Good food, great service, and a classic pizza shop ambiance is how I describe Donatina's. I had the Ala Vodka Spicy Pepperoni slice and the Detroit style pepperoni cup slice. Both were very good, especially the Detroit Style Pepperoni cup slice. The cheese crust, the sauce, and pepperoni was delicious. The Ala Vodka slice was really good too. The crust was decent. Great service, and great selection of pizza. Looking forward to trying the Jonny Gravone Detroit style pizza next time! read more

See all

had a craving for a chicken Parmesan hero and decided to try Donatina since it was close to the gym. I even worked out a little extra so I wouldn't feel guilty about indulging. The hero roll was a fresh, seeded semolina bread--crispy on the outside and soft on the inside. The chicken cutlet was generously sized and fried to perfection. The cheese was plentiful, and the sandwich wasn't overloaded with sauce. When I opened the bag and saw the hero, I was pleasantly surprised. At $13, it was a substantial sandwich and a good value. Many restaurants charge similar prices but skimp on the filling, leaving you with little more than a bread sandwich. On my first bite, I immediately noticed the tangy, acidic tomato sauce. While many people enjoy a bright, acidic sauce, it's not my personal preference. I also encountered a chewy bite, likely from the tendon that sometimes runs through a chicken tenderloin. It's the tough white cord-like strip that can occasionally make its way into a sandwich. Overall, I'd rate this sandwich an 8/10 for value but only a 5/10 for flavor. While the portion size and quality of the bread and chicken were impressive, the sauce wasn't to my liking. Unfortunately, I won't be back. read more

I get burrata slice everywhere. Definitely the worst one I've had. Burrata slice had like a cup of milk on it... margarita pie was fine. The server said it's because of the brick oven, The he burrata shouldn't be put in the oven it should be placed on after. There was a kid with no parent running around the place the entire time. read more

Donatina Neapolitan Pizza Cafe - Burrata & Basil Pesto - Pizza Near Me - Patchogue, New York

See all

Rude workers, bathrooms were filthy and there was no soap.. the food was good tho please Do a better job managing the bathroom. read more

Big fan of their specialty slices especially their pesto white slice! This pizza spot is always a hit. They make a delicious capellini cake as well. I would love to try their other apps. read more

Donatina Neapolitan Pizza Cafe - Pizza Near Me - Patchogue, New York

See all

Great pizza. Super crunchy crust. There is a large selection of premade slices in Neapolitan and Detroit styles.

Decent pizza, but don't order their zeppolis. The zeppolis tasted like old grease, were tough as shoe leather, and had zero flavor. Total fail on the zeppolis. Doubt I'll go back. read more

Poor service and not friendly. Actually decided to boycott the place after they tried to make me pay $3 for a side of sauce the size of a sample ketchup. Only go here if you want mid pizza and be charged $50. Rocco's pizza in Patchogue is so much better and more friendly. read more

Donatina never disappoints. They have many options, a small parking lot and the service is always good. A must try: Ceasar salad and the Chicago style pizza. Add hot honey to the pizza and you won't be disappointed! They have both quick booth seating or dining room seating with service to the tables. read more

See all

The two young women working last night ignored us when we walked in and sat for ten minutes. When I finally asked if they prefer we sit at the bar she said kitchen closed this is all we have. She did not appear too happy to have us there. I usually have good food and friendly staff at Dona Tina but these two with bad attitudes were miserable people not deserving of a job. read more

Me and My friend Donna used to come here all the time! I need to go back soon! Their pizza is amazing; they have something I've never seen before. Pizza with Garlic bread crusts!! I have yet to see this anywhere else and it's amazing! It's a nice establishment with plenty of ambiance and the workers are so nice and friendly! read more

So clam pie was here all along and I had no idea! Pro tip: Ask for bacon on it. According to my husband, who grew up here, this use to be a 7-11 or something. The trip down memory lane happens every time we are in the area and I may be mixing the stories up, but what I'm trying to say is Donatina a must visit in an every growing hot spot. Small dining area, but works nonetheless. Menu is incredible. In addition to the clam pie we ordered garlic knots, pizza fries with crumbled sausage, the Detroit and the meatball with the ricotta pie. Beer and wine along with soda are found in the fridge. I had a Pumpking. Also in the fridge you with fine the Cake Boss desserts. You know your girl took home the chocolate cake! The boy loved his cannoli and after we cleaned him up and packed up the rest of the delicious pizza we couldn't finish we headed home. I'm all seriousness, we really enjoyed everything we ordered. The crust was cooked perfectly in the amazing and gorgeous pizza oven which is the focal point for the restaurant. Looking forward to trying more pies for sure! read more

See all

I hadn't had there pizza in a long time. I don't live that close to run there and grab a pizza. It was amazing. The best pizza I have had in years. I will definitely be back soon. read more

Donatina produces some really good Neapolitan with very reasonable prices. There were also a lot of slices with good toppings. We got the caption and pistachio. So unique and tasty. We loved every bite. It was good enough for 2. The freshly crushed pistachio really added to the flavor and crunch. Service was great too, felt very welcomed. read more

Came to Donatina for the first time during COVID when it was takeout only and was happy to return again to see it in full swing this past weekend. Solid casual pizza spot with indoor and outdoor seating, and a beer and wine list. They're known for their Detroit-style slices which were delicious, but the stand out to me was their grandma pie. Perfectly crispy on the bottom, light and airy on top. I also ventured out to try one of the more inventive pizzas, a chipotle chicken slice. It was flavor heavy for sure, an interesting thing to put on pizza but it kind of works? Service was prompt and friendly. We decided to sit at the counter so we had a view of the pizzas being made in the large wood burning oven. I wish I had been hungrier or came with a bigger party to be able to try more of what they had to offer! Will definitely be back again. read more

Donatina Neapolitan Pizza Cafe - Pizza bar - Pizza Near Me - Patchogue, New York

New to Patchogue I needed to find good pizza! Yelp brought me here. What a delicious slice of pizza! And the pepperoni is real pepperoni where it "cups." I didn't know this was a thing until recently. The dough itself and the crust had great flavor! I saw they offer it on their menu to add Mike's Hot Honey. I had some at home and added it and it was a delicious marriage of flavors. It was also cheaper than we normally pay for a pie with pepperoni. My boyfriend and I agreed it was very yummy and this is our new go to pizza place! They one a pizza my heart. read more

Donatina Neapolitan Pizza Cafe - Pepperoni pie - Pizza Near Me - Patchogue, New York

I finally tried this pIzzaria from seeing on social media and I wanted to try the pepperoni Detroit style pizza and it was simply the best pizza's I have ever tried deep dish wise. I loved the decor and layout of the restaurant. The place is very clean and Kira is very polite and gave me a lemon for the Pelegrino water I got. The cheese pizza pie was good as well. My family had a great experience. I ordered the cheese filled garlic bread but they gave me garlic knots. I didn't mind though. I'll definitely will be coming here to pick up more pizzas from now on. I just wish you delivered instead of door dash. read more

See all

The food was ok, I don't know if they didn't slice the pie but all the cheese came off was a little disappointed for what they charged, pizza should have been amazing. It was nothing special read more

Excellent pizzas! Small and casual inside, service was great. Things the only place around that I've found that serves Detroit style pizza.

Cute spot that makes fresh Neapolitan and Detroit style pizza! On the pricey side for what you actually get but nice staff and the food is decent. Wish the sauce had a bit more flavor -- appreciate the vegan cheese option! read more

Our favorite pizza place on LI! We absolutely love Donatina's. They make interesting and delicious pizzas (Neapolitan options are our favorite) and we always have a great experience, whether we are dining in or ordering take out. read more

The greatest (original) muscles i have ever had. The pizza is great, again largest selection of different terrific toppings and style. The other appetizers are very good. read more

Great Pizza place in town , if you are gluten free definitely check out there Detroit Pizza Delicious.

No pictures this time, sorry. This is our families pizza place to go. The staff are great and the owner is friendly. They have a large selection of pizza, Stromboli's, calzones, salads and more. You can have waitress service if you like. Great selection of beer and wine. Try the truffle pizza... or the truffle rice balls!!! This is the first place we tried Detroit pizza. Not only is the Detroit pizza great the story of why it's called Detroit pizza is even better!!! read more

I have past this place multiple times and always assumed it was a quick spot to grab pizza. Until someone told me otherwise and we decided to check it out on a Saturday night for dinner. We LOVED it. We decided to sit and be waited on.our waitress was very nice and kept checking in on us. They had an impressive list of wines and beers. We had the garnley head Pinot noir. Definitely recommend that one. The quality of the food is amazing. The cheese is fresh, the sauce had so much flavor and sweetness. The crust had just enough crisp to it. The brick oven they had did not disappoint in making the pies come out perfect. We had the chili honey wings for an appetizer and while very good they definitely could have used more chili sauce. It tasted more like a honey Buffalo wing. I had the margarita pizza and my fiancé had the meatball ricotta pizza. Both amazing. Make sure to ask for a side of their sauce and mikes hot honey to add to it. Good with or without but definitely worth trying. They also have a bar top area to eat/drink . They have a separate counter for picking up, separate from the eating area which is great. Highly recommend this spot! read more

Donatina Neapolitan Pizza Cafe - View from our table - Pizza Near Me - Patchogue, New York

I was super excited for this place as Neapolitan style places are hard to come by in these neck of the woods. Plus, they have a legitimate wood-fired brick oven. The pizzas were just okay but to be fair, I ordered some usual combinations from the menu; ham and fig pie and the chicken caprese pie. The saltiness of the ham and and sweet fig sort of complimented each other but the honey was a bit too much. It definitely felt sweet than savory, which is an odd flavor when eating pizza. A little less honey there buddy. The chicken caprese tasted like a healthy chicken salad on pizza dough. While I think I understand what they are trying to do with this pizza, a little more spice (salt maybe?) won't hurt. The calamari was disastrous. Spongy and not crunchy and I picked it up immediately after the order was done. Not sure if the fryer was taking a day off that day. Nonna's meatballs were the centerpiece of the meal, which shouldn't be the case for a pizza joint. Incredibly tender and meaty meatballs and the tomato sauce was extremely flavorful. This was an overall okay experience but I'll stick to the more original pies next time and staying away from the $13.00 calamari. read more

Donatina Neapolitan Pizza Cafe - Calamari - Pizza Near Me - Patchogue, New York

We came across this pizzeria on a very rainy April day while driving through Patchogue. We were unfamiliar with the area, but a quick Yelp search led us to Donatina. We didn't have much expectation as we were looking for a quick bite on a Tuesday afternoon. Food 3.5/5: We got multiple different slices -- plain slices, Margherita, Detroit style with mushroom. In total we ordered 5 slices among the 3 of us. This came out to around $20 with tax. We asked for jalapeños and the staff were willing to add them to our slices, however we were hoping that they would be cooked a little bit more into the pizza (see picture below). The mushroom Detroit style pizza is a good size portion, but for some reason it tasted very salty. The margherita tasted very good and it was my favorite among our order. The pizza is good for a casual meal and will definitely warm you up on a rainy day. Service 5/5: very friendly all around. The restaurant wasn't particularly busy when we went on Tuesday afternoon, therefore we got our food in minutes after ordering. The staff were very accommodating to our requests. Ambience: this is a very well decorated pizzeria. I enjoyed the vibes that the place exuded. It was very clean as well. Other: - plenty of parking - good for vegetarians read more

Donatina Neapolitan Pizza Cafe - Pizza Near Me - Patchogue, New York

"One of the top five pizzas on Long Island" Detroit style pizza is quickly sweeping through the rest of the USA. I never had it before but I swear it was love at first bite. That crunchy, airy crust now invades my dreams.. My wife & I came to Patchogue for lunch. Donatina Neapolitan Pizza Cafe is close to Bluepoint brewery, just off Main St. They have their own parking lot which is nice. Walking inside, I see a serious commercial Marra Forni brick oven?! I must point out, the Detroit Style pizza is not made in this oven. Before we start talking pizza, Donatina Neapolitan Pizza Cafe has an incredible beer selection! I'm glad to see lots of beer choices from Blue Point brewery available. My wife and carbs are a challenge. I mentioned I'd like to try the pizza style, she said don't worry about me and order what you want. We walk in and order the Detroit Style Pizza and my wife orders an Italian Wedding Soup. The soup was so on point. They did a great job, I love how they used traditional acini de pepe. The pizza is brought to our table. I'm looking at this pizza like the Mona Lisa. The crust is pure perfection, its crunchy! Think of a sicilian thickness but not as doughy. From the cheese they used to the sauce, this really is the total pizza package and worthy of the top 5 Long Island pizzas. Detroit style! My wife said every time we come here, she's going to order the same pizza. To me, the menu is great and worth exploring. I'd like to try their Italian style Burrata and pasta dishes. Donatina Neapolitan Pizza Cafe, the name is the combination of their two children. It's a nice place to have a pizza and a well crafted beer. I came back with my son a second time for the same pizza style but added pepperoni and MIkes Hot Honey. If you ever wanted to try a different style pizza, Donatina Neapolitan Pizza Cafe is the place. read more

See all

Donatina's has a great vibe to its location. Kind and friendly service. Please see my pictures for some Kodak moments! We ordered the Neapolitan Brooklyn Pie to-go and it was very tasty! The combination of San Marzano Tomato Sauce, Aged Mozzarella, Pepperoni, Peppers & Onions created a blissfully satisfying yummy taste upon my first bite of the slice. It could have been cooked a bit more well-done, but that's just my personal preference. Pizza lovers looking for an atypical NY pizza vibe will love it here! read more

See all

This place does pizza the right way. They do pizza all styles, which is a daunting task, but they rise up to the challenge. I'm a huge wood fired guy, and they didn't disappoint. My margherita came out with a thin crisp crust, no flop and the ingredients were fresh and flavorful. The sauce was tangy and the mozzarella was light with no grease in sight. I don't have to go to the city anymore for quality brick oven! read more

Donatina Neapolitan Pizza Cafe - Wood fired Margherita, well done. The crust was thin and crispy with no flop in sight. So tasty! - Pizza Near Me - Patchogue, New York

Great pizza great people very clean and decent atmosphere love going there you get a small pizza for a big price but other than that it's a great place and the food is really good overall straight up great place nice tasty sauce read more

Donatina Neapolitan Pizza Cafe - Look it up perfect this pizzerias - Pizza Near Me - Patchogue, New York

Wow. My new favorite Pizza place. I usually get a regular slice. But everything looked so good--I had to try (2)--Margarita and a Boston style slice --the one missing from the photo. All I can say is wow. And it's a great place to eat while waiting on transportation read more

Donatina Neapolitan Pizza Cafe - Boston Style Pizza It's got crusty cheese on the bottom and sides. Oh boy!!! - Pizza Near Me - Patchogue, New York

After Newsday gave a glowing review of this cafe, my husband and I took a drive over to visit. First, the young man who makes the pizza is worth the visit alone. He diligently rolled out the dough, tossed it up like a pro, cut it into perfect circles and then added the necessary toppings with great care. He had to put the pizzas into the beautiful wood fired oven, carefully watch several at a time, take them out, cut and then package them quickly. He deserves a raise!! (he mentioned only doing this for 6 mos. The server was very pleasant and the pizza was delicious. We'll be back. read more

Had a great meal here! We got two Napoli style pizzas to share, both of which were great. Service was very friendly even though they didn't have a server that day. Will become a go to place I am sure! read more

Donatina Neapolitan Pizza Cafe - Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Patchogue, New York

See all

I am 55 years old, Italian male, born and raised in Queens NY. Worked at 2 pizzerias in Queens throughout college. I consider myself an absolute pizza freak, burgers too. I have been to every Rays pizza in Manhattan. All of them are good, but I still dont know who the original Ray is. So I went to a concert in Patchogue and wandered into Donatina. Cool looking place, everything in order. Clean and inviting, so I ordered a slice. I wanted to like this place, really i did. But, the good part ended after I ordered. Ugh, it felt like someone died and left the pizzzeria to their kids, who promptly ran it to the ground. Some of the worst pizza I ever had, including out of state. This was worse than most frozen pizza, cruise ship style jarred sauce. Doughy, uncooked crust. No big deal, it was only a quick slice. A few months later I go on door dash, and order a Detroit pie from the same place. I would have never done it, and I would have never known it was the same place. My girl pointed it out to me, but I thought the Detroit pie looked really good in the picture. When it came, not only did it taste like crap, but it was very small too. Not that size mattered, the pie went in the garbage. read more

As soon as I sat down at the bar, a server promptly asked me if I wanted a menu, and boy! was it creative. The Primi Patti (appetizer) menu included Clams Casserole, Pizza Fries and Arancini di Funghi. The main menu was comprised of choices of Neapolitan Pizza, such as Butternut Squash and Speck, Spicy Surf and Turf and Rosemary Ham and Figs. This restaurant certainly has a Greenwich Village vibe. I sat at the bar and ordered a slice topped with mushrooms and caramelized onions that came fresh out of the oven. It was so good!!! There is a wine, beer and soft drink menu, which I did not order from because I wanted nothing to drink. I was not in the mood to imbibe. The crowd is lively, and the service is top notch. Two screen TVs, each one turned to a different channel, were on above the bar. The parking lot is rather small because no more than about 15 spaces were available including those reserved for the handicapped. If you don't fee like making a trek to The City to eat in a Neapolitan restaurant, try Donatina in Patchogue. It is worth the trip! read more

Donatina Neapolitan Pizza Cafe - Slice with mushrooms and caramelized onions - Pizza Near Me - Patchogue, New York

Clam pizza! The BEST. DETROIT PIZZA a different twist for traditionalists. They also have an ear for the likes and culinary needs of their clients. And they are community sensitive and are supportive. read more

We came home to New York and we got a Detroit style pizza. I must have been crazy. Yeah crazy that I haven't had this before. The pizza I got was AWESOME! We came in on a Friday night (during lent not the best idea) with a party of 8 people. The place was packed. We decided that we would get a drink at the bar and wait for a table. At the bar we ordered a round of drinks. There is a decent selection of craft beers and wines. We actually split up our group with 4 sitting at a table and 4 sitting at the bar. We had the meatball app. It came with 4 meatballs and sauce. Very good. The meatballs were cooking great. Nice and dense. The sauce was a little heavy on the pepper so my kid didn't really like it. We also had to Neapolitan slices with some garlic knots. Great for the picky kid. I had the Detroit style pizza with meatballs and ricotta cheese. It was awesome. Again the sauce was a little menace of the pepper so not great for the kid. But I loved the thickness of the pizza and how crispy it was. We enjoyed everything so much that we ordered a large cheese pie and a dozen knots for lunch the next day. My kid can't get enough pizza when we come home to NY so we are glad we found a good spot. read more

See all

This is my favorite pizza around! The Detroit style is airy and crispy. There have been a few times where it's been over cooked/burnt though. The Neapolitan is consistently great. Airy crust, soft center, really fresh tasting. Add the breaded eggplant as a topping to any of the pizzas, it's so good. read more

See all

Omg yasssss Finally here! I've been dying to get my hands in their carbonara pie ever since I heard they'd be opening, but the real star of the show might be that dope as hell Detroit Pie!?! My goodness gracious it's good. read more

See all