Always great! Whether you stop by for crispy delicious pizza for lunch or come in and sit for dinner, you will be treated like family. The food is fantastic, fresh pasta options often and always homemade cannoli. This is a family owned and operated business since 1977! Truly wonderful people. read more

This restaurant never fails to make me happy! The food is consistently delicious and the owners put their heart and soul into ensuring that their customers are always satisfied. If a customer looks unhappy for any reason, they are on their feet immediately to see if they can help. (I have been there when I am just having a "bad day" and the owner always asks if the food is good and if they can do something to make me feel better.) In this day and age, this is very rare! read more

Meet up w friends for lunch. They love this place and I can see why. They treat you like family. I like that the soda is in cans so you know it's fresh. The water was good and cold. They brought us warm bread that was crusty and chewy just the way I like it. They brought both butter and an oil mixture. I had portabella roasted pepper and mozzarella salad w balsamic dressing. Good portion and lots of flavor. My son had chicken franchise. It had good flavor but could use lemon in the side to add more lemon flavor. It was two chicken breast and pasta (you can chose your favorite it is made in house). My friend had the Capelli in red sauce that looks good and the daughter has the ravioli with spinach on top. Because we were celebrating our birthday, they gave us chocolate mousse cake, which was phenomenal and my girlfriend loves their carrot cake. I didn't try it but she loves it. Lots of good things on the menu. Can't wait to go back to try more. read more

Ordered a small cheese pie (6 slices) with sausage ($5 topping). I asked for pie to be delivered which was in a timely manner...about 20 minutes. Pie was fresh, delicious and 2 slices was very filling. The total of pie was $24.44. Delivery man did not have change to give back from $30. While placing order I was asked if it would be paying cash or charge & I said cash. Please have cash available to give back. If it wasn't for that 1 blooper, I'd given a 5 star review. read more

Fratelli's Pizzeria - Small pizza with sausage - Pizza Near Me - Bay Shore, New York

The pizza and desserts are always good but ordered linguine with red clam sauce yesterday and was very disappointed.

I've eaten here several times before and always liked it. Today, however, the pizza I got was the sorriest excuse for pizza I've ever had. Very little cheese, too much sauce, and just plain worse than ordinary. The homemade minestrone soup was just OK, nothing exceptional. And the price for 2 slices and 1 quart of minestrone soup???? $29!! I am so disappointed in this place. If it wasn't raining, I would have returned all for a refund. Very pleasant owners, but they lost me as a customer. Too many excellent choices out there to put up with mediocre food. Could have been an off day, but I wouldn't have let those slices out the door. read more

Tasteless pizza, not enough cheese. Paid $10 for two slices and a can of soda, expected better quality. Service was good, very welcoming. Hope they work on the food a little, especially if they're going to charge those expensive prices. read more

Tried Fratelli's for the first time today, very welcoming and top notch customer service. Ordered 2 regular slices price reasonable, but pizza itself looked like a frozen pizza. Sauce tasty, crust doughy. I may have just got it on a bad day, will try again. read more

I hate to write something negative but this just stood out that I had to. The price of their slices is insanely high, over $10 for 1 regular slice & 1 specialty slice. They charge $3.50 for a regular slice & they charged an additional $3 for the sausage & peppers on the other slice, so $6.50 for the specialty slice. I took 1 bite of each and just threw it out. No lie, it was that bad. If you are going to charge top end prices, at lease use top end ingredients and serve good pizza. The cheese was horrible on the regular slice and the the sausage & pepper had no taste. The place was clean and the staff was nice so that brings it up to 3 stars. read more

Delicious food and old school friendly service by owner--can't ask for anything better than that!

Love Love Love their food !!! We have NEVER been disappointed! I have also catered parties from Fratelli's ! All I can say is YUMMM!!! John and Vinny are the best !!!! This is our " Go to " for Italian food !!! read more

ordered delivery last night, only positive was it arrived hot, food was terrible, could not even eat it (and stale bread) $90 worth of food went in to the garbage I would not recommend this place at all read more

I have always loved Fratelli's. But lately their prices are through the roof and the quality is not up to par. So expensive and was told the prices are going up! Their eggplant parm hero's were always stuffed and delicious. Now they barely have any eggplant on them, with very little cheese. Such a shame. We won't be going back. read more

Great food and customer service is amazing this will forever be my go to for great pizza

Wowwww freshly made and the service here was quick. My family loves pizza. We can eat it every single day. Since February we have now tried a total of 3 different pizza spots between Bay Shore and Islip, NY. I have to admit this is so far the best of the 3 different pizzerias. An added bonus is that Vinny is so chill mode. One thing I look for when reviewing eateries is the demeanor of the employees and owners. I purposely chat it up with staff about anything and everything. I observed customers coming in smiling and I was happy to see that. This is definitely a family friendly place with more than enough seats to eat in. Again, everyone I encountered was smiling, sociable, and welcoming. The actual pizza: Oh my word it had just the right amount of sauce, a tiny kickback of spice from the pepperoni slices, cheesy, but not too much, and the best part of the pizza is that the slice was not flimsy when picking it up. The bottom of the pizza was light golden brown. The crust had just the right amount of crunch. I was so hungry I forgot to take a picture before grabbing slices. I'm not homesick for NYC pizza anymore yay. This thin crust baked deliciousness was just right with a generous spread of fresh marinara sauce, cheese, and pepperoni topping. With pizza like this, who needs a husband!!! I love my hubby and my pizza. read more

Fratelli's Pizzeria - Yummy - Pizza Near Me - Bay Shore, New York

See all

Fratelli's helped me make a memorable pizza party for my son. They were attentive and kept the pizza coming. The dining room was the perfect space for him and his friends. Thank you so much! read more

Good pizza , however the slices are tiny, if they had a larger diameter pie it would be great! You need four slices to fill you up or order two pies for a family of four. read more

The slices are very small, unmistakably really small. I ended up getting a whole pie several times and the taste was mediocre. My comparison was : 1) Difara's Ave J/E. 15th Brooklyn, 2) Little Vincent's of Huntington, and 3) Di Raimo of Huntington,4) La Casa of BayShore, 5) Gio's Pizza of East Islip. I walked to the shopping center directly across Saxon to La Casa. The pizza was notably larger and the flavor was excellent at La Casa, the price similar. read more

Jon and the staff at Fratelli are committed to helping people by serving them good food and doing right by the community. A group of friends pooled money to buy a meal for the ICU staff at a local hospital, where our friend's parent was being cared for. The hospital staff requested Fratelli's, so that's an endorsement already. Jon worked with us and the amount we had raised to get hot Italian food into the bellies of these essential workers, and he said he's been doing that kind of thing ever since social distancing went into place. If you order from Fratelli's, not only are you getting a delicious meal, but you're also helping a restaurant with a heart to stay open in these crazy times. Let's all do the right thing. read more

I came to "Fratelli's Pizzeria" for a little bite to eat. Little did I know it was literally going to be little. Coming inside, the place looked nice enough. They have TV's playing in the background and a nice atmosphere inside. I was unimpressed with the staff. A group of people that can't even greet you is what you get from them. I went over their selection of slices and landed on my two favorite. Once I sat down to eat I took a closer look at my slices......a real close look. They were smaller than average and I felt for the price, they should have been bigger. Eating the meat slice I was not satisfied. It had no real flavor nor did it fill me up. The next slice the buffalo, did no better. It tasted like buffalo sauce mixed with chicken and cheese. I almost felt cheated after eating my lunch. I walked out with my head down, because the building was beautiful, but the staff and the food left much to be desired. If I was a betting man, odds are I'm not going back. Atmosphere alone isn't enough to get me to go back. read more

See all

Great old-school pizza place: pizza is good, the sauce is great, garlic knots outstanding. glad we stopped here on a whim. the guys were friendly. It's a family run business. Love the neon sign! read more

1 slice and a soda for basically $5, 2 slices and a soda for about $8 and then 3 slices and a soda for about $11 (all regular slices and w tax included). Not a bad deal! The owner is always nice and respectful. The kids behind the counter are very good, too. I wouldn't mind paying an extra 50¢ to put pepperoni on the slices though. read more

This is the best pizza in the Bayshore area. The ingredients are excellent. We hade the Margarita pizza and the Sausage and pepper pizza both excellent crust was crispy great cheese not oily. read more

Pleasantly surprised! We meant to go to a different pizza place and made a wrong turn so we decided to stop and try this spot. Thank goodness we did! We started off with a slice of cheese pizza, the crust was authentic NY and we loved it. We also got an appetizer of calamari and it was excellent. Not chewy and the sauce was spectacular. I had a taste for pasta with Alfredo and a side of meatballs and let me tell you... it was amazing! The sauce was creamy and not thick and salty. The pasta was cooked to perfection and the meatballs were the perfect touch. read more

Moved out of state, but my choice for birthday before moving was having some delicious pizza such as the Crostini pizza --- delicious flabtbread, with tomato, mozzarella, roasted red peppers, garlic, basil, olive oil --- oh my how much I miss it already!!!! Delicious, order it and have more for leftovers unless you can devour it all in one sitting. A great choice and will not disappoint! ***I love NC, but have not found something even close to this delicious crostini pizza!*** We were frequent patrons when we lived in the area, as it was within walking distance for us. We always received courteous service from what I can recall and the crostini pizza we would order for pick up/take out and then we would drive and rush home to eat it, yum yum!!!!!! read more

low quality & over priced pizza. though the staff is very friendly, the pizza is sub-par as far as Long Island standards are concerned. The average cost of a slice of regular pizza in New York is approximately $2.30, but at Fratelli's Pizzeria a regular slice costs $2.85. There was not nearly enough sauce on the slice (although that could just be my preference), & the dough had been stretched far too thin before being cooked. When folded, the slice was unable to support itself, & instead, it flopped down & the cheese began to slowly slide off. I thought that this may have just been an off-day for whoever was making the pizza, but after visiting again two weeks later & experiencing the same lack of quality, I've determined that the pizza at Fratelli's Pizzeria is simply not very good. read more

Food was decent waitresses were very welcoming women Andrea and Gina are outstanding. I got a white slice and too my surprise it tasted better then it looked I later then ordered the garlic knots and cheesy knots....and I advise you to not get the cheese knots it was very maggot like could not stomach it...tasted like it was drenched it bleach read more

Fratelli's Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - Bay Shore, New York

See all

Pizza is mediocre as well as the establishment. They use a microwave to reheat items at the counter. Huge no no and unprofessional. What's wrong with the ovens? Only reason they got 2 stars is because the waitresses seem very nice and polite. The staff working the counter lacked professionalism and seem forced to be there. Slices looked like they were from last week. Better off going a shopping center over to La Casa. At least at La Casa they keep the place clean and have fresh slices. read more

Waitresses were lovely young ladies. Men upfront gave creepy unwelcoming stares upon entering the establishment. Food below average.

They handle the food without properly wearing masks (below their nose, not wearing one at all until coming to talk to a customer).

Fratelli's is my favorite pizzeria! The pizza is amazing! The stuffed chicken or chicken roll and mozzarella sticks are great as well! It's an authentic Italian family business, in which I highly recommend others to try. read more

Hands down the best pizza, never been disappointed. Their food is consistently awesome and delicious!

I decided to give Fratelli's another chance after charging me an arm and a leg for a stuffed meat slice last time. One thing that really bothers me about this place is that most of the pies aren't under glass and they exchange money directly over the pies!!! So gross!!! They really need to fix this immediately!! Not only is it gross but it is also a health code violation. I got a buffalo slice. It was good but about 30 minutes later I got explosive diarrhea! Never again will I eat here. And to too it all off, as I was leaving, there were two regulars leaving in front of me. The owner said bye and thank you to them. As I walked past him I said "Take care" and the guy didn't even acknowledge me. Just totally ignored me because I wasn't one if his regulars! Well I have been going to Fratelli's off and on for the past 30+ years but I will never go there again! read more

Fratelli's Pizzeria - Buffalo slice. Awesome! - Pizza Near Me - Bay Shore, New York

I recommend this place to go and get a slice such a good pizzeria. I got their Buffalo chicken slice and a regular slice so good. The guy Brandon behind the counter helping me was very nice and I would definitely go back again. read more

Upon further review and a Sicilian pie with meatball(not frozen) and sausage(kinda boring). I kick it up a notch. Good solid pie. I mentioned there garlic knots already how great those are. For cost of this pie...$27.00. in comparison round pie from Gino's with EVERYTHING on it...$28.00. read more

Great veal and pizza. Homemade pasta. Had an excellent salad tonight. Nice AIr conditioning. Family owned. They have been in Bayshore for 40 years now. read more

I've been going to fratellis for 15 yrs , real Italian recipes, great food,large orders ,great service ,, great pizza,,I give them 5 stars

The pizza is good, waitstaff is friendly! but it's not worth the owner checking your daughter out for.

Called Fratelli's this evening to place an order for pickup, a girl took my order and told me it would be ready in 25-30 minutes. I go to the restaurant and tell them I'm picking up and they said they didn't have an order placed and I must've called the wrong place. I showed them the number and confirmed that it was theirs. They said they'd make me my order and it would be ready in 15 minutes. 20 minutes later my order was ready and I go to pay, the owner did not even have the decency to give me a discount. I understand people make mistakes and things happen but at least a little something to compensate the fact that I waited over an hour for food I should've had in 30 minutes. Very disappointed. Will never come here again read more

Ordered for the first time. penne alvodka and penne with brocc in garlic sauce was AMAZING!!! Will be ordering again!