I had an excellent experience with Mario's! Fast service and I had the meatballs and spaghetti! Boy was that good! Hit the spot comfort food. The sauce was so delicious, very tomato-y and well seasoned and NOT salty. I enjoyed it immensely! Can't wait to go back and get it again! read more

Mario's is a pizzeria that is in my family's rotation of local pizza spots on a Friday night. The place is nice and modern - plenty of seating even on a busy Friday night. I like how they bring the food over to the table. Pizza is good - always offers a wide variety. I feel like my slice could have been a little hotter and in the oven a little longer today, but maybe that's just me being picky. Garlic knots were tasty. Great garlic taste and not oily at all. I don't like oily knots. I wish they had the fancy coca-cola soda machines. I like having the option to choose from a variety of sodas/teas, etc. read more

Mario's Pizzeria - Garlic Knots, Spinach & Broccoli Pinwheel, Chicken Roll, chicken bacon, thousand island - Pizza Near Me - Commack, New York

See all

After years, I had to come back to update my review. We are regulars here, at least twice a week. The pizza and wings are always good. You are greeted warmly each time as well. The place is new after being completely flooded out and it looks great. Today is world autism awareness day, 4/2/25 and I'm updating my review specifically on this day. When we come in, I'm always with my son who has autism. He is so excited to eat his pizza so he is usually stimming and lining up the stools-typical autism stuff. The other customers look and/or stare but NEVER the guys behind the counter. They are always so kind to him. They wave, they ask how he's doing (even though he's nonverbal) and sneak him a cookie. Thank you Mario's for the kindness you show him. It keeps us coming back and it means the world to me. read more

Mario's pizzeria in commack, has got to be one of the best pizzerias I've ever been to. From the modern aesthetic (completely new reno) to the customer experience, cleanliness, great atmosphere and food. As far as food goes, every slice & every dish is prepared with fresh ingredients and the best alla vodka sauce (in my opinion) in town. I can tell you from experience, they are highly invested in giving the best quality in all areas of service to the public. Parking lot is huge. Place is huge as well. Have lots to do near. Great location. Employees are so sweet and kind. They go the extra mile. Great management. Five stars are well earned. Music is great. Big tvs, just incredible guys! Check it out. read more

They use very fresh ingredients and prepare to your preferences. The staff at Commack location, are cordial, and excel in customer service, We have dined in their comfortable large indoor area, and we have also done two large caterering orders. They ALWAYS get the order correct, and home delivery is always on time. We prefer to order direct from Mario's, and do not recommend using Ez cater. Ez cater screws up deliveries and addresses ALL the time read more

I saw "Mario's Pizza" and assumed it was part of the Mario's chain of pizzerias, boy was I wrong. But it's definitely on the same level. Parking was a breeze. The lot was huge. Looking at the building I admired the modernness. Inside, what you first notice is how clean it is. I mean it's perfect. In my mind, that means the food is good if they care about important things like cleanliness. There was plenty of seating, with booths and bar seating throughout. They definitely can handle volume. After admiring the building I made my way to the counter to order. They had a lot of specialty slices to choose from. I always go for the normal. This time would be different. There were plenty of people working in the back, but two guys in particular helped me. They recommended the chili slice with pineapple. I thought, what! I don't know why people like pineapple on pizza, but I let them talk me into it, needless to say, I'm glad they did! Everything on the slice worked. The little sweetness from the pineapple complimented the chili. I couldn't believe how delicious it was. I had to stand up and clap.....well, not really, but you get the point. I became a patron at that point. I definitely will be going back. If the rest of the slices are as good as that one...I may need bigger pants. read more

See all

I've order from Mario Pizzeria for many many year, ok mistake happen, but when managers don't want to speak to customer when catering order is placed and only half the order is delivered then you call they tell you that the delivery person just left with your order, 45 min later still not delivered, call back with being told manager is to busy. ohh well just they will lose all my business. and I will let people know REALLY SAD THIS IS HOW YOU TREAT LONG TIME CUSTOMERS read more

I've been to Mario's many times over the years, as it's located near my family's house. According to my cousins, Mario's is the place to go for specialty slices. They had a bunch of options, including meat lovers, my favorite. If you're going for a plain slice, I don't think it's the best around. Mario's is a decent spot to dine in or take out. The inside of the restaurant is pretty nice for a casual pizza spot. They have other food options as well, but we just went for the pizza. Our slices were ready in a reasonable timeframe and the employees seemed to be efficient overall. No issues from me! read more

See all

Consistent quality for quick traditional Italian dishes Uses a decent delivery service read more

My go to spot for a personal margherita pizza. Always good, I get mine with regular crust. Look at the picture. It makes my mouth water every single time. read more

Mario's Pizzeria - Margherita personal pizza - Pizza Near Me - Commack, New York

As far as pizza in Suffolk County goes, I was actually impressed by Mario's Pizzeria. I went with my family for a quick bite on a Sunday afternoon. We have our own pizza spot, but figured we try something new and more local to our home. The customer service was really good despite the multiple reviews that criticized the service. I ordered my food at the front and within 3-4 minutes, got my slice at my table. While they are known for their pizza, they offer other food items, such as salads, soups, and pasta. The slices are very large and affordable. They can make the slice a little more crispy if you specify. One slice will leave you satisfied. This place is good for vegetarians. Plenty of parking in the complex. read more

Mario's Pizzeria - Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Commack, New York

Call to place an order for delivery at 6:30 PM ... the women stated it won't get to us until 9:30 PM what a joke !! Called the next pizza place in town and got food at 7:25 PM !! Don't waste your time at Mario's read more

I ordered the Marsala and couldn't find the Marsala anywhere. It tasted like a brown gravy sauce. Not good and will not try them again.

*THE BEST SPECIALTY PIZZA SLICES IN SUFFOLK* OVERVIEW: Dave Portnoy, from Barstool One Bite Pizza Reviews, has become immensely famous, reviewing pizza restaurants all across America. When filming these YouTube videos, to keep things simple, Dave almost exclusively rates plain round cheese pies. But now, if I visit a pizzeria, I'm not always going to get a regular, or a Sicilian - mostly, I'm ordering specialty slices. And nowadays, it seems every pizza restaurant offers specialty slices. However, more often than not, they're usually mediocre at best. Marios, on the other hand, has some of the best specialty pizza slices I've ever eaten. Take a bite, and you can tell they are carefully crafting each pie, and using only the freshest ingredients. Now, have you ever bought a slice somewhere, and you could tell immediately that it had been sitting around for a really, really, long time. It's disgusting right? At Marios, there is no chance of this happening. Here, everything is so good, the slices fly out the door, all day long. And lastly, if you enjoy salad pizza, like I do, they have a few offerings here, that are going to blow your socks off. WHAT TO ORDER: - You can't go wrong with any of the slices served here. It really depends on your preference - The grandma, and the grandma vodka sauce slices are garlicky delights. -The grilled chicken Ceasar slice here, is the best version I have ever tasted. - The Milanese with arugula, tomatoes, chicken cutlet cubes and a light garlicky dressing is the best salad pizza slice I have ever eaten. Sometimes, I remove the chicken and eat it as a pure salad slice. Other times, I enjoy it all together. Both ways are absolutely delicious, and I always have to order at least one of these slices. - The Margherita with fresh mozzarella, marinara sauce, basil and olive oil is unique. - If your looking for something lighter and more healthy, try their Bodybuilder Bowl. It's served with whole wheat penne pasta, vegetables, and grilled chicken in a light garlicky sauce. DECORE/ SERVICE: The restaurant is nicely decorated, organized and very clean. There are about twelve tables up front for a quick bite, and then, a separate dining room area for full meals. The service is fast and friendly, and they always let you know they're happy to see you. Even more, your order is always correct, which is something that is becoming less common at food establishments today. PARTING THOUGHTS: What would Dave Portnoy rate Marios regular cheese pie? Who the helll knows, but I would rate most of their specialty slices in the high eights, and some like the Milanese in the nines. So why don't you come rate it yourself - I promise - it will be a good time. read more

See all

They offer vegan pizza!!! But its not flavorful enough... if they added a few common spices ( hot pepper flakes , basil etc.,) the flavors would be easily enhanced ... so 4 stars for trying and 2 for actual taste,,, it was bland vegan foods are amazing but at times need more or different enhancing. read more

Horrible. We had a birthday party and there was a family of vegans. We ordered a basic vegan cheese pie to accommodate them and it took over 2.5 hours to arrive. I was so embarrassed at my kids' birthday party. My husband was on hold for over an hour with a gentleman and when I used another phone to call, a female answered immediately so they were clearly playing phone games. And of course, "it will be on its way in 15 mins" was a lie after lie. When we finally got our damn pizza, they gave small a bag of free garlic knots, which I admit were pretty good. Fine, businesses have flukes and Mario's got a great reputation. We decided to give it a try... and it came at a decent time..(40mins) but the photos speak for itself. The Sicilian pizza is unappealing, tasted bland, and a soupy...the pasta-was ok but could use a bit more salt. The pinwheels and Stromboli were just embarrassing to look at and even worse to eat, it was short on ingredients and was dry/ clearly old -just reheated. The basic cheese pizza was good and the kids enjoyed that. I really tried with Mario's but with their disappointing food, horrible customer services and lies, I can no longer support this business. read more

See all

delicious pizza, but so overpriced for this specialty slice. i think i paid $7 or $8??? it was delicious but wtf i never paid that much for a slice of pizza. i'd come back but not anytime soon...... read more

Mario's Pizzeria - eggplant ricotta slice - Pizza Near Me - Commack, New York

I went here after work on day and I was amazed. I usually go to another pizza place near my house but this is my new favorite. The food is amazing and from pastas to slices there food is so so good! The service is is quick and they even offer good delivery that isn't killing the bank! The restaurant is super clean and kept well. Staff are kinda and not counting down till they can leave like most places treating you rudely. Definitely recommend!!!! read more

Delicious fresh flavors, for those gf, I had a margarita pizza on a cauliflower crust. It was a 10 inch pie and wanted to eat it all. So yummy! read more

Good pizza overall, just pricey. I usually get it from TooGood2Go and can't complain for that price. But $7 for a specialty slice? No thank you read more

A new "course record" for me... One regular (plain) slice and a soda - $7.34 The slice was awful. Badly reheated and just no good. So why 2 stars? Because it was a very large slice. read more

Decided to try Mario's this evening as it's close to my home! What a mistake- I ordered ONE dinner- an eggplant parm at 6:03 pm online.The order was to be ready between 6:25 - 6:35. I arrived at 6:25 to be told it would be a few minutes. No problem. I took a seat and waited only to hear the cashiers tell people who came to pick up and or order- " We are busy, it will be a while". Next a group of 3 walk in and place dinner orders. It's now 6: 40 and I inquire again and am told the same thing- " oh it will be a few minutes" . I take a seat and wait... wait... 6:55- and the food for the group comes out! At that point- I ask again- is my one dish ready? The ONE dish should have been ready before the three walked in- The same response- sorry, we are busy" Really, because I just watched dishes come out - I'll take a refund !!!! The excuses were unacceptable and definitely NOT good for business. IMO- they need a better system! Do not take orders if you cannot fulfill them ! Not a fan nor will I return. read more

I wanted something light so I ordered the salmon and it was dry as a bone. Ended up feeding it to my dog. Everything was smothered in too much oil including the spinach and mixed vegetables. Nowhere on the menu did it say there were mushrooms in the vegetables. I am allergic to mushrooms so I picked them out and gave them to my husband to eat. Hopefully I won't have a reaction to the mushrooms. read more

They make great pizza. There isn't to many on Long Island who have great pizza. Great prices as well

Stopped in to Mario's after checking out Dortoni's new location in this same strip mall. I returned when I picked up an order from the bakery days later. Tale of the tapes: Visit 1: Garlic Knots Small sized with a light texture, and unfortunately little garlic flavor. One tastes more of the light dough than the barely perceptible garlic flavor Spinach and Artichoke Empanada Shell is thin and light, filling is savory with a good flavor. At a $3.89 price tag, though, trying their various flavors could be an expensive, if not a sustained hunger proposition given the size of an empanada vs that of a specialty slice, which is just $1 more. Customer Service The guy who took my order was a bit gruff, even though it was toward the end of their work day. Still, that doesn't excuse his rather abrupt behavior. It was a little difficult to hear through a nicely designed and installed, yet utterly useless and frankly pointless acrylic screen. Would I return? Yes, but only to get a slice of their vodka sauce pizza, which some reviews proclaim as excellent. ================================= Visit 2: Buffalo Chicken Empanada Filled with small chunks of breaded chicken cutlet, cheese, and a savory buffalo sauce, which has just the right amount of spice. Another good one, and I'd like it a lot more if they weren't so expensive . . . Mac & Cheese slice Creamy, with a decent flavor . . . at least, that was my thought until I realized the cheese they used is Velveeta, and not a homemade recipe. Velveeta? Really? Come on, now! That isn't necessarily to say it doesn't taste ok, but the realization that they are serving up Velveeta on a rather good, light and crispy crust left my disappointment immeasurable. Penne alla Vodka slice There is a dearth of sauce on this slice, which also has their light and crispy crust. Unfortunately the cheese is more plentiful, thus overwhelming the overall flavor of the slice. From what I could tell of the sauce, it doesn't seem to have much flavor. You keep chasing the flavor, but it evades capture, leaving one frustrated. There are a three reviews here that peripherally say that their vodka slices and pasta dinner entrée are good. So far this has not been my experience, as my own empirical evidence toward that end is lacking. Perhaps next time I'll try the Grandma Vodka slice on a return visit. We'll see . . . Customer Service This time the guy who took my order was the one whom, in visit #1, was fulfilling the orders. He was a lot more friendly and customer service oriented, just as he was on the prior visit. read more

See all

Amazing pizzas, lover their Caesar salad and cannoli's to die for. Good service, place is always very nice and clean.

Ordered a few days in advance online to send to my son's school for his birthday celebration. It arrived on time. Everyone enjoyed the food. Reliable and convenient, I will definitely order again in the future. read more

I've been ordering from Mario's for over 10 years. It's usually very good pizza but on 11/19/22 I ordered a margarita pie that was so bad I had to throw half out. The dough was so bad it was hard to chew. It really ruined our night. They obviously screwed up that day. We emailed them to find out what happened. No response so I'm going elsewhere for my pizza. If I get an explanation I'll try them again but if not I'll just have to assume they don't have their act together anymore. read more

I usually order from Mario's but today we ordered a medium pizza and it wasn't worth the money. and the service wasn't good when we went to pick it up. Terrible read more

First time trying Mario's and I have to say the plain pie we ordered was good. However, I was not satisfied with the slices I ordered. The grandma slice was dry and sloppy looking. The dough and cheese were too much on the white pizza. Sadly, it just didn't taste fresh to me. I was looking forward to eating garlic knots as well, but theirs lacked garlic flavor at all and were a bit stale. I felt that I was just eating bread. Overall, not the experience I was looking for. read more

Mario's Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - Commack, New York

Online delivery order was 25 min late, and when it arrived the police was cold, the "large" pizza is not a large by any means, small slices for over $20 big time rip off .... First time last time for Mario's read more

this place has been open a long time and my family has ordered delivery and pickup from here for years with no issue. great service, great food (great interior decorating too), and their pizza reheats well! what more can you ask for. read more

Mario's Pizzeria - pizza slice - Pizza Near Me - Commack, New York

See all

The pizza was good but kinda soggy but there was a massive amount of yummy toppings. They are on the more expensive side. Two pizzas 1 half pepperoni/half cheese, and the other half cheese/ half pineapple &bacon. It came to over $50 read more

Not what it use to be, quality is down while the prices are up. Ordered a chicken parm hero and the chicken was full of grizzle every time you took a bite the whole piece of chicken pulled out. My wife bought some skirt steaks at a crazy high price and they also were tough. Done with this store, read more

I thought I had COVID cause this was probably the blandest pizza I've ever had in Ny state. Multiple slices with all the toppings couldn't help this. read more

Mario's food, service and decor can't be beat! Our group of 20 gathered in the tastefully decorated private dining area for a dear friend and coworkers birthday this past Thursday. John was more than accommodating with any and all requests before, during and after our party. He made sure everything was perfect- even buying the birthday girl a bouquet of flowers! We started with delicious grandma pizza and garlic knots then the large buffet trays were brought out . We had eggplant and a delicious pasta/chicken dish in pink sauce. The salad was abundant and yummy. Thanks to the fantastic service , tasyand attention to detail, this restaurant will be our go to spot for many more events! March 4th 2020 Another delicious dinner tonight at Mario's with my hubby. Fantastic food and friendly service makes eating here a treat! Thanks to John and his staff for always making sure were pleased with our orders. read more

My family and I loved it. The pizza was very hot and fresh. Delicious. The place was clean and very nice inside as well. Friendly service. A must try my picky kiddos loved it. read more

Bad slices no taste to the pizza I got the broccoli before there's so much water in the container y serve it with water ewww

I am writing about Mario's of Commack to warn others not to order for delivery. The staff and management here believe that you should eat whatever they make for you, and not necessarily what you have ordered. I have patronized this establishment for years and had no problems until the last year or so. It seems when I have an issue with something not being correct or not cooked as per instructions...it is my issue not theirs! I have had multiple issues that have ordinarily been rectified, by them, usually either sending out the right food, or giving credit for future use. That has now changed...I am on their black list because I have complained too many times when they do not deliver what I order. Assuming I am a complainer and no errors on their part. First they indicated that my phone number was some sort of business that they would not deliver to. I was able to order however, under an alternate phone number. Each time they don't get something right it is my fault, nothing to do with possibly their incompetence. I utilize them because they deliver directly and had been going to the Restaurant for quite some time. Their delivery personnel are friendly and courteous as well, initially the management was too. I had an incident where my online order was delivered and the items were incorrect...so I called asked for the manager and he told me that I was wrong and I received what I had ordered. He was telling me "maybe you hit the wrong button" and other nonsense. I had a screenshot of what I ordered, and it did not match their printout. He kept telling me I was wrong, basically implying I was stupid or crazy. After a heated exchange and quite a few expletives, I drove down to the Restaurant and apologized, and showed the screenshot to him. It did not phase him whatsoever, and, as if he already knew, that the IT was at fault. I know this is lengthy and not many will read it, but it must be said. I have never experienced in my lifetime, an food establishment that automatically assumes the customer is wrong, or in fact is not aware of the food they order, and does not try to improve their staff. When anyone goes to a Restaurant they should expect to receive quality food that they have actually ordered, not what the places wants to give them. Had I been in the Restaurant I would not have accepted these mistakes. There are too many items to list here, but just be forewarned if ordered from them, do not be surprised if there are errors in your order. The Manager, said "you're the guy that gives us a bad review in our Email when something is wrong". I told him I was and I was expecting thing to get better. He told me to go to LaScala across the street from now on...which I believe is a great idea. The customer is first priority at LaScala, so it is a great idea. Apparently Mario's of Commack doesn't need Customers. Their food is decent, when it is cooked to order and correct...but at all costs avoid their delivery or you just may find yourself with whatever THEY decide you should get! read more

This is a large bacon pizza ordered on 7/23. I paid over $24 for this greasy unappealing mess. I was advised that I have the option to drive the pizza back and pick another but it was "going to be made the exact same way and no pizza leaves their location that's not perfect". I would not recommend this location.. EVER!!! read more

Mario's Pizzeria - This is a large bacon pizza ordered on 7/23. - Pizza Near Me - Commack, New York