Never went here before. Always go to the Hauppauge location. And you know what, the Miller Place location has Hauppauge beat. To be fair I only had their plain regular slice ... but the Miller Place Branchinelli's was def better than Hauppauge . I see a great battle starting to brew. Next I will judge the dinner entrees Let's get it on! read more

Typically I would tell anyone who would listen, that Branchinelli's is one of the best Pizza spots on Long Island. As far as what you would can consider a "Great NY Slice" this place is a must try. If you know pizza, you know that consistency is not easy. Lately, Branchinelli's has been slacking and I can only attribute it to management, turnover and no one paying attention to the kids behind the counter. Whether it is missing items on take-out orders, or lately just rushing through the pie making motions. Two nights ago, we ordered two pies, only to arrive home and find two undercooked slop pies. Pepperoni was thrown on with carelessness with mounds of it all over the place and it was cooked line the pepperoni was an afterthought. The crust was under cooked and overall a soggy mess. This is my favorite place.... Slow it down people and pay attention to detail. Maintain pride and quality along with consistency. The owner needs to be more present and make sure the kids are executing! Attached is a picture of an Undercooked soggy pepperoni Grandma Pie read more

Branchinelli's - Pepperoni Grandma Pie... Undercooked and soggy. - Italian Near Me - Miller Place, New York

The best meatball heros. Flavorful meatballs unlike most italian restaurants where they're bready and gray looking. I travel for both of their locations read more

Delicious baked clams, bread and house salad. Chicken parm and ravioli are also delicious. Very good waitstaff. Thank you for another delicious meal! read more

This is our "Go to" Italian restaurant. We probably visit several times a month! I especially enjoy the "Hot and Cold" salad. My daughter the specialty penne alla vodka. read more

Branchinelli's - A specialty penne alla vodka - Italian Near Me - Miller Place, New York

See all

Two options- sit down restaurant with larger menu or pizza bar. Opted for quick grab-and-go pizza slices and garlic knots. We sat down at the counter to eat but were kindly told we could enjoy the tables in the dining room if we wanted. Original slice was my favorite, and Margherita was 2nd best. Grandmas slice is thick and super cheesy with flavorful marinara sauce. Garlic knots were great- doughy and warm. read more

Branchinelli's - Pizza and Garlic Knots - Italian Near Me - Miller Place, New York

Branchinelli's is very generous with their seasonings when it comes to their food and other restaurants should learn from them. Hungry? You won't be waiting long for your food after you place your order! Service 5/5 Food 5/5 Cleanliness 5/5 My boyfriend and I decided to visit Branchinelli's for dinner. I'm really glad we decided on this restaurant because everything was fantastic! Everyone was welcoming and very friendly. The restaurant is very clean and everything smelled delicious. I didn't see any red flags with the staff handling food. Seneca was our server for the evening and we loved him. He did an excellent job, was very polite, professional, very attentive. We were happy was our server and we are very pleased with the service he had provided. We sat down and Seneca served us a basket of warm bread. Well, I should really say that the bread basket was hot and fresh. The two of us agree the focaccia bread tasted great and based off of that, we thought about ordering pizza. We ordered fried calamari (single size), chicken parm (dinner), veal parm (dinner) with a side of ziti. For dessert, we ordered cheesecake and cannoli to take home. My goodness, everything was scrumptious! Guys, I recommend you order dessert. If you'd like more detail on what we've ordered, please continue reading below. Their portion sizes are big. We couldn't finish our meal. A single sized order of fried calamari that was more than enough for us to share. I don't know what they did to the marinara but it was phenomenal. They use real squid and yes, that matters (to me, anyway). Our Chicken and Veal Parm dinners came out piping hot on a metal plate that they've placed on top of the dinner plate. . Two servings of ziti with marinara was served and I was impressed. As I have mentioned at the beginning of this review, the restaurant is very generous with their seasonings! I highly recommend coming to Branchinelli's and we're definitely stopping by again when we're in the area. read more

Branchinelli's - Chicken Parmigiana dinner - Italian Near Me - Miller Place, New York

See all

Garlic knots are $0.50!!!!! Pretty big place, I like that you can sit in or do take out. Grandma pie was yummy, but probably shouldn't eat more than one slice in a sitting because it did feel a bit heavy. Tried the spinach capenollini and was a little disappointed. Didn't feel like a pasta dish as much as a soup of cheese. Waitress recommended adding Alfredo sauce but then it became too heavy. Worked as a good dip for the garlic knots, though! If they offered it as an appetizer where you could dip the knots in this, like spinach artichoke dip, I would definitely be a fan read more

Branchinelli's - Grandma Pizza - Italian Near Me - Miller Place, New York

See all

Love love this place! The food is always delicious! Staff super friendly and on top of things. We are regular clients and every meal is delicious! A def recommend! read more

Amazing pizza and a perfect location! The crust was crispy, the toppings were fresh, and the whole place had such a fun, laid-back vibe. Easily one of the best pizza spots around! read more

It's. Become my go to Italian food restaurant. I pass at less 3 other Italian restaurants to get there. Best pizza , chicken parm , I've been there with a large group, all gave it 5 stars read more

these people are amazing! To open during the snowstorm to provide food for those need such as our drivers fireman is absolutely act of stewardship for our community! today was empty because of the storm as you can imagine, but yet they opened and took a financial hit to do so. Essential workers get a free warm meal before heading out into the brutal cold to keep us all safe thank you Branchinelli's. ! read more

My favorite restaurant . Everyone does a great job . The food is great! Love the baked clams, Eggplant Parmigiana & chicken parmigiana.

I've been coming here since I was a little girl, well, the Hauppauge location. This was my first time here. This has become a favorite over the years for our family. Every trip I take up to New York, this is one of my 1st stops and 1 of my favorites. Their pizza is great but they have delicious Italian food as well. My favorite thing to order is the quattro pali, 2 balls of mozzarella and 2 meatballs. It's in the most delicious red sauce. I also enjoy getting the hot and cold salad, which is absolutely delicious with their lemon dressing. The Buffalo chicken pizza is a staple as well. I never knew they had tartufo so I was excited when I found out they had it on the menu as it's my favorite dessert. They also have the best Italian ices. Marco and Anthony were working on this busy Friday night, which is nice to see the owners behind the pizza making. This is a real good family owned, local spot, with authentic food, good service and a homey feel. read more

See all

Wanted to try a new Italian spot and decided on this place. We always drive past it and figured it was time to finally try it. It was a busy night so we just decided to do takeout. Glad we tried the food here. Everything we got was do delicious! Here's what we ordered: - small tossed salad with Italian dressing and chicken - grandma pizza (pie): thin crust pan pizza with mozzarella, a touch if garlic and topped with crushed plum tomatoes - buffalo chicken pizza: Neapolitan pizza topped with spicy chicken pieces, blue cheese sauce and mozzarella cheese - quattro pali: 2 meatballs and mozzarella in tomato sauce The food was really good here. I plan to come back and dine-in to try other stuff on their menu. read more

See all

Branchinelli's is my go to local pizza place. Pizza is consistently good every time and they always have great service. I usually go for a classic slice with some garlic knots, and pair it with a Coke. They are great and not overly garlicky. I definitely recommend checking them out! read more

Branchinelli's - Italian Near Me - Miller Place, New York

Came here on a weekday lunch! This place was pretty busy, but we were still seated immediately! Great service! She was attentive and nice! The bread basket was delicious! It paired well with the soup and shrimp oreganata! The sauce was delicious in the shrimp! So garlicky and lemony! The bread was used for dipping all that goodness! The soup was perfect for a cold winter day! Very tasty! The prices are also super reasonable! Will definitely be back! A nice casual restaurant to hang out any time and have an anytime meal!!!! read more

See all

I always have a good experience here, the food is very delicious and I love their fried chicken cutlets, they are seasoned very good. The dining room was pretty dirty when we were there almost every table was left dirty for the entirely of our meal. The waitress was attentive to us... just suggest cleaning the dining room while other guest are there it's sometimes a little off putting read more

Branchinelli's - Italian Near Me - Miller Place, New York

Pricey but really good food. The chicken parm hero and pie is fantastic. Nice looking restaurant and clean.

Today my family and I ate here I just need to come on and say they young man that's was our waiter was absolutely amazing ! He was so polite and on top of his job ... shout out to the parents that raised that young man .... The manners the work ethic as a parent I would want someone to recognize that .... Food was amazing as always but I had to share how great this kid was ! read more

They are so nice there. the food is so fast I would rather eat this than McDonald's! They also have lots of workers there too! They can improve on their bathroom though. The fries and chicken is very good! I go here a lot of times!! I hope they improve their bathrooms though. read more

best pizza on LI-not skimpy with the toppings! Pasta Branchinelli is a must try! Staff is great!

This is our go to restaurant for dinner. Large menu from salads to heroes and everything in between. Pizza is also available for takeout or eat in. My favorite is veal parm with ziti. Second is rigatoni Branchinelli. read more

The pizza is hands down one of the Best I have ever had; both the neopolitan & sicilian pies.

Branchinelli's Miller Place is a casual Italian pizzeria restaurant. Hubby and I started with the fried calamari and fried zucchini. They were both crispy and well prepared. The marinara sauce that accompanied them was light and flavorful. Hubby ordered the baked pasta Branchinelli, which was a rigatoni like pasta with sausage, mushrooms and a tomato sauce with melted mozzarella. It was an ample portion and it was served piping hot. He enjoyed it very much. I opted for the chicken bruschetta. Fried chicken cutlets topped with ripe tomatoes, basil, and fresh mozzarella. The topping was very fresh and flavorful and the cutlets were crispy. It was a very large portion and I had to take some of it home. This was our first experience at this location and we enjoyed the food very much. read more

See all

Best Tasting Food and best Customer Service Experience and Reasonable Prices employees was very helpful

A Paula S. summarizes my feelings on this Miller Place facility. Whether eating in or during the chaos of picking up one of maybe over 50 a take out orders ( we live about 1/2 mile away) that we have bought since it opened.... the staff is very robotic and unfriendly, the counter staff is also lacks any emotion or eye contact .... negative aspect of the millenial workforce. However the real measure when you get past the service and people is the food. A LOT of pizza and italian competition in RP, MP, MS, SB etc They are not the best plain pie by about 5 places according to my "experts" (smile) However the buffalo chicken pizza has NO PEER and is stunning and tasty. Also their vegetable lazagna which they sadly only have on Friday and Saturday is worth the trip. While portions are large pound for pound 9f per entree per person its a bit pricey. I would prefer a less impressive pile of food in the teens $$ instead of having to take half my plate home for $26. Quality not quantity. And looking at Americas waistline we could use some restraint. (I get it from the business andn turn of the table per minute $$$ perspective.) Just saying expensive. read more

Branchinelli's - Buffalo pizza - Italian Near Me - Miller Place, New York

It's a family go to each week with pastas and's pizzas, always delicious and the staff is very kind. The site itself is really cute and low lit Italian vibes, haven't sat down yet but it looks cute. read more

Love the wait staff, love the vibe, the tomatoes sauce and the sauces in general BUT the chef needs to spend a week in Italy- to learn how to cook pasta , it MUST be Al Dente and NOT MUSH. read more

Friendly staff. Delicious food. Exceptional pizza! Love that you can have a great dinner there or home. Suitable for children or a date night too. Minutes from our home, a staple favorite for us. read more

Have been going for years and the food is amazing. Greta pizza and pasta dishes. Good for takeout and sit down. Service is amazing and you feel very welcomed. Nice Italian vibe inside. Would highly recommend. read more

Pizza very good. However, dinner was a huge disappointment. Would not go back for lunch or dinner. I asked for clams with angel hair pasta. They didn't have this so I ordered spaghetti. The clams were canned, not fresh, and there was way more garlic than clams. Awful. Partner asked for linguini. They didn't have it do he got spaghetti. There was a pool of red water in the bottom of the bowl. Awful. read more

Top notch! Busy store-front restaurant serving delicious pizza. Ask for it well-done, so the crust is crispy. They don't skimp on the pepperoni! Take out or eat in--all of their dishes are fantastic! read more

Great food, fast service. Try the chicken parm entree. Excellent portion, taste and quality.

Food is delicious. The aroma when you walk in is intoxicating. You are always greeted by someone no matter how busy the place looks (and it always looks busy)! read more

Great pizza, great Veggi Lasagna, great Ziti allabranchanelli. Amazing rollatini, and amazing baked clams. Please Please Please. Make a baked clam Pizza pie with your amazing baked clams. Pretty please!!!! read more

Their Neapolitan pizza and garlic knots are solid staples! Along with their marinara sauce, too. We are new to the area and have been searching for our local pizza spot for almost 2 years, and we were surprised that it took us so long to realize it was right in front of us the whole time! We haven't had any pizza here that we didn't like. Grandma's pizza is great, too. Sicilian is solid. Our favorite is always keeping it simple with the Neopolian + meat, because the crust is just so good! Staff is very friendly and accommodating as well. read more

Best Sicilian slice on Long Island. Great salad and dinners as well! Highly recommend the rigatoni alla Branchinellis

Aye here for the fist time in a long time the food was delicious and the service was even better read more

Branchinelli's - Italian Near Me - Miller Place, New York

Went on a Thursday afternoon. At 2pm the place was packed. There was a bit of confusion because the guy behind the pizza counter told us to have a seat in the dining area, but there was no hostess or anything. Eventually the server noticed us and took our order. Very sweet young girl, got our order exactly correct and never missed refilling the drinks. She also seemed to be the only one there serving about 15+ tables. We gave her a good tip. A+ on service. Food was good. I guess I was expecting to be blown away based on reviews. But good. They brought a complimentary bread basket which had DELICIOUS focaccia (as well as regular bread). Soft, buttery, tomatoey, garlicky. Very tasty, especially if you're hungry while waiting for entrées. Baked whole clams- good. Reasonably priced. Served with a nice buttery sauce that you could mop up with that focaccia (if you had any left)! Grandma pie- great. Excellent crust, nice and fresh. Spaghetti with white clam sauce- good. Not the best I've had. No whole clams in the shell and I almost cracked a tooth on a piece of shell mixed into the sauce. That wasn't too great. Atmosphere- typical pizzeria front, restaurant behind. Seems like they're doing quite well. Would recommend, for pizza especially. Pics next time. And that focaccia was *chefs kiss* read more