Warning. Big change after new owners took over the once reliable Pizza Place three years ago. One of the slices smelled way too fishy too eat for a calamari slice. Brought in to let them know. The som of the owner hid sheepishly by the ovens and .the manager came over to tell me he wouldn't exchange. They took it and Threw it out but no exchange or refund. Be warned. Food service requires trust that management will keep things fresh and stand behind their foos. Not here. Not meant to be in food service. Pies LOOKED good but Calamari was clearly not fresh and come to think of it the cheese seemed a little too white like some melting spread. There were lots of refrigerated rolls not selling but kept in the case. Pies were moving and tasted ok but would NOT return. read more

This place has a pizza oven but it is not pizza they are serving. Not even close and not good at all. I stopped here on my way out east for a slice and received an extremely hot slice of poorly prepared, cheap ingredients with an over abundance of flour. I had asked that the slices be just warmed, so my young daughter could eat it and the man nodded, and sent out these boiling hot slices. Also, I did not feel welcome here at all. I received no smiles from anyone, no hello, no goodbye or even a thank you for coming. Not recommended. read more

I decided to give the pizza place another try. I spoke with Luis about my last review which wasn't good. We had a great conversation. I'm upgrading my rating to 4 stars. Today I just ordered a slice with double meat, it was excellent. I will be back again. read more

See all

Awesome pizza, great friendly staff and conveniently located in a big parking lot. The ambiance is cool too it's a great Italian fusion spot with lots of unique offerings. The regular cheese slice was cooked perfectly, nice and crispy, high quality cheese, and a nice punchy/tangy tomato sauce. Loved it, 5 stars!!! read more

Wow, if magnificent and out of this world pizza. I would go back again . Fantastic place great people

Great costumer service, good & ambiance. Ordered the carne asada, burger, pizza, & encebollado. All is 10/10, def recommend

You would think that a place called the pizza place would have decent pizza. The pizza at this place is horrible! It's a floppy sloppy mess of a slice of pizza and they should be ashamed of themselves for calling it pizza!! read more

I have been going here on and off since it was John's in the 70's. Most of the newer owners at thie place, the food average Now as the Pizza Place our Mushroom and onion pizza was as good as i have had anywhere. The Pina Coladas good but pricy. read more

The pizza looked good but stomach ache followed. Needs some fresh spices cause very plain tasting. Ahhh someday we'll have a good pizza place out here read more

I dream about the pizza and empanadas. Wonderful people, great service, great ambiance. Going to drive 30 minutes maybe today for more

We visited this place on Feb 22nd around 2pm. I thought I posted this review already, but some how it got stuck in my drafts. It was on the way after visiting the South Fork Natural History Museum. It was a pretty cold day, so coming into this warm establishment felt like such a relief. There was no one when we got here, with plenty of parking. My first impression of this place is like a combination of a Latin food, pizza place, and breakfast deli! They had everything to satisfy your needs! Bagels? breakfast sandwiches, pizza, rice beans, and hot foods, they have it all! We just got three slices of pizza. Plain, chicken broccoli, and chicken parm. The pizza didn't taste that special it just tasted like good Long Island pizza. This place is like your one-stop shop for you and your hungry family and friends. They had many drink selections and several tables to site at. Of course right now they are probably doing take out, but give them a try! read more

See all

Wrong phone number provided through google. So we ordered from here and picked up pizza from somewhere else, very confusing and needs to be sorted out between the BUSINESSES. The manager of this place called my friend and BERATED her for ordering from the wrong place. My friend was confused since she was not even the one who called originally and he said he "recognized her voice"- impossible. So rude, will NEVER go here. read more

This place is under new ownership. I walked in today to check it out and I must say its one of the BEST pizza places locally that I have been to if not the BEST in the area! The staff was super friendly explaining all the specialty slices they prepare. They have a wonderful TV menu board to see all the vast amount of specials they offer. So we sat down while they warmed up our specialty slices and then they brought them to table. The aroma of the food is overwhelming! It was not overly hot just right. My wife and my kids enjoyed their slices and I did as well. I also had some terrific garlic knots. I must say this is a great addition to the community. I look forward to visiting often. I should have gotten some slices to go because as write this review. I'm craving another slice ! read more

See all

Stop in from South Hampton as much as I can. Pizza is great also the penne aka vodka is wonderful too. Always a nice staff. TVs are great for watching games. read more

Before a movie why not a pizza, went for a pizza they all looks kind of sad. Notice that they had Latin food we order a soup, horrible soup full of those fakes knor flavor or consome. My husband got carne asada not same no flavor. Sorry probably the other food is good I don't know. Also.. the owner is creepy. read more

Good pizza, friendly service and a nice clean booth! It was fun to go here right before seeing a movie next door.

We late getting to town due to a two hour flight delay and wondered around Hampton Bay trying to find somewhere to eat. Manager let us order, and sit to eat while were cleaning up! Good pizza and kindness! read more

Today I bought a Sicilian pie not so good no taste but garlic knots to die for people were pleasant be a while before I go back everything else looks good read more

The Pizza Place - Went here ordered a Sicilian pie not so good very dry tasteless people were very nice garlic knots to die for h - Pizza Near Me - Hampton Bays, New York

We have been there many times when it was Johns and several times with the present owners. Yesterday I bought a pizza and Caesar salad to share with 3 other people. I asked if anything contained soy and they said the dressing did. I told them that's no problem, I can't eat soy, but my other friends could. When we got to my friend's house to eat, there was no dressing included in a container- it was just lettuce, a few croutons and grated cheese. My friend called to ask if they could drop it off when they delivered in the area and they were laughing at us on the phone and in the background saying that I had said I didn't want it. I never said that- if they weren't sure they could have clarified it. Since they were laughing at us, we won't be back. It is not good to mock customers. read more

Food was good. Had a couple sicilian slices. I was there on a Wednesday so I got the wing special also. Relaxed atmosphere where you can drink a beer or a soda. Many different options available food wise. read more

The Pizza Place - Mild wings - Pizza Near Me - Hampton Bays, New York

See all

So delicious! Great pizza. Great fresh salads. Great service. Hidden gem near Dunkin Donuts! Clean Inside too

I try to give this place so many chances. I've been coming every now and then since it opened. Ingredients get cheaper and prices get higher. You can tell in the cheese and sauce. It was $15 for 3 average slices when I could've got 8 for $20 with higher quality ingredients down the road. Not to mention the place can't decide their target demographic. Hopefully this place figures it out :/ read more

Place is super nice, I love the broad variety on their menu, really nice ambiance, kind staff.

This place is disgusting gave me rotten Shrimp linguine was overcooked And the steak was all pieces of fat beware stay away from this place my stomach is still recovering read more

I don't really write reviews but I'm done here. The pizza is decent but the slices are way to big. Too much dough. The staff is too busy being pre occupied with themselves or on thier cell phones. Twice I came here and my pizza was left in the oven and was burned badly he had to put another slice in and it's not even busy. There customer service plain sucks. Then to make it up they give you free garlic knots and shit. How the hell do you burn pizza? Save yourself the headache and go to Scottos for real pizza and service. Ps your knots suck too. Literally a ball of bread read more

The restaurant is amazing and because they did an really huge change in the store and the people that work there (one of them is the owner) was nice enough to give a small drink and 2 free samples of pizza and it really made my day and the food is really great and one more thing you will get good service. read more

Delicious food, friendly service. Food is awesome, Johnny helped me and he was so nice.

I wish I could give zero stars. My family and I have been customers for years. Two weeks ago I picked up pizza and a salad with my mom. When we arrived my mom asked boy at the registers if the salad dressing had soy in it, as she's allergic and the people in there had no clue so she said it was okay and that we would take it anyways. We went to a friends house with the food and when we opened the bag there was no salad dressing. We called up right away and the same boy answered and asked them why there was no salad dressing and he started laughing and said we said we didn't want it? Which makes no sense because you need to put it on the salad. He then passed the phone to a lady (not sure if she was the manager) and he made up a story of how we said we didn't want it when my mom specifically said she'll still take it she just wanted to know the ingredients for herself. They were whispering, talking about us and laughing and then she finally responded to me. She had a terrible attitude and the boy continued to laugh in the background. She responded with, "he said you told him you didn't want it", which was a complete lie because he wanted to save himself from his mistake. I would understand they may have gotten confused because of my mom asking about the ingredients inside but act professional. Laughing at a customer is extremely disrespectful, especially when it was your fault. We will not be returning & will be sure to warn our friends and family because this was not professional at all. Extremely disappointed and you need to retrain your staff. read more

The service is and always great!! Salads are fresh and pizza is delicious. We thank you for the unconditional customer services and we enjoy the atmosphere. read more

We grabbed a few slices before a movie. Nice selection. Kind of bland honestly. $5.00+ for a slice if Grandma!

Luis has redone the entire Restaurant, so it is lovely and fresh with BRAND NEW Equipment and New and Improved Food and increased Menu selections that are delicious. Great food and they have Specials every day of the week. Well done Luis !! Wishing you all the best !! read more

where's my pizzabruh i'm hungryget me my pizza now AHAHAHAG why is this not long eniughhhhhhhhh hi ok bye

I typically don't take the time to review a place, but had to with this one. I ordered a sicilian on the way home, picked it up and drove 5 min to my house. My family took a slice and it was not hot. Not even warm. Not cold from a refrig, but not edible. I called and was basically told by the person on the phone that I was lying. I said that I was trying this place instead of my usual (trying to support our local businesses), and again was made to feel like I did something wrong. I explained that all I wanted to do was bring this one back and have them make me a fresh hot one. After a few minutes of on hold, they told me 45-50 minutes. The pizza is ok. Nothing to rave about. But the customer service is what will kill this place. Keep making your customers feel like they did something wrong and you will be out of business. If the owner would like to contact me, I would be more than happy to go over the incident. read more