Slice on Broadway in East Liberty is the BEST!! Just got a large Supremo Friday night and it was AWESOME!! Huge shoutout to Hannah, Wesley, Mike P, Cody P and the rest of the crew!! Thank yinz for the best pizza ever and for treating me so well!! Love yinz and I will be seeing you again soon!! XOXO Miss Tania read more

A seriously solid slice! This has been on my list to visit and we came out on a nice evening for a slice or two. First impression, no flop. This isn't a soggy slice and the cheese falls off; the crust is crispy and the edges has some pull to them. I like the crisp to the pizza; every bite was nice and crispy but not overdone. On a 1-10 scale, just under an 8. The interior is nothing special but the prices are fair and it was comfortable. I will come again. read more

Slice on Broadway - Pepperoni Roll and Pepperoni Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania

One of the stops on the Best Bites of East Liberty where we enjoyed a slice of pizza. It was so good we are planning to go back this weekend and get a pizza to enjoy during the Steelers game. Staff was friendly & helpful. They were ready for the crowd and had the slices ready to distribute, There's some seating inside, but seems like mostly a take out sort of place. Loved the pizza! read more

Slice on Broadway - Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania

See all

They refused to give me a smaller box to fit the pizza in my bag. Cook was on her phone during food prep. Didn't wash her hands. read more

See all

Such incredible pizza. I love it here. The employees are amazing and to have a great slice or whole pizza is worthy of entering the door. HeHe Enjoy the Pizza and order some of the knots for your side. read more

Slice on Broadway - Love their pizza. By the slice or the whole pie. So delicious here. - Pizza Near Me - Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania

We ordered a cheese pizza, which won an award we heard. It was ok not special. We do not go to this place again.

December 2025 When they're on, they're great. I mean completely awesome. We've been customers since this location opened. Kitchen relentlessly inconsistent, alas. I love this pie so much AND we have had so many complete disasters sent to us from this store. Overcooked. Undercooked. Psychotically messed up orders. I haven't had the courage to order in the last year after having to apologize to my family again and again for utter fails. I can not recommend this store, to my utter dismay. read more

This is nice thin crispy crust classic pizza Nothing bad to say about the place The night we were there it was close to closing so we could tell they didn't really want us to sit We took our slices and ate on a public bench on centre It's a good slice read more

Time and time again proves to be a consistently delicious pie! Their Tuesday $12.99 large cheese pizza is unbeatable and delicious right out of the oven! The line will probably be long during popular meal times but highly recommend. read more

Slice on Broadway - Pizza Near Me - Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania

2/14/25 Ate List: Slice of Cheese - 6.4 Slice of Pepperoni - 6.7 A local pizza chain clearly in a "NY pizza spot cosplay." The slices would not measure up to those truly from NYC. However, as an affordable spot and one that actually serves slices, not just full pies, it's not the worst option. In a pinch, this is a good option for bang for your buck and I think is cheaper and better than some of the other "fast food" options locally. read more

Slice on Broadway - Slice of Cheese and slice of Pepperoni. - Pizza Near Me - Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania

Partner got a meatball sub. Smelled like it had been sitting in the freezer for days, and had a bone in it. I got a chicken parm sub. Sauce was delicious. Chicken had an ultraprocessed, McDonalds-chicken-nuggets-like texture (ie, like biting into sponge -- NOT fresh, unprocessed chicken) Never going back. read more

Fast great service. $4 a slice. Good vibe. Will come again. Great thin slice pizza. Plenty of seating. read more

See all

The food needs a lot of improvement and less making up stories. My stomach was feeling queasy and I read somewhere "slice on Broadway #1 cheese pizza" so I thought I'd give it a try. Bad decision. I have no idea what kind of cheese they used but it was tasteless. And the crust? Horrible! Also flavorless and hard. Couldn't even chew the end crust it was hard and unappetizing. Even my favorite steak& onion rolls were very dry and to make matters worse I asked for 3 red sauces and they sold (at $2.45) me all ranch which I cant stand! Goodbye Slice On Broadway!! read more

Slice on Broadway - Pizza Near Me - Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania

Food is good, customer service needs help. The young lady who rung us up needs to be more engaged with the customer, respond when spoken too. read more

How in the world does this place ONLY have a 3 1/2 / 5 ? This place was, by far, one of the TOP PIZZA places I have ever had (1) & in Pittsburgh (2). Outside of Mineo's, this was one place I felt so happy to eat at !!!! My sister ordered us the margherita. The slice portions were VERY generous, and the fresh basil alongside mozzarella cheese was the RIGHT combo. I will be back and hope you all give this place a raving review. Definitely underrated! read more

See all

Friendly chefs the moment you walk in the door. Authentic by the slice, brick pizza oven experience. It's all a touch pricey, but great value for what you're getting. This food is diabolically good. The pizza by itself is probably the best slice you'll have in Pittsburgh. Only rivaled by Pizza Parma in terms of thin crust slices. At Slice on Broadway they also offer a seasoning that I look forward to using every time I go. Their garlic knots are a great texture and don't give your mouth the "too much garlic" sting. If you have a couple extra bucks to shill out or a special occasion coming around, get something from these folks cause it tastes awesome. (Also it tastes like Pizza My Heart for my California friends) read more

I've had 3 bad experiences with Slice. There won't be another. Ordered a pizza to pick up, was told 30-35 minutes. Arrived 45 minutes later, it wasn't yet in the oven. Told another 30-35 minutes. This follows 2 prior bad experiences. No more Slices for me. read more

This is the best pizza in Pittsburgh and the employees were very caring and sweet! I recommend everyone to try it

As a New Yorker this is my favorite pizza in Pittsburgh. They also have solid pepperoni rolls and garlic knots. Service is solid and have diner in before. Ambiance is good for a pizza joint. read more

Ordered delivery from Slice on Broadway recently for an intern party at work. I was quoted an hour for 3 pies -- two cheeses and a pepperoni -- and they were at my door in 30 minutes flat during lunch rush. Excellent service. The pizzas themselves were a hit with everyone in the office, as well as my boss who grew up in NYC. Good flavor, and good crisp, chewy crust. If you're looking for a good New York style pizza in Pittsburgh, Slice on Broadway is a great option for a treat yourself night at home or a larger party or work function. read more

I swear by this place. They have some of the best pizza in Pittsburgh. Be prepared because I've never been there and they weren't busy. They are still pretty quick to get you in and out. The place is small with old style pizzaria vibes but I don't think I'd mind dinning in even though I just never have read more

Very average experience ordering from here. They are best known for their NY style, thin crust pizza. But, they also sell other things, like pepperoni rolls, calzones, and desserts such as cheesecake. The cheesecake is from Junior's in NY, I believe. I ordered the classic, plain cheese calzone. It was decent, nothing special really. The size was fine but I've had better deals. I would have liked it to be baked a little longer for the crisp. Not too doughy though. They use an adequate amount of cheese. It's mostly mozzarella, very little ricotta. The inside is a bit greasier than at most place. No sauce on the inside to keep it from being soggy. The little tomato sauce container served on the side was pretty tasty but cold. All in all, solid option for a calzone but just not impressive in any way. I think their pizza might be better than the calzone. May come back to give that a try. read more

Slice on Broadway - Inside cheese calzone - Pizza Near Me - Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania

See all

A very nice NYC style pie!! Just the way I like my pizza to be. Definitely is a place I recommend!

I was in the area and had an hour I had to kill and was hungry. Stopped at Slices on Broadway and had 2 slices of pepperoni pizza to go. I ate in my car as there where people sitting not wearing masks ???? the pizza was ok nothing special at all. The pizza had a ok taste. The crust was a little thick and did not have any taste at all. Chances are I would not go back. read more

Slice on Broadway - Pizza Near Me - Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania

See all

There was something missing from this pizza. It was surprisingly bland overall. The crust was good and cooked well. Pizza needs more flavor overall. read more

The food here is tasty. Pizza slices are large! The biggest hurdle is finding convenient parking. I love pizza shops that sell slices. I will be returning. read more

When I tell you that you've never had pizza like this, you've never had pizza like this. They even gave me you ranch. I told my bf, "they know how to do pizza" when they asked if I wanted ranch. The tables aren't exceptionally clean, and they could do with an actual soda machine, but they don't call this place "the cleanest on place on Broadway" or "the best soda on Broadway". You come for the pizza because the pizza is advertised. And honestly. I would come back again. read more

Slice on Broadway - a slice of pizza on a plate - Pizza Near Me - Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania

Unbelievable pizza. Been wanting to try it for years. Great job. Cooked to perfection. read more

Slice on Broadway - Pepperoni Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania

I'm such a big fan of thin crust pizza so I was really excited about this place. I like when my pizza is a little charred at the bottom and crispy. I really enjoyed it for these reasons. read more

I haven't been to the one in Carnegie in a long time, but that is where I first got hooked on the green monster. This is the only thing that I order from them and for good reason. It has just the right vegetables on it and all around flavor combinations. The pesto, the spinach, the artichokes, roaster red peppers(oh come on now!), lastly but certainly not least the ricotta that melts in your mouth and brings it to the next level. I went in there and got a small and the small is not small for one person. It is a ton of pizza really and especially with all of the ingredients. Anyways, this monster is to die for. As I told the pizza maker, I can't understand why anyone would want anything other than the green monster! Ha! read more

This place used to have great pizza when it first opened. The pizza we most recently ordered on from DoorDash was completely undercooked. The dough looked almost raw and the cheese had no brown on it at all. The crust was mushy and floppy. Completely inedible. This is not New York style pizza. Then when I asked them to remake a new one for me and I would pick it up, they hadn't even made it yet and we had given them 30+ min to prepare. The excuse when I got there was something to do with flour made the crust white (and somehow the cheese not brown?) and they couldn't put a new one in for me because there were too many orders in front of me. Well, actually I was in front of all those orders and if it was made correctly the first time, I wouldn't need it to be remade. It takes a lot for me to complain but honestly this pizza is expensive so it should be high quality. read more

Slice on Broadway - Pizza Near Me - Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania

I like this location because the workers are always super friendly and the pizza is spot on just as you would get it at the original location. There are a few places in the city that do a decent NYC style slice and this pizza shop is one of them. Like anything it's never going to be the real thing but hey glad to have this version. Toppings are fresh and pizza is always cooked to perfection. read more

See all

Slice is a great pizza place to stop and get a slice or a whole pie. The pizza is always fresh and cooked just right

We always, always order from Slice on Broadway when hosting work events at our office around the corner. We always get great service and everyone is more than happy with the quality of the food provided. The white pizza is much loved by all and often requested, so we now ensure that it is ordered each and every time. If you're interested in a salad, don't skip on ordering one because they are also very, very good with some seriously tasty oil and vinegar house dressing. Many pizza places toss some cheap lettuce and sparse toppings into a container and call it a salad, but Slice on Broadway makes a fabulous salad with deep green lettuce, sliced red onions, cheese, and marinated red pepper slices. Many times we are placing large orders (8 pizzas and 4 salads) and are able to pick-up our food within the hour after ordering around 11 AM. We love this spot and it will continue to be our go-to for office-sponsored lunch. read more

First off the pizza is delicious, I absolutely love pizza thin, large New York style pizza & this is as close as you can get without a quick six hour drive to the nyc. We got a slice of cheese and pepperoni and both were delicious. The star off is because of the staff. I needed to use the restroom when we got there but they had just mopped and the staff said I couldn't go back there because it was wet. I said, okay I can wait till it dries and just hold it till I eat my pizza I guess. The floor dries and I again try and go back there but they say it's too close to closing and the bathroom is closed?? Ended up going next door & getting a drink at Kelly's (10/10 recommend) so I could use the restroom. read more

This is the ONLY place we order our pizza from. If you like a thin crust pizza, Slice has the BEST crust!!! We love their margherita pizza. It's a football game day staple in our house. read more

This makes me sad to write because they make a really solid NYC style pie, but they constantly get orders wrong. And if you read enough reviews (even on apps other than this one) you'll see this appears to be a persistent issue at this location. We've gotten everything from a no topping pie covered in olives, pie with no red sauce covered in red sauce, paid to add sausage no sausage. It's maddening. We've ordered from there about twice a month for a long time, but after yet another incorrect order - with clear and simple instructions printed on the ticket stuck to the box but blatantly ignored, I am DONE. Create you own? Pfft! More like, "you'll get whatever we decide to give ya." We'll miss chatting with the Friday night delivery guy - he's a sweetheart. It's a shame this otherwise decent pizza place can't get it together and start, like, reading (it really is fundamental!). read more

SLICE is the best spot for Pizza in town!!!! Jeff is the manager and always gives great service and welcomes everyone in with a smile. Good lunch spot too or take out read more

Decent slice. Got plain cheese and a Greek slice. Put them all in one box and made a mess of them.

slice of pizza was blah, the spinach rolls looked like they were cooked last week so yes they looked really old and tasted old.stop making so much food and leaving it to sell for the next day. read more