Yesterday, I was in the area and I was starving. I ordered a chicken parm hero. It was $16.86. I felt that was tad too expensive. Five minutes later, my order was ready. It was so delicious. The only problem is that the hero was so ginormous that I was barely able to finish it- and I had heartburn afterwards (not the fault of the pizzeria). I hate wasting food. I highly recommend this pizzeria. And unless you're Joey Chestnut, I suggest sharing the hero with another person. read more

I made a medium sized catering order for a work event ( about $500). The food was ok. Wraps and pizzas and was ready on time. But man were the staff complete assholes about getting me my receipts. It was clear that after the business was done customer service went out the window. If you are just looking for any old slice, sure take a look (theres many comparable places tbh) but if youre looking for food and the minimum level of customer service try somewhere else. read more

Came here to get a slice of pizza before kicking off the afternoon and their hot honey pepperoni pizza was incredibly delicious! it had the perfect amount of hot honey drizzle and the crust had such a nice crunch! i also tried their chicken bacon ranch slice and it was good but i think im phasing out of liking that slice in general lately. my boyfriend got a pepperoni and buffalo chicken and really liked both! this is great place to stop at when you're looking for something quick! read more

See all

I stopped here after being forced to shop all day long with my friends without any food! The service was friendly and fast and the pizza was tasty! The chicken bacon ranch pizza was sooo good! The pepperoni and hot honey was simple and delicious as well. read more

Fierro's Pizza - Chicken Bacon Ranch Pizza Pepperoni & hot honey - Pizza Near Me - East Hampton, New York

Always fun to go in here. Staff is always friendly and the pizza never disappoints. One place you don't have to get dressed up to eat in East Hampton. It's a great place to just stop in for lunch and there's never a long wait for your food. read more

The best pizza in east hampton. Their dough is perfect. Bring some home and make pizza in your own oven it's very good. And the staff is very nice and accommodating. read more

This place is amazing- our go to in Montauk every year! Best pizza and great location. read more

Fierro's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - East Hampton, New York

Yummiest Buffalo chicken slice in town! Also it just so chill being in there it's not fancy but it feels homely Come here annually. It's also a good spot because their ample parking space but also get crazy during peak peak summer hours. Indoor dining only. Its such a friendly vibe. Food had always been great and staff and owner was always really chill to me and my husband. I think they recently change ownership have not been in since but certainly will be there again this summer. read more

The pizza was good but the service was terrible. We had our children with us and the owner told them they were being too loud. The children were simply being children. Not running around, being disruptive. Extremely unwelcoming environment and will not be back. read more

this pizza place is undeserving of your money. There are plenty of other KIND AND DELICIOUS pizzerias in the area. The staff is unhelpful and unkind especially if you're POC, 0/10 neither the food or the service is worth your time. read more

Fierro's Pizza - They also feel it's wise to threaten customers, beware !! - Pizza Near Me - East Hampton, New York

how do you make a Margherita pie without any sauce definitely should explain that to people really nice staff but truly disappoint in the pizza read more

Fierro's Pizza - Margherita Pizza lol - Pizza Near Me - East Hampton, New York

This is the best pizza ! Melts in your mouth. The dough is sweet and the sauce is delicious with the perfect amount of cheese. The guys who work there are friendly and sweet. read more

I spent two weeks in Eat Hampton and this was my go to spot . Great pizza , great friendly staff. I highly recommend this place

The food is good. Honest and well prepared. The people behind the counter are friendly helpful and care.

Very friendly atmosphere. Good prices and excellent food. Nice selection of Italian foods to try.

Classic NY pizza from my childhood. Doesn't get any better than this. I like the thin crust and my sister likes the Sicilian. They have been around for years and I know why! read more

Sicilian Pizza is on the dry side. Unevenly cooked and needs a little bit more sauce.

I recently ordered a 10 pizzas and a number of trays of food for a very special family party- everything was delicious! The owner, John Fierro, was a pleasure to work with, and he went out of his way to assure everything would be ready on time, and to our specifications. It was! Thank you Fierro's!! Roe K. read more

Pizza is good and service is fast and staff friendly. I haven't eaten anything else but the pizza. A bit crowded and loud.

Best pizza I've had on all of Long Island. Reminds me of Brooklyn. Staff is always so friendly. Pizza comes out fresh and perfect every time. read more

opened in montauk and tried. in former blade salt pizza place location. sad replacement. amazing location. food. just really bad. gave my food to my dogs who appreciated/enjoyed. won't last. read more

Fierro's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - East Hampton, New York

Best pizza ever in my experience. Absolutely good, delicious, amazing, and there service was okay but the food.. chefs kiss. Fierros is good and amazing! Hoping to go back anytime. read more

The aroma of the food fills the town with sweetness, it's conveniently in town and they're so friendly and they Eve have my all time favorite- root beer-- but the pizza is alright. read more

Great pizza and very friendly service!! Definitely worth stopping in for a slice!! I plan on going back soon.

I love this place. The pizza is good so are the garlic knots. The service is fast and the staff is friendly. So happy they are right in town. My kids also love it here we have been coming for years. read more

I live in East Hampton for 18 years, I have been in other good pizzeria, but nothing like this. The pizza is soooo good and the place it's great to seed down, I love it. Will be there later today again! read more

We ordered this weekend chicken Parm eggplant Parm meatball Parm dinners and some pinwheels and we brought it home and had a great meal totally recommend read more

Very rude staff. I asked for blue cheese and the owner made fun of my accent and laughed in my face read more

The pizzas are too salty and make you thirsty. Horrible service and the tall guy is outright RUDE!

This place has really gone down hill. You can tell by even looking at the slices.... What weird triangular proportions.

Great pizza spot, great service everyone behind the counter is super nice and the pizza is super fresh and super good. Couldn't be more impressed with the pizza probably the best out east read more

It is one of the few old school businesses left in East Hampton and we all love it. They welcome little league, kids after school, and are open year round. Very clean with local photos and art for sale. Stay just the way you are. read more

This place is fabulous! If you're looking for the best New York slice in the Hamptons, look no further. The pizza here is really well done and there are always a number of varieties, from traditional pepperoni to buffalo chicken, which is out of this world! They sell other stuff as well, but why would you bother? Get the pizza! Everyone who works there is really friendly and they know all the regulars by name. They are open year round as well, so no matter what time of year you're in the Hamptons, you're in luck. Make a point to stop in! read more

Best place to grab pizza in the Hamptons! Its located on the entrance road into the town lot from Race Lane, across from the Waldbaums. Be SURE to check parking regulations, as you WILL get a ticket if you go over the time limit in the lot or on the street. The food has always been terrific. I primarily order the pizza, the buffalo chicken and BBQ chicken being my favorites. The sandwiches are also terrific. The owner John is a super nice man and a true gentleman. When I need a quick meal, this is one of my favorite places in East Hampton. They have a TV for those who like to watch sports while eating. read more

See all

The positives are good location and ample seating. From there it goes down hill. The pizza is pretty poor. Taste not special and crust nothing special. The biggest problem is that they put on very little cheese. I have tried it twice with the same result. What a missed opportunity. read more

Fierro's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - East Hampton, New York

I had a Sicilian slice which was served lukewarm. The fact that it wasn't hot makes it harder to judge the quality since there's a possibility that it could've been good if it was served hot put it probably wouldn't have been good even if it was hot. read more

We came here after a terrible visit to Rowdy Hall. The staff at fierro's was nice to us and chatted for a bit and the pizza was hot and tasted good--we got pepperoni, white, pesto, and buffalo chicken. The buffalo chicken slice was the favorite. It's a little expensive (16-17 for the four slices i think) but we were visiting from out of town and were expecting to pay more because it's the Hamptons and there aren't a lot of other open restaurants in the winter. read more

The baked ziti pizza is the best I've ever had. My family loves this place and they always have tons of choices so everyone finds exactly what they are hungry for. Can't beat the prices and the customer service is amazing. Will always make this a place a priority to eat at every time we are in town. read more

Amazing gluten free pizza! Sicilian was perfection as well. Been coming here for years, will keep coming back! read more

Fierro's Pizza - a pizza on a pan - Pizza Near Me - East Hampton, New York

See all

Best pizza in the Hamptons, hands down. Fast service always and consistent. Here on a weekly basis and it's always enjoyable.