My first ever YELP review...I have been ordering from Angelas forever, but I must say, the OG chicken roll that was delivered was epic. It was by far the best chicken roll ever! I called to give cudos, and the owner, Vinny, thanked for the call and told me he made it himself. GREAT food, GREAT family owned business. HIGHLY recommend!!! read more

I enjoy their fresh pizza and sausage parmigiana hero. One question though, since you're my neighborhood pizza place, how come I have to drive to Amore's to get a personal pizza? read more

I'm new to the area. This pizza spot was recommended by a local. I ordered a half cheese,half pepperoni pie. The sauce was delicious, the pepperoni tasted fresh and the crust was thin and crispy. The owner was friendly and welcoming. Pick up was fast. They had a few booths for dine in. I took my food to go. read more

Best pizza in bayshore. Friendly service and environment. The owner Vinny was very welcoming and kind. read more

Angela's Pizzeria - Great sizes too! - Pizza Near Me - Islip, New York

3 slices and they were very good definitely coming back for more , thanks Angela's! Lots of windows and friendly folk to warm up after a cold day in long island. read more

Every time I'm in the area I will stop and so should you!! Pizzas are amazing and "oh my" to the pasta dishes. Fan favorite is the ziti . It's a hole in the wall gem. Service has been great every time . So satisfying. I highly recommend!! read more

Angela's Pizzeria - Baked ziti - Pizza Near Me - Islip, New York

See all

Have people who work there know what's on or not on the menu? Also I got multiple calls from workers about an order I did not make

Food - pizza was definitely oily and not what we ordered. Service - definitely messed up because we wanted a grandma pie. Ambiance is n/a. read more

Angela's Pizzeria - Is this a grandma? - Pizza Near Me - Islip, New York

Gave them another chance and pizza was horrible. Layed flat on my front seat and this is what came out read more

Angela's Pizzeria - Complete mess - Pizza Near Me - Islip, New York

I decided to try Angelas pizza in Islip, because of the reviews. I'm completely disappointed with the pizza. I ordered a square speciality sesame chicken slice and the dough was RAW.. the regular slice is to saucy and heavy. I will stick with the pizzeria on Gibson in bayshore. they are best with friendly staff. read more

There's a lot to unpack here. Angela's definitely has a cult-like following in Islip. It was always a little far for me growing up, there were just 12-13 closer pizzerias. But I remember hearing great things. I've gone a few times now. I enjoy it, my wife does not. Which hinders my ability for repeat visits haha. Many people rave about the sauce. I think it's pretty good, not my fave. But sauce is a highly subjective business. Where they really excel is the variety of options. They have tons of specialty pies. A cornucopia of pizzas to pick from. Garlic knot crusts? You got it. A half pizza half calzone monstrosity. No problem. The tough thing with a pizza calzone hybrid is it takes a while to cook the plump calzone half, usually resulting in an over cooked pizza half. That was the case with this bad boy. The bottom was rough at best. But it was fun! A novelty item I wanted checked off the list. Will I get it again, probably not. Am I glad I did, hell yea. read more

See all

Whenever I come across a consensus best restaurant I can't help but hold them to a high standard, in this case Angela's lives up to the standard set. This place is situated on a relatively quiet local road, it's rather small with about 4 tables inside and maybe 4 outside and 3 employees running the show at the time I was there. I went with their hot honey pepperoni slice and their chicken bacon ranch slice. The hot honey pepperoni pizza I noted has been trending online lately so I wanted to give it a shot. The crust on this thing was THICK so if you like bread you'll love this. I however wish the ratio of topping to crust was a bit more equal, aside from that this slice was a total flavor bomb. Salty pepperoni, sauce, and hot honey. Sweet and salty. A tried and true combo. I will note that there wasn't much spice at all but that may be for the better. The chicken bacon ranch was LOADED and tasted superb, I loved that the chicken was not dry at all as opposed to some places I've been to for a cbr slice. Oh yeah and the slices are MASSIVE. It took me a while to actually finish these slices over the course of the day but I did and I enjoyed every bit. I was super impressed with this pizzeria, so much so I think it might be my new go-to spot. read more

Angela's Pizzeria - Chicken Bacon Ranch Slice - Pizza Near Me - Islip, New York

See all

Okay this has been one of my go to's since I was a child and I completely forgot about it until the other day when I stopped in for a plain slice. Their sauce is just PHENOMENAL. It's sooo sweet and tangy I love it! Their plain slice was thin and just slightly burnt, how I enjoy it, maybe grandma allá vodka was lacking a little in flavor but the dough and the service well made up for it. I haven't been to this spot in forever but will eh dragging my boyfriend towards coming here over Gio's from now on. read more

See all

Very good service and good food I loved it here also it taste very good love it and always get it

Came from Chicago and had this on a business trip, delicious pizza and 10/10 service makes it an easy 5 Stars. Highly recommend!

I've been going to Angela's for a few years now and it's always the best spot for a slice of pizza!! The owner is always welcoming and friendly and the staff are always attentive and helpful. The food never disappoints and I recommend this place to everyone :) read more

If your looking for a place with a variety of specialty slices, Angela's is definitely the place to go. My ultimate fav is the Big Mac Slice. Staff and owner are friendly too. Definitely worth the drive. read more

Vinny and Tara opened this restaurant with heart ! He perfects every pie he makes, Working 7 days a week 12 hour days. He offers amazing pizza, lasagna, manicotti salads, the best garlic knots ever. He's a creative genius who learned how to make pizza from his Nonno..Tara was the creative genius who came up with the rainbow cookie desert pie. They even make gluten free Cauliflower garlic pie and their knots are to die for. Together they created an amazing family atmosphere with amazing food "Anything you want" he can create. Delicious food, read more

This was the coolest and most unique pizza I've ever had and I want more! The service was great, super friendly and got the food out quick. It's non stop busy in here and it's fantastic. You're not waiting long and your quality is amazing. It's really fun and and festive inside and it's a nice spot to just relax enjoy a slice and have a laugh. I already can't wait to come back and try some more. MAKE SURE YOU GET DESSERT! Fried Oreos, peanut butter cups and rainbow cookies were heavenly. This is one spot I'm glad I ventured all the way from Levittown for read more

See all

Angela's Pizzeria has the best pizza bar none. 3D pizza is what it is - there's amp!e sauce, lots of cheese, and a well made delicious large slice leaving one very satisfied. Nothing to comp?ain about here if you appreciate good pizza and most important - feel as if you got more than your moneys worth. I go to Angela's once in a while as I'm not a local, so usually end up buying a pie and have it for the whole week. The Sicilian and regular slices are phenomenal and Sicilian square slices toast very well and are great tasting days later. On offer is a wide selection of specialty slices which I haven't availed myself with due to the satisfaction of p!ain regular and Sici!Ian, both using lots of Angela's signature sauce. Here's where I qualify myself - I have a job getting around the tri - State area so am lucky enough to sample pizza everywhere. I don't eat hamburgers, beef, tacos, sushi, fish, pork, hot dogs, Poke, etc. With a lack of choices, pizza is on the menu for me every day. It really is hard to find a place like Angela's that is the full package. Most places the slice can be good but its cracker sized, or the cheese looks spray painted on or easily counted, light as a feather with fancy sprigs of oregano, etc. Rarely do I feel fulfilled as with Angela's on all aspects of pizza. Also the taste you get here is the same taste as when it first opened in the early 80s! Well done and maybe some day Ill get to try a specialty slice for sure! read more

Amazing pizza crumble sausage slice was heavenly!!!!! Highly recommend eating here workers were pleasant and kind

Big difference with a new owner. Kinda miss Joe and the family. Specialty slices are good and there are so many ones to choose from. read more

We drive 4 towns over for the best pizza on Long Island. Today we went traditional but their specialty pizzas are absolutely amazing!! read more

Angela's Pizzeria - Pepperoni Slice Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Islip, New York

I order a extra cheese half roni pie it looks disgusting like they thrown the pie to the Box cheese was all over the place and they didn't even cut it right didn't call or anything cause I live far but very disappointed bout this read more

Angela's Pizzeria - half roni pie and extra cheese it look bad looks like the throw the pie to the box cheese was all over the place - Pizza Near Me - Islip, New York

They claim to be the best pizza in town, and may I add definitely true, there are many Pizzeria's to choose from my Long Island and this is truly one of the best, they have so many different types of pizzas, ziti, slice, outstanding love, their vodka sauce, ravioli, I even tried the chicken and pickles. That's right pickle slice. Which was very good, I highly recommend the pizza with Chicken, cutlet, spicy, pepperoni, and garlic knot, That was amazing and a meal within itself,, The chicken barbecue was very good, the chicken, bacon ranch was one of the best I've ever had, I had the pleasure of meeting Vinny the owner, Amer. he say he's a gentleman first time I met him there's like no one in 20 years read more

See all

man do they really live up to their slogan, it is without a doubt the best pizza in town!! the chipotle chicken slice and the boom boom are my go to ! i try to swing by as much as possible to get my slices!! Very friendly environment and always very enthusiastic, and very generous as well! If you're ever around the islip area i'd really suggest making a stop at Angela's, the best pizza in town ! And if you're not close to islip, i would highly recommend going out for a drive if you have time and come give it a try, you will not be disappointed read more

I'm not pleased with this place...the meat balls were not shaped like balls and tasted bland. The pizza delivery person did a crappy job. My cheeses was all over the place read more

Angela's Pizzeria - Why does my pizza look like this? - Pizza Near Me - Islip, New York

See all

TJ, Lucy, and Greg were phenomenal. They were very helpful and the pizza is delicious. Every time I go to Angela's they never disappoint.

Pizza and service here are phenomenal! Whenever we are back in town visiting this is a must have!

The regular slice is just eh. The dough was heavy and the overall slice lacked flavor. But the kicker.... My boyfriend had gotten a Sicilian slice, he took one bite and a LONG hair was baked into the slice..... needless to say, we will not be returning. You can see the hair in the picture but I also have a video of the hair being pulled out of the slice. (Hair is blonde - no one has blonde hair in my house.) read more

Angela's Pizzeria - Hair baked deep into a Sicilian slice - there is a video for those that request. - Pizza Near Me - Islip, New York

The best Grandma and Grandpa pie I have had EVER!!! Great service and accommodating and pleasant staff!! Try them as soon as you can!!

Pizza is a little less than so-so, nothing was particularly tasty and I probably won't go there again.

Excellent pizza, greek salad, rice balls and hot heros. Chicken parmigiana hero and sausage and broccoli rave hero excellent!

The food was very good, the service is where I had to take off stars. The first time I ordered from here they forgot the large grilled chicken salad and when I called them the woman didn't seem to care or want to help. She was surprised I still wanted it. I figured everyone forgets something and whatnot. Then I ordered again the following week. It took twice as long as the time stated. The delivery driver did not ring my bell or knock. He just left my food on the porch. Luckily I was checking every few minutes for him. Then when I opened up the mozzarella sticks we had ordered the sauce container was opened, spilled all over and the sticks were sitting in the sauce soggy. The bag must have been shaken around or not handled very carefully. No one would eat them. This time I used their app help and was given a refund. But after two bad experiences in a row and with so many other pizza joints around we won't be ordering from here again. read more

Ordered something with sauce on the side.. came with sauce on it. Ordered a chicken dish and it was very rubbery.. usually very good here.. maybe just an off day? read more

Food is absolutely awesome!!! The sauce is delicious, everything is always cooked just right

something was wrong with the owner last night. He came out of the kitchen and was yelling at the customers all up in their face. It was actually scary. we've ordered from there a lot. Never going there again. read more

Great pizza and service. Lots of options to pick from, would definitely come again and try the rest.

We have a standing order of veggie pizza and hot wings. It's delicious and always on time. Love this place.

Vodka parmesan Hero is awesome. I would definitely recommend it. They also have great slices.