After 20 years and lots of money spent at Matt's today they failed BIG TIME!! I had my family over and I ordered A large pizza, 2 chicken cutlet Parmesan and 2 pepperoni rolls and garlic knots !Well over an hour I live 5 minutes away. The delivery guy apologize for looking sideways and smashed. Everything was squished into a pizza delivery bag. Pizza was undercooked ice cold pepperoni rolls were never heated up. They were just put into the box last, but not least my nephew bites into the chicken Parm and a long hair comes out of it Absolutely repulsing. My order was close to $70. I called immediately to express my unhappiness. I have to speak to two young men and then supposedly a manager in the background and he's saying over the two young boys and not himself getting on the phone as a man should Bring me back the stuff and I'll make you a new order. Are you kidding me right now. I threw everything in the garbage at this point it was repulsing. I told him it's in the garbage. He said he needed to see it in order to give me a new order at that point. I told him you'll never hear from me again, this is disgusting and I was hung up on.! Duces Matt your actions today proved you don't care about your customers even after 20 years very disappointing eat at your own risk whoever reads this!! Lucy read more

I had two scoops of birthday cake Italian ice. And then I ate half of it then I was mixing the ice cream around and a bug was in it read more

Matt's Pizza - Bug in my Italian ice - Pizza Near Me - Coram, New York

Worst pizza ever, never coming back to this place when I got my pizza the cheese wasn't melted it was like a solid not to mention the crust their crust was so hard and unpleasant, the service isn't good at all the owner has no patience with customers nor with their employees he yells at the employees and curses at them rude owner and bad pizza wouldn't recommend. read more

The prices went way up and the quality went way down. I was disappointed in the last few years ordering here. And I'm sad to say because this I hardly ever get the pizza or anything here anymore. I will try again maybe a few times a year in hopes the quality goes back to what it once was. read more

I live in the city & I still have to make the trip out here for the bbq or buffalo chicken pizza. Best slices I've ever had still read more

Matt's Pizza - Buffalo Chicken Pizza BBQ Chicken Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Coram, New York

Love the folks at Matt's Pizza! The pizza is always hot and fresh and the wings are amazing as well! Nothing like a Friday night pie from Matt's read more

Looked delicious over the counter, then I got home with my garlic knot slice...even put it in the air fryer to crisp it up a bit. Have definitely had better tasting slices too. read more

Matt's Pizza - Matt's garlic knot slice....the ultimate sag. - Pizza Near Me - Coram, New York

Great pizza, crisp crust and great delivery guy who's been there for years. Also great wings!

I cannot say strongly enough how much you should avoid this place. We had a less than great experience a few weeks back, and I let it slide. But tonight we ordered again through DD, and it all went down hill from there. My order included some modifications, so I added a side order and put in notes that I did NOT want the side, it was just extra money to cover my changes, bc I don't expect anyone to modify an order for free. The restaurant calls to say that "this is too many changes". So I ask if they just need more money to cover it and he says "no, we just want to make it the regular way." Excuse me? Then remove the option to make changes on your menu. I get him to agree to make the order the way I wanted it, if I cancel the order and re place it with TWO sides, so now adding $10 to cover the modifications. Fine, whatever. My Dasher gets there, picks up the order, and then texts me to ask why the amount went from $20 to $10. I inform her that this is bc of the canceled first order, which I had already called her about so she wouldn't be confused looking for an order that didn't exist. She says she understands, and that she'll be here in 15 min. Then her name drops off, and I have a new dasher. He calls me from the parking lot of Matt's to say that she had taken the food before canceling the order, so now it's gone. He's incredibly apologetic. DD calls to tell me they've received the issue, and while they tried to have the store remake it - and pay them for both - the owner refused, and was as rude to them as he was to me. I ended up managing to place a last minute order at a different pizzeria (Pompeii in Rocky Point), again with a kids meal added just to cover the modifications. Pompeii calls me to say ABSOLUTELY not, he's not letting me pay $10 for no more than $5 in changes, and refunds the kids meal, and STILL makes my chicken the way I wanted it. In short? Stay away from Matt's, and hit up Pompeii in Rocky Point. read more

Best-priced Italian for value, as compared to competitors.... hands down. I've never once been displeased with the food quality, and they pull off rustic dishes very well. If you order delivery, then say say, "Hi!" to C.J. , the most cool & mellow delivery-worker you'll ever meet! I really enjoy talking to him for a little bit each time he delivers a hot meal. read more

We have been frequenting Matt's often. Definitely once a week, sometimes twice, we enjoy their dinners. Today, my husband went to pick up a few slices for lunch. My husband asked for 2 garlic knots and was told they can only be sold in 6 or 12. Really?? So he opted to get 1 garlic knot slice and 2 regular slices. He said, he would take the lunch special plus the extra slice. The guy at the counter rejected him saying lunch was over - it was 2:15pm!!! This is how you treat a regular customer?? Now you have no customer, because we will not be back. read more

I ordered an eggplant roll and this is what arrived. It is clearly a calzone- loaded with ricotta and mozzarella cheese. When I called to inform them that I received the incorrect item, they questioned me multiple times. The owner/delivery guy called me back 10 minutes later to tell me he will drive back to check it. Never did he say he would bring me the correct item. Another 10 minutes later (now 1 hour after the time of delivery) he shows up, and uses his fingers to pull apart the roll to prove there is a tiny piece of eggplant in it. When I explained that you should not have to dig through an eggplant roll just to find the eggplant, he argued that there is eggplant in it. This was a total joke because you can't find the eggplant unless you completely dig through the excessive amount of ricotta cheese and mozzarella just to find a small bite of eggplant. This is a disgusting way to run a business. Was I supposed to eat this after he dug through and pulled it apart?! read more

Matt's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Coram, New York

Been ordering here from years thru DoorDash. I can except a cold pie once in a while. But a delivery to a complete different address when your hungry don't fly. Seems like all they care about is pumping out food and when it leaves there shop they wash there hands of it. read more

Pretty good pizza / pasta is okay as well. Baked ziti and their mozzarella sticks are tasty. Recommend this pizza if you live in the area.

In the top five Pizzeria Restaurants on Long Island. Consistently. Once a week at least. The pie crust. The pi crst. The picrst. Tpicrst.

I called in because my children ordered from the wrong place and we just wanted to switch the order all we ordered is a plain pie and garlic knots and we wanted to return and get our money back and they hung up we called back and they kept declining they finally answered and they told us there was nothing they could do. They are very disrespectful. read more

Best pizza I've had and customer service is phenomenal. The store is very well kept and welcoming.

Hit them up on my way from one job to the next. Not knowing what to expect, I gave them a shot. That crust is unique in a good way. Solid slice. read more

I feel compelled to write this review after I saw the 1-star rating. While I still lived in the city I came home from spending the weekend at my summer cottage on Long Island and and took a new route home. On our way home we stopped at a pizza place late at night and I remembered that slice of pizza for years but couldn't remember the name of this little gem of a pizza shop or how to find it again. When I moved out East I found this little diamond in the rough again by accident -- and it and it was Matt's! Since living out here I've ordered (for delivery and pick up) several times and I've always been very happy with their pizza. It's simple, nothing fancy or gourmet, and I love the thin, crunchy crust. I usually go for their Neapolitan pie but once I tried their Grandma, which is my second favorite type of pizza. It was basically their regular 18" round pie with cheese directly on the crust and sauce (loads of it -- too much of it) on top of the cheese. No garlic, no basil. I was disappointed so I just wouldn't order it again. Next time I think I'll try their Sicilian... One little tip: If you call for delivery at around 1:00 p.m. the soonest you will get your pizza is about 2:30 -- something about not having a delivery person between 12:00 and 1:00. read more

The food is decent the chicken wings are good if you tell them you want the burnt with extra sauce on the pizza is nothing special

I don't mean to be dramatic but I have never been so in love with a slice of cheese pizza in my whole life.

Delivery was super fast. Pizza is much better than I expected given the location of the shopping center is really only meant for people who live in North Isle. They use too much panko on the pizza and wish they would put more cheese. The garlic knots are really good and small just how I like them. Haven't tried anything else from there yet but I will definitely go back. read more

My go to pizza place. Breadcrumbs on the bottom of their pizza give great texture and the pizza is never soggy and doesn't droop when holding it. I've ordered plenty of things from here - mozzarella sticks, pasta dishes, salads, chicken rolls, hero's, cannoli's, etc and the food is always great. Just a side note: I grew up in a very Italian family and have very high standards for Italian food. read more

Very yummy and the garlic knot pizza is incredible. Great prices and have different size pizzas, which gives you options.

I came here because it was the highest rated pizza restaurant near my new home, and I wanted to try it out. After reading all of the great reviews I guess my expectations were set too high. That being said, I was not impressed. The slices were tiny compared to other places like Nick & Gina's and Bella Maria. The taste was good, but not the best around. I'll drive the extra four blocks to Colosseo. read more

I have heard people on Facebook talking about this place so I looked at their site and saw that the pizza looked amazing!! I was in the area so I stopped in. They had pizzas in the case and these were not the pies on their site. They were thin and covered in cornmeal. I decided to just get some sausage and meatballs. I got a dozen meatballs and 8 sausage. I also got a garlic bread with cheese. I can without a doubt say this was the most disgusting food I have ever had. The meatballs are very suspect. They have that texture of frozen but the taste is something they should be ashamed of. The sausage was wrinkled and obviously old and reheated. It was rock hard. The sauce is watery and greasy. The garlic bread was so heavy and I was like wtf is going on. There was a half inch layer of "melted" cheese and it was literally DRIPPING in butter I am assuming. I mean DRIPPING. I WASTED about $38 for literal dog food. This place should also be paid a visit by the health inspector sometime so they can see the employees not wearing a face covering. To all the people that claim this place is epic, you clearly are used to eating at a drive thru. Cannot stress enough how horrible the food was. Btw no...I am not and did not call the "restaurant" to complain. I'll take it as a loss read more

I couldn't even tell you how the food is since it never showed up. I ordered for delivery at 5 PM and waited over and hour. I called and they said 30 minutes more. An hour later the food still wasn't here. Basically I waited over 2 1/2 hours and never received my food. read more

very respectful staff and the food was amazing. ill make sure i go here everyday now.

Ok... I'm gonna chime in here. Some mixed reviews, but I decided to try it since it's practically across the street from where I live. I figure... If I can't get a fresh, hot pizza from this joint, then something's wrong. It showed up fresh, and hot.... and probably one of the best pies I've had in a long time. Crust is thick, but not too thick - covered with that rustic crunchiness I thought I'd never find anywhere again - crisp on the very bottom, but soft and chewy. Good quantities of toppings, and a flavorful sauce. Loved it! read more

I came in from upstate to visit my daughter, and HAD to stop by Matt's for a slice and a coke. STILL the best pizza in this region of the galaxy! read more

This review is for the pizza. Matt's is everything you want from a casual pizza joint. Friendly service and great pizza. They even whipped up a ziti slice from scratch when I mentioned it's my favorite and it was excellent! Will definitely be back when I'm in the area. read more

I'm basing this review on their pasta dishes. Had the garlic and broccoli in oil minus the broccoli...they forgot, and bottled garlic, not fresh. Second dish was a mushroom sauce again canned mushrooms...no more pasta here. We'll stick to the pizza which is really good. Nice try guys! read more

Good pizza at good prices! Love the breadcrumbs or semolina they use on the bottom of the pizza

Solid pizza spot in an area where pizza places are a dime a dozen. The pies are always consistent and the prices are definitely fair. Oh, and the white slice is amazing! What really needs to be noted is the bread crumb coating on the bottom of the pizza. No other pizza place in the area does this, and it really separates Matt's from its competitors. If you're not a fan of it...you probably won't be a fan of Matt's pizza. I've actually never had anything but the pizza from here before, but I have the utmost confidence that everything else will be on par. read more

Matt's pizza has to be my favorite spot for pizza on Long Island. I've gone here countless times and have not had a bad experience. The food is always fresh and hot when you pick it up. Not only is the food delicious but it's also inexpensive. I'm a bit plain Jane when it comes to pizza because I love just a cheese slice and Matt's has the best. Every aspect of this pizza is good; the sauce, the cheese, the crust. The crust to the pizza is nice and crispy with no flour on the bottom! Perfect. If I'm being honest I think the crust is the magic to Matt's Pizza! I also love their Sicilian slices which are made fresh to order. The garlic knots are small but packed with flavor. I also love the pepperoni pinwheel. As far as entrees go they give you more than enough food. One entree may be enough for two people! The entrees come with bread and salad as well. read more

Always pleased with Matts! We get this pizza once a month and it's always good. The crust is one of a kind and like others eluded to, it's no frills, just pizza. So good! read more

Matt's Pizza - It's in a shopping center, kind of hidden - Pizza Near Me - Coram, New York

My grade here is purely because I feel an establishment's grade is only as good as its service. The food is really good - the pizza crust is so unique and crispy - although the bread for the chicken parm hero seemed stale. I did an online order and there were several mixups which resulted in us not getting a couple of items. Would not have been a big deal, except that the person helping my husband when he picked up our order was not very tolerant and insisted our order was a certain way. I know people have bad days but his attitude really wasn't warranted. I may sneak back there again without telling my husband (since he was the one who received the unwarranted attitude) but it would have to be an exception. read more

Great pizza. Love the semolina crust. Extensive Italian menu and never had a bad order. Great as far as a pizza/take out Italian place.

So Glad to have Ordered Pizza from this Establishment last evening. The Pizza was Some of the Best We've had within a 10 mile Radius of Home in All the many years we've lived Here., Crust Can't Be Beat, Sauce& Toppings also. The Owner & His Staff All Very Kind & Courteous...We Will Be Baaack! read more

I go in and I just have a slice of pizza heated up till it's piping hot. The crust is crispy and flavorful. A beautiful Pizza experience