This is one of those places that gives you that nostalgic vibes! Got the veggie slice and the chicken Marsala with some knots on the side. Let me tell you. I always do the fold and lift. If it doesn't sag then that's a pizza! This place pass with flying colors! The crisp on the slice, the cheesy pull and the toppings galore! The knots may be simple but done corrected! You have no idea how many places just serves you old or dry knots. Not this place! Chewy, soft with that garlic buttahhhhh. Don't let the outside fool you. Signs might be a bit outdated but the food speaks for itself. I'm glad I came across this spot. They not trying to be fancy or new trend, over priced bs. They keeping it real and making them pizzas like how it use to be. This will definitely be my goto for sure ! read more

See all

Been coming to Nonna's for a while. It's our go to spot every time we go shopping at Patchogue mall. Their lunch specials are AMAZING! Always fresh, delicious and generously portioned. We had the spaghetti and meatballs and the potato and egg hero. The garlic bread they give you is SO good too! What I appreciate the most is the consistency at Nonna's. We've never had a bad meal there and always look forward to coming back. read more

See all

Honestly, how did I never hear about this place.??? Please try this place. It is in the same shopping center as Marshall's. The Focaccia pizza is slamming. All fresh ingredients and the best I have had in a long time. You will not be disappointed. The girls at the counter were nice and honestly the price was good too. The next time you are in Patchogue check them out. I am sure their dinner items are delicious too. I will be back for sure!!!! Enjoy!!!! read more

Nonna's Pizzeria - Focaccia Pizza!!! It's amazing guys...please try it you will love it for sure. - Pizza Near Me - Patchogue, New York

I drove here from Islip Terrace doing errands in the area and this place doesn't disappoint at all! The service is pleasant and their regular slice is nice and thin and flavorful. read more

Decent pizza. Good location. Good vibes. We had two specialty slices and they were fine

This was a few years back. Pizza was pretty nasty. They were caked up with flour on the bottom of the pie. I didn't expect myself to order a powdered donut as a pizza pie. The sauce was too sweet. Their mushroom pie was even more nauseating. It had sliced white mushrooms instead of portabello. Which was incredibly bland. You're only getting the texture of the mushroom, not the taste. Their garlic knots were just...*knot* good. Who puts parmesan powder on a garlic knot for the customer? Isn't that an optional thing the customer should do? I guess to hide from the fact the knots were bland. I swear it's hard to find decent pizzerias on Long Island. It's sad. read more

Most delicious shrimp pizza!!!! From the sauce, to the shrimp, to the cheese!!!!! So good! I've never had this before but will definitely have it again. We highly recommend. The buffalo slice was also very good. Friendly staff makes everything better as well. We'll be back. read more

Nonna's Pizzeria - Buffalo chicken slice what - Pizza Near Me - Patchogue, New York

See all

I've been ordering from Nonna's for years, and the food has never let me down. The lunch specials are a great deal, with generous portions that are pretty close to the regular dishes. They offer a wide variety of specialty pizzas, the staff is friendly, and the place is clean. read more

They make you use a third party driver because they don't deliver. It took 3 hours to get to me and the pizza was wet and cold. I called up to ask to talk to a manager and I get a kid on the phone. He says we don't do anything because it's a third party. First of all why would you give them a cold pizza to bring me instead of making a new one when you know it's no good. I wrote on there site to get in touch with me before I did a review. Looks like they do not care. So after this I will do facebook and all social media. They will lose my business and my company's business. We order 14 pies all the time when we have things going on. Do not eat at this place!! The owner doesn't care. read more

The girls behind the counter were on their phones the whole time while I was trying to order. The one girl touched my food without gloves which is a violation of food and health standards. Ordered garlic knots and they were raw in the middle and were bathing in cheese not even any garlic to the knot. The chicken roll didn't even taste like chicken, tasted like eggplant with no mozzarella cheese instead there was grated parmesan ? No sauce came with my food. Very immature and inappropriate staff read the reviews and thought this place was good but you can't trust everything you see online. read more

Nonna's Pizzeria - suppose to be a garlic knot but i don't know - Pizza Near Me - Patchogue, New York

This place was nothing special, over priced too. Everyone behind the counter was very unfriendly. Won't be coming back. read more

This afternoon I came in and ordered the scrumptious fried calamari appetizer and the succulent and flavorful meatball parmigiana hero. The service was spectacular because the cashier, waiter and owner engaged in small talk with me and promptly provided me my orders. The only thing keeping me back from giving Nonna's five stars is that their menu is not as creative as many nearby competitors. For example, where is the Chicken Marsala hero? or the Nutella-stuffed Zeppole? read more

See all

From time to time I go here. It a typical Long Island pizza place. They have a good selection of choices. The regular slices are good. The place could use a make over but as for the food it's on par. read more

Nonna's Pizzeria - Regular snd Sicilian - Pizza Near Me - Patchogue, New York

Service is wonderful. The food is a different story. Garlic knots are so oily. BBQ pizza is sweet. Missing parm cheese on the tables there's only the garlic, salt, pepper, and others. Place looks clean. read more

Food was delicious first time in had to wait a few extra minutes the girls behind the counter were super nice and insisted i take some food for free for the extra wait on a saturday night. Will definitely be returning. read more

Solid pizza. Good soup. I enjoy the variety of gourmet slices they always have available.

I usually do not write reviews, but this very upsetting which my family and I always come here to eat pizza as a family. Two ladies were very arrogant with us to just simply order a whole pie and eat there together as family. We've noticed the customer service changed. We also do not like to speak about race, we are hispanic and we noticed they treated other customers with much more respect and that is truly unfair. We asked for the menu because we forgot the name of a kind of pizza and the lady says "it's behind you", until my Aunt had to say it again because we didn't know where it actually was and we do not like to be spoken that way especially the tone she gave us, so she ended up saying "it's right behind you". Honestly if you are in a bad mood then don't show it because it may come off arrogant which we saw as. We noticed the lady assumed we wanted our pie to go, but she never even asked us if we wanted our pizza to go or for here. So it was just a matter of the small things that we noticed. The other young lady came with plates and only gave us 2-3 when we were a family of 7. Therefore we did wait about almost an hour for the pizza which was really good. We overall did not like the young girls's attitude and respect towards us, we hope it can improve for the future. read more

Called to order 1 large pie and 2 ceaser salads at 6:22 pm for delivery. Was told delivery would be well over an hours so I said I would pick up. Was told 30-35 min. I get here to pick up and salads aren't ready yet. Was told a few minutes more. I pay and I wait and wait and wait. FINALLY 7:16 the salads ready and I leave. As I walk out I can feel the bottom of the pizza and it's not that hot. Of course not! It's now almost an hour later!! Not to mention that while I waited the owner was making pizzas in the corner and 3 of the employees were standing around chatting, one was on his phone. Not one of them could go and make the salads? Very dispute say the least. We loved Nonna's and they have always been our go to. Time for a change i guess! read more

Ordered a pizza tonight and waited way over an hour to get it, ended up calling them back to see if the pizza was coming and was told on the phone that my pizza just came out of the oven it will be out to you soon. Living around the corner we get the pizza and it was ice cold, and looked like it was sitting around all day... old!!! Just absolutely disappointing. I will not be ordering from this place ever again!!! Happy New Year!!!!! read more

Not my favorite pizza but its close to home and good enough! It isn't bad, the crust is just not as good as I always expect it to be read more

Nonna's Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - Patchogue, New York

The food I ordered was actually pretty good. It's in this shopping center that doesn't have much, but hopefully the new Ashley's Furniture will give them a little more business. I went on a Sunday and there was actually nobody in there. Apart of my order was a white slice, which they didn't have any, but they gladly made for me. There was younger people working, and the only friendly one was this kid with glasses. He was so nice and made it seem like he was so happy to have us as customers. I wouldn't even be surprised if it was the owners kid or something - that's how good he was. Customer service and good food keeps people coming back, and absolutely no reason this has less than 4 stars. read more

See all

Excellent pizza! Always delicious and consistent! Love the music! Highly recommended! read more

This will be the most simplistic review I've ever written. But for good reason...hands down the best pizza I've had on the island. I live near close to 10 other pizzerias but drive the extra 15 min to come here. Reasonable prices, great selection of specialty slices, and friendly staff. Surprised myself that I hadn't reviewed this place years ago. You won't be disappointed! read more

The pizza was amazing very friendly employees especially the girl with the black and blue hair was very quick to get me my slice and get me outta there very fast definitely would 10/10 recommend going there for a nice little dinner read more

I have been to this restaurant twice. One last year and once this year. I didn't like it last year so I gave it another try. I ordered through Uber eats and got it delivered with in 45 mins. Pizza was thin and ice cold. It was delivered right away so i don't blame Uber. It probably was sitting around the store. I will not order from here again. I'm done read more

Easily the best pizza in Patchogue. Will not disappoint you. Not sure why this place is rated 3.5 but trust me it's 5 star pizza.

Awful service. So rude. Do not order from here. Never get it right. Was told I was getting new order sent to my house. Never did. Would not recommend! Staff does not treat their customers right. Also last time I went to dine in. I was served black burnt pizza..... what a shame. read more

Rude! First time here. I only asked what the toppings were on one of the slices. Rude! Started rambling every topping available. Rude to the very young girls ringing me up. Know wonder why there was a "Help Wanted Sign" in the window. Sad thing, the food was good. Maybe just a bad day. I'll try one more time & revise this review if necessary. read more

A family member ordered Nona's for a graduation party yesterday and all I can saw is WOW!!!! The garlic knots (that were in the shape of a rectangle - never seen that before) was amazing. The penne a la vodka could not be anymore perfect. I'm not a fan of chicken francese usually, but I tried it yesterday and THAT was also amazing! I think I found my new spot for Italian food for take-out!!!!! read more

Ordered on DoorDash.... this is the worse Italian food I've ever had. Rig vodka was horrible; meatballs flavorless, mozz sticks terrible. 1/10 would never get this ever again... shame to Italians and "nonna". read more

Went today with my 80 year old mom for lunch, excellent choices on the lunch menu. Prices were great found portion and taste awesome highly recommend. The 2 young men working the counter were very friendly and a credit to the business' my new lunch spot with mom,,,,,,,, read more

Great pizzeria with excellent service. The pizza has great flavor and well made. I would highly recommend the salad slice. Very good and somewhat healthy ;) Dinner plates are very good as well. The grandma squares are very good followed by the terrific garlic knots. Overall the experience at Nonna's has always been good. Great friendly services and good food makes it always a return place to eat. I would also recommend the ice cream and Ices as well. Special shout out to the crew behind the counter. Awesome staff and extremely friendly. read more

Ordered pizza delivery tonight Pizza was delicious and delivery was an awesome guy very polite Def no.1 in my book read more

Took a chance and ordered from here after shopping at Marshall's with my wife. Called in the order and picked it up. We were blown away by the quality of the food and service! A real neighborhood spot. I had the Rigatoni Bolognese that was off the hook delicious! The Italian bread was hot and fresh. My wife had the shrimp scampi nicely done with lemon and olive oil. I am now a regular customer. Highly recommend! read more

Love this place!! Pizza is always hot and fresh!!! The lunch specials are amazing and the value is so worth it!

Wonderful service, good food, and delivery. Ordered 30 Eggplant Parmigiana dinners individually packaged with spaghetti, salad and garlic bread. To be handed over to friends as take out for our CoVid time celebration. Food was delivered in trays and set up for quick transfer. Food was delicious, Salad crisp and fresh. Everything was delivered on time. Thank you. Compliments to the Chef and Staff. Martin, discussed options and take the order. read more

I was unimpressed by the selections available. The regular slices were small, and dough depth was inconsistent... Parts of the slice were very thick and some parts were very thin, they didn't taste very good. read more

Great spot for special slices! Not my favorite plain slice but I their special slices are amazing. Also, the Chicken Alla Nonna dish is a must try. TRUST ME! Quick service and great staff read more

Pizza was cold, dry and overcooked. The quality has gone down; I won't be ordering from here again. Staff is nice and my order was ready on time, but there are better options in the area. read more

Driver was rude and this is not the first time. Every time he delivers to me, he makes a nasty comment. This time he says "you know we dont deliver on mondays, right?" I told him update your slice app then, how am I supposed to know what hours this angry delivery boy feels like bringing pizza. Last time he says again in his condescending tone "you really like that philly cheesesteak huh?" And the time before that he says "really, you preordered at 5 am?" Like dude whats with the comments, just deliver the pizza and take the 20% tip. This guy made it certain I'm never ordering from Nonnas again, which is probably what he wanted anyway 'cause he hates his customers. read more