Really cool pizza spot tucked away off the main strip in Greenport. Its warm and inviting atmosphere with the brick oven is probably the best pizza spot in town! I would've loved to stay for dine-in but had to bring lunch back to our Airbnb. The pizza only took a few minutes to cook. And it was up there in delicious-ness with some of the best NYC pizza! Perfectly thin, crispy crust without being dry, overcooked or burnt. The cheese and sauce had perfect balance of salt and tang, and not dry, not too greasy either. Toppings were fresh and just the right amount of toppings so it wasn't too heavy and not stingy either. read more

1943 Pizza Bar - Pizza Near Me - Greenport, New York

See all

Pizzas are made fresh to order and was so delicious. Pizzas cook quick inside the huge oven! Nice, thin pies, and they are made as a personal size pizza (14"). The crust still had the perfect ratio of dough making it fluffy, thin, and not crunchy. The white pie with the truffled ricotta and roasted mushrooms is a must try if you love anything truffle. It was loaded with flavors of garlic, mushrooms and the perfect amount of truffle. I'm so glad I ordered this pie! This will definitely be a spot we will visit again in the summer time. Inside is small, but they have additional seating outside. read more

See all

I stopped by with my mom for lunch when I was in town visiting and absolutely loved everything about the food here! The service was great, seating was easy and wasn't too busy for a Saturday. We split the burrata and the red pie with mozzarella, ricotta, red onion, and meatballs and it was delectable. You really can't beat the pizza here! read more

See all

Food and service are great. Innovative salads and pizzas, great wait staff, etc. very accommodating and comfortable.

Our favorite pizza spot to visit when in Greenport. So thin and crispy with a delicious red sauce. Highly highly recommend! Also, not that many tables so usually have to go on a wait list but it goes quick. There are other restaurants and bars in that circle that you can walk around to as well! read more

The pizza is incredible as well as the fantastic service by James. The ingredients are so fresh, they also have wonderful salads, meatballs & homemade chipwich sandwiches! Not to be missed when in Greenport or make a trip just to eat the best pizza in NY! read more

We came in 20 min before closing, the pizza is amazing. We had the white pie. Service is friendly, courteous and attentive which I always appreciate. Locate in the back of the hotel. Outside us very pretty. Will definitely come back n try other things. read more

1943 Pizza Bar - Great pizza - Pizza Near Me - Greenport, New York

Best pizza in the north fork. Absolute must whole visiting. Love the seating and staff is always pleasant. Visit the downstairs bar for a pre-dinner drink. read more

I previously posted this review on Google and the owner responded, acting like a child. So, I'll post it here too. The two ten year olds working at the hostess station were incredibly rude. There were open tables for over an hour but we still waited for no reason. I am not even surprised that the owner responded in such a condescending manner, what a great way to run a business! Clearly they know exactly what they are doing. This is just the icing on the cake that you shouldn't come here. 0 accountability for their horribly run business. For the record, we waited 90 minutes and the open tables remained vacant the whole time. If it were 10 minutes, we wouldn't be here posting this. Shame on you. read more

1943 Pizza Bar - A salty business owner - Pizza Near Me - Greenport, New York

There is a lot of hype about 1943 and I waited till my second time visiting to write a review. I absolutely hate writing negative reviews, we put our name on an hour wait list at 7pm. We were finally seated after 9pm. It took 45 minutes to get 1 pie, salad and 4 meatballs. you only receive good service if you know someone here. 20 minutes after we were seated a party of 2 received all their food within 15 minutes of sitting down. Very disappointed as I drove 2 hours to come here. Will not be eating here again. Very overhyped and underwhelming. read more

1943 Pizza Bar - Pizza Near Me - Greenport, New York

Great pizza and food. Unfortunately, the staff is miserable and ruins the experience to an extent. Many rude and passive aggressive employees (hostesses, server) working face to face with the customers. Would be a great spot if they hired some new workers who didn't take their problems out on their customers. The service far undersells the product, coming from a North Fork local read more

Had this place bookmarked for years and finally got to visit on a cold, wet day. High expectations were met. Tried a red pie with mozzarella, and it was great. It didn't need anything added to it as the flavors stood on their own. If I try again, I'll get more adventurous with toppings. Other notes: the restaurant is small. On the day I was there, I counted 16 seats. Decent beer selection. Super friendly service (Delaney was my server, but everyone behind the counter was great, too). In peak season it looks like parking might be a challenge. read more

1943 Pizza Bar - Young child devours red pie with mozzarella - Pizza Near Me - Greenport, New York

Excellent, high quality, New Haven inspired bar pizza. Well worth the drive out East. The service was incredible. We made the trip out East just for this pizza. When our waiter heard, he told us drinks were on the house. The cocktails were great and the pizza equally as good. If you can, sit downstairs. It's dinky lit and a little more private if you go around lunch time. If made for a very cool experience. I can say with certainty that this is one of the best pizza spots on LI and a must stop at if you're in the area...or if you're a real pizza enthusiast, take the drive. read more

See all

The pizza was amazing as was the arugula salad. It was very heavy on the Parmesan though, a bit less would have been better. Staff was professional but not exceedingly friendly, which is why I gave it 4 stars not 5. Restaurant was clean as was the restroom. read more

Great place! Classic thin crust well made New York style pizza. The classic margarita was done very well, simple but perfectly balanced flavors. We got the white pizza + caramelized onions which added a nice touch of sweetness. The best of this place was the service - one of our parties had lost their voice and the server went out of their way to accommodate hot water and without asking brought honey and lemon on the side. What a nice touch! Really sweet of them The ambiance was great, it's tucked in this garden with numerous restaurants so it's lively and cozy environment. read more

1943 Pizza Bar - White pizza with caramelized onions - Pizza Near Me - Greenport, New York

The basic red pie is amazing! The garlic and basil was on point. Probably one of the best pizzas Ive had. I only did take out but would definitely get this again. Ambiance seems pretty nice sitting outside on the deck from what i could tell. Service was great too! read more

Pizza was really really good. Sat right away. Staff was friendly. Will definitely come back again when in the area

This is the hidden jewel in Greenport, amazing, thin crust, pizza hidden off the beaten path i, I can't believe I've never been here, I highly recommend this pizza and the restaurant. The service was impeccable ,super friendly, and the pizza is out of this world, I can't wait to go back, if you're heading to the North Fork, you must put this restaurant on your list of places to visit read more

See all

I absolutely love this pizza place THE BEST! The food is always fresh & super delicious! I ordered a margarita pizza and Caesar Salad I placed my order to go it came out fast and with a smile. I recommend this pizza place to pizza lovers. The salad is the best around! Definitely a great place to eat! Enjoy! read more

Wow! You are greeted by friendly staff, and the brick oven pizza is out of this world! The dining area is small, but weather permitting, there is outdoor seating available. If you have to wait, it is definitely worth it! Nonna's oven fired meatballs are to die for! Make sure you ask for extra bread to sop up the tasty sauce. There is a wide variety of specialty pizzas to choose from. You can even create your own. Don't forget to check out their Rolling In Dough pizza truck for your next event! It is worth every penny! Enjoy! read more

See all

The food here was delicious. We had to wait about 45 min for a table and it was worth the wait. We started with the burrata salad which I still have dreams about. It was slightly sweet to counterbalance the bitterness of the arugula and had fresh figs on top. The burrata was so creamy. We also got the clam bacon pizza which was amazing. It saved well for the next day too! read more

They used to have a pie on the menu called The New Haven. You can still make it yourself (white pie, mashed potatoes, garlic, and bacon). It's one of the best things I've ever eaten. Atmosphere, service and drinks are great too! read more

Many pizza styles to choose from, and they were delicious! We got a classic red, a margarita, and a red with goat cheese and meatballs. Also an arugula salad. Service was excellent, kind, and quick. We went in early May around 9pm and there was no wait for outdoor seating, and the atmosphere was so enjoyable and pretty in a tucked in square with neighboring restaurants/cocktail bars. Looking forward to coming back! read more

1943 Pizza Bar - Arugula salad - Pizza Near Me - Greenport, New York

See all

Update: Many months and many pizzas later (as illustrated by the embarrassing number of sexy pizza photos in my camera roll), 1943 Pizza Bar is still a favorite for dine-in and take-out. The pizza is NEVER not delicious. read more

See all

Very good pizza. Staff is very polite. I like the indoor/outdoor dining. Great selection of regular & gluten free pizza.

Finding great pizza - really great pizza - outside of an urban center like NYC or Chicago is very rare. There is a place in Connecticut that serves White Clam Pizza which is delish! However that is an anomaly. 1943 Pizza Bar in Greenport has decent pizza. Not great pizza but enjoyable. The crust is thin and usually nicely charred. The red sauce is mediocre at best. The rest of the toppings are ok to good. There are some typical Italian American appetizers and mains to choose from too The service is what you would expect from a suburban pizza parlor with local kids running the joint. Sometimes good sometimes awful. I usually order take out because the ambience is dominated by large families with lots of bratty kids. There is some outside dining which can be pleasant on a pleasant day... as long as the kids are still in school! The price of the pies is decent. You get what you pay for. read more

Fantastic pizza place, especially with the outdoor seating. Very impressive crew - they were assembling pies quickly, and they don't skimp on toppings! Definitely worth a try. Order early because they sometimes stop accepting takeout orders when they're busy. read more

See all

We just got in to Greenport for the weekend, and knew it'd be tough to find somewhere to eat. They were super busy, but the manager sat us down right away. It was delicious. We got the marinated olives, side of meatballs and a build your own pizza. Great food, great service. We have a weekend house right down the road, so glad that this spot is so close by. We will be back, many times over! read more

See all

Love this place! Great pizza, great salads, fun vibe, always a treat. Nice staff and good service. Never disappoints.

Delicious, the food was delicious (margarita pizza with pepperoni, hot peppers, caramelized onions and mushrooms along with an order of meatballs), the staff was welcoming and the service was perfect. Thank you *also I love that pizza oven. read more

1943 Pizza Bar - Margarita pizza with pepperoni, hot pepper, caramelized onions and mushrooms - Delicious - Pizza Near Me - Greenport, New York

The last pie we ordered was absolutely inedible The cheese tasted as rancid as the place looked read more

Very busy spot that deserves its reputation with chewy crust pizza with great toppings. Order early because the lineup for pick up can get pretty long and the kitchen gets backed up. read more

Wow 10/10. Stayed at American beach and ate at multiple different restaurants in Green port and this was by far my favorite! The pizza was perfect and crispy. I can here twice in one day read more

1943 Pizza Bar - Pizza Near Me - Greenport, New York

Absolutely disgraceful behavior with the staff Rude and completely unprofessional. This is not a Michelin star restaurant it's a pizza place. I don't know who they think they are but clearly the money boom in Greenport had gone to their heads and they have forgotten what it's like to be a real person dealing with real people. All I can say to the manager is get a grip and tell your staff to get a grip before the word spreads far enough that this place is run by jerks. read more

I had a pleasant experience with a meal served by a patient staff. The pizza was great but as they were packed on a Saturday night

1943 is the best pizza place on the North Fork. Actually it just might be the best pizza place on all of Long Island, North, South, East and West. Wood fire oven, crisp thin crust. Excellent fresh assortment of toppings to create your very own personal favorite pie! There are also a few options of appetizers: marinated olives, creamy Burratta cheese with roasted cherry tomatoes and arugula, Nonna's homemade wood fired meatballs (polpettes, not polpettinas). They serve a revolving selection of local micro brews, plus select local New York Long Island wines, along with French and Italian vino. Cheers! Definitely worth stopping by when visiting the lovely village of Greenport! read more

See all

The Quick: Build your own pizza heck yes! I love that you can make your pizza vegan/plant-based, vegetarian, or as meaty as possible. That way there's an option for everyone! We love this place they have great take out or dine in and the cutest little part of Greenport. Highly recommend especially during covet it's really reasonably priced and a great spot read more

See all

Been going here for years, truly a north fork stable. Pizza is light and crispy! With dozens of options to put on pizza! Even Clams! read more

1943 Pizza Bar - menu - Pizza Near Me - Greenport, New York

Loved this restaurant especially the hostess Bella, so kind. And the food was straight fire . The restaurant was very well decorated and reminded me of the beach. #would come back any day. read more

I went for lunch here for the first time ever, and I was pleasantly surprised! I'm from the NYC area and visiting Long Island for the weekend, so I was very happy to find great, thin crust pizza out here. The service was fast, my boyfriend and I being waited on and served our pizza in 15 minutes tops. Overall, we were there for less than 45 mins, and the staff was friendly. It's a cozy little restaurant and I definitely will return next time I can. read more

1943 Pizza Bar - Pizza Near Me - Greenport, New York

See all