We came here after a show at the theater next door. Surprisingly it wasn't busy at all. We ordered a calamari pizza. It was beautiful and it didn't smell fishy. My only caveat is that it cost around $42 and I didn't think it was worth it. The star of the place has to be the rotating pizza oven. Entertaining to watch. All in all a good time. read more

Delfiore Pizza & Food - 18" Calamari Pizza - Italian Near Me - Patchogue, New York

Long time customer (20+ years). I shouldn't have to say "please make sure there's enough cheese this time". But if I don't this is what I get. I don't know what is happening but it's beyond disappointing. Don't skimp on basic ingredients like this, you've got loyal customers with high expectations. read more

Delfiore Pizza & Food - 18" NY Style Pizza - Italian Near Me - Patchogue, New York

It's a great establishment; it's a nice ambient pizza place. The food was great and the location is perfect since I refuse to go to Gino's pizza, as the one time I went there, they were rude to me. The nice cashier at Delfiore makes up for it! I highly recommend it! read more

Not having had their chicken cutlets or fresh mozzarella, and quite some time we decided to order bread, which is from God knows where but it's the most amazing bread, sautéed peppers and sun-dried tomatoes. All this was then put together into a beautiful sandwich and the bread was the highlight of the sandwich. Delis never disappoints and always over delivers you get what you pay for. read more

Delfiore Pizza & Food - These rice balls, chicken, cutlets, mozzarella, fresh bread, sun-dried tomatoes, red peppers are amazing - Italian Near Me - Patchogue, New York

I got the chicken parm takeout here for the first time and OMG was it delicious!!!!! The cheese was flavorful and the chicken cutlet was just perfect! For $16.95, I received pita bread (although garlic bread is listed on their website which was annoying), a house salad and three pieces of chicken parm. Highly recommend! read more

Delfiore Pizza & Food - Italian Near Me - Patchogue, New York

I've been coming to this place for years. I love the mozzarella balls. I literally get them twice a week. 10/10.

Best Brooklyn Pizza . Great staff love the place. Very clean try the garlic knots. My grandchildren love it here.

A staple pizza place in Patchogue.. Brooklyn slice is out of this world... on fridays they have a calamari pizza special but sometimes if your lucky you can snag the left over slice Saturday!!! read more

Delfiore Pizza & Food - Italian Near Me - Patchogue, New York

See all

went here tonight for something to eat after a play The food was excellent. The dining room was very nice and comfortable except it was a little cold. It just took a very long time to get off food. There was only two young guys working behind the counter. They were both extremely nice, very pleasant, but I don't think that just the two of them alone should have been there with the crowd that was coming in from the theater , but I have to say the food was hot and delicious when we got it will definitely go back again read more

Bottom Line: I know this is not going to be popular. Let me say - I LOVE DelFiore. Their pizza - not so much. Their toppings are spectacular. Their crust on those spectacular pizza are not so spectacular. We ordered a Bianco, a White, a zucchini and a pepperoni. The pepperoni was delicious. This crust, good sauce. Pizza. The other slices - the toppings were delicious but it wasn't pizza. The crust was more like focaccia. Focaccia with great toppings cut in pizza shape but not pizza. Bottom Line: for pizza I'll go somewhere else. read more

Excellent service and pizza. We had several individual slices that were all amazing. Can't wait to go back again! read more

Delfiore Pizza & Food - Back entrance - Italian Near Me - Patchogue, New York

See all

Their food is amazing. Despite a mishap, I'm giving them 5 stars because of how delicious everything we were able to eat was. I ordered food from them through door dash. The DoorDasher left our food on the porch, knowing there was a rip in the bag (we could see him trying to cover it up WITH HIS FOOT on our doorbell cam, which we checked later that evening). When we picked up the bag, door dasher was just walking away, the bag tore and all of our food fell to the ground. Our salad exploded... which I personally was very upset about because it looked really good, even piled on the stoop of our house. The dasher told us to call Delfiore. I unintentionally "karened" my way to the manager who sounded very apologetic and said that once the food leaves the building the responsibility is on door dash, which I totally understood. I'm only writing this to highlight the food that we were able to eat (packaged in secure plastic containers, which only leaked ) was incredible. I also appreciate the tone in the mangers voice as he apologized, he really sounded sincere. I was able to get refunded through door dash (I am sincerely apologetic to Delfiore for this, I honestly didn't expect them to refund what they did). I will be ordering from them again, a nice big order to make up for the last one. Your food is always on point. Thank you for making social distancing a bit better by providing a delicious meal. read more

Delfiore Pizza & Food - Driveway salad - Italian Near Me - Patchogue, New York

See all

Amazing pizza!! So perfect it looks fake on display! My favorite pizza on the island! read more

Delfiore Pizza & Food - (L to R) Brooklyn slice Margarita slice. - Italian Near Me - Patchogue, New York

Pizza was very good. Very creative. We got the mini Burgers also. They where good the Garlic knot bun was good. read more

See all

I've been to Del Fiore a handful of times for lunch but surprisingly the other day was my first check in. Man.... if I lived in Patchogue or Bayport or Sayville... THIS would be my pizza spot. Oooo so good like 4.5 stars good. I've had the Plain, Margarheita and Brooklyn. By far hands down Brooklyn wins. Both the Margarheita and Brooklyn are a nice and crispy crusted pizza! And not too thick. Next time I come back I'll take some pictures. I promise! Definitely giving this place a 4 cause it's solid pizza! read more

Delfiore Pizza & Food - Brooklyn Pizza! - Italian Near Me - Patchogue, New York

See all

It's no secret I've had a differnce in opinion of Delfiore over the years. In fact I've reviewed them as "Hands down the most overrated, cruddy-crusted compilation of crap I've ever consumed." I feel bad for being harsh, but I've had such grumpy service and such bad experiences when grabbing a slice or two. Well, tonight I had a bit of a Eureka! moment; I realized the reason I go back and forth is that some places, you can get great slices but a pie to go just fails, well Del fiore is just the opposite. The pies I order really are pretty great. The slices on a whim, always let me down. I'm a little cheap I guess but they really are overpriced since their move to Main Street years ago. What has really out-shined though, are their meatballs, some of my favorite over the years, tender as can be, saucy, and wonderful! This being said, what kind of pizza shop doesn't make a hero? They will only make you a meatball panini... sorry but a panini by definition is pressed, a pressed meatball is a burger, what BS. read more

See all

HANDS DOWN: my favorite pizza place ever. They make such great specialty slices that I've never once ordered a plain slice...but I'm sure they're just as good! Usually we order a fresh Margarita pie which they whip up right there and cook to your liking. When it comes out it is hot and bubbling with fresh basil on top. You can't get any better than that! A couple of my other favorites pizzas they have are the Fiesta, Brooklyn, and the Irish! The Irish is only around once in a while and it's cheese, potatoes, bacon, scallions, and served with a side of sour cream. YUM!! I've been coming here for yearsss now and the staff is always super friendly which makes you feel comfortable. If you haven't gone here, you must. Oh, and their garlic knots are to die for! Don't forget to try one of those! read more

veryyyyy small slices for $8??? this place is so overpriced. the slice was good but that's very expensive for a tiny slice. i've gotten a huge slice w lots of toppings for 5 most places this is new york not LA read more

My order was ready at the time they said. The Brooklyn Sicilian may be the best pizza I ever ate. Really. Counter staff was great as well.

This Pizza shop moved a while ago, so their parking is a bit harder to find as its now on Main St I parked in back super friendly staff make you feel warm and welcome do your self a pizza favor get the Sicilian its what I consider deep dish and its round the crust is so nice and crispy fresh salad self serve soda counter find yourself a table and start enjoying great pizza, friendly staff , clean restaurant what more could one ask for? GO read more

Delfiore Pizza & Food - Ceasar - Italian Near Me - Patchogue, New York

See all

I'm so addicted to their lemon chicken salad. Beyond delicious! Their pizza is amazing too but I could eat this salad every day! read more

Delfiore Pizza & Food - Lemon chicken salad - Italian Near Me - Patchogue, New York

First off there is no option for a half star so I decided to bump this to a 5 star rather than lower it to a 4 but I would give this a 4.5 Regular slice is like a 2/5 not great at all in my opinion However everything else is fantastic Speciality slices are top notch and I just got this gazing thing today...oof it is slammin! Never seen anything like it and looooove it. I got chicken parm fazzini it's like a folded half pizza panini type thing its hard to describe but it is unreal Highly suggest this place just not for the reg slices read more

Delfiore Pizza & Food - Chicken park fazzini - Italian Near Me - Patchogue, New York

We got take out from here. We got the Del Fiore Shrimp, Chicken Special and Arugula Salad with grilled chicken. Our favorite dish was the shrimp, little bit salty but still good. The chicken was chewy and the salad didn't have enough toppings. The portions were kind of small. They wouldn't also let us substitute the pasta that came with the chicken for penne ale vodka so we ended up with a side of pasta that we didn't want to eat. We also had to wait along time. I called half an hour ahead and still had to wait additional 15 minutes when I got there so all together it took 45 minutes for the food to be ready. read more

See all

Best local pizza in town. Everything tastes fresh and homemade. Even delivered, pizza is piping hot with a crust that is sublime. Better than most pizza you can get it NYC these days. read more

Tonight was the second night, I personally have ordered food from Delfiore! My friend orders, goes here often and recommended it to me one night when I couldn't think of what to eat for dinner. The first time I ordered from here, I ordered penne alla vodka- delicious, but a little heavy on the sauce. Tonight, I was craving soup and love lentil soup (if it is made right). Well, I took a chance and boy oh boy am I glad I did- this was the best lentil soup I have had in a long time! This soup was made Italian style, and I have not had lentil soup as wonderful as my Grandmothers since she passed- this was pretty close! So delicious! Thank you! I will definitely continue to order from you, and try new things in the future. I cannot wait to tell my Mom about your lentil soup, and maybe her and I could try it together some time soon! read more

Their pizza is great! But... they made a big stink about giving me a box one time. We ordered about 7 specialty slices (dinner date) because we wanted to try everything, drinks, garlic knots, etc.. and we only finished 2 slices because they give you a good size slice! The kid behind the counter went to give us a box to take home, and he got repremanded in front of us..about wasting a box. Then they offered a small paper bag that couldn't even hold 2 slices. It made us feel awkward and bad for the kid behind the counter. We haven't been back. read more

My boyfriend and I stumbled upon this place while walking along Main Street, and I'm so happy we did. This pizza was the bomb! We ordered a fazzini each, which they describe as a folded pizza. They cook it fresh so its nice and hot when you get it. It was heaven on a plate. I got chicken cutlet and eggplant and it was phenomenal. If you want a great pizza spot, you need to come here! read more

Delfiore Pizza & Food - Cheeeeesy - Italian Near Me - Patchogue, New York

See all

We ordered paninis and they were awful. First of all , the menu described them on Chibata bread, these were on regular hero bread... ends were burned . One was shrimp & the other was chicken . These just looked like regular not so warm heroes NOT GRILLED PANINIS . Very disappointed that one of the easiest menu items was presented so terribly. Not worth returning ... read more

Got the grandma and Brooklyn. Brooklyn is legit good pie. Really enjoyed both though. Fresh good taste.

Pricey but Dee-licious... A friend of ours recoommended this place. We stopped by late on a Tuesday night and order the $29 Fiesta Pizza and OMG was a treat. The fiesta pizza [pic attached] has a thicker crust as opposed to thin crust, but don't think Sicilian. I'm talking a hare thicker. The crust is also Chicago-like with a pie crust and buttery flakiness to it. Covered with just the right amount of grilled chicken, buffalo mozzarella, arugula, red onion and balsamic vinegar it is a great end to a long day. I'd recommend Del Fiore Pizza Co to anyone and we'll definitely be back. read more

Delfiore Pizza & Food - Fiesta Pizza - Grilled Chicken, Arugula, Balsamic Vinegar, Mozzarella and Red Onion - Italian Near Me - Patchogue, New York

See all

My favorite pizza place in NY! I swear by this place and every time we have friends come in from out of town we bring them here for the best pizza in NY. I was living in Patchogue last year and have been here countless times and have yet to be disappointed. The BROOKLYN is to die for. My personal favorite. Also the Buffalo is FANTASTIC and just the right combo of sauce and chicken. The Chicken Parm, Margherita, Meatylicious, and Grandma are also at the top of my favorite list. The bbq was a little too rich with bbq sauce for my taste but still a great slice if you like bbq. Honestly you can't go wrong at Del fiore!! read more

See all

As a native New Yorker, this is by far not the best pizza I ever had in my life. Having said that, it's not the worst either. Not your typical pizzeria in downtown Patchogue that serves all sorts of specialty pizze like buffalo chicken, lasagna or fried zucchini to margherita. It's more "out of state" pizza than downstate NY but they use fresh ingredients so it doesn't taste like absolute crap. The crust is too thick and crunchy but the sauce is nice, the not overpowering fresh mozzarella was good and the addition of fresh basil gave it extra flavor. Slices are quite small so one won't fill you up (even after two I wasn't quite satisfied) and it's rather over priced. I know I'll catch flack for saying this, but it's almost like a chain pizza joint but with fresh ingredients. Can I recommend it? Well, you try it and decide. read more

See all

Honestly the wait is sometimes really long. The last time I went I waited about half an hour for a slice of cheese pizza and it was burnt... when I asked for it to not be too hot. The what seemed like owner asked me if it was too "done" lol really... yes! It's Black on the bottom! He put another cheese slice in the oven and I waited for another 10 minutes The salad tasted unwashed. I threw it out. I give this place a 3 star review only because I have had good experiences here the pizza is NOT traditional NY pizza, but usually good. The have sourdough for the pizza, different but not bad. read more

Ordering was like pulling teeth when the counter girl can barely speak and understand English and is entirely unfamiliar with the restaurants menu to begin with. The order wound up being incorrect AND on top of the poor experience expect to pay through the nose $50 for 2 meatballs, one wrap and one penne ala vodka. With the many options to dine available in Patchogue - I certainly won't be returning to Delfiore ever again! read more

Great food and even better service, prices are fair but considering food and service well worth it. My girl friend tends to be picky and she often talks about going back. read more

Old world Margherita pizza is to die for! We came here for the white pie and Brooklyn but quickly found that the jewel of this place is definitely the Margherita pizza! The sauce, cheese crust combination makes it truly worth the trip. When I come back to Long Island, I will go out of my way for Delfiore. read more

See all

The absolute best pizza in the area. The owner, Joe, is a great guy as well! The pizza was nice and hot and tasted delicious. Perfect amount of cheese and sauce and great texture. read more

Delicious food. My friend had a sweet 16 catered from here. Everything was delicious. The chicken parm, great vodka sauce, awesome francese... However when I went to order chicken parm as take out... the portion was really small... and I thought it to be on the more expensive side.... 5 stars if bigger portions read more

Today was my first and last time coming here. I decided to stop here for lunch and I was ahead of two of the other ladies that were behind me waiting to order after I ordered the person behind the counter took payments from them and from two other people from even asking me which I kinda let go but the final straw was when I said thank you very much have a nice day he couldn't even say it back but he said it to everyone else. I mean it's 2019 there are more gay people than fucking cows and farms combined like if you are homophobic than you shouldn't be operating a business or you might as well put a sign out front that says no gays allowed.. read more

I have been loyally coming to this pizzeria since they first opened when I was a young girl and they always have and always will be my favorite pizza shop. If you've never been there then I'm taking you there. The Brooklyn slice is a classic, the fiesta slice is a specialty favorite of mine and the new buffalo chicken slice is to die for. Also the rosemary French fries are a hidden gem. Their new soda machine is a very cool upgrade I've never seen anywhere else. The staff are wonderful people who know how to make a customer feel welcome and satisfied. You can never go wrong going to this pizzeria! read more

Delfiore Pizza & Food - Buffalo chicken and a regular - Italian Near Me - Patchogue, New York