If I were rating the pizza alone, this would easily be 5 stars. Slice On Broadway in Robinson has the kind of NY-style pizza I really enjoy. The crust is just right, the little pepperonis curl up perfectly around the edges, and there's a great balance between the cheese and crust. Their white pizza with spinach and tomato is my absolute favorite. I also really like their sausage pepperoni (the sausage is ground) and it's delicious. The reheated in store slices are fantastic. They put them back in the oven, and they come out absolutely delicious and crispy. The reason I'm giving 4 stars overall is the dining area. There's minimal ventilation, and the dining room can sometimes be a bit messy. I'd recommend getting your pizza to go or keeping your expectations modest when it comes to the seating area. The pizza itself is absolutely worth it! read more

See all

Small, local New York Style pizza joint. There is ample seating for amount of business with 2 and 4 seat tables. Typical pizza place atmosphere. The pizza here was pretty good and a great value at only $4.00 a slice. Service was friendly, but the current 'hip-hop' style music may not be agreeable to most or those with young children. My pepperoni slice had a thin crispy crust (with a hint of sourdough) and was topped with a light sauce, ample cheese and small curly pepperoni. I thought it could have used a tad more sauce, but delicious. Highly recommend for the flavor and great value read more

See all

The pizza is very good. The crust is nice and crispy. Don't bother to get just a slice, get a whole pie. Legit.

Came here on the way to the airport after trying a location closer to where I live. Pizza has been great to go, decided to stop in and get slices for a quick lunch. Staff was great, pizza came out quick after picking which I wanted. Only thing that kept this from 5 stars was the plain slice was pretty burnt on the bottom. Not the type of burnt like a thin, coal fired pizza, this was just genuinely burnt. Didn't get a picture but the pepperoni slices were fine! And they tasted great. A bit more crust on the slices than I'm used to but this place remains one of the better slices in Pittsburgh. read more

Slice On Broadway - Robinson - Pizza Near Me - Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania

Slice on Broadway is a pretty good pizza place, even though it can get a little smoky inside. Definitely better than average but not top ten. Service is normally pretty good although this time we stood at the register with nobody there, waiting to order for a little longer than necessary. Only one person was behind the counter, making dough, so we had to wait for another to come from the back. Not a big deal but feel like I have to mention it. Regardless, the pizza was heated up and was decent. read more

Slice On Broadway - Robinson - Pizza Near Me - Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania

Service was fantastic. Pizza was great. MET two friends here to try it out and a large worked for all of us. Highly Recommend!

Slice on Broadway, in general, is a hit or miss. This time, it was a miss. I ordered extra cheese and they cooked the heck out of my order and essentially gave me cheese crisps. Service is usually friendly and greets you quickly upon entering establishment. Pizza shop is kept tidy. read more

Slice On Broadway - Robinson - Extra cheese sausage pizza. Clearly they didn't do this A-grade work when they supposedly won "best cheese slice" in Vegas. - Pizza Near Me - Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania

Tried the square pizza, just plain cheese- it was really good. I think when you get a "slice" it is never as good as a fresh pizza, but the flavors were still good. Maybe they didn't reheat it long enough b/c the crust wasn't crispy and the center of the slice was barely warm. Obviously fast service and only $5 for lunch was nice. The store was open and bright, but wasn't the cleanest place. It's still worth trying, the flavor is good. read more

See all

Large plain pizza to go ordered They burned it boxed it and said nothing about it. Shame on them! And they charged full price for it! Check your pizza before paying and before leaving the store because you may be surprised at what is in the box. read more

We were anticipating the opening of this location/ so excited to give Slice a try! Spoiler: It lives up to the hype! A smooth process ordering online, a warm welcome upon arrival at pickup, efficient service, and a delicious za! We enjoyed the Hawaiian Pizza and "The Little Guy" salad. The Little Guy, though placed into a small container, provided plenty of salad, with wonderfully fresh and plentiful cheese. Thanks for a great pizza night! read more

See all

This is just what you NEED when you're a single person and JUST want lunch ! Price is good and when you're ONLY dealing with YOURSELF . . WELL . . . read more

Slice On Broadway - Robinson - And there ya go ! No more to say - Pizza Near Me - Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania

See all

The restaurant is cute and there are a lot of places to sit. The cheese pizza was really good. The buffalo chicken lacked flavor, and it tasted like bagged chicken. I can't recommend the buffalo chicken, but I did like the plain cheese slice. The service was qui k and staff was friendly! Overall, we did enjoy our visit and would go back to try other flavors. read more

Slice On Broadway - Robinson - Cheese Pizza slice and buffalo chicken pizza - Pizza Near Me - Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania

I'm not afraid to pay more for good food if I think it's worth it. I didn't think it was worth it.... I got 2 slices. One pepperoni and one buffalo chicken. $9. The pepperoni was ok. Not bad but nothing that would bring me back. The buffalo chicken was a complete let down. Could not taste the buffalo sauce at all and the entire slice had one tiny little cube of chicken. It literally had zero flavor. Not worth anywhere near $4+. I'd rather go to Sam's club and get a whole pie with a million more toppings for less money. I stopped here out of convenience. Will not do it again. read more

Wonderful lunch place...go in even if no one else is there! We got there on Sunday a little after it opened and there was one man leaving and one man picked up a to go but that was it! We ordered each a slice and shared a steak and onion roll. We waited about 5 minutes and then an employee brought out our food. We both thought the pizza was good...cheese and dough fantastic! The roll was good but really great when dipped into the ranch. We want to try some other options the next time we are on the area. read more

See all

Everything was crisp and fresh. Cute place, nice staff. Would come again! Spinach and tomato pizza recommended. read more

Slice On Broadway - Robinson - Pizza Near Me - Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania

Ordered a large goomba pizza and this place does it right. Great crust. NY style and the ricotta sauce is awesome! read more

Slice On Broadway - Robinson - Pizza Near Me - Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania

Not sure what the whole rave about their pizza is. It's ok but just average and music in the place was way too loud. Wouldn't go out of my way for it. read more

I've ate here before but this is a place to eat New York styled pizza the people that take your order are awesome and so nice best service from Matt in robinson. Best environment also I am gonna eat here everytime read more

Slice On Broadway - Robinson - Mushroom, Pepporini pizza from S.O.B - Pizza Near Me - Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania

I got a pizza that was way different than what I ordered, bizarre even but I was hungry so I ate it. Cold. Why? Because it was delivered to the hotel entrance where it was 32 outside and left for over 30 minutes even though it was to be brought to my hotel room door. Fine, you don't do that, at least tell me. read more

Grew up on NYC thin crust. Picked up a pie to bring back to my hotel room. It was fantastic! I liked the vibe of the restaurant too. Good work guys. This is legit. read more

No complaints. Stopped in for a quick bite on the way to the airport. Light, thin and crispy. Solid sauce. Appears they do more pick up than dine in. No alcohol. read more

Slice On Broadway - Robinson - Inside - Pizza Near Me - Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania

See all

The duplication of the original seems to always leave you with a faded image. Not that it is a bad copy, but a copy nonetheless is not the original. I've had Slice on Broadway ON Broadway and was never disappointed. I ordered a pepperoni pizza and an Italian hoagie. The hoagie was not good at all. I didn't finish it. The lettuce was an unusually green leafy lettuce; almost spinach like. Not something I've ever seen on a hoagie. The dressing was off; not quite Italian dressing, not quite balsamic dressing? Still not sure. The pizza was the only thing that kept this trip from being a total waste of money. It was okay. Like I said earlier, it was like someone tried to copy the original slice. It's not the same. Sorry. read more

Closest to a NY slice that we have found in Pittsburgh.. Very good pizza!!! Friendly staff

Food is great!! Restaurant is very clean!! Staff are all very friendly and sweet!! I'll def eat here again!!!! read more

Slice On Broadway - Robinson - Italian hoagie - Pizza Near Me - Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania

See all

The food was delicious I loved their sauce that was on the pizza it was the most flavorful and unique sauce I have every had. The service was very fast too it only took 20 minutes for 2 whole pizzas. If you are the type for crunchy crust this is for you too it is the best pizza I have ever had I wish I lived near it but I live 1000 miles away and was just visiting for the Steelers! read more

The pickup order was ready way sooner than they estimated. Delicious pizza and the best garlic knots I've ever had!

So glad to have this replace the previous pizza place. Best pizza around. Hands down. Service is always quick the all of the options are great read more

Pizza was bland. Over priced. I ordered a small pizza with three topping and it cost 27 dollars after taxes. It was an 8 cut pie. The slices were half the size normal sized slice. The counter lady did not greet me. Bad customs serve. the cooks were loud talking over any conversation you could have ordering. I would definitely not suggest this place to anyone. It was like blaze pizza. But way more expensive. read more

Amazing, cheese pizza was amazing and so were the garlic naughts. Service was good and every type of pizza we had was delicious!

Wonderful service! Their pizza is amazing! My friends and I come in for lunch about twice a week and their staff is ALWAYS so welcoming. Thank you Matt, Matt, and Conrad!!! read more

I always go in here when shopping around in Robison for a quick slice or 2. I love the convenience of a quick slice or 2 of pizza without ordering a whole pizza. It's always good size slices, good price and the service is quick and timely. They have quick bar seating along the walls and tables if you want to relax. Pizza is pretty average pizza, thin and good but big slices. The convenience, quality customer service, and and food always makes me appreciate how it is. Not enough places sell pizza by the slice. read more

The hoagies were burnt to a crisp, we could barely bite into them. Which is disappointing since the flavor was delicious.

The pizza was awesome. perfect amount of cheese, sauce and toppings, and the sauce didn't over power the taste of the pie. thin crust was great for folding read more

The BEST NY STYLE--thin, large, tasty! It gets pretty busy on Fridays, so order ahead if you can. The last time I ordered to go, I ate a slice in the car before I pulled away, and another slice at the red light at the top of the hill! Yes, it's that good, I couldn't wait the 25-minute drive home. read more

Just picked up 2 pizzas. Great taste. They do an excellent job. It was busy so I had to wait a bit but that's a good sign the pizza is good.

I had a coupon for Buy a large, get a 12" free. Unfortunately, a plain large was $20 with tax! The small pizza was burned on the bottom and the crust tasted like crackers. The large crust was a bit better but there was hardly any cheese on it. Will not order again. I will go to Garden of Eating where you get two pizzas for $25 and twice as much crust and cheese and it tastes much better. read more

My first time there....very clean....great employees..very friendly....awesome pizza...especially the crust. Will definitely go back!

This experience started out with my husband calling at 630pm to make sure you could "dine in". We were on our way to the airport and wanted to grab pizza on the way. The girl that answered the phone said "yes, but we close at 8." We thought this was a little odd since that was 90 min away and we were going to be there in a few minutes. We arrived to an empty restaurant a few min before 7. When we asked to order and dine in the girl ( I am assuming this is the same girl from the phone) says "yes but we close at 8" . Ok, we got it! We won't keep you! We proceeded to order a pizza and a salad. Our food took 35 min to come out and the pizza was burnt. Now we are familiar with Slice of Broadway ( used to get it at Prates games all the time) and we're looking forward to it. I can handle a little dark crust but the majority was inedible. I picked at what I could. The whole time we were eating she was pushing and stacking chairs behind us very loudly and then was mopping right next to us. When we got up to leave she tells us "the garbage is up front for you to take care of your trash". I am familiar with and have no problem with the establishments that have you take care of your own dishes but that was just the icing on top of a horrible experience. I only wished we had waited to tip until we were done but of course we had added it when we ordered and paid. Our mistake! read more