Alfie’s Pizza

Best pizza on the island. My wife has can't eat gluten and they had a gluten free pie and it was…read moreamazing. I can eat anything and I had 2 slices with sausage and it was hot and very flavorful. Everyone should come and eat here. The owner even came over and asked how our food was and thanked us for coming.

We get Pelligrino's frequently. The pizza is consistently delicious, and nicely cooked. Their…read moremeatballs are excellent. The chicken tenders and fries are also enjoyable. The owner and their employees are very friendly and helpful.

Gluten free Onions and Peppers.

Sicilian Pie

See all

Neapolitan Pie

Pazzo Ristorante and Wood Fired Pizzeria

3.9(205 reviews)

4.4 mi

I'm a bit confused how my white bean and escarole soup had so many red kidney beans in it... I'm…read moredumbfounded that they sent meatballs in an unsealed container with a thin, watery sauce, and I'm dismayed that this awesome short rib and mushroom pie was so oily it saturated the pizza box. All of this, yet the food was still quite good despite all the misfortunes and mis-steps. I don't even know how to rate them ... 3.5 seems right, so do I go 4 stars for the solid flavors, or do l go with 3 because the pizza needed a third ingredient for complexity and a lot less grease, the white bean soup was made with red kidney beans, and the meatballs were in an ounce of this sauce... But that short rib pie could be something really special, I added a balsamic drizzle, even great with some horseradish. We definitely want to explore the menu more, am I right? Who else has tried em?

Right off the bat when you walk in you know it is different - the smell is AMAZING! The wood lends…read morea unique flavor and aroma to the food and the air! I had a couple of slices that were nice and thin, crispy and very flavorful. Dean, who is making the pies and doing the cooking, busy as he is, is one of the friendliest guys you will meet in a Pizza place! He says hello, welcomes you, and makes sure you know something about his offerings. Sure, its a small place and sometimes they are very busy and do not have all the time in the world to chat, but ask any question and Dean is happy to help! Maria is soft-spoken and kind, and the food is always top notch. Service can be slow at the counter, they have been understaffed a few times while I was there, just Dean and Maria. But the food is worth the wait. On another night, eight of us ate in the dining room, which is very attractive, and the food was excellent! We will be going back in a group again - especially after the Cruise Nights at East Wind in Wading River. Pete G.

Pazzo Ristorante and Wood Fired Pizzeria

See all

Meatballs

La Bistro

4.4(145 reviews)

4.4 mi

Ginger Calamari Salad ...amazing! Fresh, big, tasty, unique, FTW!…read more La Bistro a special treat every time we come here, explore the menu!

Love this place! I come here almost every day for lunch, staff is genuine and always greets me with…read morea smile. My order is always ready fast, and it is always delicious (Pepperoni and knots are the best I've had on the island)! If you're looking for good people and good food, you'll find it at La Bistro Wading River!

Love La Bistro! Ordered catering from them and everyone loved it!

See all

Marinelli’s Pizzeria and Restaurant

4.5(24 reviews)

3.2 mi

You got to love this place! Joes the best and is always putting out new fresh pizzas. Today I tried…read morethe grandma Ala vodka with ricotta cheese which was delicious! You want good classic pizza or to try something new, this is the place to go. Everyone's super friendly and it always smells amazing walking into this establishment. Great sound beach spot

Amazing food, great service and comparable prices. I moved out of Sound Beach to Sayville on the…read moresouth shore and I still go back to Marinelli's for my pizza on pizza crust Fridays! Well worth the trip!

Interior

Marinelli’s Pizzeria and Restaurant - Deep Dish Old World Pizza Fresh mozzarella, plum tomato sauce, breadcrumbs, garlic, olive oil, basil and romano. Absolutely incredible

See all

Deep Dish Old World Pizza Fresh mozzarella, plum tomato sauce, breadcrumbs, garlic, olive oil, basil and romano. Absolutely incredible

Alfredo's Pizzeria

3.3(187 reviews)

4.0 mi

Omg AMAZING! The Pizza was Awesome, the Garlic knots delicious, mozzarella sticks GREAT, and the…read moreCheese Cake SOOOO OUT OF THIS WORLD DELICIOUS! I honestly liked it better than Cheesecake Factorys cheese cake! My Son ordered Chicken Alavodka , A good amount of chicken , the portion size was amazing for the price ! I highly recommend you don't go to Any other Pizza Place , They r Amazing at Alfredo's in Middle Island NY !

Amazing service and the pizza is delicious. Definitely a great place with old school ambiance.read more

The Italian Hero

Dining area

See all

Buffalo Chicken Slice

Pompei Pizza Restaurant

3.5(129 reviews)

1.1 mi

Firstly I'm a retired executive chef and have opened and run three Italian restaurants over my 26…read moreyrs of experience.My family eats at Pompei 's 2-3 times a year when I visit from Tennessee. The food has always been good but this time it was excellent with huge portions. My wife had the clams and absolutely loved it. Only my dad could finish all his! It comes with some nice warm types of bread and real butter pads. If you aren't totally full they give you mini cannolis at the end. The service was prompt and attentive, our waitress seemed fairly new and inexperienced but she made up for all the little errors with a smile and " ill take care of that immediately". Since the full remodel the place is very elegant and very comfortable, beautifully appointed.Well the only quibble I had was and I don't know if its I'm from Tennessee or i its just I know exactly food costs but I'm guessing the menu was up 25 to 50 percent since last time we were here before the remodel. Maybe its just New York but here 's the deal great food, good portions,good service, excellent ambiance just bring your wallet.

This used to be our favorite local Italian restaurant for take-out and dining in…read more No longer after the horrible service we got for delivery via Door Dash. Gave us the wrong sauce on the penne primavera. Menu stated cream sauce and I requested substitute red sauce instead. Was delivered with cream sauce. Called restaurant and got nothing but arguments from person who answered phone, who said my American born husband cannot read English, to the "manager" who seemed totally unaware that the menu stated cream sauce. Finally "manager" read menu item and realized it says "cream sauce." Said they could not deliver what we wanted and that we had to pick it up. Was able to instantly get refund from Door Dash, plus $10 Door Dash credit.

Options

Slices, Sandwiches, and Pinwheels

See all

Outside

Branchinelli's

4.0(207 reviews)

3.3 mi

Never went here before. Always go to the Hauppauge location. And you know what, the Miller Place…read morelocation has Hauppauge beat. To be fair I only had their plain regular slice ... but the Miller Place Branchinelli's was def better than Hauppauge . I see a great battle starting to brew. Next I will judge the dinner entrees Let's get it on!

Typically I would tell anyone who would listen, that Branchinelli's is one of the best Pizza spots…read moreon Long Island. As far as what you would can consider a "Great NY Slice" this place is a must try. If you know pizza, you know that consistency is not easy. Lately, Branchinelli's has been slacking and I can only attribute it to management, turnover and no one paying attention to the kids behind the counter. Whether it is missing items on take-out orders, or lately just rushing through the pie making motions. Two nights ago, we ordered two pies, only to arrive home and find two undercooked slop pies. Pepperoni was thrown on with carelessness with mounds of it all over the place and it was cooked line the pepperoni was an afterthought. The crust was under cooked and overall a soggy mess. This is my favorite place.... Slow it down people and pay attention to detail. Maintain pride and quality along with consistency. The owner needs to be more present and make sure the kids are executing! Attached is a picture of an Undercooked soggy pepperoni Grandma Pie

Inside

Salad with mozzarella

See all

Chicken Parm Hero

Rocky Point Pizza

3.2(89 reviews)

1.2 mi

Just go down the road not this place. I don't even know where to start with this one. I've lived on…read moreLong Island my entire life I've been to pizzerias quite extensively. Including working at one when I was younger, so I really know how these places work. This pizzeria has to be one of the stingiest non-agreeable worst customer service place I've ever experienced. This place operates with the mentality like they're the only pizzeria in a 5 mile radius when there's three pizzerias down the road. I understand the stinginess when you are low on money, but there is a thin line between price gouging and good accounting. On the other hand when you do price gouge to increase margins customer service has to go up degrading customer service along with price gouging has to be one of the worst combinations I've ever seen.

Rocky Point Pizza is one of our go-to spots, and for good reason -- the food is always really good…read moreand they've been great to deal with. They also worked with us when we ordered pizzas for a birthday party, which made the whole experience even better. This time we ordered an eggplant hero (with Alfredo sauce instead of red sauce), an eggplant rollatini roll, and a meatball hero. The eggplant hero with Alfredo was amazing. The eggplant rollatini is always fantastic -- easily our favorite eggplant out of the local places. And the meatball hero was great too. No misses. We also really like their pizza and end up ordering from here about every other week, which is probably the strongest endorsement I can give. Inside has that classic pizza joint vibe -- perfect when you just want to grab a quick slice while you're out and about. One small suggestion that would make them even better: it would be awesome if individual slices were available for online ordering. You can order slices when you walk in or call, but having that option online would be super convenient for nights when we just want a slice or two for the kids and heroes or meals for us. Overall, great food, reliable, and easy to recommend. We'll definitely keep ordering!

Love that we had it delivered to Friendship Beach

See all

Grana

3.9(432 reviews)

17.8 mi

Small place with very good service and wonderful food... reservation is a must for the weekendread more

7/30/25 Grana is always a special treat. It is close by Home…read moreand we have been there several times in between my reviews. This evening we chose to sample two of their appetizers. Baked clams and a grilled artichoke salad. As an entrée hubby chose to have the pasta Bolognese is it and I tried a pizza that had zucchini, flowers, and a medley cheese, a white pizza that I found wonderful and delicious. Our Server was attentive. The wine is always an adventure. The venue is cozy, but it tends to be very loud. The food is always tasty and different.