Always a must order when visiting friends. Take away is always on point. Warm, stays together what I've ordered, each time has been a different choice. Always with a slice though, even cold it's awesome. This stop I ordered the Burrata & Tomato Small $10.95 | Large $15.95 * Arugula, vine-ripened sliced tomato, roasted peppers, creamy burrata, and balsamic fig glaze. I did C&P this description so everyone could see all the yummies included. I personally would ask for extra glaze when ordering. read more

Alfredo's Pizzeria - Burrata Salad - Arugula, tomato, roasted pepper, dried cranberries, toasted almonds, balsamic reduction, topped with burrata. - Italian Near Me - Ridge, New York

Typical pizza place but with a separate dining room on the side. Parking in the back was a surprise. We have passed this place by for years thinking there was little parking, duh! The friendly waitress Grace promptly took our drink order and gave us time to review the menu. She brought a basket of delicious warm garlic knots and bread with both butter and olive oil balsamic dipping sauce. My husband ordered the Sunday sauce complete either pork, sausage, two large meatballs and a huge dollop of ricotta. He thoroughly enjoyed it with plenty to spare. I had the lemon cream pasta. Very rich but needing more lemon. Such a huge portion I will be enjoying it again. Great to have a local place to sit down and enjoy a casual meal read more

Came here last night for family dinner. Pizza was decent, but the service was sooo slow. Wound up taking 1.5 hours and the pizzas took the longest! Not sure why, but the entrees came out staggered. With a table of 9, three salad and pasta dishes came out first and then the pizzas came 15 minutes after. Kind of awkward for the table, but thank god we're family. Apps were pretty good, and the waitresses were friendly and helpful. read more

See all

Amazing service and the pizza is delicious. Definitely a great place with old school ambiance. read more

Alfredo's Pizzeria - Spinach & Broccoli Roll - Italian Near Me - Ridge, New York

See all

We were looking to try a new pizzeria; Alfredo's was highly rated and nearby, so we ordered a Sicilian cheese pie with pepperoni. When we got home, the first thing we noticed was the absence of cheese. The sauce was dried, and the pizza was very doughy. I usually don't complain, but over $30 for dough was an insult... but at least there was plenty of pepperoni. read more

Alfredo's Pizzeria - Italian Near Me - Ridge, New York

Was good once . Sadly they lost their mojo. Order and it doesn't come . If it does the food is cold and basically tasteless! Sad that they used to be a good place to eat or order for delivery. Not anymore read more

Let me start by saying I live in Ridge. This place is great if you are in a bind, but by no means do I go out of my way to get food here. It is more of a pizza place than an Italian restaurant. Although they have a wide selection of different types of pizza slices, they are are very generic. Out of all of them I believe the OG Grandma pizza is their best. They try to overdo it with all these crazy flavors but if they stuck to the basics (6-10) different pies they can really take the pizza to the next level. Same goes for the dining food, I take quality over quantity any day. Again, its not BAD, but it wouldn't be a place I take my friends/family from out of state for authentic pizza/Italian. Something worth noting. I had a bad experience the last time I went there which unfortunately made me decide not to come back. If you haven't herd of 'too good to go', google it, it will help with story. I called Alfredos a half hour before closing to order 1 plain pie. I got a bad vibe on the phone like I was inconveniencing them. I arrive 15 minutes later I didn't want to keep them waiting and my pie is just getting 'sent' (Placed in oven) so I know its got a solid 10-13 mins (average) So I wait and while I'm waiting I ask the clerk "Do you do too good to go?" because I noticed a significant about of leftover pizza in display case. He replies "No" I then asked "What do you do with all of this pizza at the end of the night?" He replied "We throw it out" I know for a fact based on experience that MOST pizza places either give it to staff to take it home, or will sell it all for a cheap price opposed to just wasting it in the trash. So I ask and the guy gave me a really hard time. I said "If you're not taking it home, can I pay you (offer cash or charge whatever's easier) I don't want it free" He then rushed my pie out of the oven and said "Have a good night!" It really rubbed me the wrong way, what a complete waste. Take the cash and pocket it, share it as a 'tip' I don't care. Why would you not want to make MORE money and make a customer happy? Between that the the unprofessional delivery drivers in street clothes eating behind the counter and touching everything with their bare hand I said I'm done wit this place. Overall Rating- 6/10 Recommended dish- Chicken Parm Hero- Vodka Style Taste & Flavor: 5/10 Very generic, Marinara is 'sweet' Quality: 5/10 Average Italian food/ pizza. So-So Texture & Temp: 8/10 No remarks Portion Size: 6/10 Fair for price Presentation: 6/10 No Remarks Service: 8/10 Even on busy Friday nights they prepare the food in a timely matter Staff: 5/10 I usually see half the people busting their ass and the other half hanging out Order Accuracy: 10/10 No remarks Process: 10/10 No remarks Ambiance & Atmosphere: 5/10 Comfort: 8/10 No remarks Uniqueness: 5/10 Typical Pizza Place Cleanliness: 8/10 No Remarks Dining Area: 7/10 Surprisingly large dining area however generic. Gives more pizza parlor vibes than Italian restaurant. Restrooms: 8/10 No remarks Price vs. Quality: 5/10 No remarks read more

We came here because the restaurant we wanted to go to was closed. Staff was friendly. Atmosphere was delightful. Garlic knots were AMAZING. Stuffed shells? Not so good. Literally they must have cooked everything together at once because the shells had a funny taste to them, not all of them but some of them were just unbearable. The cheese was watered down. Not the best. Won't be back. read more

Alfredo's Pizzeria - Stuffed Shells - Italian Near Me - Ridge, New York

Omg AMAZING! The Pizza was Awesome, the Garlic knots delicious, mozzarella sticks GREAT, and the Cheese Cake SOOOO OUT OF THIS WORLD DELICIOUS! I honestly liked it better than Cheesecake Factorys cheese cake! My Son ordered Chicken Alavodka , A good amount of chicken , the portion size was amazing for the price ! I highly recommend you don't go to Any other Pizza Place , They r Amazing at Alfredo's in Middle Island NY ! read more

Waited 90 mins for a pizza to be delivered, I live 1.5 miles away, horrible attitude from whoever picked up the phone

My go to spot in the area; no one compares. great pizza, great dinners, very clean and nice atmosphere. great staff!

Came here for a mid week quick lunch, casual pizza spot. Seating inside, but we chose to sit outside since it was sunny. Lots of pizza/ other Italian staples to choose from. The salad was something I'd come back for, along with their garlic knots! Veggies were fresh and the chicken was an add on. Would like to come back sometime to try another salad and pizza. read more

Alfredo's Pizzeria - Small greek salad, mushroom pizza, chicken slider, and garlic knots - Italian Near Me - Ridge, New York

The guy behind the counter brings life to this place!! The customer service he brings to alfredos is unmatched. The food is great and place is clean. 10/10 read more

Alfredo's Pizzeria - Dining area - Italian Near Me - Ridge, New York

The only reason we have to go here it's because it's one of the only spots in Ridge. They never got the order right they're always rude on the phone and then they're rude to you when you go in. I order the same thing every Thursday and my son went to go pick it up and they didn't have our cheesy bread. No problem he goes back in and they say oh we didn't get it in your order we placed the order they charge us now we're waiting another 10 minutes when he comes back to the car they handed him a salad? I had to go in now. We have been sitting in the car for over 25 minutes at this point waiting for the right food my husband is a little bit more forgiving than I am so he decides to go back every time but every time we do, we always have a problem. read more

Pizza before and it was always good last night to go when I get home to slices or cold cold spoke to the manager. She put the price of slices right back on my card. No problem now that is Customer Service. read more

I Ordered delivery , driver was so nice, paid on the card reader at my door. Food arrived Hot and fresh. Couldn't be happier. Alfredo's food is consistently good. read more

See all

I moved to Ridge in 2005. Not gonna lie. I didn't like Alfredo's for many years, but they have really stepped up their game. They make a good pizza. Get the Grandma pie or the LI Clam's Casino pizza. You won't be disappointed. read more

Oof! We ordered a plain pie and calamari last night. They said 45-60 mins for delivery. It was actually almost 2 hours. That's fine. The pizza was not good. It was of course cold at this point, the bottom of the pie was really burned and bitter, while the actual crust itself lacked crunch. For me, it was inedible. The calamari was status quo but I hate to think what would happen to it on a hot summer day. In a car for an hour and a half. It was probably the worst pizza I've had in quite some time. I would opt for a different place in the future. read more

Food is excellent. Employees are wonderful. Getting orders out on Friday nights in awful. Dont say 25 minutes when its 50. Dont make people wait another 30 mins to get your food. Hire someone to organize your busy nights. read more

I tried their Thai pizza last night, and it was delicious. The other pizza in their showcase looks really fantastic too

The food is great . But, I live on woodville road shoreham and just saw delivery truck fly through stop sign doing at least 50mph in a 30. Totally ignoring stop sign. There are kids that play near road and their safety is more important than getting food on time. Guy blew sign going and coming back. 220 pm on a Saturday. Dec 13 2025. ​ read more

Love their salad pizza!! Service is always good!!! Fast and friendly!!! Thank you!!! See u soon read more

Just ordered a pie . They said 40min to a hr .took 1hr and 50min later the pie comes room temperature. Had to send it back . Just a waste of time . read more

The Dinners are great, just be sure to ask for the marinara sauce instead of the thinner one they give by default. Ordering takeout is something else, pizza often arrives cold, I advise you custom order your pizza and try to order during busy times. Veal and Calamari are above average for Pizzerias! read more

the two females that work the counter are nasty and rude. Just because your busy or frustrated doesn't mean you take it out on the customer. absolutely disgusting. read more

No matter what meal we've had there it's always been phenomenal from the average meal to things we've never tried before all of. It's amazing. read more

There's only one rude person at Alfredos, but I think they took care of it with some female who used to answer the phone. I had so many issues with her, but I think she's gone cause she hasn't answered her phone in a very long time but otherwise, their food is phenomenal. Their service is great. Sometimes you have a weight but what are you gonna do? I'd rather wait for Alfredos then go to Carlos's anytime. read more

We stopped here on way home from a Dr appointment mostly because it was on the way. I got the Pasta Rustica "Light on the olive oil" and my mom got the Veal Parmesan with spaghetti. I arrived before my order was done and while I waited I got to look at all the delicious pizzas they have available by the slice. They even had a salad pizza which was a cold salad, on top of a slice of pizza. Our bag must have weighed 10 pounds! We got the bag home and there was so much food! Honestly, one dish would be enough feed at least 2 people. My pasta rustica was delicious. Perfect amount of sausage, beans, escarole, roasted garlic and I chose rigatoni. My mom said her veal was a little dry and she was not crazy about the sauce. I do not normally have red sauce so I could not confirm or deny this. The garlic knots - which were really more like breadsticks- were also delicious. I would definitely go back. read more

See all

Very, very disappointed tonight. We've ordered from Alfredos a few times now. We absolutely love their angry vodka pizza, the Thai chili is delicious, and the cowboy chicken roll is an awesome change from the usual. Tonight, we ordered the linguine carbonara for a change. Listed as onions and peas in a cream sauce, we figured it was a classic, and therefore assumed there was also some form of guanciale, pancetta, or bacon. Sounds great. Delivery shows up, we're enjoying the counter items, then we open the pasta. It is COVERED in mushrooms. Mushrooms weren't mentioned anywhere in the Doordash description. Mushrooms don't belong in a classic carbonara, and aren't going to be assumed. The person it was intended for is highly allergic, and the other person hates them. Like, complete aversion. This could have been incredibly dangerous for the intended recipient. We do love most of their foods, and we'll likely be back for the ones we love. But we'll be much more careful about the dinners from now. read more

Just left there totally disgusted. been going there for years and never any problem. Today I ordered two calzones and the guy helping me was disgusting. Kept touching his face / wiping the sweat. Handling my food with only one glove puts my food in the oven. Then goes to the bathroom and out quick. Did he wash his hands, were they dry??? puts on only one glove at takes my food out the oven handling it with questionable hygiene. All the time I'm watching. Bothered me so much on the way to my truck I just threw them in the dumpster in the back. The girls there wear two gloves and never an issue. Out $20.66. read more

They have so many options of all really good pizza. The fried garlic cheese was delicious. Service was good just a nice neighborhood pizza restaurant. read more

Alfredo's Pizzeria - Italian Near Me - Ridge, New York

See all

I had to think long and hard about this one since it's been hit or miss so 3.5 stars but I rounded up. I'm not crazy about their pizza but their entrees have always been decent for the most part. The last order was a total miss. I ordered pasta polocioffo which was chicken and artichoke hearts. Meh. Very underwhelming. Their pasta fagioli was also a bust. I make my own excellent pasta fagioli ::pats self on back:: lol, but when you don't feel like cooking you try to find comfort in a comforting bowl from a restaurant. It was toooo tomato-ey like so many other Long Island restaurants/pizzerias and some beans and whole cloves of garlic The rice ball was some weird thing that I can't even explain. They cut the ball in half and smothered it in cheese. No meat, no filling and the rice was undercooked and crunchy. Big fail The Greek salad was enough to feed an army and was the best thing an Italian restaurant could have come up with to resemble a Greek salad. I did enjoy although probably not as much as from an actual Greek restaurant. Lots of yummy kalamata olives so who can complain about that, not I! I think I'll stick to their pizza from now on. I didn't like their grandma but I have a note saying that their lasagna was "the bomb" lol read more

I've gone to Long Island for years to visit my family, and I always look forward to getting Alfredo's. Their pizza is some of the best pizza I have ever had in my life. It is so fresh and light, I love the dough! They have some of the best pizza flavors, too, like their chicken parm pizza. Amazing! I've never seen another restaurant do that, and it was so good! They're all so good though, It's hard to pick a favorite. Not pictured, but I also absolutely love their hero's! Again, everything just tastes so good and fresh. read more

See all

Visited on 3-5-23. First time here. Came with a group of people so we ordered a bunch of menu items and shared everything. Ordered a baked ziti dish, a Bolognese dish, a "Sunday Sauce" dish which had pasta, meatballs, sliced sausage and a pork chop, and it was in a tasty tomato sauce with ricotta cheese. Also ordered a nice house salad with prosciutto and a riceball special as an app along with a grandma slice and a bbq chicken and broccoli slice. Everything was very good but the Sunday Sauce and Bolognese dishes were definitely standouts. They give you complimentary garlic knots to start everyone off. Service was excellent as well. Very attentive wait staff. They offered quite a large selection of specialty pizzas that I wasn't able to try this time around, but I'll be back. Nice meal out with family in a casual atmosphere at a price that won't break the bank. 4.5 stars. read more

Nothing to brag about. Pizza was thick and doughy. I had requested thin and well done. Service was pleasant and place looked clean. But I won't be coming back for the pizza. read more

Whoever made this ate this up. I genuinely was surprised at the excellent presentation and absolute beauty in this meal. Thank you very much. You deserve a raise!! I will now go enjoy my sammich read more

Alfredo's Pizzeria - The Italian Hero - Italian Near Me - Ridge, New York

Amazing Pizza! The Sicilian slices have a perfectly crispy crust. Their buffalo chxn slice is the best I've had so far & the chipotle chxn slice is something special. read more

Alfredo's Pizzeria - Sicilian - Italian Near Me - Ridge, New York

See all

Call to order a pizza and the woman on the phone I don't know if she had hearing issues I gave her my order at least 10 times and she kept coming back at me saying and what did you want on it and what did you want on it I must have told her at least 10 times what I wanted on my pizza and she had to go to audacity to give me an attitude I've had experiences with this female before she's a very nasty they really need to get rid of her I'll never go there again or order from there again I should say read more

I Can't say enough great things about Alfredo's pizza and dinners. Great quality pizza and dinners at great prices. You are always greeted with a smile along with a great meal. read more

Great consistency with quality and service!! Also a nice family owned, community restaurant.