A Delightful Late Lunch Experience My wife and I stopped in for an early dinner and were pleasantly surprised that we had the entire place to ourselves. Maria ordered the Tortellini in brodo alongside a caramelized pear salad topped with grilled chicken. I opted for a Caesar salad with grilled chicken. The lettuce in my salad was crisp and fresh, though the grilled chicken was slightly dry. Fortunately, the Caesar dressing more than made up for it--it was among the best I've ever tasted, elevating the entire dish. Maria thoroughly enjoyed her tortellini in brodo, savoring its rich flavors, and found her salad to be equally delightful. Overall, despite a minor drawback, our meal was a satisfying and flavorful experience. One thing to keep in mind: The village of Port Jefferson has removed the ability to pay for parking via credit card. A patron is required to scan a QR Code and pay via the site that appears on the screen. read more

The Pie - Caramelized pear salad with chicken - Pizza Near Me - Port Jefferson, New York

See all

Ordered a pizza on our way to the ferry. Not on the menu but they made us a Chicken Parmesan Pizza. Great coal fired crust, homemade sauce and fresh mozzarella cheese. The chicken was ok. Ate the pizza in the car waiting for the ferry to let us in. read more

The Pie - Chicken Parm Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Port Jefferson, New York

Nice early dinner cozy spot to eat! Fast service. Our waitress has such great energy and positive vibes it made the experience even better. Started to fill up once we started to leave around 6pm. They host large parties too. I was craving coal fired pizza and that is what i got! Medium sized personal pie enough for two and a house salad also enough for two. read more

The Pie - House Salad - Pizza Near Me - Port Jefferson, New York

See all

Came here curious, left disappointed. Margherita pizza: 8/10. Thin crust, sauce was nice, but no fresh basil... which is like forgetting the lime in a margarita. Buffalo pizza: not even worth the calories. One bite and I was done. Wings: reheated vibes !I didn't order leftovers, thanks. Calamari: soggy, not crispy. Service: meh, not attentive. Tried it once, checked the box, but never going back read more

The Pie - half margheria, half buffalo - Pizza Near Me - Port Jefferson, New York

See all

The Pie generally has a way of turning an ordinary appetizer into something special. Not so last night with the bruschetta. Was expecting crispy bread covered with vine ripened tomato. What we got were pieces of an odd colored, spongy baguette covered with unripe tomato and an inordinate amount of mozzarella cheese cubes. Awful! Luckily we also ordered a Margarita Pie, that rocked! Next time we'll stick to the pizza. read more

Had reservations! When I arrived was told another 45 min wait .... Management could care less ...... service is horrible and food is good/not great ! read more

Went with my girlfriend and another couple and had an amazing experience. The restaurant is beautifully decorated and the service was outstanding. We split a Margarita pizza and it was delicious, the sauce was my favorite part. We also had a chicken bacon ranch pizza (secret menu item) which was absolutely exquisite. The other couple got the chicken Marsala which they said was amazing. We got garlic knots as well which were okay, lacking in any garlic flavor. For lunch this was a perfect spot, would definitely come back. read more

See all

Just moved out here 3 months ago with my fiancé and have been wanting to find a really good Italian spot. I just so happened to get recommended this place recently and decided on checking it out. We ordered two pies. A buffalo chicken pie and a margarita pie as well as an order of pasta. All of which came out fast and incredible. The service was also spot on. I'll be coming out here a lot more especially when it starts to get warmer. Do yourself a favor and stop in here if you're even remotely in the area. You will be far from disappointed. read more

One of the best tasting NY pepperoni and sausage pizzas and pear salad on the side combo we have had in Long Island!! Would highly recommend and would go back for this combo! read more

The Pie is my favorite pizza place for thin crust pizza. My mom and I shared the mozzarella sticks to start which seemed deliciously homemade and are very stretchy. I got a classic margarita pie for my entree and my mom got a focaccia flatbread piled high with their house salad. We both enjoyed our meals and the service. We finished it off with a cookie dough blast, which is a chocolate chip cookie lava cake warm with vanilla ice cream. read more

See all

Great food; great service! I always enjoy eating there. The ambiance is very inviting as well!

Came here with my in-laws and my fiancé sister for lunch and wasn't surprised at all on the quality of food coming out this restaurant. Located in the heart of port Jefferson and along the strip where you'll find plenty of great food spots/ bars for brunch, lunch, or dinner. Came here because this is great place my in-laws visit and eat a lot at. The staff here was very welcoming and I see why my in-laws love this place. Our waitress was very sweet and helpful with food options and I wish I remembered her name, but was amazing all around. She offered great options on food and gluten free options. We ordered 3 brick oven pies and every pie was great. I'm a Brick oven pizza whore and can eat brick over pizza every day. This an old review and I wish I wrote it sooner, so I could detail exactly everything we had. We ordered a margarita pie, chick pesto with bacon, and a sausage pie. Every pie was great, but my favorite was the chicken pesto with bacon. My fiancé sister got chicken fingers with French fries and the chicken fingers here are 10/10. I would never order chicken fingers in a pizza/restaurant, but they were 1 of the best I had. Came here in the summer and what I love about port Jefferson is you can make a great day out of it. Easily convenient to the ferry where you can go from port Jefferson in your car to Connecticut or keep it local. There is plenty of bars, restaurants, site seeing, shopping, etc. Great restaurant with amazing food and brick oven pizza. This place offer amazing pasta and Italian entrees other than pizza. Highly recommend if you're looking for great food ! read more

So I want to start off by saying that this restaurant was really fun and it went from Fancy to pizzeria to outdoor dining bliss. All the chitter chatter going around was really nice. All the laughter and everybody enjoying their time there. The food was so good. I stepped outside of my comfort zone and tried the watermelon and feta salad. It was absolutely phenomenal. I definitely cannot wait to make this at home. The pizza was so perfect as well. It was just enough for the both of us. The bad part. Our waitress was absolutely horrible. She forgot about us, she never checked on us, I literally had to wave somebody down after sitting there and waiting for 30 minutes to get our check. There was never an I'm sorry, there was never anything. We literally never saw her again. I would come back for the food, but I would definitely avoid this particular waitress we had. Definitely three stars for food, but due to customer service, there's definitely room for improvement. read more

See all

We were in the area and decided to check out this restaurant for dinner because the reviews all looked great. For an appetizer, we got the garlic bread. It came out in the shape of a mini pizza and had delicious thin crust. We also got a medium pie with half buffalo chicken and half chicken pesto. We were initially going to get 2 separate small pizzas, but our waitress suggested we get a medium with half and half instead. She was right because this was the perfect amount for 2 people. The pizza was pretty good, but I wasn't crazy about the chicken. Maybe it would've been better if it were breaded. The service was great though! Our waitress kept stopping by to check up on us and refill our drinks. The owner even stopped by at one point to ask how we were doing. read more

The Pie - Coal Fired Garlic Bread - Pizza Near Me - Port Jefferson, New York

See all

I picked up a Margherita pie to go and it got glowing reviews from 3 people with very different and picky views about pizza. It was the right balance of cheese and sauce and the crust had good flavor. I added a hint of salt but that was all that was needed. Highly recommended and will return to try more. read more

The Pie - Margherita pizza large - Pizza Near Me - Port Jefferson, New York

The Pie was a mixed experience. The ambiance in the restaurant is very nice, it is well decorated. However, being there at an off time it was still quite loud inside. The service was friendly, but again for 3:30 on a Sunday it is surprising it took my server 10 minutes to come to the table. The food was definitely where the place shines. The pizza was sweet and savory with a silky olive oil and crisp crust, definitely the Napoletana experience the place promises. Similarly, the rice balls were the best I've had in the US. The wine selection was great as well. The downside, however, was how much this cost. Before tip, a glass of wine, a medium pizza with no toppings, and three rice balls came to $55. Not a complete deal breaker, but a bit of a surprise. The Pie delivers on flavor, but choose when you visit carefully and be ready to spend. read more

The Pie - Classic Margherita Pie - Pizza Near Me - Port Jefferson, New York

See all

I've gone to The Pie many times with kids so have always had the pizza which is spectacular! This time however it was a kid free so we ventured to the food menu. Calamari to start I recommend the garlic dip! I had fettuccine Alfredo & added shrimp. My wife had the gnocchi, both excellent. I would recommend any of their desserts. Will visit again. If you go ask for Kerri as your waitress, she is hands down the best waitress I've ever dealt with read more

Came here a few times and while I enjoy the food and the authentic Neapolitan style pizza, I wish the price tag was a little friendlier. The pizzas run you around 20+ each and the pasta needs a lot of work. PIZZAS Thin, stretchy crust, chewy, stretchy cheese and a nice balance of flavors makes for quality Neapolitan style pies surprisingly authentic to what I experienced in my travels to Italy which can be hard to find, and is surprising for the area. I'm glad they're in port jeff. When it comes to Neapolitan pies simple is best imo. PASTA Have had their pasta a few times and since pasta is something that is relatively easier to cook at home what I really look for is pasta that tastes freshly made vs fried pasta that you can boil yourself. Unfortunately I did feel that the pasta tasted like the latter and doused heavily with oil, with toppings that were soggy (veggies) or dry (chicken) and for the price I def would have liked a better quality but at a place whose name is the pie shame on me for not sticking to the pies! I will probably come back here for the pizza for a nice occasion or celebration but it isn't a place where I keep on rotation just yet. Keep up the great work with the pizzas guys! read more

See all

Second Time back .. just as yummy! Really great atmosphere. Fantastic service never leave hungry for sure read more

The Pie - Margarita Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Port Jefferson, New York

See all

Super yummy and fast service! Reasonably priced especially for an individual margarita pie. I've never dined in, but when I've gone inside to pick up my order it seems like a cozy and family friendly dining spot. The pizza definitely has a bit of garlic (which I happen to love but you might want a piece of gum/mint afterward), a great sauce and the perfect amount of cheese. Yum! I need to try some more items off the menu at The Pie. read more

Good fresh pizza. Fresh ingredients. Salads are great too. This has been go to pizze place outside from Ginos in lake R. Will miss coming here ! read more

Really good coal oven pizza! Really good ambiance! Great waitress! Great salad of the day. Beer way overpriced - draft $9.

Came here for lunch while in the area and it was good. Cute decor in the place. Pizza was yummy. Service was great. I'd definitely come here again. read more

The Pie - a chandelier made of branches and lights - Pizza Near Me - Port Jefferson, New York

See all

Great pizza with fresh ingredients and friendly service. You can do 2 different toppings if you can't decide between all of their options. Loved the holiday light decorations and the restaurant was quiet and clean. read more

The Pie - Blanco - Pizza Near Me - Port Jefferson, New York

Popped in after picking up our grandson from the ferry. What a great decision. Kerry our waitress was amazing. Attentive, friendly and totally checked in on us throughout our meal. Pizza and salads were great. Can't wait to come back. read more

Such a warm and fun spot right near the waterfront in Port Jeff! The service was wonderful and our waitress was so attentive, had good recommendations, and had great energy all around. The pizzas were good and those that ordered pastas also enjoyed their meal. The desserts were also great here. The tiramisu and fried oreos were awesome. read more

Have to say the wait staff was very nice and it's not their fault. But this is a very unbiased review. This place is terrible. Absolutely flavorless everything. I can not believe this place has ANY stars. Mozzarella sticks and fried ravioli inherently have flavor, idk what they did but these had Zero! My daughters chicken fingers, just as bland, literally tasted like fried paper. The pizza. $30 for a med white pie with fried eggplant, terrible! Needed to add salt, garlic and pepper. Save yourself $100 and go to the hole in the wall pizza joint by whiskey barrel. Much cheaper and the pizza doesn't suck! Never going back again. read more

Sometimes you're just in the right place at the right time. We had a wedding to go to nearby later that day and were enjoying the lovely neighborhood when we decided to grab some lunch to hold us over. This place happened to be the closest. My mom, daughter and I ordered a plain Margarita pizza. Usually the three of us don't finish an entire pizza, but we could not stop ourselves, it was SOOOO GOOD!! One of the freshest most flavorful pies I have had in a long, long time. On top of amazing pizza, the service was fast and very friendly. If you're in the area, do not pass this place up!! read more

The Pie - This is where the magic happens. - Pizza Near Me - Port Jefferson, New York

Great Italian food. They serve a thin crispy crust brick oven pizza. We had our traditional pepperoni and cheese. Our appetizer was the crispy mozzarella sticks. Great food and atmosphere! read more

See all

My favorite pizza on LI. Perfectly cooked crust and slightly sweet sauce. The fresh mozzarella makes it. Get the large pie if you want to take any home because 2 people will easily take down a medium. The caramelized pear salad is amazing as well. read more

The Pie - Classic Margherita - Pizza Near Me - Port Jefferson, New York

I have no idea why this place has 3.5 stars on Yelp??? The Pie had the best Neapolitan pizza in Suffolk county area with thin crust that is crunchy, fluffy, and chewy all at once. I am a local and have been coming here for 7+ years or even more; The Pie is a must have staple of Port Jeff. Please go here and support local businesses! read more

The Pie - Classic Margherita Pie - Pizza Near Me - Port Jefferson, New York

I spent $200 on Mothers Day dinner tonight for my family, only to receive broken mussel shells all in my pasta. I quite literally choked about 3 times before I had to throw the entire dish out. EVERY BITE HAD BROKEN SHELLS IN IT. ALL OF THE SEAFOOD TASTED LIKE RUBBER. The chicken francese was dry & chewy and the penne was undercooked. Also this is the first time I've ordered from an Italian restaurant & didn't receive any complimentary bread with our food. Extremely disappointed & dissatisfied with our meal. *Edit* one of my guests just vomited from the seafood. NEVER AGAIN will I be ordering here read more

The Pie - BROKEN SHELLS ALL OVER MY FOOD - Pizza Near Me - Port Jefferson, New York

Stopped by the Pie for a Margarita Pizza. I called ahead of time for carry out and I was told that the Margarita Pizza was their best seller. The pie was ready in 10 minutes and it filled up for the entire day and night. I was born and raised in Boston, and find that New York style pizza is by far the best. The inside of The Pie is spacious, clean, and professional. I wouldn't have minded eating inside the restaurant. Additionally, I would like to say that $22 for a pizza is expensive, but it seems to be the mean on Long Island. That's New York for ya' read more

See all

Decided to take a drive out East and ended up in port Jeff. On the way we talked about getting some good pizza hopefully brick oven and when we saw this place we had to go in. Absolutely amazing lunch. The margarita was charred to perfection with a great undercarriage all throughout. The dough was light and crispy. The vegetable pasta was even better with all the veggies getting charred in the brick oven. If you like the taste like I do you will love it. Some people see this and think it's burned I see it and say delicious. Oh and the deep fried Oreos is a must !!!! read more

The Pie - Classic Margherita and Capellini Primavera - Pizza Near Me - Port Jefferson, New York

See all

BIG fan of The Pie. Fun Italian spot in downtown PJ. Nice menu with lots of options but not overwhelming. LOVE the thin, brick oven pizza. I always pair it with the gorgonzola salad. Staff and service are always very friendly and meeting needs of customers. Great menu for catering !!! read more

Honestly really delicious personal pie. So hard to find a good personal pie but it was cheesy and saucy and not too thin. Definitely will be coming back here !! read more

The Pie - Personal pie with garlic and basil - Pizza Near Me - Port Jefferson, New York

I can't say enough about The Pie. We came here for an impromptu dinner with a party of 10- 5 adults and 5 young (ages 4 and 6) children. This eatery in the heart of Port Jefferson not only served excellent food but purposely set us up right in front of the pizza oven so the kids could enjoy watching pizza being made while the adults talked. Our waitress Kerry made sure to learn all of their names and they each felt extra special as a result. It is not easy to accommodate a larger group with young children and they did so with bells on. After enjoying the fresh pizza and pasta we easily walked the few minutes to get ice cream and enjoy downtown PJ. Next time your looking for a family friendly eatery in this area please do not hesitate to check out The Pie- you won't be disappointed! read more

The Pie - Inside area by pizza oven - Pizza Near Me - Port Jefferson, New York

Consistently good whether it's pick-up or dine-in! When dining in, the food comes quick and the restaurant does a great job moving tables without negatively impacting the dining experience by making customers feel rushed. Quality food and quality service all around. read more

Have been here at least a dozen times. Went for a late lunch with my daughter around 2:30. We ordered what we often have. I had unsweetened iced tea, my daughter just water. Both tasted like nasty tap water. We ordered calamari Arrabbiata. The sauce was weak with a funky flavor. Did not have the usual kick or taste. We also ordered a large Neopolitan pizza which ordinarily wonderful. This one looked great on top but the bottom was mostly black. Granted it is a coal fired pie but in my opinion he didn't clean the oven and we had the outcome. I understand we came at an off time but you need to do the right thing in a kitchen. Please note I was an executive Chef for thirty five years so I know a little bit about food. I'm writing this off to them having a bad day or the wrong person in the kitchen. I will go back and I hope this was a one time occurrence read more

So we're back here because we can't agree on another place to go. The place hasn't changed at all. We ordered a standard large coal fired pie ... plus wifey ordered a lunch special: grilled eggplant sandwich, which she raved about. Me & grandson, Bobby knocked off the pie. It was OK. Price was very reasonable & we left happy. read more