This seems like the place to go after a high school game. The place is large enough to fit groups of people. The owner was a little caught off guard by me taking photos but I explained my mission and we had a quick chat. The rest of the staff were cool and helpful. My daughters and I enjoyed our slices and my mother enjoyed her spaghetti which comes with enough pasta to feed two people. read more

See all

Pizza garlic knots Zeppeli and chicken noodle soup was all great I always enjoy there food the service is on point they're friendly one of the best pizza places in the neighborhood from the food to the service. The ambiance is big enough. read more

See all

Been going here for years at girst the pizza was great but as the years went by the pizza is raw and greasy

Amore is always a good go to for catering. Their prices are fair and the portions are large. It always tastes fresh. Lots of people love their specialty pizza slices. read more

White cheese and regular slices a bit on the heavy side Nice taste not overly greasy or salty Service very fast Ambiance yep your at pizza restaurant No a bad place to stop for a slice read more

These guys are the best. We had a small pizza party for my son last night and they could not have been more welcoming or accommodating. They even set up a table for us with a tablecloth and made the kids feel super special. And the pizza and garlic knots were absolutely delicious. This is a place that feels like a neighborhood staple with folks who care. read more

I went there tonight at about 5:30PM to order a few pizza pies for my 23 students, to bless them with a holiday pizza party to no avail. I stood there in front of about 5 workers who basically ignored my presence for about a good 5-10 minutes. They saw me, and most of them glanced into my face, but never asked me what I needed! So I looked at my wrist watch, turned, and left to go to Pizzaiola in N. Babylon, which is more near the Elementary School where I teach. It costed more, but the quality of food, respect, and honor of my soon ending career as a 31 year veteran teacher is emphatically appreciated! read more

Best Sicilian around, everything else is above average. Highly recommended try it you'll like it read more

My girlfriend and I (repeat customers) ordered a $40 'garbage pie' and called to speak to someone because we werent satisfied and got the garbage owner. He told me to get lost and "go to Joe's" from now on (we will) or the Pie at Salvatore's, The Slice etc. there are quite a few places to get a pizza in Bayshore and not have to deal with low IQ and attitude. Your food sucks "amore" and so does your punkass owner who needs to hang up his phone like a pussy rather than talk out a simple business dispute like a man. read more

Pizza was delicious, going to order from them for Sunday or Monday football. The guys liked the pizza, we all said good quality!

Ordered 5 trays of food for catering. Service was excellent. Food was excellent -- got rave reviews from our guests. Would order from them again without hesitation. read more

Had my first taste of Amore at a friend's house when she used them to cater a birthday party. The penne sauce was just like I remembered and one of the best I have ever tasted. The garlic knots were so delicious I didn't get to snap a photo before finishing them The buffalo chicken slice was HUGE and packed with chicken and flavor. I only tried a piece of meatball from the hero because I was stuffed, but it was delicious as well. Looking forward to trying more items on the menu especially the potato and egg hero! Thankful for the friendly man who took my order over the phone and the equally friendly young lady at the counter! read more

See all

I don't typically like to bash places on yelp, and consider my reviews fair for the most part. The restaurant industry is challenging enough, and now with all the hardship as a result of the pandemic times must be really tough. That being said, I've eaten Amore many times over the past two years, both their pizza as well as the catered food. I work for an outpatient oncology practice and we receive catered lunches from pharmaceutical reps quite often. Amore is one of the preferred vendors (for reasons I cannot quite understand) so I'm extremely familiar with their food. I feel that the quality of the food is so poor across the board. The ingredients look and taste as if the are straight out of a Cisco box. There is nothing wrong with using prepared ingredients on your menu, however food from here just feels egregious. I know taste is very subjective and from what I've taken from other reviews, some people truly enjoy the food here. While I don't agree, I can respect the subjective nature of eating out. So I just wanted to take a moment to express my opinion about this place. Located in Bay shore, this place is within a couple miles of several exceptional places to eat. Being on the Nassau/Suffolk border of Long Island I cant help but wonder how this place can serve the food they do and remain in business. The pizza and catered food both lack the flavor and quality that is to be expected for Long Island. Average Italian American food is abundant where we live, and there's a bunch of standout places as well! For me, this is the worst tasting Italian food I have ever eaten in my 31 years of living on Long Island. read more

Outstanding upside down pies that are just loaded with cheese. Excellent sauce, and plenty of it. The dough is nice and sweet, thin and crispy. The regular pie is a good standard rendition. The meatballs and sausage are heavier on fillers than I prefer, but they don't skimp on anything else. The daily blue plate specials are a bargain, and they always have good coupons out there. Tremendous value. read more

Amore Pizza - Upside-down pie in the back, $9 Sunday lasagna special in the front, which also came with bread and salad. So much cheese! - Pizza Near Me - Bay Shore, New York

Pizza is okay! Had eggplant special with spaghetti and side salad yesterday. Tasteless and no cheese in between the layers of eggplant and the salad was all brown on the bottom and watery. It's a shame because there are so many medical facilities around there-DO BETTER read more

I was at Southside Hospital waiting for hours on end and got super hungry. So what's the answer to that? Pizza. This pizza place was super close to the hospital so I decided to give it a try. I placed an order for a whole Buffalo chicken pie since there was a couple of us at the hospital waiting. Since it was a nice day and I was really bored, I decided to walk it to the pizza place and it was only about a 10 minute walk. Definitely some sketchy houses on the way there but it was okay lol. The staff was really nice and I liked how they had flags supporting PD and FD. They have a lot of tables to dine in also. The buffalo chicken pizza was to die for! Sooo much chicken and cheese and sauce, and cooked to perfection. Definitely stop by this pizza place if you're looking for delicious greasy Long Island Pizza. read more

Amore Pizza - a counter with a variety of pies - Pizza Near Me - Bay Shore, New York

See all

Love the traditional pizzeria style pizza and best garlic knots I've ever had. Super garlicy!! I'd pass on the wings though, way too much breading. Best pizzeria in the Bay Shore / Islip area. Extra large 18 inch is the best for our family of 5. read more

Amore Pizza - Hot wings. Lots of breading. - Pizza Near Me - Bay Shore, New York

I like the fries here a bit expensive but hits the spot the Pizza is ok not the best. Ive tried the Pepperoni and white pizza and it was not the best . read more

Loved this place. Clean and inviting as you walk in the door. Fast paced pizzeria with a lot to offer. I was working and got a couple of slices for lunch. On the money. Fresh with little grease. The crust was nice with little bending so eating on the go was no problem. Owner/manager was present keeping things in order. Will definitely keep this place on my rotation. Nice work!!!! read more

Amore Pizza - Nice!!! - Pizza Near Me - Bay Shore, New York

I'm not sure if the food is any good yet. But COVID protocol is seriously lacking here. Hardly anyone on staff wears masks and the people working there walk around behind the glass by the pre-made slices without a mask on. Not in the trying to 'get a breath of fresh air' sort of way... just walking around boldly without any care in the world. It's a shame they are like this but I can't say I'll be coming back, people are dying every day and sadly places like this perpetuate the issue. Don't go here until it's a post - pandemic world. read more

I worked at the Great South Bay YMCA in Bay Shore for a few years and they ALWAYS would order from this place, for all kinds of events Not sure if they're BFFs with them or what? The pizza from here always tastes like paper. It may be the worst pizza I've ever had! Also, since the Y would use them for the childcare/summer camp lunches, the pizza would almost always arrive a solid 15-30 min late every single day at the Y. I guess there aren't many other options? Slice of Bay Shore is so good, why can't they consider using them? ‍ read more

My shrimp scampi meal was terrible, I couldn't believe it. It tasted like 10 year old trying to cook, and forgot all the ingredients except the lemon. read more

Closest pizzeria to work. Southside hospital employees order from here all the time. I have only tried a regular slice it was good, the chicken roll wasn't my favorite. I've heard the salads are good. Gotta try more to either lessen or add stars. read more

Amore Pizza - Menu - Pizza Near Me - Bay Shore, New York

See all

We enjoyed the owner Richie and entire staff who prepared the pizza slices to perfection!! Pizza was delicious! Conversation with Richie was entertaining. He is a gracious and host! We will be back!! read more

We catered a 60th birthday party from Amore and everything was exceptional. Almost everything was eaten after our guests were going up for seconds and thirds. We were very happy. Amore provided us with everything we could have needed. We will definitely be using Amore for our parties from now on! read more

My go to take out Italian spot in Bay Shore. Been ordering from here for years. Pizza is good and responsibly priced. Food is always fresh.

Ordered delivery and no one liked their food. My raspberry goat cheese salad had no goat cheese - it came with Gorgonzola instead. Yuck. Everyone else is complaining about their salads. None of the lettuce was fresh and the chicken that came with it was rubbery. Very disappointing. read more

Amore Pizza - None of the lettuce was fresh and no goat cheese (only Gorgonzola) for this goat cheese lover. - Pizza Near Me - Bay Shore, New York

Pizza is soggy can't even finish it 5.7 at best your better off going to giios or la casa it's pizza is trash

Rough experience on take out here. It was obviously a busy Friday afternoon and when I got there 20 minutes after ordering over the phone, my small order (salad, pinwheel and one slice) still wasn't ready. Then they didn't have the kind of pizza my coworker ordered, so I had to call back at work to ask her to make another selection. And I waited longer for that one to come out of the oven. So I got a salad and it was terrible. The chicken pieces were chewy. Looked like they just put two huge handfuls of mozzarella stuffed on top of a salad that had feta already. The pizza is good, so my advice is to stick with that. read more

LOVE this place! Great selection of slices, Stromboli, calzones, and pizza rolls. Slices are huge and packed with flavor. Also offer zeppole which is a childhood favorite of mine. Chicken bacon ranch pizza is a favorite. Huge salads! Favorite lunch joint in Long Island. Must try! read more

Very good pizza and the little buffalo chicken bites are awesome. Anytime I have ordered, there have been no issues or problems and everything is hot and served fresh. The prices are reasonable and they accept all forms of payment. read more

I might give it 4 stars once I repeat. Really Tasty and melted in my mouth in the most perfect way. BIG slices where 2 can be too much. Friendly customer service and the more you repeat they will hook you up. All there slices are well above average and banging Sicilian. Just redone dinning room is nice also. Good luck Parking. read more

They have the best meat sauce out of any pizzeria restaurant in BayShore, and I've tried them all. A matter of fact I'm going again today.

Besides the food being excellent at Amore's , the girl behind the counter is excellent too, so sweet, kind and friendly, I just love her. Thank for being you, we need more people in this world like you! 7pm wednesday. read more

Amore Pizza - Breaded and Fried Chicken and Prosciutto Penne ala Vodka! - Pizza Near Me - Bay Shore, New York

Got a chicken pizza delivered and a chicken parm. New to the area and trying to dig up a quality pizza delivery option. This place was better than mulberry st but I found the quality of the chicken to be low on the pizza. Not that it was fatty, but it wasn't good. Not nearly as good as the chicken in the chicken parm. It was also too wet of a pie. The slices were all totally floppy and drooped, dropping all of the toppings on the plate. I like a thicker, doughy crust, a slice with some support and I like delicious chicken on my pizza. This was sort of a mess. Not bad though, just not good. Delivery guy came In like 10 min, so if you need pizza now, make the call! read more

I been calling this place for years and they are always so polite and sweet on the phone. Love them!! Great customer service. Delivery is fast and the food is delicious. They accommodate food allergies with no problem. Will never order from anyone else. read more

This place came highly recommended and they didn't disappoint! The garlic knots were delicious , pizza was perfect and the fried ravioli was amazing!! Staff was friendly and very accommodating. I'll definitely be back for more!! read more

My family and I love Amore pizza! My daughter is very picky when it comes to food and she will eat almost 3 slices from here! They have a nice friendly staff and delivery is always on time if not sooner then what they say. Very good pizza. read more

Ordered pizza for a social distancing birthday party. Pizza was amazing. Service was top notch!! Everyone raved about it!! Definitely going to go back! A+++ read more

Recently ordered a catering package for my baby's dedication. First and foremost, the food was delicious!!! I called and ordered the food a few weeks before I needed it. We picked it up since the time we needed the food was up in the air but delivery was offered as well as stereos, plates, cutlery and serving spoons. We picked up the food a bit later than scheduled for but the transaction was smooth and a worker even assisted carrying all the food to the car. I would totally recommend. Great food and service and prices are great for the catering packages as well!!! read more