak. Tried to order online and after a lengthy process would not accept my order and had to call it in. Definitely better than your average beach pizza. read more

The pizza is A1 from Day 1. Been here more times than I can remember. Prices are fair for the location and they have consistently had great pizza over the years. Nice location with a clean kitchen. Customer service is good, nothing personable, but it's a fast pace environment most days. Try any pizza and grab some garlic knots/rolls (they are surprisingly cheap, and definitely delicious). read more

Fair pizza. A bit doughy and too much like Sbarro for me. Last time I went they just opened and nobody else there on a 95 degree day. So, after ordering they still tell me to wait outdoors for a loudspeaker announcement it was ready. Total BS when nobody is there. Won't be back...and you're about the closest place to my house. I'll be driving right by you. read more

I drive down from Corolla every year We are down here for their delicious pizza! Since 2008 this is probably my favorite pizza place in NC and Jeremiah and staff do a great job! read more

See all

Great pizza! We ordered a Pepperoni Pizza, Cheese, and Cheesesteak pizzas and all were ready on time, piping hot, and delicious. Won't go so far as to say it is authentic NY pizza, but extremely tasty and great crusts! read more

The drive took longer than we all expected. It was past the kids bedtime. All were a bit hangry. My wife was getting us settled in for the week. My job was to get us dinner which we could all enjoy and considering it was 8pm, the clock was ticking. We ordered two cheese pizzas and they did not disappoint us! They were delicious!!! It was clear this is a locals favorite. Everyone knew each other. I was greeted by a very friendly woman who juggled everyone's order and made it look effortless as if she was directing a symphony. What it lacked in a formal restaurant setting was more than compensated in an absolutely delicious pizza...the family fought over the crusts!!! Thank you, Slice Pizza!!! read more

They told us 45 minutes and we waited an hour and 30. Brought my whole family. They were so rude and the pizza was NOT worth the wait. Will not be coming back. read more

Will only deliver if they are in the mood. Ordered delivery on a Saturday, few days later called to order again and said they didn't deliver to us. Advertisements say Mike marker 8.5 we were at 5. Lady said they never delivered that far (5-10 min drive). The lady didn't believe us and said they never delivered that far before and the address didn't exist. Obviously didn't want the business. Food was really good the one time we actually got it. read more

Walking through the door of this establishment you wonder why these people aren't in the business of cleaning(I don't blame them). You can pretty much see your reflection on any hard surface that has been wiped down which is everything. They stay almost as busy cleaning as they do preparing delicious food. The employees aren't overly friendly, but not stuffy either...just getting down to business to make sure that you get your order in a timely manner. The order was prepared and served to us much more quickly than I had anticipated given the number of customers. The manager served us our food and asked if we needed anything else. Mouthwatering food in the display case made for a great presentation. I thought it a bit unfair that my budget wouldn't allow me to purchase one of everything. Nevertheless, my eyes were much bigger than my stomach with two slices of pizza and a couple of garlic knots. A single slice alone was bigger than half of a small pizza in some places. And the garlic knots...divine. The first bite left me with questions...do I devour this quickly or savor it and enjoy it? I did a bit of both. I began to devour it and halfway through began to slow down and savor the flavor. It wasn't long before the 'itis' set in and I wondered if I would make the hour and a half drive home awake. The manager came over and boxed our leftover pizza. That's right...left over. The slices are so large we were only able to eat one piece each. Let's not forget the patio outside for customers that want to enjoy fresh air, sunshine, and maybe a few flies. ;) I will definitely visit this establishment again. The price is right and the food is excellent. read more

Slice Pizzeria - Yumm! - Pizza Near Me - Kill Devil Hills, North Carolina

First time here went on past reviews. Pizza was the best in OBX since coming here for vacation the last several years. One note very busy so call ahead. Pizza was cool well had half cheese and half sausage. They sell by the slice which is good. read more

Slice Pizzeria - a slice of pizza - Pizza Near Me - Kill Devil Hills, North Carolina

After a late arrival in Kill Devil Hills, we ordered delivery from Slice Pizzeria. Order and delivery was simple with no problems. Our pizza arrived before the promised time and was clearly hot out of the oven. We had very generous servings of all of the toppings we ordered and everything was good. It was a solid pizza! We ordered two side salads that featured fresh romaine lettuce with appropriate amounts of all ingredients and dressing. I have very low expectations of pizza at the beach, but this was very, very good and a reasonable value for what we received. Recommended when you're in Kill Devil Hills. read more

Stopped in for a slice and it did not disappoint. Staff was great and the pizza was even better.

Wife and I absolutely loved the pizza and garlic knots. We have gone to hundreds of pizza places around the country and Slice is better than all of them. Five Stars!!! read more

The pizza was very flavorful. We tried both Chicago and NY. The Chicago was. It not very authentic, as it was mostly thick crust with minimal topping and worth the cheese on top, but still tasted good. It was a little disappointing they there was no inside seating as well we had not planned for that. Plan to grab your food to go. I would definitely eat there again but I'd stick with the NY style pizza and probably try a calzone. read more

No indoor dining...and roaches all over the back patio where we sat to eat our pizza :(

This pizza joint is currently a in and out pizza place. It stayed pretty busy the time we were there. We ordered a 14" pep and mushroom pizza. It tasted great, was piping hot. The only complaint I have is that they were disorganized. They handed me the wrong pizza and had to swap it out. The only good thing is they caught it before I left. I was not the only one. I watched someone else walk back in with theirs and have to exchange them. They get this straight and this place will be a solid 5 star location. read more

Solid choice for pizza! Sauce makes the pies. Garlic knots are pull-apart and just so-so.

Very good pizza Chicago style perfectly cooked ! Margarita awesome Regular We will be back again ! We ate the Chicago one too fast for a photo and margarita. This place isn't too expensive for the taste ! The smell of the brick oven yummy! Only thing was the cashier was a bit "snotty " with me bc I couldn't hear here and she was in a mood -- read more

Slice Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - Kill Devil Hills, North Carolina

Visiting from out of town, after a large seafood lunch a slice of pizza was perfect. Currently offering outdoor seating. Pizza was fresh and hot and has a unique and delicious "crunchewy" crust. I had the Margherita and husband enjoyed the Meat Lovers. read more

It was ok.....pizza could been cooke a little longer. Crust was right on target. Great people working there....would give it another try for sure.....Covid is hurting a lot of places. read more

Very clean and enforced social distancing. Masks were required and ordering was quick and easy. Tables outside for eating. Food/Pizza was fantastic!! Had the Margaritah and was not disappointed!! Will definitely be back to try other pizzas read more

Slice Pizzeria - Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - Kill Devil Hills, North Carolina

We had tried to go to this place on June 22nd but place was closed due to low staffing, per there sign. I couple days later on our way back from go-karting we decided to stop by this place. The guy we ordered from was rude and curt. We couldn't even put in an order without the guy rolling his eyes. I don't know what the big deal is about this place. Pizza was just ok. The experience with rudeness made it even worse. I'll never go back here again. read more

The pizza itself is pretty decent but the garlic knots are frozen rolls with a little garlic salt and olive oil brushed on them. Such a disappointment, like I said though the pizza was decent. Not that it matters but I was born and raised in NY and have had the hardest time finding actual garlic knots in the OBX. Dinner rolls with garlic and olive oil are not garlic knots, it was really disappointing. read more

Amazing pizza! They have it all and it's so good. Appetizers, entree and fab desserts. Great service with quality food- u can not go wrong!

This is, HANDS DOWN, the BEST pizza on the eastern seaboard. The variety of pies here is outstanding, and all of them are done exceptionally well. My favorite is the chicken bacon ranch. Perfect salty, savory, sweet......umami for sure! Their garlic knots are the best I've ever had, you'd think they'd be hard to screw up, but nobody does them like this. They also do deep dish, which was ooey gooey extraordinary. The service is fantastic, one of the managing partners was there for one of our visits, really friendly guy. We were here three times during our 8 day trip, they were all memorable and delicious. Need I say more?? read more

Slice Pizzeria - Best pizza (and garlic knots) ever!!! - Pizza Near Me - Kill Devil Hills, North Carolina

The pizza was great. Wide selection of canned and bottled beverages. Outside seating only. I had the Chicago deep dish with pepperoni and sausage and a hand tossed supreme. Both were great. Both the crusts and toppings were excellent. read more

Best white pizza I've ever had!!!!! We got both broccoli and spinach. Definitely going back again