We were able to get a table for 2 on a Friday evening without issue. The drinks were good and strong. Not pictured is the bread starter and oil which was delicious. Portions are biggg The Sicilian calamari was delicious but my friend didn't know it had a kick to it and she was dying lol. Pasta/entres delicious! Pasta well made. The meat savory. I took most of it home bc I was full from the bread and calamari. Lovely experience and great food. read more

See all

The good: Meal was excellent. Huge portions. Fresh pasta. Love the atmosphere. The bad: Sat for at least 15 minutes before a server came to our table. And Sat close to 20 minutes at the end of our meal before getting our dessert to go and the check. read more

Butera's - Bay Shore - Fettucini with crab and scallops - Italian Near Me - Bay Shore, New York

What a wonderful night. Julia was our server, she was absolutely fantastic. She helped us work through what would be best for each one of us. I had the suggested pistachio, crusted salmon, and it was fantastic. It was so moist light and fluffy. The flavor is blended perfectly. Filling but not over filling. My husband had rigatoni short rib, Ragu and oh my God it was outstanding. It was homemade pasta, perfectly done with the most exquisitely flavored rib meat I've ever tasted. This place has it down to perfection. Every bite was more enjoyable than the last with good friends and good food. You can't go wrong. read more

See all

Drinks were good, food that we had was good even though it was only the rice balls. We sat at the bar and the bar staff was so nice, very friendly and smiley, I think that goes a long way. They had a good attitude the entire night, quick service, good drinks. Happy hour on the drinks but the drinks were still $13 a pop, however that's normal nowadays! Inside was well kept and it had a good ambiance. I'm a local and always overlook this place, I'll def be back for drinks and food. Worth a try for sure! I'll be back read more

Had a great meal at Buteras last week. We came with a large party (about 14). They couldn't accommodate a long table so we were awkwardly sideways and couldn't communicate with the rest of the party. For appetizers, we had the margarita pizza and Thai calamari. Both came out quick and delicious. My penne a la vodka was outstanding! Definitely an ample amount and has to take the leftovers home. The ice cream cake that my family brought was melted by the time it was served, but still delicious. read more

See all

Open airy restaurant for those who like good service and good menu assortment. Popped in for lunch and to check there event spacing option and availability. Hostess and seemingly shift manager at the time was gracious enough to check our suggested party date and space availability. Yes available so was walked over to the main center dinning area where my size party could be held. Decor is just enough without being over the top. Easily able to add a bit of party themed decorations with little restrictions, great! Took catering details and then sat for lunch to try some of their menu offerings. We started with the crispy Coconut Shrimp appetizer which was a good Large size and not greasy or burnt. Got to love clean frying oil ;) I then opted for the Grilled Shrimp & Goat cheese salad entrée and the Mr went for the Chicken BLT sandwich. Large portion sizes to easily bring half home for a 2nd meal. Too full to try any desserts but had a fair selection of items. Would consider going back to try more or even have an event at this location, easily. Only non-perk is the towns metered parking. So being prepared to look for functioning meter station and pay. Not worth a ticket or tow not to. read more

See all

Came here for a late dinner for two on a Monday night, no reservation needed and we were sat right away. This place isn't quite like all the other Italian places I've been to around the island that love to shape their atmosphere around brick and that old world Tuscan villa kind of vibe. It's much more modern and contemporary, and I actually kind of like that, even if the cheesiness of the others does give a nostalgic feel to me. There's some paid parking on the street and in a few nearby lots, and if you really want to stretch your legs there are a few free lots just a little bit further down the road. Our server, Jeffrey, was fantastic. On top of being very friendly and helpful, he checked in on us more than I can say for a lot of other restaurants! Sure it might have been a slow night, but he still made sure we were taken care of. Starting with some cocktails, my date got a glass of red wine and I got one of the seasonal cocktails, the Angel's Share, very bright and citrussy, I might not classify it as a fall drink per se, but it was delicious nonetheless. On to the food! They start you with some complimentary warm bread and garlic knots, which is always a good sign (make sure to save a slice for dipping is my word to wise). I got the grilled chicken with spinach and roasted peppers and my date got the ravioli pomodoro. The ravioli is as classic as it gets and I loved the plate they served it on, but we both agreed the chicken was the better of the too. A lot like chicken florentine and paired with some deliciously crispy potatoes, its not a dish to be slept on just because it isn't deep fried and covered in cheese. And on that point, one thing that actually really endears me to this place a little extra is their healthier options, like chicken meatballs, fish and veggie options, plenty of grilled over fried options, and a gluten free menu that's longer than anywhere else I've seen! The portions are also a bit un-italian, and what I mean is that they are not disgustingly huge, which is a good thing! Although I am a sucker for leftovers. We finished up dinner with the chocolate peanut butter cake as the perfect sweet treat. I'd be delighted to come back here and try out more of the menu anytime. read more

See all

The apple pie moonshine martini is the owner's secret recipe that he makes himself, it is such a star. If for nothing else I will certainly be back for that. Service was good. Our waitress was great, constantly checking in to make sure we were enjoying everything. The food wasn't anything out of the ordinary for an Italian restaurant. read more

See all

Here we go, As you know Butera has many locations. Butera is now in Bayshore. They have been there for some time now. It's located off Main street on 3rd Ave side street. There is a parking lot next door. Located up the block is a huge new apartment complex. Very convenient for ones who live in the area. Butera is also in walking distance of Long Island railroad and South Side Hospital. Nice place to get great food. My best friend and I decided we wanted to go to a new restaurant so we chose Butera. Great choice was made. The service was OK. I felt as though the tables were too close together. However the food was amazing. Real authentic Italian food. Of course the pricing was about 110 dollars but it was well worth it. For anyone who is looking for some great Italian food check out Butera's. It's worth every dime you spend. Happy Yelping.... read more

Food and drinks are never a miss!!! The chicken meatball pizza is the best pizza I ever had! That's my husband and I sweet escape when we want a quick bite and drinks read more

The Food was Wow! The pizza was good! But, the pork chop was Great! Service was right on top of all needs! The restaurant felt open and was clean! We felt very comfortable! read more

Butera's - Bay Shore - The pizza is a thin crust! We went with the eggplant, onion, and mozzarella! Very tasty! - Italian Near Me - Bay Shore, New York

See all

Omg love all the dishes here. Practically a weekly diner at this point. Homemade fresh ricotta (love it!!) just amazing. Mozzarella Fritta is light and flavorful. My go to almost every meal is there for the table chicken meatball pot. Just wow enough for the table. The biggest part of what I am drawn to is that the sauce is not sweet and not too acidic so no heart burn. Their service is friendly and inviting. The ambiance is modern and open. read more

See all

Fantastic girls night with my daughter. Delicious food and great service . Warm and welcoming Italian vibe!! Great choice for a nice night out with absolutely delicious food. Looking forward to our next experience. read more

See all

Just a quick update ... I had another wonderful lunch here at Buteras . The staff is fantastic, professional and polite as always ! I had the grill chicken with spinach , roasted peppers and mozzarella on focaccia bread .. it was outrageously delicious! Tender flavorful chicken with the veggies and cheese made it so delectable! I opted for the salad with vinaigrette dressing , it was so fresh and tasty ! Perfect place for a really nice lunch ! read more

Butera's - Bay Shore - Italian Near Me - Bay Shore, New York

While the service was good, the food was terrible. Order 2 appetizers, rice balls and calamari. The rice balls had a strange flavor, the calamari was very tough. After the appetizers was afraid to order a main course took the calamari and remaining rice ball home and put it in garbage pail read more

Not sure why it's taken me so long to try Butera's! I went here this past Friday with my dear friend, Emily B, to celebrate the end of her internship. At the recommendation of both her and our amazing waitress, Tara, I ordered the chicken BLT. I opted for the fries, which I, of course, dipped into the garlic aioli sauce that came with the sandwich. Each bite of the BLT was somehow better than the last. And the fries... wow. They had that rare yet perfect crisp that one can only hope for when ordering them. I came into this meal absolutely starving, yet the servings were so generously large that I ended up taking half of it to go! I'd be remiss if I didn't mention Tara again. She was so warm, down to earth, and absolutely genuine. As you can tell by their nearly perfect Yelp rating, their combo of great food and incredible service is surely a winning one. Can not wait to come back! Easy 5/5 for me read more

See all

My wife and I met a friend here for lunch one Sunday. To be honest, the restaurant itself is not as nice as other Butera locations. Kind of like dining in a spruced up garage. The food was decent enough, and the prices were going rate. The service was also decent. read more

Food is always great here. Large portions so you'll have lunch tomorrow. Its really nice casual spot . Drinks are good and the staff very helpful. This time we ate at the bar. Our server Beth was excellent and really cared that we were happy. The Thai calamari is one of our favorites. My only dislike would be the bar pie pizzas. Just dont think they match the quality of everything else . That being said. Love this place. read more

Another 5 star lunch. Had to try the shrimp bowl, amazing! Paired with a nice glass of toasted head Chardonnay. Always my go to restaurant when in the area. read more

See all

Met up for a much needed gal lunch. The food was delicious and good portions. We had wine which did not disappoint. I enjoyed the casual ambiance and the waitress was delightful. Not anyone fault but the parking is a challenge so plan ahead folks! I would come back here for dinner to try their entrees. I've attached photos for your viewing pleasure read more

See all

All the food was so good! Portions are family size which got a little confusing and crowded, but no one was disappointed with what they ordered. Highlights were the spicy calamari, veal rigatoni vodka, and brownie dessert. Service was attentive and the space is located downtown which is great for a post-dinner walk. Great for family celebrations! read more

Butera's - Bay Shore - Goat cheese salad - Italian Near Me - Bay Shore, New York

See all

Went for lunch. Food came out fast and tasty and my drink was great. The waitress was professional. There was outdoor seating but we sat indoors which was also nice. I would definitely go back. Hope you go and enjoy. read more

Butera's - Bay Shore - Billionaires Margherita - Italian Near Me - Bay Shore, New York

See all

Everything about the location went well truly a beautiful experience the drinks, the ambience, the service very intentional, free, flowing family atmosphere great food great service read more

Visited this restaurant for the first time for lunch. They had a lunch special which was great! Pizza and sandwich were delicious. Service was quick and knowledgeable. Would definitely come back! read more

Butera's - Bay Shore - Italian Near Me - Bay Shore, New York

See all

What I loved most about this place was the outdoor patio and the service. The food was definitely just alright. I got a chicken parmigiana sandwich and fries. It wasn't bad. I think if I went back to bay shore, I would try another restaurant on Main Street. The indoor seating area had like garage doors so when the weather is nice, those open too. There is ample parking as well. read more

Butera's - Bay Shore - Italian Near Me - Bay Shore, New York

We went Buterra's again the other night, i had the double cut pork chop Scarpiello style. Absolutely insane good! 5+++++ huge portion too! It was a few days ago and i'm still thinking about how good it was. And its not easy to perfectly cook a double cut pork chop! It was perfect, maybe the best ive had! Perfectly cooked, flavored and plated! Also, our Server was top notch, think her name was Nancy. Shout out to Nancy! This was my 3rd appearance here. I will be back again and again! read more

Butera's - Bay Shore - Veal Milanesa - Italian Near Me - Bay Shore, New York

Fantastic service. Lissette was an amazing server. So attentive and knowledgeable about the menu. FYI the Thai calamari and the Broccoli Ravbe dish with chicken meatballs outstanding! read more

Today we enjoyed our second visit to our new favorite restaurant. Nancy was our server and was very helpful. Nancy pointed out that all menu items are cooked to order so if we had any changes to be made they could accommodate us. We ordered appetizers and almost immediately changed our mind. Nancy was patient and polite about that. When ordering entrees, I ordered the gluten-free chicken and eggplant sorrentino and commented I'd love the veal dish but it's not gluten free. Nancy said no problem we will do the veal gluten free for you. WOW! It was very impressive to say the least. So, we ordered the short rib app and the flight of meatballs app. Our entrees were gluten free veal and eggplant sorrentino with corn penne and penne with chicken and shrimp in vodka sauce. Everything was delicious. The corn penne was even better than most pasta penne. The three different flavors in the flight of meatballs were remarkable, sweet and savory and spicy. The atmosphere is comfortable and service very attentive. We will be back! read more

See all

Started off promising we had a great waiter who was very attentive, the fresh bread was superb. I had to spit out 3 different pieces of calamari that were unchewable, however to be fair the rest of my party enjoyed it. Definitely frozen food from restaurant depot. The penne ala vodka with chicken was unappetizing, my girlfriend just flat out stopped eating it. The 6 mini scallops I had were good piled on top of the 6 cups of risotto. The lemon chicken had little to no flavor. The pizza may have been frozen with super low quality cheese. I tried a piece and almost gagged on it. My son actually got sick from it. Only giving 2 stars because the waiter was great I hope he makes it out alive. read more

I have been coming to this Butera's locations for years. This is the first time at Butera's in Bay Shore. The atmosphere is quite nice and there is a large bar. The food was awesome from the garlic knots and bread to the pasta with broccolini and chicken meatballs. read more

Two words: Blown. Away. Butera's of Bay Shore is worth the hype! My family and I started with limoncello shrimp which was in a creamy sauce with almonds and the pesto calamari which was over broccoli rabe and cannelloni beans. Never have I had broccoli rabe cooked perfectly from a restaurant before. Only my grandma could do it but consider me impressed that Butera's knocked it out of the park. For my main I got the linguine with clams and again they were cooked perfectly. Not fishy at all, and not over cooked. The sauce wasn't so heavy that I felt like a brick after either. This was a phenomenal dinner. Our waiter was amazing, attentive and made sure we had everything we needed and was quick to refill a glass or bring some cheese. It's a little noisy so I wouldn't recommend for a quiet date spot but for amazing Italian food you should definitely give this spot a try. read more

See all

The ravioli is great! My fiancé loves the chicken parm! The service is always good. I love their desserts as well! It can get a little loud inside though, making it hard to hear people at your table. read more

SMOKED SALMON BENEDICT Literally this is one of the best brunch spots. Staff are all super nice & friendly. Love going here. read more

Butera's - Bay Shore - SAUSAGE, PEPPER, ONION, POTATO FRITTATA (Italian omelet) brunch - Italian Near Me - Bay Shore, New York

See all

Food is amazing, service is excellent with a friendly smile , place is great for large party's or two . Ambiance is clean and inviting.

Everything was great! We went there for lunch and were greeted at the door warmly. My wife had a Coconut Martini and loved it. We ordered the Pulled Short Rib and Herb Ricotta Crostini as an appetizer (which was delicious and a large portion). I ordered the Chicken Cutlet BLT on house made focaccia and really enjoyed it! My wife ordered the Ravioli Pomodoro and which she loved! Big portions, so bring your appetite (we couldn't finish and came home with lunch for tomorrow). The service was excellent (thank you Desmond) and the owner came by to check on our experience and we had a nice conversation. We'll be back for sure, and look forward to live music while enjoying dinner - and when it gets warmer sitting outdoors. read more

Great dining experience! For coconut lovers, their martini is a must have. The service was excellent & the food delicious all while sitting in a great atmosphere with a great playlist. We'll definitely be back. read more

Stopped in right after happy hour so we missed the specials at the bar by ten minutes but stayed for a drink and had the cauliflower pizza and grilled calamari with beans and broccoli rabe I believe. Ended with two desserts. Sat at the bar. Brought us bread basket with garlic knots and bread and oil. Food was excellent. Tiramisu was dry though. Apples weren't cooked enough. Overall I'll be back but will skip the desserts. read more

See all

In a town loaded with restaurants, this one definitely stands out. Situated just off the main strip it offers delicious Italian food in a modern atmosphere. All of the food we tried was delicious (especially the double cut pork chop). The only issue we encountered was the service was slow, but I think they were understaffed the night we went (plus it was a Saturday). However, the waitress more than made up for it and she was wonderful throughout the night. read more

Butera's - Bay Shore - Double cut pork chop. Has a little kick to it, but very juicy. - Italian Near Me - Bay Shore, New York

I absolutely love Butera's! I've gone here a couple of times now both privately and for staff events and this restaurant never fails to impress me! I can't wait to come back, I'm definitely overdue! The food is absolutely delicious, drinks are greats, and the ambiance and staff are welcoming and kind! Love it here and highly recommend visiting! read more

It was New Years Eve and Bon G. and I decided to go out for dinner to celebrate the coming years end. We so liked Buteras for Mothers Day that we couldnt wait to return to Buteras on another busy evening for dinner. We had a rezzy and were seated quickly and were immediately visited by our wonderful young server Claire. You get a warm feeling in the dining room with all the attention received...from water refills to cleaning the table. We ordered a couple of cocktails; Bon had a wonderful Tequilla Coconut Martini, really pretty loaded with coconut around the rim...almost like a dessert! I had a delish Bourban Old Fashioned with Bulleit Bourban.. my fav. For Appy we got Fried Calamari with two sauces...Asian and Marinara. Was a nice touch. Also shared a wonderful Caesar Salad with anchovies on the side. My fav dish at Buteras is the Incredible Pork Chop Scarp!! Thick, tender and most delish Pork Chop I have ever had! A must have entre... Bon had the Veal Parm...tender white veal cooked to perfection. We were visited twice by owner Nick...a wonderful gentlemen who took the time to talk with us about our experience. We finished with a Tartufo, cool and sweet.. a fine finish to a wonderful meal. Thanks to the staff and wishing them all a happy new year!! read more

See all