Ambiance (5/5): On a Friday evening around 7:30p, our party of 6 were quoted a 45 min wait time but the real wait ended up being 20 min! The establishment has a narrow hallway for indoor dining in large booths. Past this are some smaller tables and a bar with high top seating. We enjoyed some cocktails as we waited before we were seated in their outdoor space with several tables that can accommodate large parties. The lighting was a bit dim but otherwise bustling and nice atmosphere. Service (5/5): They were incredibly busy but we felt like we were serviced quickly and our food came out fairly quick! Our waitress was super courteous and lovely! Food (5/5): Each dish had large portions that was perfect for our family style dining. The food was delicious OMG the table bread!! TO DIE FOR. We had a refill of them and we didn't want to spoil the rest of appetite... Calamari: cooked to perfection, nothing was chewy or hard to bite into. Light but flavorful breading. Port Pear salad: superb blend of textures and flavors from the variety in toppings. The vinaigrette was light but flavorful! Vegetable stuffed mushrooms: Hard to go wrong with mushrooms stuffed with chesse Pistachio pesto tortellini: This was the most flavorful of the 3 pasta dishes we ordered! Felt like the pesto flavors were done beautifully. Pappardelle Bolognese: Classic taste, overall solid Scarpariell: My least favorite but mostly bc the sauce wasn't for me. The meats were cooked wonderfully. The bed of risotto was fire. We were stuffed to the brim with all the food and were very happy with the whole experience!! read more

See all

Came here for dinner with my daughter and her friend. We were greeted and seated, then Ashley came and took our order. She had to come back a couple of times, as we decided what we were having. She was so cheerful and pleasant! I was THRILLED to discover that there's GF penne, and you can swap out roasted vegetables or risotto for pasta in the chicken dishes. There's also cauliflower crust PIZZA!! It's the usual 10" crust, but it was DELICIOUS!! I don't know what they did--added butter or olive oil?--but it was the BEST cauliflower crust that I have EVER had. I researched them once, and it was (at the time) 10 crusts for $15 from a web restaurant supply place. IF Mary's uses those crusts, they somehow greatly improve them. The pizza toppings were also WONDERFUL. We ordered three different pizzas, to share, and there was some confusion about one of the girl's orders, so Ashley got them ANOTHER pizza! That was unexpected and so very nice! The roasted vegetable side, and the burrata caprese appetizer were both incredibly flavorful. We had planned to go somewhere else, but it closes on Mondays. I am SO glad that we came to Mary's! The pepperoni and hot honey pizza, and the Marguerite pizza, were so yummy! The spinach (yuck) and artichoke was good, and so was the extra buffalo chicken, but the first two are REALLY good! read more

See all

I've been coming out East every summer since I was a kid, and Mary's has always been one of our must-visit spots. We make it a point to stop by several times each summer because it's consistently that good. The staff is always friendly, welcoming, and attentive, making every visit enjoyable. The ambiance has a modern Italian pizzeria feel, and there's a huge selection of fresh slices to choose from. We've also dined in the restaurant on several occasions, and every meal we've had has been exceptional. Whether you're looking for a quick slice or a sit-down meal, Mary's never disappoints. I highly recommend stopping by if you're in the area! read more

Big fan. Grandma pizza may be the best in the hamptons....certainly around WB, East quogue, and Hampton Bays. Sauce was just the right amount of sweetness and it has great garlic. Cheese pizza and roni were decent too. We all shared the Caesar salad and the crotons are massive. Decent take out/delivery option. Would love to dine in and try pasta. read more

We came to celebrate a birthday and had a rather large party. They seated us in the back, there was plenty of room and everyone was comfortable. Our main waitress and her helpers were on their game! Our drinks were never empty, food all came out at the same time, she was very attentive even with there being so many of us. The food was delicious! They start you with the warm garlic bread. This stuff is trouble bc if left alone with it, I could eat the entire tray. The main plate portions were huge, most had to get a to go container. We will absolutely be back! read more

The waiter was very kind and attentive. The food was delicious and decent sized portions. The drinks were all super tasty. The ambiance overall was a very good vibe. read more

Mary's Pizza and Pasta - Dinner Special - Pizza Near Me - Speonk, New York

My wife and I live in Jupiter Florida. Originally, we lived on the Island for 26 years. My son and his wife live in Center Moriches and recommended it. All I can say is this restaurant is excellent!!! Great staff coupled with awesome food. I told one of the owners Vinny, that I wish they'd open up a Mary's in Jupiter. The interior of the restaurant is also very nice. Looking forward to our next visit. John F. read more

The best cauliflower pizza of all time! Just try and you will be back over and over again! Very clean and friendly staff!

After a couple of months in the area, Mary's has become our favorite restaurant. It's always packed, but less so in the off season. Fortunately, they take reservations. Mary's is a down to earth island in a sea of pretension. The bar is quite busy. The crowd is all over the place, from a cadre of regulars to flocks of Hamptons doyennes. The staff are lovely. The bartender makes an excellent martini. The mark up on wines is really reasonable. The food is uniformly excellent. Meals start with a basket of excellent focaccia strips. Our favorites include the personal pizzas (which are big enough to share). They are rich and have unique sesame seeded crusts. I often order the linguini with clam sauce. There is a ton of clams in the dish. I keep eyeing the Flinstonian sized veal chop parmigiana, but still haven't closed the deal. Despite going there often, we never have had enough self control to leave room for dessert. Ah well, hope springs eternal! read more

See all

Want thrilled with the dinner the last time we ate here. My husband was very disappointed in the chicken special. Probably will try it again. I like the pizza. read more

See all

Amazing food, great drinks, the staff goes above and beyond to make sure you're satisfied. It's perfect for a date night with the wife or take the family out for a Sunday dinner. read more

Cute outdoor area for summer. Big menu. Good drinks and late hours for the area, in comparison. The gnocchi was Pricy for what it is. Will return. read more

So we have been taking out from Mary's for years! The meals are HUGE n EXTRA SPECIAL VERY GOOD. The team is fantastic. Between great food and superb service this is the SPOT. Say hey to Lars (manager). Get the veggie pizza and a meatball hero!! read more

Popular with the locals near and far, for good reason too. Delicious Marys meatballs adorned with a basil leaf and a lil scoop of ricotta and delish marinara. Super good! Stuffed shrimp entree was hella good. A bottle of Ruffino Toscana red completed the delightful lunch. Do it! read more

The service was really nice and kind. Been going to this place almost since it opened. I love the bread sticks but today they were a little light on the butter. It's a nice cozy and casual restaurant. The traditional pizza that I ordered was super good. My dad was getting mad at the tiny mozzarella balls on the chicken capri. (My dad does not effect my rating) read more

Mary's Pizza and Pasta - Very lightly buttered breadsticks - Pizza Near Me - Speonk, New York

See all

Amazing place!! Everything from appetizer to mains to dessert. Staff is wonderful and so knowledgeable of menu. Outdoor dining is beautiful and well shaded read more

They changed their french fries! As a longtime customer the only reason I'm rating 4 stars and not 5 is that they used to have AMAZING fries, but now they're different and have skin on them. More like a "rustic cut" I guess. And they give you less of them. If they ever bring back the old fries, easily 5 stars! read more

I have eaten here before and loved it but the last time I was there, they had these splitters in the ceiling blowing out hot air and the place was so humid that I felt nauseous from the smells that were lingering. I actually had been seated and looked at my companion and said, I can't eat here, I won't be able to enjoy it. She agreed and we walked out and went to Buckley's instead. I'll go back when outside seating is open. read more

The food was delicious! I ordered the Caesar salad and it was fresh and chill without wilt or brown. The dressing was deliciously creamy and tasty. The shrimp were perfectly grilled and croutons were home made. It would have been nice to de-shell them but whatever. A little small for dinner salad Tasted the eggplant Parmesan was awesome. It was cooked to perfection and was not bitter or overly breaded and the sauce was hearty and a perfect mix of garlic and spices. Hearty portion! One thing--it was not a one layer fill the plate presentation but stacked in a deep dish--not that this mattered. The lasagna was perfection and the cheese velvety smooth and meat sauce fantastic in taste-- all ingredients well proportioned and prepared with intention and forethought. . Talking of portions--generously sized. The mini rice balls had amazing ingredients such as pease and beef and they were amazing taste--albeit a tad oily. The zucchini chips were NOT thin but about the 2/3 the height of an Oreo. They were awesome and cooked to perfection. The service was good--would have been great but towards the middle of the meal the waitress was no where to be found and I had to summon someone for water. Sadly, I summoned someone who I thought was our waiter but they happened to be another patron--they didn't oblige, appropriately. We were outside and therefore the noise level was acceptable--chairs and table a little backyard-ish, lighting almost acceptable and fans helped keep us cool. The fireplace added to the ambiance and helped us think we were not in a friends backyard. So, great food, good service and eh ambiance makes this a 5-3-2 but I rounded up because food was so good. read more

See all

We always get take out. The food is very good . The staff is not helpful or friendly. Pretty expensive

The food here is the BEST.... EVERY dish or pizza here is so good. The service is friendly and spot on. I HIGHLY recommend Mary's Pizza and PASTA! read more

The meatball pizza is unbelievable. The entrees are also quite good. We had chicken and eggplant parm and both were big servings that were very good. It's a little pricey but not crazy... read more

Food is always delicious and the atmosphere ranges from beach casual to date night!! Service is great and we love popping in on our way home from Cupsogue!! read more

Love you guys! Had a wonderful late lunch yesterday with my husband. Shared Mozzarella triangles with the hubs and ordered my go to Chicken parm took 2/3 home, such big portions there and so good! Service was great too. Mary's has comfortable seating and is casual. Thank you all! read more

OMG!!!! This was our second visit to Mary's. I didn't get to write a review for the first time so before I start this review, I just want to say Kudos to our waiter Stephen who was just amazing on our first visit. Tonight, Dianne took great care of us. I was so excited to be here again because our first time was just amazing. Tonight, my wife and I shared a Ceaser salad which was topped with fresh parmigiana shavings. For dinner, I had the amazing seafood marinara loaded with shrimp, clams and mussels in a delicious marinara sauce over linguini. Our friends had the unbelievable veal chop which was truly huge and unbelievable! I didn't order this because I wanted to try something different, I had the break last time.... Fuggedaboudit! My wife had the papardelle bolognese. For dessert I had the hot brownie Sundae.... Burp, I'm done! Mary's is an amazing Italian restaurant! By on appetite ! read more

See all

Have eaten here few times. Special drinks excellent, food is enjoyable, sometimes more than others, prices are appropriate to food, some would find it a little pricey for the atmosphere. Noise level is ALWAYS high, no buffers , wood floors, rather low ceilings so not even fans to disburse noise. I did like that they had tablecloths, definitely a plus for that. Our server kept touching his face, earrings, hair, so that was not appetizing. All in all less noise, less touching and I would say 4 stars. read more

This place had a great comfortable vibe! The bartender was great! Had a large group I met up with and we had some good choices. I would come again and try some of the other items on the menu! read more

Had a very nice lunch experience at Mary's Today. Celebrating my mom's bday with my wife. Ambiance was clean bright and welcoming. Our server was very friendly and did a very nice job. We had the Burratta appetizer and calamari. Entrees included chicken Marsala Caesar salad with shrimp and the chopped Mary's salad. All were very good and tasty. Dessert included cappuccino and espresso cannoli and a very nice rainbow cookie cake. We look forward to coming back again. Thank you read more

Used Mary's to cater Christmas Eve for the second year in a row. Amazing! We ordered 3 days before-no problem at all. Food was hot, fresh, and delicious. Those mini rice balls were a huge hit. Full of flavor and cooked perfectly. Each dish came as though cooked only for us. Nothing seemed cooked in large quantities. Great job Mary's! After a few health issues you came through for us, helping us host a delicious Christmas Eve. read more

This place is situated between two villages on a long stretch of less active road.. YET its non stop action at Mary's. Went in and was in shock to see how super busy this place is. Pizza counter up front, and tables to sit, and other areas in and outside of the restaurant full table service even better. Calamari is good, regular or Thai. You can't really go wrong here as most of the food seems homestyle and good. Definitely good for casual lunch or dinner and can even do well for a nice evening outside on the patio in warm weather. read more

The food was very tasty, nice building and atmosphere, chicken francaise is very good

The pizza is really god I like the test of it, and the service was amazing people are really nice.

A second visit to Mary's was great. Staff was very personable and food was great . We will visit again and we are sure we will again enjoy our dining experience read more

Very nice and quiet place I love it I'd just recommend if it's a big party to give them a heads up or reserve read more

First time here and I am definitely coming back! I ordered a Paloma. The grapefruit beverage used add a wonderful splash of flavor. For appetizers we got the bruschetta that comes on a crostini which had a soft crunch. The Thai calamari was insanely good. I've never had calamari that wasn't chewy, this was easy to chew and our bartender informed us they cut the squid in house so its fresh not frozen! What really blew me away were the rice balls. It had a crisp outside and when you bite you get a blast of vodka sauce inside. It comes with vodka sauce to dip it into as well for extra love. Lastly, we got a margarita pizza on a cauliflower crust. It was my first time having a cauliflower crust and it was so much better than I though it was going to be Highly recommend getting the calamari and rice balls. read more

See all

Friday night place packed. Great salad and pizza. Server very attentive. Ate at bar due to wait

Have been here quite a lot this past year..Can't say enough on the service...impressive might be a good description..Food is consistently great..dine in or take out...the pizza counter part is the only issue we have had..quite a few mistakes...some weeks it's over done and burnt..other weeks it's a total flop.. read more

Food was AWESOME!! Drinks were great and string. Service was phenomenal! What a nice place! Will definitely be going back! Highly recommend. I'm not a huge Southern Italian food fan, but their sauce is one of the best I've had and I just came back from Southern Italy!! Wings were insanely good too as was their blue cheese dressing!! Def homemade!!! read more

Love this place! Came here after a horrible experience at another local Italian restaurant. I was just looking for some good penne a la vodka and Mary's had it! Delicious and saucy. The interior was very nice and clean. Staff was very nice. Highly recommend!! read more

4 yums Amelya our server is amazing! We are a party of 12 and she handled all our drink appetizer and entree orders competently and with a smile. The Thai calamari was quite large in size spice to it and a bit chewy for my taste. The flatbread pizza was delish. We had the veggie margarita and spinach artichoke pies. By far the spinach artichoke pie was amazing but the veg was too mushy We moved onto our entrees not one of us had the same dish. The portions are huge! We ended up taking most of the food home. Everything was hot flavorful and delicious Our server Amelya was attentive as before and made sure our meals were perfect. We are a bit demanding because of our large party. I gave this 4 stars for food service and our server. The room is loud but decorated nicely. read more