So far so good! The fresh garlic and perfected flavor on that shrimp and garlic slice were to die for. If they made that as a regular pie with some red sauce id like to try it. So much potential there. Have T had their regular slice yet though. The meatballs were actually very good and better than the last four places ball I've tried.... . The stuffed knots were understaffed and under cooked but somehow I know they are still good and if they'd just fix that it'd be incredible. read more

See all

My go to pizzeria for lunch. Everyone is always so nice. The pizza is really good & they have a lot of different varieties to choose from. They have TV's so it's relaxing while eating. Give it a try & enjoy! read more

Always loved their pizza and it's only gotten better with the change to Caputo flour, you can definitely taste the difference. Check them out on Thursday for the hero special. The service is always great and friendly and a very clean restaurant. Can't wait to try the Roman style pizza read more

after a long day in the hospital, ordered a simple pasta dish & soup to take home; only to be very disappointed. When I called to share my disappointment, the response was to drive back for another ........ hard pass read more

I'm so happy I stumbled upon Mema's. Their pizza is fantastic, especially the grandma slice and the penne slice. I can't wait to go back!

My wife and daughter went there for lunch. Upon opening they needed the bathroom which was never cleaned from the night before. Absolutely disgusting. Health Department anyone? Their food was okay but honestly our family will never come back. read more

Tried this place 5-6 on different occasions the pizza is never consistent and I am speaking about a simple cheese pie. How can you get a basic cheese pie wrong? Some days it has been burnt and some days flat out chewy. There are much better places around that deserve local business and recognition. Will not be returning to this establishment again. read more

Came here around 8:15pm on a weeknight. There was still a large selection of slices-to-order. Some were more traditional (ziti slice, bbq chicken), but there were more creative ones (drunken grandma: a grandma slice with vodka sauce; MVP: marinara, vodka sauce, pesto). My siblings and I ordered 2 slices each and we were all pleased with our choices. The sauces were tasty, the mozzarella was plentiful, and the crust was crisp without being too crunchy). Overall, I loved it! I would come here again. Next time, I want that rainbow cookie gelato to go! read more

See all

Cheese pizza was a 3 or 4 star. The combo pizza was pretty nasty. Canned mushrooms and they just threw every single ingredient they could find on it. Not very tasteful. Penne allá vodka with chicken was quite bland and generic. Don't recommend, though if you just want a slice of cheese it's not bad. read more

Mema's - Mille Grazie Combo Pizza...wtf... - Pizza Near Me - Commack, New York

Pizza is amazing. Meal deal is amazing, penne ala vodka is the best . Service is always pretty good. Price is fair.

I regularly like to try pizza places I've never been to and sometimes it works out and sometimes it doesn't. In this case Mema's was a home run. The biggest vodka slice I've ever gotten and it was so good. That's one of my go to slices so it'll definitely be bringing me back there. I can't wait to try some of the other specialty slices they have and they do have quite the selection. read more

Mema's - Pizza Near Me - Commack, New York

5.9 on official pizza scale. Floppy, oily. Good variety but too much flop and needs a better balance of sauce and cheese. Really nice people; good service. read more

The best pizza. Also they are so nice. I will definitely back for more pizza. Best pizza ever. I loved it read more

Mema's - Pizza Near Me - Commack, New York

Great food. Friendly staff. Incredible specials! Family friendly mid-week meals and prices. read more

We are new to the area and we were looking for a place that made delicious chicken parmigiana and penne Ala Vodka. We had been going to Calda for years but moved. Our plan was to try a place and if not great move on.. My daughter had said Mema's had good pizza so we figured we would start there. Well after placing our order over phone and having the Penne Ala Vodka as our pasta side in place of the regular pasta side, I believe our search is over. The Chicken Parmigiana was outstanding and the sauce was just as good. Next time we will order the Penne as a regular dish as the portion we got as a side was a little small. The side of bread we got was fresh and delicious.. Well done Mema's see you soon. read more

Solid. I ordered chicken parm, rigatoni all vodka and a grandma pie for a summer party. Impressed and a great price. I would definitely order for a party again. read more

Favorite local pizza and Italian restaurant! Amazing and delicious food. There chicken parmigiana and penne all a vodka is the best!!!! The are always super quick to answer the phone. The restaurant has done of seats and super clean. read more

Some of the best specialty slices around. Always clean inside and the staff is friendly as well as prompt . Good place to sit and eat . I order form here at least 3 times a month. read more

Haven't been here for a while only because of my work coverage area but noticed some new specialty pizza slices. I've had the Mac & cheese which is like a meal in itself, the buffalo chicken, and today the General Taos. Everything is fresh and delicious! Prices are reasonable since the slices are generous with the ingredients. There were some other ones I saw that I must try. The Grandpa slice which was breadcrumbs & sauce. Check it out- there is something for everyone! read more

Some of the worst pizza I've had. We tried regular, sicilan and grandma. All the slices were bland; the dough, the sauce, and the cheese -- it's almost like there was no salt in any of it. I'm not looking for salty pizza, but the sauce just tasted like unseasoned tomatoes. The Sicilian slice had a ton of sauce on it too, and the cheese fell right off. Grandma tasted like bread with tomatoes. Would not go there again..go a little further east down 25 to Don Jono's instead. Their food is fantastic. read more

First we tried their family meal deal, which was amazing! Then we ordered food for catering which was absolutely amazing! Large portions and so delicious! Definitely recommended Mema's! Everyone enjoyed the food! Great service and flavorful authentic Italian food! read more

Good food, good pricing, and the owners are good to the community. That is why we patronize Mema's. Their white pie is absolutely fabulous and my family loves their grandma pie! I do not care for the regular cheese pie because find it a bit too salty. Overall, a good place for takeout or sit down. read more

Love this place! We ordered their pizza the first night we moved into the neighborhood and it was 9/10! Our favorite thing to order from them is their weekly family style special! It is worth every penny, perfect for a family, and absolutely delish ! read more

We just ordered several family fests. Everyone loved the chicken franchese and chicken marsala. The pasta and salads were a hit as well. LJ was very friendly, knowledgeable, and a great help in the ordering and pick up process. I would definitely recommend Mema's read more

The food was amazing! We ordered for delivery and it came quickly and still tasted great. Will be ordering again!

Delicious meatball parm hero at a much cheaper price than many of their competitors. I still would love to walk into a pizzeria and hear Italian music playing. One of these days. read more

Mema's Italian Kitchen is a pizzeria located on a strip mall with other small restaurants and shops. The pizza is NY style slices with a huge variety. I recommend the Margherita slice! Just the right amount of sauce and basil with a sprinkle of Parmesan, and large slices of mozzarella. My order came out in ten minutes and was fresh from the oven. The dining room is open to all guests that dine in casually. If you order an entire pie, I suggest calling in advance. They have a soda machine that has over 15 flavors. The pizzas could be a little thinner but overall great pizza with crispy crusts. read more

See all

I catered food for a holiday party and the food was delicious. They delivered the food on time and it was hot! Everyone at the party said the food was fantastic! I will definitely be ordering from Mema's from now on. read more

My sister in law raves about this place and had ordered a gluten-free pizza for me. This was the best gluten-free pizza I've ever had. And it's the closest one that resembles regular pizza. Pic doesn't do it justice, but it's a small personal pie, savory and filling! read more

For a local pizza spot this place is excellent. Great specialty slices as well as their traditional regular and Sicilian. There's ample seating if you're looking to grab a quick lunch or dinner and the staff is very friendly. read more

Best local pizza place! I've lived in the area for most of my life, so I have tried many different pizza places in the area, and Mema's is my favorite! The food is always fresh and tasty, and the service is fast and efficient. My favorite slice to get is the Cajun deep dish chicken. The dough is so thick and fluffy on that slice, and the flavor is amazing. I am also a fan of the chicken parm and meatball heros- Mema's is delicious ! read more

We ordered lunch from Mema's today and it was fantastic! Our mozzerella sticks and calamari were delicious. We absolutely loved our two pies. The vodka sauce pie is a great combination, sauce is very tasty, better than a regular pie. Our favorite is definately the chicken marsala pie...the generous amount of chicken and mushrooms is super delish! Cant wait to order again! read more

See all

*COVID-19 Quarantine Time* You can only enter the location if you have a face mask but if you dont, they have their store number posted on the outside so that someone can deliver the pie to you! This is genius for people who have mistakenly not taken their mas with them for the day! Food: Plain Cheese Pie - LOVE! I always order a large pie, well done, light sauce. The sauce is slightly sweet but you can tell that they didn't add any sugar to it. Simplicity is key! I've noticed that when I order a medium pie, they would use the same amount of dough as the large pie. If you like more dough to your bite, then a medium pie is for you! On to my next take out adventure... read more

This pizza place got high marks until today. My son is there every couple weeks ordering a half chicken parm half vodka pie. He loves it. Tonight he was coming back from visiting me in Florida and his girlfriend ordered by mistake chicken and broccoli pie. My son called him and the owner tells my son I made the pie you have to take it what am I supposed to do with it. This is how you treat a loyal customer? What do you do with it? Well It by the slice I'm sure it will go. You just lost a loyal fuckn customer over a 25 dollar pie I'm sure you could have sold slices and made back more than half. I won't be back when I visit read more

i order for my father they are great delivery on time very helpful so nice great food love there pizza and pasta

Saw this pizza joint in my travels, and went to check it out on a later date. Though I haven't sampled much of their fare, what I have had is enough to bring me back for more of the same, and then some! Tale of the tape: Garlic Knots Sizes range from between small to medium sized pieces. Dough is light, not heavy like some knots out there. Sadly, they are light on flavor and do not have nearly enough of the garlic bite one might be looking for . . . Stuffed Spinach Roll While the dough was fine, the spinach stuffed within was not plentiful enough . . . but even more unfortunately it didn't have the garlic bite you crave in a sauteed spinach situation. Where is all the garlic being used, if not some for the garlic knots and the sauteed spinach?! Grilled Chicken and Broccoli with Wheat Crust Slice Decent and satisfying bite, though admittedly there could have been a bit more chicken and broccoli atop the thin, crispy whole wheat crust. Penne a la Vodka Slice Substantial slice, a meal unto itself! Unlike many pizza places, the penne a la vodka slice was good . . and while I have had vodka sauce that was better, this was good enough for me to order it again in either slice or dinner format on a subsequent visit! Cajun Chicken Slice This slice has a thick crust, and the toppings are piled equally as high. The toppings are in turn topped with ranch and cajun sauce. A LOT of it. Too much of it . . . Chicken pieces are large and plentiful, but I didn't get any hint of cajun spice flavor from them. Not bad overall, and very substantial, but inexplicably the taste doesn't live up to the name . . . Mac & Cheese Slice This slice alone was worth five stars! The rich, creamy, and most importantly TASTY and PRONOUNCED cheesy bite took me to a place of culinary bliss, from whence I did not want to return! This is exactly what you want in a GREAT mac & cheese, whether it be on a slab of thin, crisp and light pizza dough or not! On a subsequent visit I complimented them on their mac & cheese alone, dough or no, and the very nice girl behind the counter told me they do get a lot of kudos on it . . . of this I have no doubts! Mac & Cheese Dinner The same amazing mac & cheese as above, except without the crust, and with a sprinkling of bread crumbs on top! The takeout tin was full to capacity, and there is so much cheese going on here that you could add a little of your own pasta to it to spread out the deliciousness of this dish . . . or maybe add a bit of chicken . . . or beef . . . Comes with a half loaf of cut Italian bread. I will definitely return for more of their Mac & Cheese, will sample their other fare and update this review, accordingly. read more

See all

I wanted to love Mema's I really did, but I just like it. I loved the service, very friendly, happy smiling employees. I loved that they had a local beer on tap, Spider Bite, but I didn't love the atmosphere or the food. As for the atmosphere, I heard they just remodeled, maybe they're not finished?????? It's hard to tell, it has a very deconstructed look about it, and no menus, no prices???? The pizza was ok, I've had worse and I've had better. I was a little underwhelmed by it all. read more

Mema's - Regular slice and Spider Bite - Pizza Near Me - Commack, New York

10/10 so delicious the pizza oh my goodness! I loved the fresh mozzarella with tomato and pesto slice

I love there pizza, the owner is really nice and very friendly, the staff there is very friendly and the ambiance is very calm, very clean and you can sit and enjoy your pizza and not being rushed which is not a issue there. When I went with my mom it was not busy which made it very nice. I never seen it really packed but I really enjoyed there food read more

Delicious pizza, salads and calamari. Quick & friendly service as well. My go-to pizza spot.