Slice of 48 is where us locals go for pizza! The Pizza is excellent! And the new owner actually lowered the prices on the Pies. Which is great because every Pizzeria On Northfork is horribly over priced and for no reason! Slice of 48 has great Tasting Dinners and the people working there are always extremely friendly. Definitely makes you want to come back again! I just wish they were closer to me. I live In Cutchogue. But it's well worth the trip. read more

This is our go-to delivery service after a day of wine tasting in the North Fork. Huge pies, easy and on time delivery, tons of topping choices. Yummy! read more

Nope... This is NY after all, your pizza hast to be-on-point. while the flavors were good, the crust was garbage. it was like biting into a slice of bread. Pizza crust should thin-ish and slightly crispy. not be like biting into a pastry or a slice of wet bread... and no, i did not get a sicilian. which is supposed to be thick-ish. read more

Ordered a cheese pie for delivery and it was more affordable than the other nearby options. From placing the order to the delivery driver the staff was very friendly. Plus the pie was delicious! Added a picture of the box because it's a nice touch! read more

Slice of 48 - Branded box - Pizza Near Me - Southold, New York

See all

Now that is NY pizza . Got off the ferry from New London and headed directly here . I believe it was the owner how waited on us and it it was great to get a dose of the LI /NY accent . I have pretty much given up eating pizza, I can't take the disappointment. There are things I eat that resemble pizza but this is the really thing . Thin crust , real cheese perfect ratio of sauce and cheese ... we had to order 2 extra slices after we ate the first one . They did have a thicker crust pizza that looked good but we were here for the thin crust. Wanted to atop on my way back to the ferry but has not left enough time .. we will have to make this a regular stop . Wish it was closer . read more

Slice of 48 - Outside - Pizza Near Me - Southold, New York

See all

We were here on vacation and wanted some pizza and this place was close to our rental so we decided to order pizza for takeout. We ordered the thin crust House Specialty. It was DELICIOUS! Enough to feed an army too! It was $27, packed with meats & veggies and we each had 3 slices and had enough left over for another meal. I wish I had taken a picture before we ravaged it. I highly recommend! read more

The Veal Francese was lemon forward which I liked, but the butter sauce was a bit watery and lacked in substance. Small portions. Pasta is definitely your everyday store bought variety. Their pizza is OK, not great. I've had most dishes at this place and you can bet your bottom dollar nothing here will blow your socks off. Just your everyday no frills pizzeria. 3 stars about does it. read more

Slice of 48 - Veal Francese - Pizza Near Me - Southold, New York

This place was great as we needed to order something to pick up prior to going on the ferry. Another place would had taken over an hour to pick up, so we tried this place since it was within a 20 minute wait. We placed the order and went in a little earlier and our pie was ready! It was delicious! There also a small seating area if you want to sit down. We will certainly come back here! read more

See all

Joe makes everything good and fresh . Very nice people friendly and warm . Fare pricing and a clean establishment . I would recommand this pizzeria to all read more

Slice of 48 - Pizza Near Me - Southold, New York

See all

I would give the new owners zero stars if I could. The food is awful now and they said they delivered my desserts which they didn't. The delivery driver fought with me about it and then thought he hung up the phone and didn't and said" she looked like a crackhead". I called back and spoke to a manager and he said he would refund the huge tip that I left and he didn't. He sent me a gift certificate for the amount of the tip! Which is useless to me since I wouldn't give them my business if they were the last restaurant standing. And by the way. I just got out of the hospital and answered the door in pajamas. I don't think that warrants him saying I'm a crackhead. And the food was terrible. Nothing like the original Paganos that I ordered from all of the time. Stay away! Rude and the food is terrible. read more

Probably the best Pizza on the North Fork. Anytime we are out east in Southold on a Friday night, we make a point of ordering from Pagano's. Besides having a delicious Grandma Pie with chunks of tomato, fresh basil and mozzarella, their specialty slices are ON POINT. The Buffalo Chicken slice is loaded with shredded chicken soaked in hot sauce on a sesame seed crust. Others in our family love the Chicken Bacon Ranch slice which also is loaded with toppings and makes you crave more. The staff is friendly, but try and be there when the "A" squad is in. (We went recently when the normal pizza maker was on vacation and had to wait much longer than usual.) I cannot speak for anything beyond the pizza, as we usually cook other Italian food at home. As for prices, I would not say it is cheap, but what is cheap out on the East End? You get what you pay for, and I think Pagano's is a good value for their pizza! read more

Solid pizza by the slice (or whole pies) to go. There is limited seating but you wouldn't come for the ambience. It's your standard New York pizza but they also carry one Sicilian pizza (cheese). The Sicilian pizza is substantial and managed to be both light and crispy around the edges - one of the better Sicilian pizzas I've had recently. Service is friendly. The TV is generally tuned to sports to bide the team while you eat your pizza. read more

I never leave reviews but had checked some of the reviews before ordering and maybe more negative reviews are added than positive....so I just had to give a 5+ review to the pizza we ordered tonight. Thin crust pepperoni and meatball with extra cheese. Sooooo good. I should have stopped at one slice because I was full but then took another half slice and then another. Both my husband and I give it a 5 star. We'll be back! read more

Great take out with delivery! Try the Sicilian Pizza and calzone. Salads are great value.

Food has been consistently getting better. They have some nice sub specials...chicken cutlet was delicious. I'll try again in a few months.

I ordered tomatoes and mozzarella as an appetizer and instead of getting fresh big pieces of mozzarella, which you would normally think of, I got store bought slices on top of my tomatoes. Like from the deli. Purely gross and a waste of my money. read more

Ordered a pizza from them through Door Dash. The pizza must have been sitting around for quite a while. It arrived cold. The pizza was terrible! Thin crust (paper thin), not enough sauce, not enough cheese, full of air bubbles. The worst pizza I've ever had! And, overpriced. Will never ordered from them again. What a disappointment. This is not NY pizza. We each had one slice because we were hungry and the rest went into the trash. read more

Great find. Nice, accommodating, and delicious pizza. Hit the spot! I always feel like when you're traveling, you never know how it's going to work out. This was a little gem. The pizza was really tasty even though I ordered just a simple plain. But it really did what it was supposed to. And he did it with great service and great food! read more

Bad over priced pizza. Spent $96 on 3 pies and a salad. Threw all the leftovers in the garbage.

It's a small strip mall pizza shop next to other small take outs but don't let that scare you off. Best pizza in Southold. Not artisan and unique like 1943 pizza in Greenport, but great in its own way. read more

Great pizza, chicken rolls (try a chicken cutlet parm roll, so good). Delicious sauce, pizza never oily. Freshly made cannolis - I call ahead on my way home from work & it's always ready on time. They have an extensive dinner menu & specials that I'll be trying , check them out - never disappointed read more

We ordered pick up pizza with pepperoni and mushroom which was terrible. The mushrooms were old and dry and the crust was tough. We each had 1 piece and threw the whole rest in garbage. Also ordered chicken parm sandwich which I thought was good but husband thought chicken was not fresh tasting. This was our go to spot for years but since Jr. Is gone it's not the same read more

Absolutely the best pizza I have ever had!!! And I've had a lot! Beats everything in Huntington, San Diego, and Berkeley. A nice little bit of herbs in the sauce. Thinner crust than normal pizzas but the thinnest. Can't wait to come back and have it again! read more

We had a 100$ order yesterday, tried to order tonight and their credit card machine was down. My husband and I go in there at least twice a week, and we said we could leave our card number for when the machine works, the guy on the phone was so rude and said "I don't even know you" which is BS! I will never give them my business again. Such poor customer service!!! read more

Favorite pizza around! And they deliver. Its as good as it gets at Paganos. Try a calzone if you're eating alone, or get a sicilian pie to share with friends. The garlic knots are delicious. Friendly staff as well, fast delivery. highly recommend!!! read more

Went in just for a couple slices, there was only one other customer in the place, and the owner Joey was just simply rude about getting me 2 plain slices and a grandmas slice. He put the pizza in the oven and went to the back and i could clearly hear him bad mouthing the other customer and myself. When he came back to the front he reached under his pizza making counter and grabbed a beer then started drinking it in front of us. When i was rung up it was 10 dollars... Not a good way to run a business, rude, and over priced. read more

Pizza is salty, nothing special. We ordered a Sicilian pie and it was all sauce no cheese and salty. And the guy behind counter is rude.

Rude and obnoxious counter girl. Will never return. Shouldn't work in retail if you are unpleasant and nasty. Called and placed an order for two dinners and a salad and was told 35 minutes. We couldn't wait 35 minutes so we said no thank you. She hung up. We stopped in just to get the salad to go and she said 20 minutes and we said we couldn't wait. She said you just called why did you come in? I said I didn't think a salad would take 20 minutes but that it was fine. She said why would you think it would be different and I said because I eliminated all the cooked food. read more

Never been treated so rudely by waitstaff and owner in my life. Ordered 3 heros to go on way to ferry. After 20 minutes I asked how much longer it would be only to find out they hadn't even started making our order yet. When I asked just to get our money back because we didn't have that long to wait I was berated by the owner in front of the entire restaurant. He told me I should go to McDonalds if I wanted something quick and that I was being unreasonable for expecting our food to be ready in the timeframe they originally gave me when I placed the order. If you go here call in ahead of time or just get pizza slices that are already prepared. Otherwise you are in for a long wait for your food. read more

We have 4 pizzeria's in our hometown in NJ and none compare to Paganos. He's choice of pie toppings are amazing and the sesame crust pizza is like eating really good Italian bread. The entree's are fabulous as well and all reasonably priced. read more

I just stopped in for a slice. I got the chicken parmesan slice. It was very filling and tasted great. I had a bite of my boyfriend's grandma slice. It was even better than what I had picked. Nice place and great service. read more

Ordered a meatball calzone and it was rather expensive considering there were no meatballs in it only loads of ricotta cheese and little slivers of meatball slices that would cover a small slice of pizza. When I ask for a meatball calzone, I expect meatballs in it. I can't return to a place that rips off people. I had to toss it. I couldn't even taste any meatball at all. read more

Best pizza place on Long Island. Beats michaelangelos in southold by a long shot. The location isn't as good as michaelangelos, but the pizza is better. The owner is hard working, and always friendly. read more

Best pizza and service. My husband ordered takeout and left part of the order on the roof of the car. Well needless to say it didn't make it home. When he went back not only did they remake our lost order from scratch, they felt so bad for us that they comped the food! Thank you Paganos. Truly exemplary service and delicious food!! read more

I'm a regular since the food is good, prices are reasonable, and portions are more than I can eat in one meal. I recommend the baked ziti or the chicken parm hero. read more