Here I am again giving it another chance. Ordered a cheese slice and it was just meh. No sauce just a hint of red food coloring that gives the appearance of sauce topped with cheese. Again, had to add a ton of chili, oregano and garlic. read more

American Pie Pizzeria - Cheese slice - Pizza Near Me - Bridgehampton, New York

Best pizza in town, or out! The owner of very pleasant, same owner as American Pie in Bridgehampton. Give them a shot!

Best Pizza in the Hamptons by far you want thin and crispy NY pizza this is the spot not thick and soggy like the Rest once your out east . Pie is always Good forget the negative reviews read more

The panini is amazing !!! Fresh mozzarella made there , bread made there , chicken organic no antibiotics , it is also huge !! Can feed two men easy , women four in wedges !! Tommy was awesome thanks Tommy !! the food was delicious read more

gets order wrong many times, i ordered a chicken cali and it was missing the chicken this is only the 4th time they messed up my order food is still pretty decent read more

The pizza here is extremely sub par and does not at all taste like NY pizza. It also ALWAYS comes completely burnt to BLACK on the bottom which tastes awful! The cheese does not want to stay on the pizza either which makes the experience of eating it even more dreadful. Also, anything garlic (aka garlic knots/bread.. etc) has FAR too much garlic on it to be enjoyable and they only have about 1/3 of the desserts they advertise on their online menu. The only good thing I can say is fast delivery and nice delivery people. Therefore, if I were looking for GOOD pizza I'd go to either Shelter Island pizza which is still not like NY pizza but better or to the city for some REAL NY pizza. Shout out to Michael and Sons in Queens it's the best!! read more

American Pie Pizzeria - Completely BURNT pepperoni pizza! It makes it so bitter! - Pizza Near Me - Bridgehampton, New York

Called ahead order was 2x the time estimated. I ordered a calzone with pepperoni and rather than make a fresh one they cut open a pre-cooked one and shoved a ton of pepperoni inside. Paid for 3 garlic knots but only got two. Food was otherwise acceptable. read more

American Pie Pizzeria - Ordered a Calzone with pepperoni. They didn't make a fresh one. They just cut open a pre cooked one and added pepperoni. - Pizza Near Me - Bridgehampton, New York

One of the best pizza places in the Hamptons and the best pizza slice by far. The food is great (their chicken parm slice is great) and the owner is extremely kind and the service is great! Will definitely be back!!! 10/10 read more

One of the benefits of this pandemic is that it's socially acceptable to scarf down pizza in your car to avoid other humans. The sausage and peppers slice is crispy and delicious. The plain Sicilian slice is doughy and cheesy. This is a solid pizza place. The staff are very sweet and fun, which a lot of places don't manage to do right now. The only drawback is that I've been eating healthier and two slices was way too much for me right now. So--bonus!--this meal wound up being two for the price of one. read more

I'm forever disappointed in this pizzeria. Sauce is bland and acidic, zero crisp to the center crust, hockey puck burned edges of the crust from poor cleaning. It's an over expensive Ellios frozen pizza. Utter trash. read more

Yuck! do not eat specialty slices here. food is wrapped up and put away for tomorrow after sitting on the counter all day. Place looks clean but food handling procedures should be revamped. Cheapskates are trying to save money by serving old food day after day. Come on it's a half a dozen slices. Throw that garbage out. That was gross and Will not return. read more

Was passing by and stopped in to check out their garlic knots and pizza fare. The service was friendly, and efficient. Tale of the tape: Garlic Knots These are on the large side, big enough to make a slider from if you are of the mind to do so . . . Unfortunately, the garlic flavor is light at best. The dough texture is medium, slightly chewy but not to distraction. Meatball Lasagna Slice Thinly sliced meatball and meatball crumbles with dollops of ricotta with mozzerella cheese and a savory marinara sauce. It would have been better with a bit more meatball, but what really stood out was the savory sauce - very good! The crust is very unique - it was an interesting cross between a crispy cracker and a slightly chewy dough in texture. Despite the slight lack of meat, it was nonetheless enjoyable. read more

American Pie Pizzeria - Meatball Lasagna slice - enjoyable, a meal in itself! - Pizza Near Me - Bridgehampton, New York

My favorite spot to eat. Reasonable prices and staff is friendly even if the wait time is a bit long. Pizza is delicious and so is all of their food. I love the fresh salads and garlic knots and soups! They have a few tables that you can sit and eat and it's cozy. read more

Overpriced entrees from counter service, and still (like all the Hamptons) there seems to be the tiresome expectation of a tip (with suggestion of 20%) paid before you even see food or service. You get your own napkins, plastic cutlery, and if your data plan works you can see an online menu with prices before you order. But if not, counter staff will give you a low ballpark estimate when you order of what an entree costs. Usually the entrees have been pretty decent here in the past, and servings generous-- taking some of the sting out of their pricing. Tonight, no. Smaller plate of veggies of uneven temperature from nominally warm to still cold from the fridge. So the "mixed" vegetables are mixed by temperature as well, apparently. The chicken Marsala, however, was good. Too bad they don't have the service comportment follow through to match the quality of the Marsala. They quickly set all problems right--but why are they not set up to anticipate actually pretty modest customer expectations. Like many simpler eatery restaurants in Hamptons, the expectation is normal to pay a lot for simple dishes, but the service is often at best perfunctory. I never get the feeling, of "thank you for choosing us." You might as well pay a little more find a place to properly dine. read more

I have been gluten free for over 2 decades. My "white GF pizza" was delicious!!! My son loved his veggie pizza and the garlic knots! Thank you for making pizza night a huge success!! read more

great food, amazing service really kind and quick service. i had there barbecue chicken pizza and chicken bacon ranch Stromboli. both were great the barbecue chicken was sweat and savory the Stromboli also amazing soft cheese gooey and their ranch is so flavorful 100% recommend read more

American Pie Pizzeria - some left overs lol - Pizza Near Me - Bridgehampton, New York

Quick and easy spot for more than just pizza in the bridge. Not the best but definitely a go to when hungry.

American Pie is my go to spot for delivery in the Hamptons. I've tried their pizzas, pasta dishes and salads and I l've yet to be disappointed. The delivery service is always fast and the customer service is good as well. read more

American Pie Pizzeria - Garden salad with shrimp - Pizza Near Me - Bridgehampton, New York

Some of the Best Food in The Hamptons!! As a local and frequent patron of this establishment, I highly recommend it.. Yes, their Pizza is as good as any in NYC (and I was born and raised there) with a rotating variety second to none, such as cheeseburger, shrimp scampi and Thai chicken to name a few.. However it's their entrees that really shine! They are superbly prepared and absolutely delicious. Plus It's all very reasonably priced, especially for the Hamptons. Enjoy it.. read more

See all

I only had their regular pizza, so I can only really comment on that. It was terrible and salty. It's really hard to mess up pizza, but that is what they have done. I didn't even finish it... I didn't finish pizza. Who says that? read more

Best pizza in the Hamptons ! Grandmas is our favorite. Highly recommend. Delivery or pickup.

My husband and I love the food here! We've tried a bunch of the different things- specialty slices, soups, calzones, wraps.... Literally everything is delicious! They really have the best sauce and pizza crust around. We especially love Raj who is one of the owners. He cracks us up! I highly recommend this place! read more

Good spot in the Hampton. Their pizza is just a good classic New York style. Not fancy, not crazy, good American pizza. Their Brooklyn and grandma styles are very nice. I wish they used a better pepperoni to up their game. Overall it's a good spot. read more

if i can give it a 0 i would have never written a review before this is how bad it was has nothing on the menu in store and the food tasted like dirty water read more

Don't order delivery! This was my only experience with this place. It took an hour & a half to get our food, everything we ordered was wrong & cold and they even forgot the dessert we ordered. Even though the food was cold, it tasted good, so that's why it earned more than one star. Maybe I would have a different experience if I ate at the restaurant. At least I'd have the chance to send my wrong order back. Though, I doubt the next time I go to to Sag Harbor I'll give it another try. But, you never know! This place is lucky that it doesn't have a lot of competition in the area. read more

Well...what can I say. Third review and we are back to two starts. The staff is very nice. The place is quite a mess. There does not seem to be anyone in charge of cleaning up where the customers sit. Tables floor ledges all very dirty. One star for cleanliness or lack of, and three stars for food. Pizza is just alright sometimes and good other times. Food seems fresh. read more

Been here several time over the years. Always above average. However, about 3 weeks ago, I walked in and bought 4 slices on a late Saturday afternoon. Hate to say it, but terrible. No flavor. Just looking at it, I could see the slices were from 2 pies. Reheated, leftovers. I may try once more with a full pie. If same results, I am a former customer. My advice guys. Your better than this, I know. Throw out the leftover pizza. They are garbage and not worth $12.00 for 4 slices. read more

This is the third time we ordered a pie and there was an issue. It came very quickly and leads me to believe it was reheated. The bottom was burntandnit seemed out extra irems were thrown on top. Its the only delivery place so... read more

American Pie Pizzeria - a piece of bread on a plate - Pizza Near Me - Bridgehampton, New York

First the positive: The pizza here is pretty decent. Sort of a mash-up between classic NY Slice style (crispy but not greasy crust) and New England Greek Pizzeria style (heavy layer of cheese). Tasty. Also had an order of meatballs that were better than average in a tangy sauce. Unfortunately these positives are heavily outweighed by the incompetence and lack of care from all who work here. I placed a phone order for pick-up and was told the order would be ready 30 minutes form then (5:05 pm, on a Tuesday in August). Given that August is likely their busiest time of the year I showed up at 5:35 fully expecting to have to wait for a bit for my order to be ready. I checked in and paid as soon as I arrived and was told "a few more minutes" which seemed reasonable. As the time ticked past the 20 minute mark (a full 50 minutes since I placed my order) I politely asked the young lady after my order and she let me know "a few more minutes". This back-and-forth repeated itself twice more over the next 30 minutes until finally my patience broke and I sternly asked her what the deal was; it turned out my order was there all along she just had not looked for it. Without a hint of apology she handed my my now warm-adjacent pizza. Frankly I was embarrassed she was not embarrassed. But, life goes on, I walked out the door an hour and twenty minutes after I placed my order with a pizza and the kids eventually got fed. However the lack of pride in what one does and a desire to do the best given the circumstances always baffles me. I've worked in the service industry and I get it that mistakes can and will happen but I also found that a genuine "I'm SO sorry" (and maybe a free drink when i really eff'ed up) would often turn a poor customer service situation into a happy memory. This was the opposite of that. This is a transient town with lots of summer people and tourists so I am sure their lack of care will not affect the bottom line but when you lack pride in what you do you lack pride in yourself and that is just sad to see. read more

I had a great conversation with the cashier and the pepperoni calzone was really delicious! It was definitely the tastiest calzone I've ever had. I will definitely be back! read more

This place is absolutely amazing. We always order from here when we have guests staying over. It's easy, delicious and well priced! Definitely the best pizza in the area read more

I gave this place a great rating in the past and it took one bad employee and one bad night of just ignorant service to change my mind and never order from here again. How stupid does a person have to be to cook a pizza and, hey everyone you know that little white pizza table that you see when opening the box. Imagine craving your pizza and other orders which isn't cheap (90$ to be exact) only to see that the person who cooked the pizza decided to, ya know...try something new. Maybe they do this in Germany or something but the table is upside down. Anyone else ever see that before? I immediately lost faith in humanity for the last time. That table goes only one way. Upright. Not smashed into the pizza middle so when I pull it out I see a moon of dough. Just avoid this place. It's full of idiots. Like Steve A. Who thinks that saying his boss is right next to him lying like a child is going to help him if his boss does see this review. Because if it was me. I would be fired. Oh and did I mention her purposely gave me the opposite of everything I ordered. I said plain cheese cake not raspberry and yup you guessed it. The only thing worth paying for was tipping the driver. read more

American Pie Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - Bridgehampton, New York

See all

HORRIBLE SERVICE! The ONLY reason this place has a business in Bridgehampton is because they deliver (tho they don't do that very well - they routinely take twice the time they quote to arrive and once I had a delivery guy come and get the pie out of the back seat of his car where his DOG was sitting. Routinely things are under cooked (desserts often FROZEN) and items such as sauces are forgotten. DO yourself a favor and order from Pizza Palace across the street or World Pie in the village and just go pick it up. read more

I travel everywhere as a corporate pilot. Tonight was the best pizza I believe I have ever had First time ordering from them Outstanding read more

followed guys from work to this place .it was awful pizza was days old and reheated fresh chicken rolls came out of oven and chicken was shiny and grey showing it was revoked about 6 times .servers and counter help are clueless as to what's going on and very rude . would not recommend this place to anyone not even a starving homeless person ! read more

Stopped in here while waiting on some friends who were out celebrating a birthday dinner. (Designated driver was I) I had two slices of the chicken, bacon and ranch. I asked for it not too hot and it came out exactly the way I asked. The slices were quite tasty and completely filling. I probably should have only ordered one slice, but I know me and my eyes are ALWAYS bigger than my stomach. (Damn, I must have huge eyes based on the looks of my stomach - lol) Anyway, the food was good, the staff pleasant, and there is plenty of parking. The inside of the store is maybe a little disorganized; but space is limited. Good stuff going on here. read more

Frequent customer during my stay in Southampton. Service is always quick. When they say 20 mins, they mean it. Quality is consistent. Staff is pleasant and friendly. Prices are great. Tastes like home cooked meals. read more

Walked in on a Thursday night at 10pm. They were technically closed but gave us their last 4 slices. Grandma slices were delicious! We also got the eggplant rollatini and boneless chicken wings in the prepared food. Did not disappoint and the staff was super friendly!! Will definitely be back read more

Okay, redemption. We have local friends over and true American pie again! All our friends said was "amazing". And it was. They hit tonight!! Thanks American Pie for a great meal. read more

American Pie Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - Bridgehampton, New York

See all

I love this place. This is one of my go-to spots to get their pepperoni rolls. If they don't have any they always offer to make me one. I came here a lot over the summer and it's just one of those places where you can count on them to make what you like and make it consistently awesome. Did I mention they deliver? Which was nice when I was working over the summer and couldn't leave the store. This is seriously the only place where I get pepperoni rolls when I'm in the Hamptons. Their slices are great as well. I will always have a special place in my heart and stomach for this gem. read more