Gina service was outstanding and lovely girl and the food was good hot and on time I couldn't ask for a better server. and it was a great place to eat. read more

The ambiance is very nice. Big spacious bar area, and the noise didn't permeate into the dining area. Big plus. The staff is all very nice and attentive - from Jenn the hostess to Johnny our waiter and the very nice bus person who kept out water filled up always lol. Food was a bit inconsistent. We had grilled calamari arrabiatti style. The calamari from piece to piece was different- texturally they didn't match. It was a bit off putting but we ate most of it anyway because some were pretty good. Gluten free penne à la vodka was good - it's funny, when you go to a restaurant, most times you get so much food you are like who the hell is going to eat all of that, but when you don't get a huge portion, you are like - why the hell isn't it a gargantuan portion?!? This fell towards the latter - probably exactly a portion size. It was a good gluten free pasta. Chicken Paillard was the other dish we ordered- the actual chicken was delicious- very well seasoned and cooked. The rest of the salad was just okay - I've had Paillard may times and this was a disjointed version of it. The celery was a nice touch. Probably more of a 3.5 star experience because 4 is pretty high, and there really wasn't much that wasn't pretty good. Would return. Would also dine at the bar. read more

Always have a great meal at Savino's. Food is so delicious! We were thrilled to land last minute NYE dinner reservation due to cancellations. We started with a drink in bar area. Pretty crowded at 6:30 (expected) We were seated ahead of our reservation time, I'm sure to get us in & out as quick as possible. But we were not rushed at all. We were so fortunate to be in the small room in the front..which is significantly quieter and more intimate than rest of place. My only knock on Savino's is: it gets extremely loud when crowded. Enjoyed Calamari and grilled octopus apps. Calamari was delicious but a little chewy. Happens sometimes. Dinner I had an amazing swordfish with crab meat & bearnaise sauce on top. It was perfectly seasoned and cooked. Enjoyed immensely! Husband had stuffed flounder, other friend papardelle with seafood, and lastly chicken Franchese. Everyone loved their food. Our waiter was very congenial & attentive. We were too full for dessert. Would have stayed in bar area for drinks but it was packed by time our dinner was through. Love the rustic atmosphere. Hate the crowd & loud..but it's a holiday. Expected. Love this place..we will be back read more

See all

Food was excellent great specials. The service was fast and efficient. And the location and vibe just awesome. It is a tucked away.

I have dined here many times. This eve my wife and i decided to stop in and share a bottle of wine. The female blond bartender came over took our order and that was pretty much it. Not once did she come over to ask if we wanted a menu or pour a glass of fairly expensive wine. The bar was crowded yet she would chat with her regulars. Never looking around to see if anyone needed anything. I am out on average about 5 nights weekly. Never have i had a worse experience!!! read more

Came here for my dad's birthday, we all enjoyed ourselves. To start we had the baked clams and calamari, the baked clams were nice and golden. For my entree I got scallops oreganata and it came with risotto and veggies, it was so delicious and the perfect portion. The drinks were also really good. Solid spot, they have a cute outdoor space also. read more

My family and I had a great time celebrating hubby's 82 year old aunt's engagement. We had a private event space with plenty of room for mingling. Briana was our server and she was very attentive. We started off with a choice of salads and soup. I opted for their Caesar salad but was disappointed that it wasn't a true Ceasar. It was just romaine lettuce with Caesar dressing and croutons. Our kiddo opted for the stracciatella soup but didn't care for it. I had some and it was slightly salty but it tasted good. They allowed my daughter to order from the kids menu and she went with spaghetti and meatballs, and loved it. I had their chicken francese, which was OK. My MIL had flounder francese and hubby had the chicken parm. Everyone was happy with their dish. The portions were large and the flavors were decent. When it was time for cake, they served us coffee with our dessert. We were able to order additional drinks from the bar with no issue. Everyone was happy with the event. We did not want for anything. The decor is nice and everything is clean. It was joyous occasion and we had a wonderful time. read more

See all

Disgusting. Every course was terrible. The salad was swimming in a pungent balsamic dressing: Disgusting. The Chicken Francese was dry & tough the Linguine was swimming in salt & butter: Disgusting. The tiramisu was probably a week old. It was flat and watered down: Disgusting! Every aspect of the meal was Disgusting. The tap water was good. If you want really bad Italian American food in a loud obnoxious setting, this place is for you. read more

Food, ambience and service great. Haven't been there in a while and can't wait to go back. Forgot how good it was and even though they closed for a bit....they returned just as good if not better. read more

This is our second time coming here. The first time was last year and it was terrible . We figured we try again . Terrible again ! The chicken was gamey , and the calamari was hard , hubby ordered pasta puttanesca, very underwhelming . Won't be going back . Just a pizza place trying to be an upscale Italian restaurant. read more

Great place in a "hidden location". Just east of town of Port Jefferson. Good Italian food. Nice, clean modern look inside. A TOTAL mismatch from the outside. Great parking lot. Nice bar. Good seating inside and out. Food is very good. Had the stuffed rigatoni with lobster and shrimp. Very good. Light heavy cream sauce. Definitely a place to come back and come often. read more

Savino's Hideaway - Stuffed Rigatoni - Pizza Near Me - Mount Sinai, New York

Always great delicious food, exceptional staff, with excellent service!! We Love the indoor dining & bar are as well as their outdoor bar and firepit - lots of fun times!! read more

Just want to thank Maria for the cozy table in the little room for our Anniversary. Frank and I had the most delicious dinner the service was excellent We have celebrated many events in the Filiberto family with Savinos and have always been so satisfied My lobster dinner was delicious and Franks rigatoni stuffed with lobster was also delicious Looking forward to celebrating on the Nov 9 for franks birthday Love u guys. T read more

Savino's Hideaway - Lobster and stuffed rigatoni - Pizza Near Me - Mount Sinai, New York

See all

Although the food itself was okay, the service was terrible. Our waitress (Cheryl) was incredibly rude and the experience was unpleasant. We arrived with a party of 8 of family and friends. After around 5-10 min of being seated the waitress came over to take our order. We asked for a few more minutes as not everyone had decided on a dish - she rolled her eyes and walked away without a word. After eventually taking our order, we asked if she could take a group photo for us. One of the teens at the table was having a bad day so he didn't smile for the picture. Then she said, "Did you get beat as a child?" right in front of him and his parents. We were all shocked at her comment. As for the food: Sea Scallops Oreganata: 4/5 The risotto was super flavorful and the scallops were delicious as well. My favorite dish of the night. Chicken Marsala: 3/5 I think this dish was pretty average - just regular chicken marsala. White Clam Sauce Linguini: 2/5 The pasta was way too oily and had too much lemon in my opinion. Overall, food was average but the service ruined my experience. The only thing saving this from being a one star review is the fact that the food wasn't bad. I will definitely not be returning. read more

See all

This was one of the best meals I have had all year. We went there to celebrate my birthday dinner on New Years Eve. It was crowded but we did get seated pretty quickly with the reservation which was nice. The food was phenomenal and I loved that we were able to sit in the back room because it was a quieter experience. The restaurant was decorated beautifully still from the Christmas season. Overall this is one of my favorite restaurants on long island and I will definitely return to eat there soon. read more

Five stars for service. Three stars for food. My husband and I came here for Valentine's Day. We had a 7pm reservation but we were running a bit early and arrived at 6:30. They happily escorted us to a table in the back room. It was quaint, cozy and dimly lit - the perfect Valentine's Day vibe! The second we sat down we were asked our drink order. How could I know what I want when I just sat down? We weren't even handed drinks menus which I had to ask for. The bread that arrived to our table was absolutely delicious but we wanted to try the garlic bread. It came out in a huge loaf which was perfect for next-day leftovers. It was warm and fresh! The calamari that arrived was great but I prefer breaded calamari. For my entree, I ordered the penne a la vodka. It was steaming hot which was great but took forever to cook down to eat. My husband enjoyed his meal. We ordered the chocolate lava cake with chocolate ice cream which was yummy. Our waiter went missing multiple times throughout our meal. After waiting 15 minutes after dessert, our waiter was nowhere to be found so I asked another waiter for our check. It was an enjoyable meal. Service could have been better. read more

See all

Everything here is delicious! The staff is magnificent! The dining area is relaxing and tranquil. I love this place!

I used to go here but after a few years I noticed a big difference in the egg plant parma. Was very disappointed. They must have changed hands. The egg plant Parma. Used to be the very best now it is the worst unless they went back to the original recipe. Most everything else was good. The old slogan is true; If it works don't fix it. read more

I went to Savino's Hideaway for the first time this past Saturday. What a fun, cozy but also busy with a touch of country class atmosphere! The wait staff was young and made a couple minor mistakes. I could easily overlook them though because they were friendly, engaging and did a nice job considering how busy they were. My lady enjoyed the chicken parm which is her go-to at most Italian restaurants. My red snapper was spectacular along with the delicious side of risotto. I highly recommend making a trip to Savinos! read more

Savino's Hideaway - Chicken Parmigiana Dinner & Red Snapper Special - Pizza Near Me - Mount Sinai, New York

Wanted to update my last review after attending my future niece in-laws bridal shower. Savino's did an expressive job serving with perfection and satisfying everyone's needs. The staff was very professional and friendly. My favorite server was John M. This guy was as busy as a bee and extremely personable. Major asset to this establishment. I told him that myself! Salad, soup, entree and dessert was delicious and satisfying. Our party room was cute and cozy. Restaurant and bathroom were very clean . Plenty of parking. I appreciate this hidden gem in Mt. Sinai! read more

See all

Savinos Hideaway is a throwback to a time when lunch during the week was an event to be savored. We enjoyed a cocktail at the bar before being seated. The ambiance in the bar area is spectacular. My friend and I were seated at a window view table in one of the smaller dining rooms. We sat and enjoyed a well paced and delicious lunch that we lingered over for almost three hours. Service was attentive bit not obtrusive and never once did our server use the ubiquitous and annoying phrase "perfect" in response to a menu choice. The food (mussels, chicken Parm, eggplant rollatini) was outstanding. Overall, a great experience that will definitely result in many future visits. read more

Our second trip to Savino's was underwhelming. I so enjoyed our first time here so I was pretty disappointed. We started with calamari arrabbiata which was delicious. The portion was tremendous for $12. We also had mussels which I didn't try but they were very well received by the table. We asked our waitress to bring us more bread (which was delicious) for the leftover broth from the mussels, she said okay then proceeded to take the bowl of broth away and then never came back with more bread. Everyone in our party who ordered pasta loved their food but unfortunately I was not one of those people. My stuffed flounder was basically flavorless, although the risotto it came with was very good. I tried the carbonara and thought it was great. The drinks were inconsistent; my sister and I ordered the same drink and mine looked and tasted completely different. There was a lot of good and a lot of not so good about our experience, but the overall inconsistency is a turnoff. A positive however, it is very affordable. Portions are large and prices are very reasonable. read more

Savino's's Hideaway is our go to spot for every special event with family and friends. In the winter, it's cozy and inviting inside, and in the spring, summers, and fall, everyone at our marina gathers on Sundays to wind down the weekend on the back patio and bar.The atmosphere is always amazing, the food is off the charts delicious, and the owners and staff make you feel right at home - friendly, accommodating, always welcoming. Every dish is better than the next, but some of my favorites are the chicken franchise, eggplant, Parmesan, and the butterfly shrimp over spinach in a rich, garlic scampi sauce. No wonder why this place has been around forever! If you haven't been, you're missing out on a true gem read more

See all

I had the pleasure of dining at Savino's Hideaway in Mt. Sinai, and I must say, it was an exceptional experience. From the moment I walked in, I was greeted warmly by the staff and made to feel right at home. One of the standout dishes at Savino's Hideaway is their Caesar salad. The crisp romaine lettuce was perfectly dressed with a creamy and tangy Caesar dressing, topped with freshly grated Parmesan cheese and crunchy croutons. The balance of flavors was impeccable, and each bite was a delight. The attention to detail in preparing this classic salad was evident, and it truly elevated the dining experience. Another dish that stole the show was the mussels marinara. The mussels were cooked to perfection, tender and succulent, swimming in a rich and flavorful marinara sauce. The sauce had just the right amount of tanginess and was beautifully seasoned with aromatic herbs and spices. It was evident that the chefs at Savino's Hideaway take pride in their culinary skills, as this dish was a true masterpiece. The service at Savino's Hideaway was outstanding. The staff was attentive, friendly, and knowledgeable about the menu. They were quick to provide recommendations and made sure that all our needs were met throughout the meal. The wait staff was prompt and efficient, ensuring that our dining experience was seamless and enjoyable. The ambiance of Savino's Hideaway was charming and cozy. The dim lighting, accompanied by soft music, created a warm and inviting atmosphere. The restaurant's rustic decor and comfortable seating added to the overall ambiance, making it a perfect place to enjoy a leisurely meal with friends or loved ones. I must also mention the value for money at Savino's Hideaway. The portion sizes were generous, and the quality of the food was exceptional. The prices were reasonable, considering the high-quality ingredients and the skillful execution of each dish. It was clear that the restaurant values its customers and strives to provide an excellent dining experience. In conclusion, I highly recommend Savino's Hideaway in Mt. Sinai. Whether you're a fan of their delicious Caesar salad or their mouthwatering mussels marinara, you're in for a treat. With their amazing service, cozy ambiance, and delectable food, Savino's Hideaway is a gem of a restaurant that should not be missed. read more

Perfect spot in the summer for dinner. The blackened salmon was good 8/10. My sister got the farfalle Primavera 10/10! So creamy and flavorful you can always add a protein as well. For dessert - The lava cake was more of a dark chocolate it was good but I'm not sure I'd get it again. The moose cake was perfect it was more so of a whipped chocolate in a cup. Would go back again! read more

Savino's Hideaway - Blackened salmon - Pizza Near Me - Mount Sinai, New York

My memories of this place go back to Capt. Roman's inn. Back in the early 60's it was a great place to catch lunch. As. Life long resident of the area I've seen it go through several changes. Even a closure and reopening! One thing you could count on the food!!! It always tasted as it was made by someone who loved preparing it. My wife and I had our wedding dinner there. This past Valentine's Day we ate there and the food and service was excellent. The place does get loud but it's the sound of people talking and enjoying their meal. (Like when I was young and our whole family gathered for Sunday dinner). Savino's is a gem hidden in Mount Sinai. If you haven't tried it give it a try. read more

Not bad.. busy place.. parking is full but I got lucky especially on a Friday night.. nice classy ambiance.. food is ok.. the usual Italian.. we had reservations so I recommend calling in.. from the parking lot u have to walk around for the entrance.. we got confused we entered the back door read more

Savino's Hideaway - Margarita pizza - Pizza Near Me - Mount Sinai, New York

See all

Food is very good.....service is top notch, .....it can get very noisy sometimes, but request quiet area away from bar. Bar is always crowded and a happy place. Speciality drinks are terrific and not terribly expensive. read more

Great service staff and ambiance. The food never disappoints. You go once you will never want to go anywhere else

Great service; perfectly-cooked seafood and risotto. The specials menu had depth. A great atmosphere for a dinner alone or with guests. The bar area had the game on and the staff were incredibly friendly and helpful. I drove nearly three hours from the city to eat here for the first time and was not disappointed. read more

Was there on Saturday 2/22/25.Party of 6 with reservations.Hostess looked miserable.Waited 20 minutes before we had a waiter come to table.Ordered drinks and they were very strong and not able to enjoy them.Food was OK but not as good as previous times we ate there. read more

Nice ambiance and I loved our server. Underwhelmed by the shrimp oreganata. Needed sauce. I think more dessert choices would be appreciated, but overall good food and a nice experience. read more

went for dinner with my wife, not my first trip, I order seafood dinner with pasta, What was served lobster leg in shell and i think it was some kind of pasta. I ate the lobster piece in shell and started to eat rest of dish, What followed was pure salt , asked the server to try this and tell me why this dish was all salt, The server removed the dish and told me they will give me free dessert for this terrible meal. because i ate the lobster piece. AS result have not been back, or anyone that I know, This has to be My worst experience ever read more

OK, so a few weeks ago we ordered clams casino and literally had to spit them out tonight gave them another try and got pasta that was severely overcooked along with a sub, par flounder francese Sat at the outside bar tonight and was the worst dining experience that I can recall- due to the fact they have a single bartender acting as waiter and bartender for for a large dining area. Really sad to see a great place like this going downhill so quickly. read more

One of the best on Long Island Service is impeccable Food cooked to perfection Menu has great choices Ambiance is really nice read more

I came with a party of 16 and the food came out super fast and hot. We did not feel rushed and the staff were all super friendly. Always made sure we had everything we needed. The place is also very pretty. Will be coming back read more

We sat at the bar and the blonde server, Gina, was an excellent bartender that provided some amazing mango and espresso drinks that were just the right kind of sweet!! She brought a fun personality and vibe to the atmosphere that made us want to stay all night! Definitely recommend this place for a fun uplifting time and good drinks! read more

Love this place. Family owned and the serve great food for a fair price. One of my family favorites!

Ever since Savino's renovated, this restaurant is just a great looking place with wonderful atmosphere. Unfortunately this is where it may begin and end as far as having a pleasurable dining experience Continuing with the aesthetics, the ceiling redesign and its acoustic behavior is absolutely the loudest dining experience you will ever come across. You would think diners are screaming at each other just to overcome the noise level. From a menu perspective, the choices are what you would expect from a traditional Italian menu. However, if you stray outside the norm of traditional, most dishes are grossly over done. The sauces you will find extremely thick and over seasoned. Most meat dishes are found to be swimming in gravy. If you order a steak, you once again will find the dish served with unnecessary sauce on top which will disappoint your experience. Tonight I ordered the special, Local Stripe Bass, no surprise what could have been a pleasant dish was served with a slop of sauce on top of which I found to be a disguise to make up for what should have been a fine cuisine meal. My dinner date ordered the Veal special and no surprise served with an over done preparation consisting of more gravy consistency. Recommendations: Install aesthetically pleasing acoustic tiles. They don't cost a lot of money and it will deaden the sound throughout Please re-examine your dish preparation and consider my suggestions. Most dishes are just way over prepared and whether you choose, beef, chicken or fish, allow the diner to actually enjoy the food. Another example are your vegetables. I ordered a side of sautéed spinach, there was so much garlic used, I didn't need the spinach. The bowl was left on the table! I live local and will return... you will find similar reviews pertaining to noise and food. I can tell you Italian food is tricky, however, the owners truly should consider an unannounced change in recipe. It should be tough to screw up steak and chicken, but if you can have a better steak at Texas Roadhouse, this should be very telling! Savino's don't let a full parking lot which fills your pockets stop you from improving!!! read more

Savino's Hideaway - Savino's Hideaway - Pizza Near Me - Mount Sinai, New York

The food at Savino's is incredible with a large menu of options but the service is why we continue to go there. Cheryl has usually been our waitress when my wife and I have gone there. Cheryl has not only been very pleasant and knowledgeable about the dishes but recommends specials and lunches that I loved (eg. the hideaway sandwich, the tortellini special and various deserts). She also takes the time to chat and make an occasional joke which we appreciate! I highly recommend going to Savino's for the food and to ask for Cheryl (if you can get her). Bill and Mary J. read more